recording calories on bad days

shaunshaikh
shaunshaikh Posts: 616 Member
edited September 24 in Health and Weight Loss
Hey guys! I started a few weeks ago, and have been extremely diligent about logging everything. the only time I didnt log, was the super bowl, because it was just too difficult to remember everything and quantify it. Well I just got a friend at work to join, and I don't think she is completely into it yet. She had a "bad" day today at lunch, so she said she didnt want to log her food for the day. I think it is important to log no matter what, that way it makes you more aware of what you are eating and therefore, more accountable. What are your opinions on logging food for days that you know you have gone over?
«1

Replies

  • mamagooskie
    mamagooskie Posts: 2,964 Member
    sometimes I log them sometimes I don't. I've had some 4000-7000 calorie days I've logged and some I know were up there but it was too hard to log (maybe I drank too much and can't remember everything LOL.....or hit a buffet a bit too hard)

    but I like to be accountable as often as I can.
  • Losing2Live69
    Losing2Live69 Posts: 743 Member
    Part of recovery (from an unhealthy lifestyle) is honesty and accountability.
  • I'd log it just to see how much you over did it, however your friend shouldn't let it get them down, we all have a few bumps on the trail :smile:
  • kacarter1017
    kacarter1017 Posts: 651 Member
    I think it's important to log every day, even if it was a "bad" day. Valuable lessons can be learned about eating habits, which categories were way over (carbs, fat, etc).
  • JaneZv
    JaneZv Posts: 200
    Part of recovery (from an unhealthy lifestyle) is honesty and accountability.

    I agree. I log my food even on bad days and not logging it doesn't mean it didn't happen. I've eaten 6,000 calories in a day :embarassed: and i log that too lol. The only time i didn't log was during a road trip where i ate whole bunch of miscellaneous junk food making it impossible to quantify.
  • maffydavison
    maffydavison Posts: 51 Member
    I made a promise to myself to log everything. I've had bad days where all the totals are in red because I went over my plan, but that's the way it goes. I weigh in now once a week, too - and log it. Last time, I went up; this time I'm down lower than ever before. It is reassuring to me to see the results of good behavior and bad behavior, and my progress report is more accurate. I'm not on a straight path - I'm human, make mistakes, and sometimes even do the right thing. It's okay if I inch up and down a little on the path to my goal. It's all me; it's all good; it's all part of the process.

    I know what you mean about superbowl, though. I couldn't figure out HOW to log it. I knew the big things, but there was a whole lot of munching going on... In general, though, I log good and bad.
  • jrbanta
    jrbanta Posts: 4,394 Member
    I log every day no matter what I eat. I'm afraid if I miss a day I may get out of my routine and start to slide down hill from the new habits I'm establishing.
  • Pandorian
    Pandorian Posts: 2,055 Member
    Yeah, I have to log them good or bad days. It helps me when I go back to look at progress (or lack thereof) and can spot a particular bad day with a low loss on weigh-in day.

    I've had a couple bad days, they tend to be days where I eat meals out instead of prepared at home. So just pushes me more to prepare meals at home, easier on my calorie goals, easier on the budget and I get ticked at restaurants where things are made their way only. Tried to get a club sandwich with the mayo on the side, but nope, so they won't get my business in the future.

    But for me I have to record every day, be it good, or bad, like yesterdays... what 600 calorie day? Was ill and couldn't keep anything down. Today is back on track.
  • In all honesty, I log SOME bad days, and others I just dont.
    I think its important to log on bad days tho. In a way it makes me feel better to quantify it all and see it "written on paper."
  • TonysMiss
    TonysMiss Posts: 128 Member
    I say log it!! No one on here is going to be judging because we are all on here for the same reason. :smile: Doesn't matter how much or how little we want to loose. Logging it will keep you accountable to yourself...........
    I made a dish for dinner last night that I didn't want to put all the work into putting it "in' so I just did the "quick add" and it at least still gives you something. Something is better than nothing, right?
  • EricInArlington
    EricInArlington Posts: 531 Member
    I do them all, if not why would you even waste your time on MFP? other people looking at my food keeps me in line :)
  • ajbeans
    ajbeans Posts: 2,857 Member
    I always do my best to log bad days as well as good days. It keeps me in line. There are times that I don't know exactly how much I ate, but in that case I'll do a quick add calories and just estimate what I think I might have eaten.
  • MakingAChoice
    MakingAChoice Posts: 481 Member
    I log everything, period. If I ever have a bad day that was my choice and I should be willing to accept my choice, not try to hide from it. Being honest with yourself is very important if you want to succeed.
  • MakingAChoice
    MakingAChoice Posts: 481 Member
    I do them all, if not why would you even waste your time on MFP? other people looking at my food keeps me in line :)

    Exactly, that is one of the reasons my food log is public to everyone. Keeps me honest ;-)
  • jsheph1
    jsheph1 Posts: 79 Member
    I went over today by 650 calories. I am glad I logged because I learned a lesson. I went to a seminar during the day and ate lunch with a buddy. I then went on a date tonight and got a three course meal. I kind of learned that if I am going on a date I should go as low calorie as possible for lunch, because I don't want to look like a sissy on my date and get a salad.
  • miovlb6
    miovlb6 Posts: 339 Member
    I log it all--the good days and the bad--for a couple of reasons. Mainly, because I know myself, and if I start letting the bad days "not count" I'll have more and more bad days. Also, logging it all keeps me mentally aware of every bite that goes into my mouth so there's no mindless eating to trip me up. Logging the bad days also helps if I want to look back and see trends--to see how those bad days affect my progress, if at all. And, I know it's silly, but often, when I'm craving something I know I shouldn't eat, just telling myself that I'm going to have to log it will keep me from eating it.

    However, if skipping a day where she was off track will help your friend to stick with this, then that's what she needs to do. Everybody's different.
  • Nigel99
    Nigel99 Posts: 498 Member
    I haven't really had any bad days thus far, but when one happens, I plan on logging it in my diary. Have to see exactly what the damage was, and remind myself what a bad day looks like in the diary.
  • Mariposa187
    Mariposa187 Posts: 344 Member
    i take a deep breath and log everything... i tend to do better when i know that my friends on here will tell me to be more aware and try to do better. I was hesitant at first but to make thechanges you really have to do it or else itis like you are closest eating...
  • stormieweather
    stormieweather Posts: 2,549 Member
    I log every bite. I don't cheat, but I do have days where I allow myself to eat up to maintenance (4x since Jan 4th). Cheating and not logging could very well eliminate my hard earned deficit, why would I not be honest with myself?

    Also, since I've been graphing my calorie deficits and weight loss, I'm simply unwilling to screw up what's working great.
  • I tend not to log a cheat day, mostly cause it defeats the purpose of a cheat day, but I've been really on my game since I joined.
  • monylove311
    monylove311 Posts: 251 Member
    It's ok to have a "bad" day. Though I call them load up days which I think are good once every week or two. I think its up to you to log or not on that day. I have done both. I'll think on that one some more about why I've done both. Thanks for the food for thought. : ) Monica
  • k2d4p
    k2d4p Posts: 441 Member
    Not logging it doesn't change the fact that it happened. If a person doesn't want to face what they eat, then in my opinion, they are not ready to change it.

    (Sorry, I am of the tough love mentality.)
  • sugarbeans
    sugarbeans Posts: 676 Member
    I personally record everything. It makes you more accountable and if you had a bad week you can look back and say "oh yeah I had such and such a day"

    A week ago my friend and I went to Olive Garden I forgot how horrible the food is in terms of a caloric hit. My meal was almost 2 days worth of calories and I went there starving so I ate everything(stomach felt horrible after). Normally I save half and take it home (usually it gets tossed cause I forget about it or I enter it and say Nah don't need that).

    After doing MFP for a couple of months and eating healthy you forget what restaurants can do to you in terms of serving sizes. A year and a half ago Olive Garden meal wouldn't have phased me much.. today? wow too much food.
    Anyways enough ranting the point is that if you log in everyday and you are honest with it, you can look back and see the accomplishments in the journaling as well as weight loss.

    I haven't "lost" any weight since I've joined, I have lost inches and looking back at my food journal I can see where I've made improvements and where I still need to improve.
  • zorbaru
    zorbaru Posts: 1,077 Member
    the worst day i have had since i started was about 2500 calories, and i logged it all.

    was bit hard to be accurate cos we went to a buffet, so it was a bit of this and a bit of that. im not super fussy about accuracy tho. as long as im around the mark im happy.
  • CatseyeHardcast
    CatseyeHardcast Posts: 224 Member
    Log it. Who cares if we blow out now and then. (Says this after a lunch full of beer)
  • emott84
    emott84 Posts: 108
    I say log it if you can so you feel accountable to it, but don't stress about it too much.
    I just logged a dinner at Applebees that brought me almost 1000 calories over my goal and I literally cringed as I did it, but I can't erase it. But I still gotta live (but maybe shouldn't have the cheeseburger next time :tongue: )!!
  • thektturner
    thektturner Posts: 228 Member
    If logging bad days is going to make you obsess over it and feel guilty, then I'd say don't. Better not to dwell on the bad and then start the cycle of "I'm depressed, so I'll eat, cause it doesn't matter anymore". For some people, that is how their minds work.

    I log my "off" days (which I schedule and do on purpose) so that I can see that i didn't go beyond what I wanted and just out of curiosity so I can see what typical meals used to be like for me. Makes me feel a whole lot better about what I'm eating now.
  • blessedwith3boys
    blessedwith3boys Posts: 136 Member
    I think it's important to be honest and for myself I do log bad days to show accountablity. For instance today I ate pretty much nothing but crap but stayed up later to burn off more calories. I coud see in black and white what I needed to do. If I went over by thousands of calories, then I was still log it but just start over fresh the next day.
  • LHarders
    LHarders Posts: 28 Member
    It is important to log everyday GOOD or BAD.....it holds you accountable and in the months ahead you will have something to track...I have doubled my recommended calories in one night easy to do with a couple of drinks and snack foods that you just have to try each one :) Anyway logging on daily keeps your mind in the game.....it isn't always going to be easy. But MFP plan has been wonderful!!!!
  • dconner13
    dconner13 Posts: 25 Member
    I log everything. Good and bad. And sometimes on my bad days I find it wasn't as bad as I thought! Like today. I had two Fatburgers and I thought I had done TERRIBLE! It wasn't good but not as bad as I was expecting. Besides we are not on here to be perfect. We are here to learn and be healthy. And if your not honest with yourself and your weight loss buddies. Then you won't learn a damn thing! We all have bad days, (sometimes more often than not) we are human. But not logging certain foods or on days you over indulge is not fooling your *kitten* or waistline.
This discussion has been closed.