how many know this?

krystleRD
krystleRD Posts: 188 Member
edited September 25 in Health and Weight Loss
When we first start losing weight, we are losing water weight... I wonder how many MFP knows this

Replies

  • Newmammaluv
    Newmammaluv Posts: 379 Member
    That's what they say but this is my take on it... if it's excess and I need to lose it first before I lose anything else it still counts towards my goal. So even when someone says a nice backhanded compliment like "wow great job losing 10lbs!! I bet it was all water weight!" I just smile and say, "even so, it had to go!"
  • Sarahr73
    Sarahr73 Posts: 454 Member
    Yup, that's why most people drop so much right away. It can be misleading if people don't know it before they start. I lost 6 pounds in about three weeks, I am sure most was water weight, but that's ok, it gets me closer to me goal!
  • ScarletFyre
    ScarletFyre Posts: 754 Member
    I dont think i realized it was necesarily water, but i knew the "jumpstart" weight loss was not typical and was something that went quick right at the beginning only...i agree with the one post...either way it's weight, as long as you know it's not typical and dont get dissapointed when the loss slows a bit. for many people that first bigger drop in weight is a great motivator. :smile:
  • melsinct
    melsinct Posts: 3,512 Member
    Can someone explain to me why it is all water? I am not sure if I buy this. It may be true for someone who ate total crap before starting their weight loss (e.g. all processed, fast foods with tons of sodium) but otherwise, I am not so sure. I have eaten healthy for years consuming minimal amounts of processed foods and making most things from scratch. Needless to say my sodium intake isn't a problem. I just ate too big of portions. I have also always drank water and lots of it (I don't like sugary drinks). Why did I lose a lot of water weight at first? It just doesn't make sense scientifically to me. Can someone spell it out for me? Thanks!
  • ShellyMacchi
    ShellyMacchi Posts: 975 Member
    yup.. every weight plan, Dr, nutritionist, trainer .. even on Heavy last night *L* i would have thought it was pretty common knowledge for those of us who been battling weight any length of time, first week is almost always a bigger loss because is mostly water weight lost.
  • cbirdso
    cbirdso Posts: 465 Member
    That's what they say but this is my take on it... if it's excess and I need to lose it first before I lose anything else it still counts towards my goal. So even when someone says a nice backhanded compliment like "wow great job losing 10lbs!! I bet it was all water weight!" I just smile and say, "even so, it had to go!"

    Absolutely! The water resides in the fat cells and needs to go before you can work on reducing the fat! It may be water, but it weighs like fat, looks like fat and feels like fat.
  • SongbirdLandy
    SongbirdLandy Posts: 188 Member
    I lost 20 lbs my first month! LOL! And I knew it was a lot of water weight. But I've lost about 8 to 10 lbs every month after. THAT was fat! WOOT!
  • SMJohnson27
    SMJohnson27 Posts: 146 Member
    Sure did. I lost 9 pounds in the first 6 days. I knew it was from water, but that was almost 25% of my weight lose goal, so I was happy! Water or fat-I'll take it!!
  • aristel
    aristel Posts: 110
    that´s why you lose weight fast in the beginning, cause is water
  • writtenINthestars
    writtenINthestars Posts: 1,933 Member
    Yeah I figure water or not...it still contributed to my overall weight in numbers...so loss of water or not, it still reducuction in my weight.
  • krystleRD
    krystleRD Posts: 188 Member
    Can someone explain to me why it is all water? I am not sure if I buy this. It may be true for someone who ate total crap before starting their weight loss (e.g. all processed, fast foods with tons of sodium) but otherwise, I am not so sure. I have eaten healthy for years consuming minimal amounts of processed foods and making most things from scratch. Needless to say my sodium intake isn't a problem. I just ate too big of portions. I have also always drank water and lots of it (I don't like sugary drinks). Why did I lose a lot of water weight at first? It just doesn't make sense scientifically to me. Can someone spell it out for me? Thanks!



    losing weight its inevitable that water will make up some of the weight loss. No matter how we lose weight or how long the weight loss takes, everyone will lose water.

    Many factors determine the amount of water we lose in comparison to fat loss, they include:

    •which exercise is selected

    •the diet chosen - for example, a low carb diet may increase water loss

    •calorie intake - lowering calorie intake too much will cause more water loss

    •the physical state of the person - the amount of protein and carb stores before new diet



    The water weight loss comes from a net loss of protein and carbohydrates especially during the first few weeks of a reduction in calories. On reducing calories the body needs to rely more on energy within the body and thus breaks down protein and carbohydrate for metabolism. When these nutrients are metabolised water is released. Fat stores do supply a little of the energy but , at first , a good proportion comes from protein and the limited stores of carbohydrates within the cells.



    Read more: http://www.weightlossforall.com/losing-water-weight.htm#ixzz1BO8BRc4k
    Ever wanted to lose weight? Try This Diet Solution

    I hope this helps!
    -misscnj sparkppl
  • I think we all know it and are still thrilled to see the scale go DOWN. Am I the ONLY one who wears my lightest clothes to the doctor, or any other place where weighing is involved?

    It is all good. Hooray for us.
  • cbirdso
    cbirdso Posts: 465 Member
    Can someone explain to me why it is all water? I am not sure if I buy this. It may be true for someone who ate total crap before starting their weight loss (e.g. all processed, fast foods with tons of sodium) but otherwise, I am not so sure. I have eaten healthy for years consuming minimal amounts of processed foods and making most things from scratch. Needless to say my sodium intake isn't a problem. I just ate too big of portions. I have also always drank water and lots of it (I don't like sugary drinks). Why did I lose a lot of water weight at first? It just doesn't make sense scientifically to me. Can someone spell it out for me? Thanks!

    Not everyone is subject to the same level of inflammation. Inflammation can be caused by your own hormones even if you are doing everything correct. A good way to tell how much your own body holds on to water is to see how much your weight fluctuates during the day. If it is pretty steady, you don't hold much, but if throughout the day you can see a swing of 5 lbs or more, you have to be much more aware of keeping sodium and stress levels in check in order to actually lose fat.
  • krystleRD
    krystleRD Posts: 188 Member
    I agree either way it needs to come.. water gain is just as bad as weight gain.. it dont matter how healthy you are u still have water gain
  • Jenn728
    Jenn728 Posts: 683 Member
    I was watching 'Heavy' the other night and the guy lost like 30-something pounds in the first week. I asked my guy how in the world is this possible and his answer...water weight...crazy!
  • spcopps
    spcopps Posts: 283
    I knew most weight loss at the beginning was water but does anyone know how long this goes on? I know some will always be water but when does it start to cycle down??
  • krystleRD
    krystleRD Posts: 188 Member
    I knew most weight loss at the beginning was water but does anyone know how long this goes on? I know some will always be water but when does it start to cycle down??

    . You really do not want to lose that muscle you gained because it will continue to help you lose weight. As time goes by ALWAYS change what you are doing through cardio & weight training. Keep adding to that weight, keep doing different things with cardio too. This will helps you to continue to lose fat and gain muscle without any plateas, or very few.


    1. The absolute best way to know is to include weight lifting in your fat loss diet.

    Then, if your strength (the weights you lift) stay the same OR increase as the weeks go by you will know 100% that you are maintaining your muscle and/or gaining muscle. If your strength goes down as the weeks pass, you are losing muscle.

    2. The best way to tell is to use a bio-electrical impedance device that measures bodyfat percentage. You can get these for around $50.00 on Amazon. They are pretty accurate
  • astovey
    astovey Posts: 578 Member
    I had a couple of people say "it's just water weight" when I first started loosing weight...WHAT NOW?! lol

    As I understood it, when you have a lot of sodium in your diet your body retains water to help with blood flow.
  • melsinct
    melsinct Posts: 3,512 Member
    Thanks for explaining the water weight thing, now it makes more sense! I guess I don't hold on to much water as my weight usually only fluctuates around a pound or pound and a half during the day.
  • rosieflo
    rosieflo Posts: 218
    That's what they say but this is my take on it... if it's excess and I need to lose it first before I lose anything else it still counts towards my goal. So even when someone says a nice backhanded compliment like "wow great job losing 10lbs!! I bet it was all water weight!" I just smile and say, "even so, it had to go!"
    I LOVE YOUR TAKE ON THINGS! :)
  • Jennyzfit
    Jennyzfit Posts: 175 Member
    Sorry I don't buy into this. If we all lost water weight wouldn't we become dehyrated? You can still lose extra weight when you drink your water. :flowerforyou:
  • Newmammaluv
    Newmammaluv Posts: 379 Member
    Imgine GAINING that much weight just as fast?? Women who have retained water during their pregnancy can attest to how horrifying THOSE numbers can be!! I gained 32lbs in the last 3 weeks of my pregnancy before they ultimately enduced me! I lost it all almost just as fast too without any dieting what so ever.
  • PrairieRoseNE
    PrairieRoseNE Posts: 265 Member
    I think we all know it and are still thrilled to see the scale go DOWN. Am I the ONLY one who wears my lightest clothes to the doctor, or any other place where weighing is involved?

    It is all good. Hooray for us.


    I make sure to take off as much clothing as possible without getting naked, when weighing at the Dr's office. Definitely no shoes or belt or excess jewelry! LOL
    And when I weigh at the Fitness Center in the privacy cubicle - it's down to just skivvies - LOL
  • shreddingit
    shreddingit Posts: 1,133 Member
    i know!!...
This discussion has been closed.