Becoming obsessive...
kjensen15
Posts: 398 Member
I have noticed a lot of people on here seem to have become obsessed with their calorie and macro nutrient counts. I see countless questions regarding being over/under their calories for one day or one day they aren't spot on with their nutrient percentages and they want to know if that is going to hinder their weight loss. I applaud everyone that is trying to take control of their lives and maybe I just have a different approach. I still want to live my life and I am using this site to get an understanding about making healthier decisions. I don't want to live the rest of my life freaking out about every calorie I eat or every carb I put in my body. My fear is that some people that are becoming obsessed with the counting are setting themselves up for failure. Eventually I have to assume that this constant stress over food will get old and they will fall back into bad habits.
I just wanted to give my two cents on an observation I had. I'll be curious to see what everyone else's take is on this.
I just wanted to give my two cents on an observation I had. I'll be curious to see what everyone else's take is on this.
0
Replies
-
I have noticed a lot of people on here seem to have become obsessed with their calorie and macro nutrient counts. I see countless questions regarding being over/under their calories for one day or one day they aren't spot on with their nutrient percentages and they want to know if that is going to hinder their weight loss. I applaud everyone that is trying to take control of their lives and maybe I just have a different approach. I still want to live my life and I am using this site to get an understanding about making healthier decisions. I don't want to live the rest of my life freaking out about every calorie I eat or every carb I put in my body. My fear is that some people that are becoming obsessed with the counting are setting themselves up for failure. Eventually I have to assume that this constant stress over food will get old and they will fall back into bad habits.
I just wanted to give my two cents on an observation I had. I'll be curious to see what everyone else's take is on this.
Man, I just posted about losing my motivation, and I think this obsessive behavior may be to blame. I'm eating well, getting enough calories, and treating myself, that's not the problem. It's the incessantly thinking about food and exercise--it's draining my mental energy at a breakneck pace! But I don't know how else to keep track and make sure I'm doing the right thing, without logging it and paying attention.
I think you make an excellent point, maybe this is why programs like Weight Watchers are successful. You can tally in your head and it doesn't become this "Let me whip out my iphone to record every morsel I eat/ zomg this sushi place doesn't have brown rice I did not anticipate that the sky is falling!" type of thing.0 -
I really agree with this. I have found for myself that what started as motivation has turned into obsession. I feel overwhelming self-hatred when I go over my 1200Cal daily allowance, but because I am exercising too feel that any 'extra' I have can go into crap like wine and chocolate. Then I don't lose weight and hate myself more.
It is a vicious cycle ;-) Why cant we all just be happy with what we have?0 -
It is my 12th day on my diet. I feel like right now I have to be somewhat "obsessed" with what I eat and my calorie intake. When I learn how to eat right again and get the hang of what is good, what is bad. Then I can afford to be more laid back in my "counting" for now I need to be as strict as possible to keep me on task. I know if I were in laid back mode right now I would not make it very long. I understand what you are saying but for me it is just until it becomes a way of life and then I will be able to live life not counting calories, but know what is good and bad without having to do so.0
-
I agree. While I want to lose weight I don't want to give up on regular eating forever. I don't freak out when I'm over because there are plenty of times I'm under and I figure it evens out. Once I hit my goal weight I will keep tracking to maintain but I will allow myself to indulge here and there. It's a lifestyle change, not a quick fix.0
-
haha I agree with you...! I also dislike the ones that complain they need motivation, bored exercisin'...Seriously first get out of the negative mind frame...Do what makes you happy etc. Help yourself...
But than again you have to take into consideration, that they may be 'new' to at postin'...
I vented a while back and *****ed about it on my blog one day...but what can you do...
Keep smilin' and keep truckin'
xo 0 -
I do agree with you and I myself get obsessed at times. But I do think that knowledge is POWER. I think some know more than others when it comes to nutrition and dieting. This site is a great tool for support and a safe place to ask questions without feeling dumb or embarrassed.0
-
Well I'm glad there are a few people that seemingly agree with me! I was afraid I was going to be chastised!
I have been the "obsessed mode" before. I scrutinized everything I put into my body. I never allowed myself to join friends at a happy hour b/c 1. I had to go to the gym and 2. I couldn't possibly let myself drink alcohol. While I looked better than I have in a long time, I had NO life and obivously I was not able to keep this strict of a lifestyle going.0 -
YEah..that "under calories for the day" doesn't usually happen to me...not sure how you guys do it. I have to stop myself from going over like every day.0
-
haha I agree with you...! I also dislike the ones that complain they need motivation, bored exercisin'...Seriously first get out of the negative mind frame...Do what makes you happy etc. Help yourself...
But than again you have to take into consideration, that they may be 'new' to at postin'...
