Who do you think has it worse: overweight guys or girls?
Replies
-
But really, guys are ok with sleeping with a big girl, but taking them out in public and associating with them is a whole different story. Women are more likely to get used for sex then dropped. So with being over weight, ridiculed, then used and tossed aside.. we are the "winners" here in the pity me game.
Geez that is sad and messed up. Since I never had that experience, though, I'm inclined to think it's more of a personal thing that happens to some women (or men for that matter).0 -
Both.
But I think it's how you respond/what you make of it that makes it "worse". I might be fat, but I'm not going to wallow and let that affect the things I do.0 -
No one cares if a guy is fat, but if a girl is fat she might as well be a leper.0
-
I don't think one is worse than the other.0
-
But really, guys are ok with sleeping with a big girl, but taking them out in public and associating with them is a whole different story. Women are more likely to get used for sex then dropped. So with being over weight, ridiculed, then used and tossed aside.. we are the "winners" here in the pity me game.
I knew a guy in my high school class when we all went off to college, he lived in a house with two other guys and whoever brought home the "fattest chick" and slept with her didn't have to buy beer for the week. Classy huh?
I think girls have it worse. I mean, look at Hollywood. Overweight male actors are cool and get main parts. Overweight females get to be the sidekick that makes fun of herself.0 -
I truly believe there is not right answer to this question. Every person is different and carries their weight differently - whether a man or a women.
I think it comes down to confidence and how you portray yourself. You can still be bigger and have confidence and sex appeal, but it is all in how you carry yourself. If you are bigger but don't put time and effort into yourself and just look all around frumpy, then you will probably have a hard time attracting others as it is clear you don't really care. If you carry extra weight, but put time and effort into yourself and are confident, then the way people will look at you and perceive you will be different. Weight is not the be all end all, it is personality and confidence that makes a person attractive as well as how they look.
Who has it worse: overweight people that have given up on themselves0 -
I think both have it bad. Heck, skinny people get made fun of, too. When I lost down to a size 0, I think I got more comments than when I was 300 lbs because it's not PC to make straight comments to heavy people, but there is NO filter when someone is skinny.
To be honest, anything that sets someone out from the crowd, whether it's being heavy, skinny, tall, short, purple haired, etc. is picked upon. We all have our own experiences, and we can't really say if someone has it worse than we do.0 -
Women have it worse.
A recent study showed that average salary for women negatively correlated to their weight whereas men have a positive correlation.
Also I think that women are more likely to go through life events that can have an impact on their weight (pregnancy and childbirth being the largest), and generally women are just more judged by appearance than men. A recent example is the media reaction to women being promoted in government and the story talking about the catwalk of Downing Street.0 -
I have to be honest, I haven't really had too many bad experiences being fat (as far as interactions with other people.) That being said I feel like women are more pressured to be thin, but I think men are more pressured to be "built." I have seen people of both sexes get treated real crappy for their physical appearance.0
-
But really, guys are ok with sleeping with a big girl, but taking them out in public and associating with them is a whole different story. Women are more likely to get used for sex then dropped. So with being over weight, ridiculed, then used and tossed aside.. we are the "winners" here in the pity me game.
I knew a guy in my high school class when we all went off to college, he lived in a house with two other guys and whoever brought home the "fattest chick" and slept with her didn't have to buy beer for the week. Classy huh?
I think girls have it worse. I mean, look at Hollywood. Overweight male actors are cool and get main parts. Overweight females get to be the sidekick that makes fun of herself.
I don't mean to be a jerk here -- I always really like your posts btw!
But I don't find this to be true. It seems like overweight male actors do NOT get the main roles and their weight is the butt of many jokes, too. A few actors like Seth Rogen have lost a few pounds and then get a wider variety of roles but generally are still stuck in comedies or "friend roles" and often their weight is a big part of their character's storyline or "flaws". But most overweight male actors do not seem to even be able to branch out that much...I'd say it is on a pretty similar level as the treatment of overweight actresses, honestly.
For example, Danny McBride on Eastbound and Down...same thing sorta, as typical Rebel Wilson or Melissa McCarthy roles. It's considered funny that he is aggressive and hypersexual etc, partly (or mainly) because he's considered somewhat fat & unattractive.0 -
I truly believe there is not right answer to this question. Every person is different and carries their weight differently - whether a man or a women.
I think it comes down to confidence and how you portray yourself. You can still be bigger and have confidence and sex appeal, but it is all in how you carry yourself. If you are bigger but don't put time and effort into yourself and just look all around frumpy, then you will probably have a hard time attracting others as it is clear you don't really care. If you carry extra weight, but put time and effort into yourself and are confident, then the way people will look at you and perceive you will be different. Weight is not the be all end all, it is personality and confidence that makes a person attractive as well as how they look.
Who has it worse: overweight people that have given up on themselves
So much of this. Yes.0 -
I think it's both.
I can say that since the weightloss, I have totally been treated better, both at work and social events. Sad because I'm the same funny person I was, just smaller...0 -
Women have it worse.
A recent study showed that average salary for women negatively correlated to their weight whereas men have a positive correlation.
Also I think that women are more likely to go through life events that can have an impact on their weight (pregnancy and childbirth being the largest), and generally women are just more judged by appearance than men. A recent example is the media reaction to women being promoted in government and the story talking about the catwalk of Downing Street.
also i have you ever seen a shirt that says "no fat dudes/men" on it? i sure havent ...but the no fat chicks shirt is sure popular eh0 -
Women have it worse.
A recent study showed that average salary for women negatively correlated to their weight whereas men have a positive correlation.
Also I think that women are more likely to go through life events that can have an impact on their weight (pregnancy and childbirth being the largest), and generally women are just more judged by appearance than men. A recent example is the media reaction to women being promoted in government and the story talking about the catwalk of Downing Street.
also i have you ever seen a shirt that says "no fat dudes/men" on it? i sure havent ...but the no fat chicks shirt is sure popular eh
You must not be looking in the right places.0 -
Women have it worse.
A recent study showed that average salary for women negatively correlated to their weight whereas men have a positive correlation.
Also I think that women are more likely to go through life events that can have an impact on their weight (pregnancy and childbirth being the largest), and generally women are just more judged by appearance than men. A recent example is the media reaction to women being promoted in government and the story talking about the catwalk of Downing Street.
also i have you ever seen a shirt that says "no fat dudes/men" on it? i sure havent ...but the no fat chicks shirt is sure popular eh
I've heard plenty of girls bash fat men. It really does work both ways. I've also had female friends specify no fat/short/whatever else men on their dating profiles.0 -
I think it depends on degree of overweight.
If we're talking 10-20 lbs, girls, definitely.
If we're talking 150 lbs, possibly the guys.0 -
Girls for sure because it is so much HARDER for us to lose it!0
-
nevermind0
-
Hmmm
Let's look at it objectively, ignoring the shallow reasons one would say one or the other.
Overweight women risk developing low self esteem, joint problems, heart problems, lung problems, depression related to poor nutrition, high blood pressure, stroke, type 2 diabetes, premature death, sleep apnea, gallbladder disease, and similar health conditions.
Overweight men risk developing low self esteem, joint problems, heart problems, lung problems, depression related to poor nutrition, high blood pressure, stroke, type 2 diabetes, premature death, sleep apnea, gallbladder disease, and similar health conditions.
So, I think the answer is obvious.
The social reasons people point out often ring true - but for both genders. I have been mood at when I was overweight. I've been called fatty, fat a**, disgusting. I have been watched as I ate with such contempt. I have had people yell at me as they drove past me that I made them lose their appetite. I learned not to ever make eye contact with the opposite gender, because I was often insulted if I dared to do so.
I know plenty of overweight men who have had the same experience.
There is no answer to this question. Because saying 'who has it worse' invalidates the experience of another person. Worse is just as subjective as hot is.0 -
My husband was an overweight boy, and I was an overweight girl.
We both agree that girls/women "have it worse."0 -
Think of how many famous entertainers and celebrities from the 1900s & 2000s are overweight men. Now think of how many are overweight women. Which are more positive and fun?
The fact that less than half of the popular culture fat people are women shows our society's bias against big women.
Right now, actor Melissa McCarthy and comedian Luenell are the only currently (within the last 5 years) widely known fat women I can quickly think of off the top of my head. But I can think of at least 10 men. Men dressed up as women have more visibility.
I think big women put more effort into looking presentable but big men seem to be more socially acceptable. Go to any bar or social situation where groups of adults hang out and you'll definitely see more large men than large women.0 -
haha, saw this today and it reminded me of this posting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NQrMRR6-YJA0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions