Juicing or Ketogenic?
I'm north of 350 and looking to lose a lot; my short term goal is 280 by the end of the year, because that's the cutoff for horseback riding around here and I haven't done that in almost 10 years. Miss it!
Anyway, I've experimented with both Juicing (a la sick fat and nearly dead) and ketogenic/atkins diets in the last year. I didn't make it past 2 weeks with either, I know my willpower is ****, whatever. I am going to try again though, and also try to keep up a workout regiment with it. I want to really commit myself to one of these approaches but I can't tell which will yield greater loss faster. Go ahead and tell me 2 lbs./week is the recommended speed of loss, I don't care, I've researched it and there are no direct health problems linked to losing weight as fast as 5 or even 10 lbs a week, as long as it's done through a calorie deficiency and exercise but malnutrition and hydration are avoided. I don't care about that limit, I'm not scared of it and I don't worry about it, if I start pissing blood obviously I'll go to a doctor but I don't intend to malnourish myself even if I do take an extreme deficiency in caloric intake.
First Question: What should I use? I know juicing is fast but the plants you use are so full of carbohydrates, and one of the things I like in reading about ketogenic diets is how they force the body to burn its stored fat cells by not giving it easily accessible carb fuel. Even while doing atkins I felt a change in my level of hunger (which I know for a fact was from carb denial), but also a drop in my energy. But I wasn't hungry and overall fairly satisfied. The problem is my "eat" button was on and since I was eating anyway it was easy to convince myself a little bit of carbs here and there wouldn't hurt, and before you knew it I blew it. Juicing was a much more miserable process, in terms of hunger, but after a few days I stopped being hungry and only had to worry about the temptation to taste normal food again, and the annoyance of constantly blending and such. Really prep is a pain for both because there's no quick and easy food solutions around here that conform to either diet; we don't have a smoothie place where I am and the fast food places all use too much sugar in their sauces for meat and always bundle in carbs. Anyway, I can't decide which to do, or which is going to be stronger long term?
Whichever I choose, I'm looking to do this for about 2 months, maybe 3 at the most, (yes, juicing too, it hasn't killed anyone I know, so I'm not worried about it) - I just want an extreme kickstart to weight loss then I'm going to do something more conventional (just watching intake and balancing meals better with smaller portions, since either diet for that long will shrink my stomach a lot).
Second Question: How feasible is a cheat day for each? For a short time I experimented with a 2-3 day juicing, 1 day when I can have a meal of whatever kind (since the calories were more than made up for by the 2 or 3 days off), and I did see some loss, but a lot of fluctuation as you might imagine. For Atkins I wouldn't even think of anything more than a 1/week cheat day, if even that. I know that any carbs past the limit break ketosis, but I'm curious if anyone has made a once per week cheat day on Atkins work for them and maintained good weight loss? Would greatly appreciate the insight/story if so! As for juicing, part of my fear in doing it for a month or two (I did a liquid fast once for a month) is my system not being able to handle food when I'm ready to eat again and accidentally dying hahaha, (that one I am a little worried about). So I thought maybe as my stomach shrinks I could sneak in 1 meal every 3 days or so without going overboard but still keeping my digestive system up and running.
Anyway, sorry my post is so long, I hope someone has insights for me. I've never done anything like a forum before but I thought it might be a good place to get ideas and decide which track to follow.
Thanks!