I vented a while back and *****ed about it on my blog one day...but what can you do...
Keep smilin' and keep truckin' xo
I agree completely! You're never going to get anywhere with a negative attitude. When I jump on my treadmill, I pump up a fun song and just smile because I know I'm doing something for myself. My husband laughs when he sees me grinning from ear to ear when I have sweat pouring off my forehead. Losing weight is NOT going to be easy, but it's going to be 10x's harder when you have a negative attitude about it.0 -
haha I agree with you...! I also dislike the ones that complain they need motivation, bored exercisin'...Seriously first get out of the negative mind frame...Do what makes you happy etc. Help yourself...
But than again you have to take into consideration, that they may be 'new' to at postin'...
I vented a while back and *****ed about it on my blog one day...but what can you do...
Keep smilin' and keep truckin' xo
I agree completely! You're never going to get anywhere with a negative attitude. When I jump on my treadmill, I pump up a fun song and just smile because I know I'm doing something for myself. My husband laughs when he sees me grinning from ear to ear when I have sweat pouring off my forehead. Losing weight is NOT going to be easy, but it's going to be 10x's harder when you have a negative attitude about it.
There are POSITIVE people here!?!?!?! Love it!0 -
Yes, it can be a bit exhausting to count calories and continually think about your food intake on a daily basis but it's also necessary for those of us who have alot of weight to lose, to be diligant and accountable everyday. As time consumming as it is it needs to be done. As for looking for motivation, isn't that what this site is for? To be able to ask for help and support and to not be ridiculed for doing so? We are all here for a reason, to lose weight and become healthier. It's all a learning process and we are bound to make mistakes. Yeah, I may be bored to tears with exercising and I wrote a post asking for suggestions but that is what we are here for! I know I can't do this alone and I will take ALL the help I can get! If I were more laid back with what I was eating and exercising, I would be back to where i was 2 months ago, not caring and gaining more weight. When I want to eat, I come here, I read stories, make comments and try to focus on something other than stuffing my face. So I find this site and all the support a big part of my life right now.0
-
I agree with you one hundred percent. It is a lifestyle change not a diet. I keep track of my exercise and my calories. I don't freak out if I am not under my calorie goal. I still have everything I like just in moderation, and that is what is important. I can't keep counting calories the rest of my life. I keep an eye on my portions, and what I actually eat.0
-
haha I agree with you...! I also dislike the ones that complain they need motivation, bored exercisin'...Seriously first get out of the negative mind frame...Do what makes you happy etc. Help yourself...
But than again you have to take into consideration, that they may be 'new' to at postin'...
I vented a while back and *****ed about it on my blog one day...but what can you do...
Keep smilin' and keep truckin' xo
My above post was more directed to this post here! It's not about being Negative, it's about getting the help and support you need tp feel positive about what you are trying to accomplish!0 -
It is the big picture that counts. Sometimes it is hard to remember it, though.
I was stuck on a plateau for what seemed like months and was starting to get over obsessive because I was not losing weight as I thought I should. However, entering intake and exercise have been a good discipline and have helped keep me motivated despite a depressingly stable weight!
Looking on the bright side, I did not gain significantly over the holidays and was ready to give exercise a boost in the New Year. But I am so happy that I am starting to see results again.0 -
I agree!!!!! this is totally a way of life for me, this is working for me BECAUSE I'm not obsessed with being over or under. I'm just ticking along from day to day, I'm losing very slowly because I'm still eating (in moderation) the things I love to eat. I just couldn't have a life without a glass of wine, a bowl of ice-cream, cookies and candy from time to time.0
-
Actually, Weight Watchers emphasizes keeping a food diary, too. I don't think there is any way around it. If we were all able to "tally in our heads" what we've eaten and stay honest/real with ourselves, we probably wouldn't need to lose weight in the first place. At least that is the way it is for me. Being a "grazer" I used to put away a ton of calories without realizing how quickly they added up. This site has been such a great tool for me.
This is the first time in my life I've had a balanced approach to weight loss/eating. I am eating dinners with my family (with careful planning), enjoying dark chocolate, snacking, eating lots of fruits and veggies, going out to dinner (with careful planning) - for me it is the most amazing gift to be able to EAT real food, lose weight and be accountable. I LOVE IT! I have done every stupid diet out there. This is such a HEALTHY approach for me. I am feeling happy and optimistic about my body for the first time in years!0 -
It is my 12th day on my diet. I feel like right now I have to be somewhat "obsessed" with what I eat and my calorie intake. When I learn how to eat right again and get the hang of what is good, what is bad. Then I can afford to be more laid back in my "counting" for now I need to be as strict as possible to keep me on task. I know if I were in laid back mode right now I would not make it very long. I understand what you are saying but for me it is just until it becomes a way of life and then I will be able to live life not counting calories, but know what is good and bad without having to do so.
I totally agree with you, once it becomes routine and I can eyeball portions...then I'll be a little more laid back...but right now I'm learning a whole new way of life, and it doesn't come easy. My entire routine has to be interrupted in order to adjust to a healthy way of living, or else I wouldn't be over weight...But I get what the orginal post was saying, it does make you want to rip your hair out and fall off the wagon...that's why I'm lax on weekends, and I give myself a cheat meal (sushi, but lots of it, not just the 4 little pieces recommended)...non-food rewards are another great way to keep going. I personally don't do that, but it's a good motivator, or mani/pedi's or a massage...but lots of people do give up..0 -
I feel like I have to be obsessive about logging everything, but not necessarily about calories. My biggest problem is portion control. I need to understand what an 8oz glass of orange juice looks like. It also forces me to make better decisions in combination with my food. I can have a cheeseburger, but that means I'm eating green beans with it to round it out.
The reason I need to feel obsessive about logging is because only then do I make the mental connection about how bad the things are that I'm putting into my body. Sure, every once in awhile I'll derail and over eat a bit. Going back the next day and seeing that those 4 slices of Dominos Pizza probably weren't worth the 1200 calories I spent eating them. (That's my wife's total calorie intake for the day)
Just my 2 cents.0 -
I went 10 calories over today, so I've shaved my hair off to compensate. 0
-
I went 10 calories over today, so I've shaved my hair off to compensate.
Awesome!! :laugh:0 -
I feel like I'm definitely becoming obsessed. Almost to the point where it's hard for me to even eat 1200 calories a day, on top of that I have started to work out hard, burning 600-1000 cals a day. I am taking an active vitapak for woman and it gives me tons of energy and also curbs my appetite, so that's probably why I struggle to eat 1200. I don't want to be unhealthy about my weigh loss so I'm really gonna try to between 1200-1400 cals a day.0
-
I feel like I have to be obsessive about logging everything, but not necessarily about calories. My biggest problem is portion control. I need to understand what an 8oz glass of orange juice looks like. It also forces me to make better decisions in combination with my food. I can have a cheeseburger, but that means I'm eating green beans with it to round it out.
The reason I need to feel obsessive about logging is because only then do I make the mental connection about how bad the things are that I'm putting into my body. Sure, every once in awhile I'll derail and over eat a bit. Going back the next day and seeing that those 4 slices of Dominos Pizza probably weren't worth the 1200 calories I spent eating them. (That's my wife's total calorie intake for the day)
Just my 2 cents.
THIS!
My personal mantra is "progress, not perfection." I tend to be a perfectionist and a control freak anyway, and I could, if I let myself, log WAY too much time custom entering every food I eat, but I refuse to get started down that path. BTDT, and I know from experience that I'll get burned out way too quick and quit. So I log whatever's the closest that's already in the food database (it might be a blueberry muffin instead of a banana one, for example) and move on with my day. I find that just logging SOMETHING, even if it's not exact to the calorie, helps keep me on track and accountable.
(Worth noting that this is also the first time I've ever been *completely* honest about my diet - logging every soda, candy bar, etc. I've finally embraced that this is for ME, not to impress anyone else with how perfect my diary is.)0 -
I completely get this. For a time, I started getting waaay too obsessed with it, now I realise (although it is hard sometimes) that I need to relax and 'give' a little bit.0
-
While the OP has some really great points, here are my views on this.
Alot of people are having a hell of a time trying to lose weight and keep the weight off. I see dozens upon dozens of posts every day on this forum where people are asking for help. If people do not track what they are taking in everyday and what energy they are putting out every day, weight loss to weight gain to weight loss to weight gain becomes inevitable which will completely frustrate a person to no end.
Then, they start trying crash diets, "yo yo" diets, that HCG crap and other methods of "quick fixes" to get the fast results they want in a limited amount of time with a limited amount of work.
Once you get used to finding out your BMR and daily calorie burn, and then finding out what you need to eat to complete your goals, it becomes second nature and you can do it VERY quickly.
I spend a total of maybe 2-3 minutes each day completing my diet and all while hitting my macro intake and calorie intake for the dail to fulfill my short and long term goals. It doesn't take very long once people understand how it works.
I still carry on my life and do the things I enjoy day to day.0 -
I've always been obsessed with food (not so much calorie counting) and exercise.
MFP is an awesome tool to fuel my addiction. Thank you MFP, I love it!
However, I was able to go on vacation for three weeks and I neither adhered to, nor missed MFP.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions