I've gained eating back calories. Help?!

I ate salads and exercised staying in my calories two weeks with no major slip up (over 100 calories over). Is eating back the calories really hurting instead of helping?

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/food/diary/syn70

Replies

  • KylaDenay
    KylaDenay Posts: 1,585 Member
    No eating back exercise calories is what you should be doing. It doesn't look like you are eating them ALL back anyway, so I would not think that is the issue. I would think that you are probably over estimating your calorie intake. Also how much have you gained and is it weekly. If not than mostly water weight. Fast food even salads have a lot of sodium, so you could just be retaining water.
  • diannethegeek
    diannethegeek Posts: 14,776 Member
    How much weight have you gained and over what period of time? It could be something as simple as a little water weight gain (we tend to retain water due to sodium, exercise, hormone, stress, changes in our exercise routine, etc).
  • focusedfrances
    focusedfrances Posts: 42 Member
    It has been 6 days since my last weigh-in. I gained 3 lbs!
  • Liftng4Lis
    Liftng4Lis Posts: 15,151 Member
    Two weeks isn't long enough and 3 pounds is water retention. Patience, it will come.
  • focusedfrances
    focusedfrances Posts: 42 Member
    Thanks. I will try to be patient.
  • shadowofender
    shadowofender Posts: 786 Member
    You could be overestimating your burns in your workouts. If you think you burned 300 but only burned 200, you're going to be off and that adds up. Also, how accurately are you logging? As in are you weighing where possible instead of measuring, etc.? There's a huge margin of error when you're first learning how to look at portion sizes and for me it didn't start really helping until I started weighing everything.

    But also, two weeks isn't a long time in the grand scheme of things. It may *feel* like forever, but really 4-6 weeks is a more accurate indication of the overall trend.
  • focusedfrances
    focusedfrances Posts: 42 Member
    I use the FItBit to calculate cardio and I am not tracking strength training at all. I am on a business trip so I am eating out every day. I eat pretty much the same things every day. I am depending on them to be preparing the product according to their posted nutritional information. I do use a food scale at home. I am really looking forward to getting back home so that I can cook my own food and eat cleaner.

    Thanks for your analysis.
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    You're supposed to eat back calories with MFP...but here's the kicker...most people overestimate their burn (often substantially so)...they just take the data base as actual fact...in reality, most databases and calorie calculators are going to overestimate your calorie burn. You have to make an allowance for estimation error.

    For me, I found it helpful to compare my burn to a few different sources...on top of that I would compare it to my perceived level of effort using a factor of 5-10...5 calories per minute for basically a fast paced walk in the park and 10 calories per minute being a sustained level of effort for which I could not hold a conversation or do anything besides focus on the task at hand. It is pretty hard to burn more than 10 net calories per minute...and even if you do, you want to be conservative with this method. As things went along I got a pretty good idea of what I was burning for various things...most of my workouts come in around 7-8 calories per minute.

    I would also add that a vast majority also underestimate their intake...they eyeball servings or they see that a package of chicken breasts says 4oz serving = 120 calories...so they log that without realizing that that may be a serving size, but the average chicken breast is about 8 - 10 oz...so they're easily eating twice what they log. This happens with numerous foods in my experience.

    Make sure you're being as accurate as possible...consistent in your logging...and be conservative with your estimated burns.
  • Kalikel
    Kalikel Posts: 9,603 Member
    Give it a little time. See if it works before you decide it doesn't.

    Is your period due? That can add five pounds for no reason. A high sodium intake, too, will add weight that isn't fat.

    Give it a month and see how it goes. If it hasn't worked then, make some changes involving the "eat less, exercise more" philosophy. As crazy as people get with it, this isn't rocket science. :)
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    I use the FItBit to calculate cardio and I am not tracking strength training at all. I am on a business trip so I am eating out every day. I eat pretty much the same things every day. I am depending on them to be preparing the product according to their posted nutritional information. I do use a food scale at home. I am really looking forward to getting back home so that I can cook my own food and eat cleaner.

    Thanks for your analysis.

    Ok it's probably water weight from sodium! Don't worry about it.
  • focusedfrances
    focusedfrances Posts: 42 Member
    Kalikel: menstrual cycle not due for at least 10 days... but good to know since I would have had a melt down when I weigh in that week! Thanks for the reminder.
  • dporter1183
    dporter1183 Posts: 154 Member
    def give it more time.

    and don't forget to take into account your time of the month. I gain a few lbs right before I start.

    try not to dwell on it too much. if you're like me i'll get discouraged from time to time and say "screw it, give me a cheese burger"
  • wkwebby
    wkwebby Posts: 807 Member
    Also, don't forget your extra calories that you'll get with the salad dressings. If you aren't adding those in, you'll be easily eating a hidden 100-200 calories each salad dependent upon your choice of dressings (this would be for only 2 tablespoons). For me (I love my dressing), I absolutely can't eyeball dressing and I can't put it onto the salad directly. They have to separate the dressing or I over eat the dressing. :(

    Good luck, and yes, have patience. :flowerforyou:
  • focusedfrances
    focusedfrances Posts: 42 Member
    Thanks wkwebby, I have been faithful in logging every calorie including dressing.