was my doctor serious?
mailoanmfp
Posts: 2
Hi guys basically my last doctor visit the doctor told me to go on a diet and eat half an apple for breakfast, a salad for lunch, and half an apple for dinner plus walk 6 miles a day. My BMI is a 26 so I am a little bit overweight but my question is this diet does not look very healthy to me. I want to know if I should follow his advice because I do not want to put my body into starvation mode at all. I have lurked on the forum for quite awhile and what the doctor said doesn't really add up to a healthy weight loss so I am very confused. Please help me.
0
Replies
-
time for a new dr. unless you are having a huge salad with lots of protein I don't see it.0
-
Are you sure they meant that is ALL you should eat or were they just suggesting you fill up a bit with some fruit and veg in addition to your other foods.0
-
I agree- that sound like barely any food. Maybe call him/her and ask them to go over it with you again. If this is what the Dr. meant- that just doesn't seem right to me. But I'm no professional by any means. Good luck hon!0
-
If I were you I'd question his qualifications. Does he specialize in nutrition? Doesn't sound like it. Second opinion would be wise.
While starvation mode is a myth, that is far from healthy.0 -
that does sound healthy at all to me.0
-
of course he's not serious...he meant "half apple BEFORE breakfast, a salad WITH lunch and half apple AFTER dinner".
:bigsmile:0 -
That doctor sounds ridiculous. I'd ask him for some serious advice, and if he says the same things, I'd find a new doctor or registered dietitian. I don't know where you live, but in Canada, every person can call a hotline and be connected to a registered dietitian.0
-
Doctors work in medicine not nutrition. I argue with mine all the time. He keeps pushing meds, and I keep telling him if I change my food, I'll get well. He won't listen.0
-
Are you sure they meant that is ALL you should eat or were they just suggesting you fill up a bit with some fruit and veg in addition to your other foods.
^^^ this, because eating fruit and veg before meals has been shown in some studies to result in people eating less during the meal, and therefore getting fewer calories in a day (because the fruit/veg is less calorie dense than the same volume of food in the rest of the meal). It's a bit hit and miss though, because it doesn't guarantee you'll be eating at a deficit - counting calories is more accurate - but it does work for some people. And given that your BMI isn't that high, a tactic like this plus increased activity isn't that bad advice and likely the combination of the two will put you in a deficit (although IMO calorie counting is better).
If the doctor actually meant eat nothing but those things then get a new doctor.0 -
Doctors work in medicine not nutrition. I argue with mine all the time. He keeps pushing meds, and I keep telling him if I change my food, I'll get well. He won't listen.
then prove to him by changing your food and getting well.0 -
Absolutely do not follow his advice. I certainly hope he was not serious. If he was, he should be reported to the medical board and you need to find a new doctor. Any doctor will tell you 1200 calories net per day is the lowest you should go without being under direct medical supervision.0
-
Sounds fishy to me.0
-
Did you ask him to explain what he meant by that? Can you call him and make sure he didn't mean that was all you are supposed to eat? I would hope he was just giving an example of snack ideas, in addition to actual food.0
-
Doctors CAN be experts in nutrition, but most aren't. If he wants you to lose for health reasons, by all means take the advice, but chose a different path to get there.0
-
This might be pre-mature, but I'm going to go ahead and call troll now...0
-
I've never met a Doctor who prescribed good diet advice. I've sought advice from a few.
You should ask to be referred to a dietician. They will be a bit clearer.
I once had a doctor who told me I should eat Fish Tomato Sauce and Frozen Veg.
Was I supposed to eat that 3-4 times a day?
When I asked him to explain better - he said that's all I need.0 -
This might be pre-mature, but I'm going to go ahead and call troll now...
^^ This
Yeah, I just received very questionable dietary advice from my doctor. So, do I ask him to elaborate, or justify his recommendations? Nah, I'll just hit up the forums and ask there!
And yes, docs may not be nutritionists, but this advice is laughable for even a layman.0 -
p.s. Walking 6 miles per day burns 733 calories.
This means you have to eat an absolute minimum of 733 calories to make up for what you lost,
or you risk starving yourself.
Who is Troll? I'm not American?0 -
At the very least, get a second opinion or ask the original dr for clarification.0
-
Sounds like Dr. Nick Riviera from The Simpsons0
-
Thank you for the replies everyone! I'll call him up and ask him to explain further. I've been going to this doctor for awhile now since he is the family doctor. My family has been pushing me to follow his advice and that's why I had to confirm things and get opinions.0
-
Best Wishes to you.0
-
I'd be looking for another doctor. That is ridiculous.0
-
....and reporting him/her too :-/I'd be looking for another doctor. That is ridiculous.0 -
of course he's not serious...he meant "half apple BEFORE breakfast, a salad WITH lunch and half apple AFTER dinner".
:bigsmile:
If your doc doesn't mean this, I have to echo everyone else and say get a new doc. A BMI of 26 does not justify this kind of extreme diet, medically supervised or not, unless there is something medically major you're not telling us (I can't even think of what that would be.)0 -
Your doctor really said that? That's horrible advice. I'd say to get a new doctor.Hi guys basically my last doctor visit the doctor told me to go on a diet and eat half an apple for breakfast, a salad for lunch, and half an apple for dinner plus walk 6 miles a day. My BMI is a 26 so I am a little bit overweight but my question is this diet does not look very healthy to me. I want to know if I should follow his advice because I do not want to put my body into starvation mode at all. I have lurked on the forum for quite awhile and what the doctor said doesn't really add up to a healthy weight loss so I am very confused. Please help me.
People of normal weight and overweight do not go into starvation mode. In fact, you must lose a certain percentage of fat and muscle and be pretty emaciated to be considered in starvation mode.0 -
You think so?of course he's not serious...he meant "half apple BEFORE breakfast, a salad WITH lunch and half apple AFTER dinner".
:bigsmile:
Actually, I would HOPE so.
0 -
You think so?of course he's not serious...he meant "half apple BEFORE breakfast, a salad WITH lunch and half apple AFTER dinner".
:bigsmile:
Actually, I would HOPE so.
I dunno....i was hoping he was joking, too.0 -
...this wasnt Dr. Oz by any chance?0
-
Eat the apple a day and keep away from that doctor.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions