Whey Protein Powder for a 10 year old?
CheatinLil
Posts: 71 Member
Hi,
I wonder what you all think about giving Whey protein powder to a 10 year old boy. My son is not overweight but he is husky. He has horrible eating habits on his own. However, he says I'm mean because I encourage healthy eating habits. I do allow him to eat treats. He gets to pick three junk food items a week. Which he chooses to eat the first two days of the week. So I'm not depriving him. I'm also a busy Mom. Breakfast most days is a challenge because he is just not in the mood to eat. I let him try the Whey Protein Powder I have been having in the mornings and he like it! I didn't see anything on the package that said an age limit on it. He said he stayed full till lunch then stayed full till he got home. Usually he is famished by then.
Anyway what do yall think about giving whey Protein Powder for a 10 year old boy?
I wonder what you all think about giving Whey protein powder to a 10 year old boy. My son is not overweight but he is husky. He has horrible eating habits on his own. However, he says I'm mean because I encourage healthy eating habits. I do allow him to eat treats. He gets to pick three junk food items a week. Which he chooses to eat the first two days of the week. So I'm not depriving him. I'm also a busy Mom. Breakfast most days is a challenge because he is just not in the mood to eat. I let him try the Whey Protein Powder I have been having in the mornings and he like it! I didn't see anything on the package that said an age limit on it. He said he stayed full till lunch then stayed full till he got home. Usually he is famished by then.
Anyway what do yall think about giving whey Protein Powder for a 10 year old boy?
0
Replies
-
Honestly unless the Dr indicates he should consume it then I wouldn't give it to him - instead try continuing to encourage the healthier eating habits.
My kids are a healthy weight, daughter is actually slightly underweight but this is not for lack of feeding her quality foods, it's her metabolism is just that quick and we do offer them some dessert at night after dinner, usually they have chosen ice cream or popsicles at the grocery store, and they get soda every once in a while - sadly these days my hubby's been giving it to them more frequently then I'd prefer, but they are very active kids...so I don't worry about it. That being said though, the treats they get are candy once in a blue moon - they prefer the exotic fruit treats vs. the candy/cookies, etc.
What kinds of treats are you giving him?
Can you maybe encourage more active behavior so he metabolizes his food faster?
And, honestly I'd try to encourage him also to eat a balanced breakfast - my daughter doesn't have much of an appetite right after she wakes up, but within about 10 - 15 mins her tummy's talking to her, so she has a choice of cereal or frozen pancakes w/fruit.
I'd talk to the Dr before giving him Whey Protein, his body needs more nutrients and calorie dense foods than our adult bodies do because he's still growing.0 -
As long as he's not eating it exclusively, I think that it's a nonissue.0
-
Don't know that it's any different than giving him some of the breakfast "shakes" designed for kids (Carnation, etc), nutrition-wise. If he likes the taste, and it's not an exclusive thing, than eh, not sure I see any harm.0
-
I thought of those breakfast shakes, too. At first I was thinking that it sounded like a bad plan, but if he likes it and thinks it helps then it might be a good idea. The protein powder probably has added vitamins (you could check the label). It's not optimal, but it is a step in the right direction.0
-
I don't think the protein powder is an issue in addition with a healthy diet. If you're concerned about it though, but want him to continue staying full, maybe he needs more protein in the mornings. Peanut butter or eggs are often a good option, and eggs take maybe 5 minutes to cook, or you can hard boil some the night before. He's getting to a peak growing age though and will be putting on a more muscle when he hits puberty, so I'm pretty sure the protein would only be helpful to a growing boy.0
-
If he likes it and it keeps him full, why not? My kids (ages 9-15) have them sometimes. Especially during peaks in sports seasons. Keeps them fuller than cereal or other quick breakfasts.0
-
Whey protein is basically just concentrated dairy products, so there's nothing inherently bad or dangerous about giving it to a child.
As long as you're sure it fits within a calorie-appropriate diet for him, then it should be OK although I'd be more tempted to let him have a glass of chocolate (or whatever flavor your whey protein powder is) milk instead. Whole foods are always better than concentrates whenever possible
0 -
I see no issues with it, and high fives to you for staying consistent with him and showing him healthy choices.0
-
My son who is 11 uses my Herbalife Formula 1 shakes all the time. He loves them! He usually has one for breakfast and then one for an after school snack. He still eats like an normal 11 year old would. He has never been a big candy/ junk food eater so I have been really luck with that. However I have to tell him when to push the plate away, he has no sense of portion control.0
-
Hi,
I wonder what you all think about giving Whey protein powder to a 10 year old boy. My son is not overweight but he is husky. He has horrible eating habits on his own. However, he says I'm mean because I encourage healthy eating habits. I do allow him to eat treats. He gets to pick three junk food items a week. Which he chooses to eat the first two days of the week. So I'm not depriving him. I'm also a busy Mom. Breakfast most days is a challenge because he is just not in the mood to eat. I let him try the Whey Protein Powder I have been having in the mornings and he like it! I didn't see anything on the package that said an age limit on it. He said he stayed full till lunch then stayed full till he got home. Usually he is famished by then.
Anyway what do yall think about giving whey Protein Powder for a 10 year old boy?
If you said, he had an issue with gaining weight, then maybe.
If you had said, he has an issue with getting enough daily protein, then maybe.
but for a husky person..
a Protein drink is not a diet drink.. its not going to shrink him.
If you want him to loose weight. its time for swimming lessons, running lessons, baseball, football etc..
Have him put down the smart phone, or the gaming console and have do something outside.0 -
And, honestly I'd try to encourage him also to eat a balanced breakfast - my daughter doesn't have much of an appetite right after she wakes up, but within about 10 - 15 mins her tummy's talking to her, so she has a choice of cereal or frozen pancakes w/fruit.
^^This. My 10yo daughter doesn't like to eat the second she rolls out of bed at 6:10am, so she packs her school lunch and gets dressed. Those 10-20 minutes make a difference and she eats a little something, usually yogurt and fruit, or a small bowl of cereal, a piece of sprouted grain bread with pb or a whole grain freezer waffle. She is also very conscientious to pack a mid-morning snack(usually pretzel rods and hummus or cheese and crackers), which her teacher gives the class 10 minutes for, since lunch isn't until 12:20 or so.0 -
My son who is 11 uses my Herbalife Formula 1 shakes all the time. He loves them! He usually has one for breakfast and then one for an after school snack. He still eats like an normal 11 year old would. He has never been a big candy/ junk food eater so I have been really luck with that. However I have to tell him when to push the plate away, he has no sense of portion control.
:laugh: Good luck finding any 11 year old boy who has a sense of portion control. All that most growing pre-teens know is "MOAR FOOD! MOAR FOOD!"0 -
I put a few scoops into shakes when I make them for my 12 year old and I... most kids don't get enough protein as it is, so I see no harm in it...
With that said, on a personal level, I don't give him just whey and water, I put other things in the shakes (his reward for physical activity) for nutritional density... while also trying to teach him about healthy eating.0 -
First of all, if he's "not overweight but husky" and he's pre-pubescent I'd say be cautious about anything resembling a "diet." Lots of kids are husky as kids and their body uses that extra weight in puberty as fuel for growth.
That being said, healthy eating habits are great for the whole family. If you're singling him out, no wonder he feels like you're being mean. A whole-family diet makeover may be in store for everyone, and he won't feel like you're being mean because it's about the way "we" are going to eat, as opposed to the way "you" are going to eat.
Regarding whey protein, my 12-year-old takes whey protein during football season, especially during strength and conditioning. We never give it to him in off-days, though. Chances are, you'll notice bold print on the whey protein container that says "this product is not intended as a meal replacement." This is because of whey protein's possible insulinogenic effect and the possibility of high lactose content.
Of course, he said he feels fuller, longer with it, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, then. I'd say if you do continue using whey as a meal replacement, you definitely want to supplement with a multi-vitamin. But is there anything else you can do to create a high-protein / high fiber / low glycemic environment using natural foods (chicken breast, lots of vegetables and whole grains, easy on the carbs) without resorting to whey protein?0 -
This thread makes me so sad. How about just giving them a balanced diet yep I know a pretty off the wall idea but it's worked for children for generations so maybe it could work now0
-
I make yogurt smoothies for my boys (6 & 8) for snacks and put protein powder in it. They've had no issues. Also, sometimes they eat my Zone Perfect or Quest bars as snacks.0
-
My son who is 11 uses my Herbalife Formula 1 shakes all the time. He loves them! He usually has one for breakfast and then one for an after school snack. He still eats like an normal 11 year old would. He has never been a big candy/ junk food eater so I have been really luck with that. However I have to tell him when to push the plate away, he has no sense of portion control.
:laugh: Good luck finding any 11 year old boy who has a sense of portion control. All that most growing pre-teens know is "MOAR FOOD! MOAR FOOD!"
Very True, they are like bottomless pits!!0 -
Perhaps do a green smoothie for him, if you're concerned about nutrients?
Light tasting green, such as spinach
Liquid of choice (water, almond milk, milk, etc)
Protein powder
Nut butter, fruit, or other items to add some body and other flavor
Ice
This gives him the protein as well as some fiber and micronutrients. In effect, he's eating healthier, without it being as much of a fight, and he gets a good, reasonably balanced breakfast.
That said, if it's a bust, it's not a big deal. If the protein shake's enough for him in the morning and he's eating a good lunch and dinner, then I agree with the others -- it's a non-issue. Some people just can't do breakfast very well.0 -
Just fyi that most protein shakes are classified as a food supplements and therefore are not regulated by the FDA.0
-
How about just giving them a balanced diet
Are you insinuating that a balanced diet necessarily excludes whey protein?0 -
I don't think the protein powder is an issue in addition with a healthy diet. If you're concerned about it though, but want him to continue staying full, maybe he needs more protein in the mornings. Peanut butter or eggs are often a good option, and eggs take maybe 5 minutes to cook, or you can hard boil some the night before. He's getting to a peak growing age though and will be putting on a more muscle when he hits puberty, so I'm pretty sure the protein would only be helpful to a growing boy.
Speaking of peak growing age, my son who will be 12 in a little over a month, has shot up about 4" this year (with 4 months to go), and is now 1/8" shy of 5'5" and wears a men's 9.5 running shoe. However, I cannot get weight on him. He eats plenty, but weighs a whopping 93lbs of gorgeous scrawniness, lol. I occasionally bulk up his yogurt (and the other kids, particularly my 14yo freshman volleyball player who engages in a good 10+ hrs of hard physical activity a week) with protein powder, as an ADDITION to a balanced diet.
So, my opinion is... real food first, protein powder as it's meant to be used, as a supplement, not replacement.0 -
My son is 4. About once a week he asks for a "milkshake" for breakfast. This consists of a scoop of protein powder, a full banana, and a little ice. He loves it and thinks it's a special treat.
I wouldn't let him have that every day but I don't see anything wrong with it for your son on occasion. Maybe one or two days a week for breakfast. It's a lot better than sending him off with a pop tart and if it keeps him full and happy until lunch then he can worry about learning instead of his belly. :-)0 -
I share a protein shake with my 4 year old almost every morning. The girl loves it! She eats a well balanced diet. I am happy she drinks them with me!0
-
Double check with his doctor. I don't see how it could hurt - but I wouldn't recommend letting him drink it without a doctors okay.0
-
This thread makes me so sad. How about just giving them a balanced diet yep I know a pretty off the wall idea but it's worked for children for generations so maybe it could work now
Perhaps because he seems to refuse to eat most things she's tried?
If it comes down to a protein shake or Twinkies/chips/soda/whatever he can get his hands on on the way to/at school for breakfast, I'll give my kid the protein shake any day.0 -
I'm not a child nutritionist but I don't think this is necessary for a 10 year old. I would speak with a child nutritionist if you are concerned about your child's macro targets.
If you want your kid to not be fat I recommend keeping them active and not on the xbox all day. After school sports and activities can help with that.0 -
I will agree that a nutritionally balanced diet is the correct path but I see no issue in whey protein shakes. Ensure you read the label to ensure that you are giving him what you think you are giving him. Setting a good example with your diet and exercise is always a good move but not always taken by children. They like what tastes good and that more times then not is food that is bad for us. Look for alternatives to help him get on the correct path. I give my 10 year old whey protein to help him gain for football. Unfortunately for him, he has my metabolism which burns everything and keeps him thin.0
-
I give my four year old son Vega One protein powder in his milks one to three times a day because he's a picky eater. I think it's good for him, and I wouldn't worry about it too much. I would just make sure you're getting good quality protein powder.0
-
Protein powder is just another source of food. It is not medicine. It is only called a nutrition supplement for marketing purposes. It is a food product like any other. I don't see anything wrong with it at all.
But I would suggest consulting with your pediatrician before making it part of his diet. Just simply because this is the internet and it really isn't the place to discuss health concerns.0 -
Pediasure....its almost the same thing, but geared towards children. They have one to gain weight and one to help with those children who have unhealthy eating habits. Its full of vitamins and may do the same for him. I used to give it to my daughter when she was little and didn't want to eat an actual breakfast (eggs, toast, etc) I always encouraged food with it. They come in a few different flavors too.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions