Is it possible to lose 3.5 pounds in 12 days??
NWalerys1
Posts: 16
12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
0
Replies
-
It is probably mostly water weight with some actual loss in 12 days.
Yes you could lose that amount in 12 days - but it won't happen consistently every 12 days.
You are not in starvation mode.
Why are you only eating 1000 or less calories though?0 -
Thanks for your feedback!
I have been eating to satisfaction. If I eat healthy, then I find myself craving less and full quicker. It hasn't consistently been 1000cals a day. A mix between 900, 1000, 22500 -
What???? If you exercise at all you should be getting well over 1300 cals/day. At the minimum 1200+ what you burn. so if you burned 750 the min you should be taking in is 1950 (1200+750), assuming the calories burned are accurate.0
-
It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I lost 5 pounds in 11 days0
-
Yes water weight mostly though. I've lost that much water in a few hours before. Of course that kind of weight loss isn't what you're looking for. Lose 1 lbs a week and stay consistent for real lasting results.0
-
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.
:noway: Some days you just can't turn down that awesome pizza, man. It's not an eating disorder.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Eating 2200 calories isn't a binge.
Having high and low days works for me and I consistently lose 3-3.5 lbs over a 2 week period. I generally have higher days (1800ish) at the weekend then lower (around 1200) during the week.
Well done for your great loss!0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Agree with this.
As you were typing out that line you should have realized what you are doing is no good.12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
You are weighing in at 120, how tall are you?
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.0 -
Please make sure you're getting proper nutrition. It's not recommended to eat less than 800 calories per day (very low calorie diet) so be careful. MFP suggests 1200+. You should probably eat back at least some of those exercise calories, although burn estimates are usually a bit high, and if you don't use a food scale and log everything chances are you're eating more than you think as well. So your net probably isn't as low as some people think but I do think you should eat a few hundred more calories. Also, eating 2200 calories is not a binge, especially if you exercised. You might go over your goal for the day but as long as it's not everyday it should be fine.
Can you lose 3.5 pounds in 12 days? With calorie burns and water weight, it is possible, but won't happen very often. During certain times of your monthly cycle, a lot of women randomly gain or lose water weight, so that is a possibility as well.0 -
It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot.
Losing water weight has little or nothing to do with how much water you drink. You can drink all you like, but you can't force your body to retain it. You'll simply pee it out if you're eating so few net calories that you're almost fasting, as you've been. It's not healthy and it's not sustainable.0 -
As you were typing out that line you should have realized what you are doing is no good.12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
You are weighing in at 120, how tall are you?
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.
Seriously... 2200 calories a day isnt a binge. It is like 600 cals over. To add on, the days that I did go over, I did not "fail" and crave and eat sweets. I ate healthy foods. Those would be the days that I didn't have school, wasn't working, and had nothing to do all day.0 -
It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot.
Losing water weight has little or nothing to do with how much water you drink. You can drink all you like, but you can't force your body to retain it. You'll simply pee it out if you're eating so few net calories that you're almost fasting, as you've been. It's not healthy and it's not sustainable.
Thanks for your input. i don't know much about water weight. So a 5'6" female like me, at around 120 pounds... How much do you believe my water weight could fluctuate in pounds? 1? 2? 3?0 -
Keep in mind though, while I have been eating probably a little lower than I should have been, I HAVE been really working hard, biking, swimming, running, for about an hour and a half a day, sometimes less, sometimes even 2 hours. I have been putting in the hard work.0
-
Thanks for your input. i don't know much about water weight. So a 5'6" female like me, at around 120 pounds... How much do you believe my water weight could fluctuate in pounds? 1? 2? 3?
I can't know how your body responds, but at a guess I'd say at least 3. I know I can gain or lose 3 or 4 in a couple of days without even trying. All it takes to gain is eating more than maintenance calories plus lots of salt. Losing it is the opposite.0 -
Putting in that much work, and feeling "slightly weak," should be a strong indicator to you that you are probably not eating enough for your body. Regardless of eating to "satisfaction." Our bodies need a general level of intake to function properly, and from the stats stated, there is simply no reason for you to eat such a calorie restricted diet. Whether you are intentionally restricting or not does not matter when considering whether a diet is restrictive.
Consistently eating lower than biological need will condition the body to be satisfied on lower levels of food. It is a survival tactic built into our internal mechanisms.
I do so very much hate when people use terms like "binge" when discussing high calorie intake days. Binges are not conscious and decision-based eating patterns. At the same time, one does not need to eat sugary "bad" foods in order to binge. It is entirely possible to constitute a binge eating "healthy" foods.
Basically, it's not a good idea to NET so low of calories, especially when you simply don't have that much weight to lose. In order for someone of your height and weight to achieve 750 calories of exercise burn a day, we're talking no less than 2 hours of exercise a day, give or take. If it feels right, that's fine, but you really need to fuel yourself to support such a habit if you want long-term results.0 -
You're 5'6?!?! You fully should be eating more, and remember exercise can be a diet suppressant therefore you might not "feel" hungry but it doesn't mean your not. If your not netting atleast 1200 locals find some calorie dense foods to bump your net up like peanut butter.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Thanks for your input. i don't know much about water weight. So a 5'6" female like me, at around 120 pounds... How much do you believe my water weight could fluctuate in pounds? 1? 2? 3?
I can't know how your body responds, but at a guess I'd say at least 3. I know I can gain or lose 3 or 4 in a couple of days without even trying. All it takes to gain is eating more than maintenance calories plus lots of salt. Losing it is the opposite.
Me, I can fluctuate in water weight up to 20lbs, and it often has nothing to do with eating over maintenance or eating salt. Exercise can generate water gain. Hormones can generate it. Lazy days can generate it. Simply eating more than your standard intake can do it. Our bodies will hold onto water in order to dilute and filter the foods we eat, and the best way to assist in general is keep the water intake ample. If you think it's salt related, make sure to incorporate potassium-rich foods, because unlike many people think, salt is voided from the body by binding with potassium, not simply by being flush by water.0 -
Is it possible? Yes.
Is it likely to go straight back on following a few days of eating a normal amount? Yes.
Or is likely to return next time you have a period due? Yes.
But doing 500+ calorie burn work outs of cardio, feeling faint and dizzy @ 5' 6", 120lbs and 19 years old? No. :noway:
There are better, and sustainable, ways to do this.0 -
As you were typing out that line you should have realized what you are doing is no good.12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
You are weighing in at 120, how tall are you?
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.
I was responding to her following clarifying post where she says she varies between 900, 1000,and 2200.
I don't think that is such extreme differences as to be seen as a deprive and binge cycle.
Such variation with a appropriate average, of, say , 1500 seems fine to me and not an eating disorder at all.0 -
As you were typing out that line you should have realized what you are doing is no good.12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
You are weighing in at 120, how tall are you?
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.
I was responding to her following clarifying post where she says she varies between 900, 1000,and 2200.
I don't think that is such extreme differences as to be seen as a deprive and binge cycle.
Such variation with a appropriate average, of, say , 1500 seems fine to me and not an eating disorder at all.
While I don't disagree with the above, I do think OP is at risk for an eating disorder, if not there already.
OP, you really don't need to be trying to lose weight at the height and weight you're at. And justifying everything you're doing is a really bad sign. Consider why you're doing this. Are you trying to lose weight or to get the type of body shape you want? If it's the second, consider starting a weight training program. Check out stronglifts. Search the boards, there are some awesome ladies around doing this. And you should start eating a lot more. Still healthy stuff, but more consistently.
If you're actually trying to lose weight... please go to a doc. You need some help with your body image issues (not trying to say this rudely and sorry if it comes off that way, but I'm being serious).
ETA: Scrolled down the the bottom of the forums list and happened to see this: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1392905-updated-eating-disorder-resources
haven't checked it out myself but hope it helps you0 -
This content has been removed.
-
You're 5'6" and 120 lbs. Honestly, you should not even be trying to lose any more weight. With your low calories and over doing it on cardio, you are the perfect candidate for losing lbm.
[/quote]
I agree. I'm only 1" taller and although I'm quite big boned (broad shoulders and hips) and relatively fit (regularly horse ride and cycle) anything less than 140lb makes me look emaciated! When i was younger (post kids but before middle age spread LoL) i got down to 135lb and was nagged by my husband and mother to put some weight back on, and if I now look at photos of me back then I'm embarrassed because you could see every rib and protruding bone! Be happy but not if it makes you feel even slightly weak - that is never healthy.0 -
I was going to say yes as I lost 2.9 pounds last week, but that was done on 1640 NET.
5'6" and 120? 118 is the lowest weight considered normal at that height via BMI. 130 is the absolute lowest I'm aiming for at the same height. Are you sure you really need to lose? If you think eating so few calories is what you need, maybe it's time to speak to a professional.0 -
It is never ever acceptable to net so few calories. Period. Feel free to defend it all you want.
As you were typing out that line you should have realized what you are doing is no good.12 days ago i weighed in at 124. Today I weighed in at 120.6... I don't really understand how this happened. For that first week I was eating in at about 1000 calories a day and was exercising around 500 calories off. Then the last 5 days, I was sometimes eating around 900-1000 cals a day, exercising 750 off. I did though, have about 3 or 4 days in that 12 day period where I didn't binge, but just ate around 2250 cals a day and did a little bit of exercise, so I don't think my body is in 'starvation mode' if it even exists.
Is it possible that I lost this weight? It can't be just water weight because I always drink a lot and yesterday I rested and drank a lot. I have been eating very healthy these past few weeks. No added butter, no added salt, no takeout or restaurant eating, only one day where I ate some unhealthy sugary high calorie food. Been eating protein - cereal, fish, meats, and many vegetables
I haven't pooped in a couple days. Maybe I haven't been eating enough to even poop.
I do feel 'slightly' weak but can still function perfectly fine. Maybe I should be eating a little bit more.
I do look 'slightly' slimmer but i hope it isn't just muscle that I am losing... please help me determine how I lost this weight?
You are weighing in at 120, how tall are you?
Sorry but netting so few calories then going on a binge for days is not "all good". It's basically an eating disorder.It is the average that matters though.
If she is averaging, say, 1500, by eating 1000 some days and over 2000 other days, then all is good.
I was responding to her following clarifying post where she says she varies between 900, 1000,and 2200.
I don't think that is such extreme differences as to be seen as a deprive and binge cycle.
Such variation with a appropriate average, of, say , 1500 seems fine to me and not an eating disorder at all.
And yes, when you really look at what the OP is doing and that she is trying to lose weight even at her low weight, it's a problem. And help might be in order.
I agree OP may have an eating disorder, based on her current weight and goals.
I don't agree that it is never ever acceptable to net fewer calories if that is balanced with higher calories other days and the average is on target.
Many people eat less on some days than others, due to various forms of short term fasting or different circumstances.
Am not talking huge deprivation/binge cycles but things like varying between 900, 1000, 2200 - ie the post I was addressing with my comment.0 -
Please eat more. Add in some good fats... will help give you extra cals, great skin, numerous health benefits and should get your bowels moving.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions