Worst doctors visit EVER! In tears

13

Replies

  • Crowhorse
    Crowhorse Posts: 394 Member
    A good doctor truly listens to the patient. A good doctor also tells you what you need to hear, even if you don't like it. A good doctor will try to get down to the root of a problem and not just diagnose the symptoms.

    This doctor is NOT a good doctor, and the suggestion of one meal a day pretty much proves it. What did he get in medical school...a "C" average?

    I would try to find another doctor, if you are able to.
  • I am soooo sorry you had to endure that. Clearly that doctor missed his training on how to treat his patients with compassion, and that is terrible. Nobody deserves to be treated like that. I personally would not waste any time filing a complaint and then moving on getting a second opinion and a doctor who actually cares about his patients.

    I remember years ago, my mother went to a walk in clinic b/c she somehow managed to get a chemical burn on her chest, and all her doctor could say is "have you ever considered weight loss surgery and a breast reduction?" Clearly that was not why she was there, but talk about unprofessional.

    You deserve better...there are fantastic doctors out there, your goal: FIND ONE :)

    i walked out in tears, wishing i could call my childrens pedi. i was thinking "is 20 still considered a "child"?! lol i love their pedi and wish he was a family doctor. he is amazing
  • Crowhorse
    Crowhorse Posts: 394 Member
    I am soooo sorry you had to endure that. Clearly that doctor missed his training on how to treat his patients with compassion, and that is terrible. Nobody deserves to be treated like that. I personally would not waste any time filing a complaint and then moving on getting a second opinion and a doctor who actually cares about his patients.

    I remember years ago, my mother went to a walk in clinic b/c she somehow managed to get a chemical burn on her chest, and all her doctor could say is "have you ever considered weight loss surgery and a breast reduction?" Clearly that was not why she was there, but talk about unprofessional.

    You deserve better...there are fantastic doctors out there, your goal: FIND ONE :)

    i walked out in tears, wishing i could call my childrens pedi. i was thinking "is 20 still considered a "child"?! lol i love their pedi and wish he was a family doctor. he is amazing

    Maybe they could recommend a good doctor for you.
  • That's terrible, and you should file a complaint with the state. Also, look at your insurance records and specifically how he codes and bills for this visit. It sounds like he did not do any type of decent exam, but I'm sure he is going to bill for a level of visit that MUST include a physical exam. You can notify and complain to the insurance and ding him for fraud. Hit him where it counts... $$$. Sorry you had this bad experience.. we aren't all like that. =)



    Great advice from DocRunner! Follow through on it......then find a new doctor. It's just plain rude ignorance for a "professional" to treat you that way. B-)
  • kwardklinck
    kwardklinck Posts: 1,601
    Um stupid. He said eat one meal a day but don't lose more than 2 pounds a month? How is that even possible? That's like eating a whole lot of calories at one sitting every day and that's not good for your stomach. I'd say find a new doctor. He's ridiculous.
  • What an idiot... He knows nothing about health and fitness.. I was so sadden for you. He's not a real Dr. thats for sure. I would do something about it.. He needs to be turned in. I wish you the best and hang in there you will be ok..

    SusieQ
  • He might have thought you were after pain meds... what kind of doctor was this, a family/general or specialist?
    family doctor. and yes, at one point he tried saying that he was trying to get me to do a squat because "if the patient does it, or attempts it- they are faking" that makes no since. whether someone was after pain meds to not, anyone smarter then a rock knows that
    "hmm if im claiming my knees hurt- i better not tell him i can do squats!"

    but no i wasnt after pain meds. i dont even like taking tylenol! i hate pills and i avoid them if at all possible!
  • Do you mind if I ask what kind of insurnace coverage you're using?
    oh this was a family doctor. and right now i have sooner care (state insurance) because i was recently laid off.
  • Flacachica
    Flacachica Posts: 328 Member
    Chin up! You know what's best for you... and by all means GET A DIFFERENT DOCTOR! I'm so sorry you had to go through that. Good luck!
  • janemartin02
    janemartin02 Posts: 2,653 Member
    Sounds like a real quack.What dr in their right mind would suggest 1 meal a day.That is definetly NOT healthy.I would definetly find a new dr.weight might be an issue with your knees,but what he did and said was unprofessional.Some drs are so insensitve and don`t belong in the medical field.Good luck.
    jane
  • thedestar
    thedestar Posts: 1,275 Member
    OMG what a dirt bag!!! I agree with everyone else, find a new dr. and REPORT him! And have a little "me time" to feel better :blushing:
  • candlegal
    candlegal Posts: 220 Member
    I am also sooooo sorry you had to go through this terrible experience!!! Any "Doctor" who recommends that you eat ONE meal a day is a BAD! doctor! I'm sorry but that is the most rediculous advice that a anyone should EVER give someone who wants to lose weight! How stupid is this guy, I'm not even going to refer to him as a doctor. Yes you should report his advice that he gave you!
    Don't let this bad experience throw you off your weight loss game though. For sure go to a new doc. You should go to a orthopedic specialist, if your insurance allows, skip the family practice docs.

    I wish you the best of luck with everything!!! Again so sorry you had to go through that and with your little kids there too!!!

    Take care, put that knee up maybe some ice. Sounds like you could at the least use an X-ray or MRI.
  • Oh girl, what a crappy crappy doctor! He has no right telling you that you are overweight and that you should only eat one meal. I would be sooooooo upset at him too. Like everyone else said, find another doctor. Enjoy the weekend and try not to stress about this. He's just a Jack A who has no clue what he's doing. You are a awesome person and a great mother. Now, you have a great weekend with those kiddos!! :o)
  • Marll
    Marll Posts: 904 Member
    A lot of doctors are idiots. It took many, many of them almost 14 years to figure out that a sinus problem I have was actually a condition called "silent reflux". They then tried to blame that on my weight. When I tell them I had the same problems at 175lbs (5' 10" man here btw) they said "That's not likely". They then won't prescribe anything to reduce stomach acid. I found on my own that Hoodia reduces acid by about 40-60%. Started taking that and what do you know....my sinus issues have diminished by about 80-90%!

    Needless to say, find a new doctor.
  • austepants
    austepants Posts: 356 Member
    I think you did great! Despite the moron of a doctor you know your facts and know what you need to do to be healthy. That one meal crap and all the other horrible things he said should be reported!!! He should NOT have a medical license!!!! Go find a new doctor and keep doing what is right and comfortable to you. You are doing amazing don't let crazy people lead you off course!!! Uggggg this is so infuriating to me I'm so sorry you had to go through all this!!!
    :flowerforyou: Keep your head up your AMAZING!!!!
  • annie_p
    annie_p Posts: 319 Member
    You are a hell of a lot better than I am! Of course, as you said, your kids were there. I seriously wouldn't started screaming at him, and then as I was walking out screaming at anyone who would listen, what a POS he is. One meal a day? Are you serious??? No doctor in their right mind would say to only eat one meal a day. And to quit exercising?? Mmmk that sounds reasonable...NOT!

    My doctor touched the subject of my weight lightly, and ONLY if my visit there has something to do with it. With my knees, no one has ever said it was due to my weight. I still have yet to find out what IS in fact wrong with my knees...but it's not my weight.

    Report him, see a new doctor, and hope he gets what's coming to him.
  • Maybe he was grouchy because he had only had one meal that day. :laugh:

    I CANNOT stop...laughing!

    All right, to the OP, you officially rock. I'm so happy to hear that you stood up for yourself and your children! I think you handled it perfectly and that man was obviously in medical school circa 1805! I mean he might as well have said that asbestos cures cancer wtf!!!
    One meal a day? What a complete idiot!

    I am sorry for laughing, my sense of humor..it gets me in trouble but when I read that he was eyeballing your children eating wheat thins and insinuating things I was LMAO because my children are super active, slender as a rail, very very healthy appetites! If my children are the slightest bit hungry they eat like ravenous animals that have been starving for eternity..it's hilarious and embarrassing! HAHA. The fact that he did not recognize even that one relatively often known behavior of children when they get a snack they enjoy he should really consider retiring and trying to solve word puzzles for fun instead of dispensing any kind of advise about anything and particularly medically!!

    I would do as others have suggested re: reporting him to the authorities. I would also endeavor to find out if there is an online site that rates medical professionals in your area and writing your complaint there so people will know to avoid him!
  • AngelUK1985
    AngelUK1985 Posts: 84 Member
    can you report him?
  • F that guy, i would get a second opinion. And report that guy. your doing great. Although till you get a second i would just stick to walking and doing less intense workouts.
  • 30tips
    30tips Posts: 132
    Wow, very bad visit..the good thing about the fact that it´s so bad is that you are allowed to entirely not pay attention to anything he said, and get another doctor! Everyone knows that it´s good to eat several times a day....and a lot of other things he advised you not to do...
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    Maybe I watch too much House, and always think of the diagnosis, but I wonder with the bug bites (they love chomping on me, too) if you might have gotten a tick bite and have some kind of tick borne illness like Lyme Disease. That can start with painful joints and it can flare up long after you've had a bite.
  • manymuses
    manymuses Posts: 162 Member
    OMG!!!
    What a Jacka$$! Write a letter of complaint to the HMO or group that you use. That is appalling lack of care and clearly should not be tolerated.

    In fact, send ME his name and address and I'll write a letter too. That kind of bad karma he is putting out into the universe needs some redress. Immediately. Before he harms anyone else. Evil troll.

    xx to you from me.
  • TakeOne
    TakeOne Posts: 345 Member
    I'm sooo sorry. No one deserves to be treated like that! I agree with what some of the other folks have said, you should report him. What a jerk!! Hang in there :flowerforyou: and def. find a new doctor!
  • CalorieNinja
    CalorieNinja Posts: 645 Member
    Do you mind if I ask what kind of insurnace coverage you're using?
    oh this was a family doctor. and right now i have sooner care (state insurance) because i was recently laid off.

    I will call my step - mom she is in Oklahoma as well and is a PA there in Miami (what location are you, or you could msg. me if you dont want it on the board)
  • tinboy
    tinboy Posts: 121 Member
    I am outraged by his behavior! Unprofessional, negligent, verbally abusive, incorrect about nutrition, a disgrace to his peers, discriminatory, intolerant, and unkind. Not to mention, worse than a waste of time for you and your children. I am so sorry you had this horrible experience. Good for you to stand up for yourself to him. You need a new doctor and a formal complaint towards him. {{hugs}}
  • Briacha
    Briacha Posts: 160 Member
    What an utter and compkete jacka$$. :mad:
    I am sooo sorry you had to go thru that. Definitely file a complaint asap. he is the kind of doctor that may end up killing someone.

    You are doing the right thing. Don't let him get you off your path. :smile:
  • heathercd
    heathercd Posts: 20 Member
    Wow. That is insane. I would have done more than walk out and yell, yes even with my 2 young boys with me lol. You are strong. Definitely do what everyone else is telling you to do. File a complaint. But also. Was this in a "clinic" . You know, several doctors and such seeing tons of patients a day? If so (i use to work in one) complain to the Clinic Manager. The man/woman who runs the show. Show them your blog, write a very long descriptive letter of how emotionally hurt you were and how this "medical" Doctor showed NO bedside manner, and aggressively insisted on not helping you diagnose and treat your medical issue. If this was his own private practice, definitely contact the state medical board and keep going until you get results. He is clearly not good at his job and does not deserve to be seeing patients! It just makes me so mad because at the clinic I use to work at we had a doctor like that, and with just 2 or 3 similar complaints like yours he was quickly fired.... Your healthy lifestyle changes seem like they are the good things to be doing... So just keep them up!

    Just wanted to say that as a nurse of nearly 8 years, I second this!!! I'm so sorry you had to go through such abuse. Sounds like you handled it with grace, self-confidence and pride!! There have been lawsuits for less than this in regards to "weightism", where physicians refuse to see the patient as a whole being and simply see them for a number on the stupid scale. Stick it to him, girl!! :explode:
  • InMyJeans
    InMyJeans Posts: 87 Member
    Oh My Gosh! Im not sure if I would've kept my cool in that situation. Where did he get his degree from, suggesting one meal a day and losing 2 pounds a month? =/ I don't have my doctorates but you don't need one to know thats not right. SMDH. I am so sorry that happened to you. He needs to work on his bedside manner.
  • OMG! that is horrible!!! Report him!! And I would call everyone papers and everything.... how dare he?? I think you were a lot calmer than I would have been.... f that. Stupid people!!! I had the same problem with my knees and the shred the first few days. I took a weeks break and started taking glucosamine chondroitin (sp? it's for joints), and walked. It worked, they still hurt a little if I do to much jumping, but no where's near as bad! They say it takes a bout a month for them to completely stop with the vitamins : )
  • You are a hell of a lot better than I am! Of course, as you said, your kids were there. I seriously wouldn't started screaming at him, and then as I was walking out screaming at anyone who would listen, what a POS he is. One meal a day? Are you serious??? No doctor in their right mind would say to only eat one meal a day. And to quit exercising?? Mmmk that sounds reasonable...NOT!

    My doctor touched the subject of my weight lightly, and ONLY if my visit there has something to do with it. With my knees, no one has ever said it was due to my weight. I still have yet to find out what IS in fact wrong with my knees...but it's not my weight.

    Report him, see a new doctor, and hope he gets what's coming to him.

    i could understand if there was no logical reason behind the issue. (not working out or trying to lose weight- no family history of joint problems, if i wasnt knock kneed) then sure. if all you can come up with is weight- fine be honest! "i dont know what is causing your pain. but itd be beneficial to lose some weight. in the mean time lets get a MRI and make sure there is nothing torn in there" or something like that!
    but my father is 42 and has had 4 hip replacements (same hip), and has bad knees as well. there are several things that could be causing these issues. and again, im trying to lose the weight! humiliating me (or trying to- im been called a fat *kitten* too many times to be affected by it any more) and making it seem as if i am not doing anything to fix the problem, is uncalled for!
This discussion has been closed.