What BMI are you heading for?
Sued0nim
Posts: 17,456 Member
Or don't you care? I know some people discount BMI as a measure
I was happy with how I looked with a BMI of 26.2 (my weight used to be stuck there before children). Now I am aiming to get there and then reassess how I look
I was happy with how I looked with a BMI of 26.2 (my weight used to be stuck there before children). Now I am aiming to get there and then reassess how I look
0
Replies
-
BMI is a decent indicator for most people especially those who haven't done a lot of muscle building. It's worthless for me personally though. I am overweight according to BMI. Pisses me off every year when I go to my employee health screening and I lose a point due to being "overweight". Last year I went so far as to lift my shirt up and politely ask where they thought I should lose the extra weight from. You can put some stock in to BMI but it's not the end all be all indicator of heath.0
-
BMI is a decent indicator for most people especially those who haven't done a lot of muscle building. It's worthless for me personally though. I am overweight according to BMI. Pisses me off every year when I go to my employee health screening and I lose a point due to being "overweight". Last year I went so far as to lift my shirt up and politely ask where they thought I should lose the extra weight from. You can put some stock in to BMI but it's not the end all be all indicator of heath.
^^^^^^ THIS.0 -
I've learned to not really care about any number, be it scale weight, bf%, or BMI. the only thing they are really good for is measuring yourself against others and tracking progress, but thats about it
what i strive for is to look better and gain endurance and strength0 -
24 or less0
-
Last year I went so far as to lift my shirt up and politely ask where they thought I should lose the extra weight from.
Heheh, what did they say?
(You look great by the way)0 -
my mirror is my BMI...nothing more.0
-
I always chuckle at my BMI. "Slightly obese." The BMI is not a very accurate metric.0
-
AT 10% BF, I will have a BMI of 25.1 "overweight" if I continue to maintain my current lean body mass.
It's useless as a measure of anything. The only reason people even continue to talk about it is because it's easier for a doctor to look at a chart and pass a diagnosis in 10 seconds than it is to actually measure a body fat percentage which would *actually* be more accurate. Who cares if it's not the *correct* diagnosis? Next patient, please!!
It's nonsense on stilts, and it's not scientific in any way, shape or form. It's like trying to determine IQ by measuring skull circumference.0 -
I just want to be in the range they have for my height (5'1). Preferably the higher range, as I cannot see myself (nor do I want to see myself) at 100 pounds.0
-
Anything in the healthy/normal BMI range... preferably low 20s.0
-
20.5 but that is based on the weight I want to get to.0
-
24.9 is what I'm aiming for right now. 6ish lbs away. Will be the first time I was a 'healthy' weight, going by BMI (which I honestly don't put too much stock in - because when I was still technically 'obese' back at 175lbs, I still felt amazing and was healthy, especially compared to when I was actually obese at 215lbs), since I was about 8 years old. My 1st goal weight will put me at 24.0, my ultimate goal at 22.3.0
-
-
I'm aiming for pretty much slap-bang in the middle of "healthy" (21.5), but that's just until I reach my weight loss milestone. When I move onto improving fitness, strength and blood pressure/cholesterol I'll ignore it.
I know it has limited applicability for the active and fit, but it's been a useful metric for me while losing weight. It neatly segments weight loss into nice easy groupings.0 -
I'm going for 20 until I start weight training. Then I want to put back on 3 - 6 pounds of muscle.0
-
BMI is wonderful for people in denial. If someone doesn't realize how fat or skinny they are, the BMI is there to tell them.
I don't really care about the BMI when I'm done. I loved moving out of OBESE and into OVERWEIGHT. Nobody was ever so happy to become overweight, let me tell you! Did a dance of joy.
Looking forward to entering Normal. It's not far off.
But the actual number, when I'm done? I don't care.0 -
Or don't you care? I know some people discount BMI as a measure
I was happy with how I looked with a BMI of 26.2 (my weight used to be stuck there before children). Now I am aiming to get there and then reassess how I look
30.
Now, we should totally have a discussion about why you're looking at such a terrible metric such as bmi.0 -
When I was at my physical peak 10 years ago (around age 30), my BMI was well into the "overweight" category because I had so much lean mass.
Now my BMI is "normal" and I'm trying to get back to a *lean* BMI of >25. The only thing that sucks about it is that as soon as I hit a BMI of 25, my health insurance company will start sending me weight loss tips again. :-)0 -
Right now my bmi is 21.4, but I would like to be under 21 if possible. I'll see how I look and feel at a lighter weight.0
-
I want to be under 25, maybe 22/230
-
I decided to put in my target weight and tell you what my BMI would be. Based on my body mass analysis two weeks ago, I decided that I need to lose about 75 pounds to be at a good place, assuming that I stay on track with my muscle mass. The BMI number that I got based on that was still considered highly obese.
BMI can suck it. I'll know when I get there.0 -
I always chuckle at my BMI. "Slightly obese." The BMI is not a very accurate metric.
Got me chuckling too0 -
im currently: 33.1
THEY want be to be: around 23.0
I WANT TO BE: 27.5
which is "overweight" BUT not for my my body type!! :bigsmile:0 -
According to my cardiologist, I should have a BMI of 25. Right now I'm at 31.
I don't know if I will reach that number, because while I'm losing fat, building muscle will also add weight to my body. So, BMI is not an "integral" health indicator.0 -
Or don't you care? I know some people discount BMI as a measure
I was happy with how I looked with a BMI of 26.2 (my weight used to be stuck there before children). Now I am aiming to get there and then reassess how I look
30.
Now, we should totally have a discussion about why you're looking at such a terrible metric such as bmi.
LOL...I got an invitation for a "health check", it's a programme that is offered to all over 40s here.
However I have a fear of health checks when I'm feeling healthy (I do have a reason for this based on anomalies that show in people but that's too much to go into right now) ...I have told myself when my BMI is closer to normal range I might just go
But the other part of me discounts it as a stupid measure
So I was just mulling it over really0 -
BMI is such a poor indicator for anything other than your height to weight ratio. It has nothing to do with health or physical fitness. According to my BMI (30.1) I am Obese (Height: 6'2" Weight: 235#) I have the same BMI as a person that is 5' 5" and 180# or person at 7' 5" and 340#. See how ridiculous that is? I would have to weigh 180# to have a "normal" BMI of 24. I wrestled at 180 my freshman year of High School.
Athlete's have high BMI's but are in excellent physical shape because (surprise, surprise) muscles weigh more than fat. No one would consider them Overweight or Obese. They really need to STOP using BMI as an indicator for Health. The BMI does not take into account factors such as: muscle mass, body fat %, activity level etc.
The ratio was designed by a mathemetician 200 years ago. Not a Doctor or Nutritionist or anyone that knew what the hell they were doing. I'm pretty sure Doctors could up with a stat more indicative of physical health these days.0 -
BMI was never intended to be a measure of an individual's health or fitness. It is a figure that was created to measure the health of a population of people. So IMO I think it is worthless measure of individual health or fitness and is grossly misused.0
-
My doctor was happy when I hit the normal BMI range. I wasn't. I couldn't care less about BMI, I care about how I look.0
-
69 srs0
-
I'm looking to get to 21.5, which is only in the middle of the healthy range for me, but asking to go lower feels completely impossible. Just wanna get out of the overweight zone.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions