Is skipping meals generally an okay habit?
Chuck_Finley
Posts: 29
Let me preface this by saying I haven't had breakfast in over 5 years. Maybe an apple or so tops if I'm hungry. I'm just disgusted by food in the morning.
I'm not very overweight. I'm a skinnyfat. I need to lose about 15 pounds ideally by 6 months. Plenty of time, I'm already well on track for a pound a week.
Now here's my predicament. I love drinking. I drink twice on the weekends. I estimate it to be a +1,000 calorie ordeal for both Friday and Saturday. I want to say it's the reason I've become a skinnyfat, but I've been this way since high school (wasn't drinking back then).
I want to keep on track with my pound a week. Currently my diet hasn't really been much of a diet. My log this week looks like it was taken from an anorexic bloggers page. I'm netting around 900 calories a day on my non drinking days. Lately I've been skipping lunch to save the calories for "weekend beer o'clock". I can sustain this for the most part. Is this a safe practice though? I'm well aware I'm still consuming a dangerously low amount of calories each day. .
Is this going to have long term bad effects? I don't care about shedding all of my weight asap. I just want to meet (or exceed) my 1 pound goal in a sustainable lifestyle.
I'm not very overweight. I'm a skinnyfat. I need to lose about 15 pounds ideally by 6 months. Plenty of time, I'm already well on track for a pound a week.
Now here's my predicament. I love drinking. I drink twice on the weekends. I estimate it to be a +1,000 calorie ordeal for both Friday and Saturday. I want to say it's the reason I've become a skinnyfat, but I've been this way since high school (wasn't drinking back then).
I want to keep on track with my pound a week. Currently my diet hasn't really been much of a diet. My log this week looks like it was taken from an anorexic bloggers page. I'm netting around 900 calories a day on my non drinking days. Lately I've been skipping lunch to save the calories for "weekend beer o'clock". I can sustain this for the most part. Is this a safe practice though? I'm well aware I'm still consuming a dangerously low amount of calories each day. .
Is this going to have long term bad effects? I don't care about shedding all of my weight asap. I just want to meet (or exceed) my 1 pound goal in a sustainable lifestyle.
0
Replies
-
In general when you have the calories does not matter - but the real details depend on the individual. Personally I can't skip meals. I get light headed, feel funny. Have to eat every 3-5 hours. My husband on the other hand is the sort who can get to working on a project and 'forget' to eat, go 12 hours, and have no ill consequences.0
-
Let me preface this by saying I haven't had breakfast in over 5 years. Maybe an apple or so tops if I'm hungry. I'm just disgusted by food in the morning.
I'm not very overweight. I'm a skinnyfat. I need to lose about 15 pounds ideally by 6 months. Plenty of time, I'm already well on track for a pound a week.
Now here's my predicament. I love drinking. I drink twice on the weekends. I estimate it to be a +1,000 calorie ordeal for both Friday and Saturday. I want to say it's the reason I've become a skinnyfat, but I've been this way since high school (wasn't drinking back then).
I want to keep on track with my pound a week. Currently my diet hasn't really been much of a diet. My log this week looks like it was taken from an anorexic bloggers page. I'm netting around 900 calories a day on my non drinking days. Lately I've been skipping lunch to save the calories for "weekend beer o'clock". I can sustain this for the most part. Is this a safe practice though? I'm well aware I'm still consuming a dangerously low amount of calories each day. .
Is this going to have long term bad effects? I don't care about shedding all of my weight asap. I just want to meet (or exceed) my 1 pound goal in a sustainable lifestyle.
Since Aug. 2013, I stop eating by 8pm, and don't start eating until after my workout, which is usually around 1pm the next day.0 -
Whew okay. I was worried. I try googling this and get both sides from a plethora of shady blogs that appear to be for profit.. trying to peddle wares and stuff on people. It's very predatory.
Basically, my diet layout is this. MFP suggests I hit 1800 calories a day. It says I need 2,300 to live. I'm a 26 year old male, 180 pounds, 6 feet tall and very lazy. I think that number is outrageously high.
My goal is 1,200 a day. I haven't even hit the goal once since I started, I'm always much under. Today was the first day I actually hit the goal because I skipped so much the past few days I decided to treat myself to some fried chicken and vegetables. Skipped lunch to help ease my mind. It was great, I'm still full by the way. But because I drink, I need to plan ahead right?
So my week is generally
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday + Sunday are all 1,200 days. Any less is great. Some days I can push myself and skip lunch, some days I can't.
Friday and Saturday are my beer days. I'll try to eat responsibly those days (my best friend here in Korea is like me and loves to eat health food and sushi etc.). However we both like to drink. Even though I still exceed my food intake expectations, I still drink. Going to guesstimate those as 2000 days.
Is that a good plan? Literally -1000 5 days a week, possibly more. Usually more actually.0 -
Skipping is fine.
Regularly netting 900 calories not including alcohol seems less fine.
How many non alcohol calories total (not net) are you consuming in a week?
Edit: okay, I see you just gave that. That's not healthy, but the issue isn't skipping meals.0 -
This was my last weeks total caloric intake
8/6: Wednesday 800 calories
8/7: Thursday 350 calories
8/8: Friday 1800 calories
8/9: Saturday 650 calories
8/10: Sunday 700 calories
8/11: Monday 850 calories
8/12: Tuesday 400 calories
8/13: Wednesday 1250 calories
didn't drink saturday. I'm aware these are scary numbers, I'm doing my best to eat a little more.0 -
Whats wrong with this by the way? I'm just curious.Skipping is fine.
Regularly netting 900 calories not including alcohol seems less fine.0 -
Are you sure you need to lose weight? Toning, building muscle might be more appropriate? Just asking as my husband is 5'9" and his goal weight is 175.0
-
It will work for a short time... but it may have unintended consequences. With that low a calorie goal, you will lose muscle. I wanted to lose muscle, you may not wish that. (I had hormonal issues I was also fixing).
I cut alcohol except for 100 cal of whiskey in the evening if I had calories left over. Cutting beer was painful for me (I homebrew). While I ate more regularly than you, my calories were low but well balanced. I had a breakfast of low calorie high whole-grain cereal (Kashi GoLean)... a salad for lunch (with chicken) and a salad for dinner (with chicken or steak). That was 1200-1500 calories for the day.
I dropped weight (fat AND muscle) very quickly. It will work and my diet was maintainable for the long term (it was interrupted for social / emotional reasons). Your plan sounds less maintainable.0 -
I don't need to lose a ton. Gaining muscle would be great too. However I'm a little fat. I got a bit of a belly, bit of boobs.. thats my biggest problem.0
-
I see..It will work for a short time... but it may have unintended consequences. With that low a calorie goal, you will lose muscle. I wanted to lose muscle, you may not wish that. (I had hormonal issues I was also fixing).
I cut alcohol except for 100 cal of whiskey in the evening if I had calories left over. Cutting beer was painful for me (I homebrew). While I ate more regularly than you, my calories were low but well balanced. I had a breakfast of low calorie high whole-grain cereal (Kashi GoLean)... a salad for lunch (with chicken) and a salad for dinner (with chicken or steak). That was 1200-1500 calories for the day.
I dropped weight (fat AND muscle) very quickly. It will work and my diet was maintainable for the long term (it was interrupted for social / emotional reasons). Your plan sounds less maintainable.
your cure to this would be to eat a little more? I'm not planning on staying on this for the long term. I'm probably finished in October with the blunt of it.0 -
I don't need to lose a ton. Gaining muscle would be great too. However I'm a little fat. I got a bit of a belly, bit of boobs.. thats my biggest problem.
You may find better luck just trying to gain muscle with a normal caloric load. The fat will come off that way, too. Drinking will slow your progress, but not stop it, I think.0 -
Whats wrong with this by the way? I'm just curious.Skipping is fine.
Regularly netting 900 calories not including alcohol seems less fine.
You body needs a lot more calories than 900 daily.
That low, for to long is bad....
hormones get out of whack....
lacking nutrients....
just not good...0 -
Going extreme on calorie deficit makes you lose a good bit of muscle mass in addition to fat. Eating at a slight deficit (250-500) and doing regular strength training would allow you to strengthen the muscle tone you have left while losing mostly fat. And the leaner, toned muscles would make the remaining fat look better.
You may want to look into cycling between eating over to build muscle, then eating under maintenance to cut fat.0 -
Heck I eat 900+ calories at lunch usually0
-
Whats wrong with this by the way? I'm just curious.Skipping is fine.
Regularly netting 900 calories not including alcohol seems less fine.
Inadequate nutrients for one, and it will make the skinny fat issue worse by leading to muscle loss.0 -
What's the plan here - should I up my calories to 1,200? I'm still not that fond of exercising. I should but I'm just so body conscious in the gym. I also need my beer. Somethings gotta give I guess.0
-
Do you WANT to be skinny fat? Your diet is telling me you do....your body will catabolize muscle (along with fat and whatever else it can use for fuel) if you are eating at the kind of deficits you are talking about. The drinking is a whole different issue than the skipping meals,etc. If you don't care what you look like or your health in general then this seems like a great plan.0
-
What's the plan here - should I up my calories to 1,200? I'm still not that fond of exercising. I should but I'm just so body conscious in the gym. I also need my beer. Somethings gotta give I guess.
You tell us...
What is your plan??
What do you want to do??0 -
What are your stats?
Height
weight
activity level
age0 -
I want to be able to drink and I want to lose 10-15 pounds of fat with minimal exercise. I know this sounds crazy but I just wanted to know if it was possible. I'm feeling very unmotivated right now. I feel like quitting altogether at this point..0
-
I want to be able to drink and I want to lose 10-15 pounds of fat with minimal exercise. I know this sounds crazy but I just wanted to know if it was possible. I'm feeling very unmotivated right now. I feel like quitting altogether at this point..
Don't fear exercise! My diet I gave earlier in this thread was based on no exercise. Exercise made me hungry and unable to resist emotional / stress eating. I totally understand not wanting to exercise.
But it sounds like you're not overweight, just sedentary. You will lose muscle. If you're "skinny fat," the solution is exercise. If you're obese, only then will diet alone work (and not permanently). You might be able to get some good results if you completely clean up your eating, but exercise is still very important.0 -
I want to be able to drink and I want to lose 10-15 pounds of fat with minimal exercise. I know this sounds crazy but I just wanted to know if it was possible. I'm feeling very unmotivated right now. I feel like quitting altogether at this point..
hmm....
After reading this....man, I really want to smack you.....
You feel like quitting???
Srs??
Have you started anything to quit, honestly??
Do you want me to give you actual helpful advice?
Or would your prefer I pat you on the head and say "there, there"??0 -
I see. I'm terrified of exercise here. I'm out of shape, I sweat a LOT, and since i'm in Korea people go to the spas completely naked. Sometimes even younger people (like kids walk in). I can't deal with that.
It's that dumb old high school cliche you see time and time again. I'm scared.
If I eat more (and maybe drink less..) do you think that this will be okay? Like I said, I'm only interested in a little loss. I don't need to lose more than 15 pounds tops. If I lose the weight, I'll feel more comfortable being naked/shirtless around people. And sweaty. I hate the way when I sweat I look even fatter.
I admit that much. I am also very sedentary in general anyway.0 -
1200 is the estimated lowest # of calories for a woman. For guys, I think it's at least 1500 if not 1800. As other said, eating too little is very likely going to make you lose muscle along with the fat so you're still not going to get the look you want.
Set your MFP account up to lose 1/2 a pound per week. Eat as close to the daily calorie goal as you can. If you feel like you can't eat more food, eat more calorie dense foods like peanut butter, nuts, seeds, dried fruit, dark chocolate, lean protein, avocado, healthy oils, etc. If you want to save some calories for weekend drinking, that's fine to but make sure your weekly calorie intake is as close to goal as possible.
You don't need to go to the gym. Start out with body weight exercises at home. Either buy weights or use gallon jugs filled with water (about 8 pounds per gallon). There are many videos (YouTube, Fitnessblender) and other resources online for these types of workouts but here's a good one to start you out:
http://www.nerdfitness.com/blog/2009/12/09/beginner-body-weight-workout-burn-fat-build-muscle/0 -
@ Mity. If you're going to be antagonistic, I'm sure theres a lot more threads where you're welcome.
I'm just asking for constructive criticism on making my goal and what I know I can sustain work for me. I don't want a whole revamp. I want to know that what I'm doing will make some difference and not just make me look like a smaller skinnyfat.0 -
1200 is the estimated lowest # of calories for a woman. For guys, I think it's at least 1500 if not 1800. As other said, eating too little is very likely going to make you lose muscle along with the fat so you're still not going to get the look you want.
Set your MFP account up to lose 1/2 a pound per week. Eat as close to the daily calorie goal as you can. If you feel like you can't eat more food, eat more calorie dense foods like peanut butter, nuts, seeds, dried fruit, dark chocolate, lean protein, avocado, healthy oils, etc. If you want to save some calories for weekend drinking, that's fine to but make sure your weekly calorie intake is as close to goal as possible.
You don't need to go to the gym. Start out with body weight exercises at home. Either buy weights or use gallon jugs filled with water (about 8 pounds per gallon). There are many videos (YouTube, Fitnessblender) and other resources online for these types of workouts but here's a good one to start you out:
http://www.nerdfitness.com/blog/2009/12/09/beginner-body-weight-workout-burn-fat-build-muscle/
I see. I can do that. Thank you!0 -
Math says you're consuming more than you think.
A 180lb male consuming only 900 calories a day on average cannot possibly only be losing 1lb a week.0 -
@ Mity. If you're going to be antagonistic, I'm sure theres a lot more threads where you're welcome.
I'm just asking for constructive criticism on making my goal and what I know I can sustain work for me. I don't want a whole revamp. I want to know that what I'm doing will make some difference and not just make me look like a smaller skinnyfat.
Dude...I am being very serious with what I say.....
I have been on these boards for a little while now, and I will offer advice, criticism, help, etc....
So if you don't want my help, I will leave your thread...suite yourself.
But look at it from my perspective for one min.
I am willing to take time out of my life, to run the numbers and give you some advice and to help you....
And then you post the $#!% you just posted....
If that is how you think....then I have no desire to waste my time on someone with that kind of attitude....
So you tell me....
You want my advice/suggestions/help??
or not?0 -
Whats wrong with this by the way? I'm just curious.Skipping is fine.
Regularly netting 900 calories not including alcohol seems less fine.
If you don't eat enough you can easily become malnourished and sick. other side effects, hair loss, weak nails, bad skin, etc. Also not eating enough will also lead to a larger % of your weight loss coming from lean muscle, not the fat you want to lose, which will keep you "skinny fat" You need to eat more, much more and get 100+ grams of protein per day while partaking in a strength training program if you want to lose fat without losing much muscle.
I suggest setting your MFP goal to lose 0.5lbs/week and eat what MFP suggests, including burned calories from exercise and get 100+ grams of protein/day.0 -
You are not eating enough. Even if you were only hitting 1200 calories a day!!! I think you should be eating AT LEAST in the 1300 to 1500 range. You definitely will still lose weight if you do that consistently as I am sure that is below your BMR.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions