Fitted Running Shoes – worth the money?

LoganScottsMom
LoganScottsMom Posts: 112 Member
edited September 25 in Fitness and Exercise
Okay, I’m trying to decide if I should fork out the $100 for shoes plus the $50 for inserts for a pair of running shoes. I wouldn’t call myself a runner, but I want to be. Over the weekend I ran a 5k (first time I ran in a month), and my shins are killing me. OKAY – the shoes I ran in are YEARS old. Typically, I don’t have any issues. When I run, I will run on pavement/streets in my neighborhood. If and when I run, I’ll run about two miles but hope to start doing three miles at least three times a week.

I went to get fitted for running shoes at lunch. I was told I had “neutral” feet. So, WTH? Can I just go buy a pair of running shoes from Academy and pay about $80 and call it a day?

I’ve got two friends on MFP…and I know… they will tell me to fork out the money. BUT, just wanted stranger’s opinion. 

Replies

  • michelletyler38
    michelletyler38 Posts: 469 Member
    EXTREMELY worth it to get fitted for shoes!
  • Pandorian
    Pandorian Posts: 2,055 Member
    I've not gone for them but I WILL go for a proper measurement before my next investment in a bicycle so properly fitted running shoes would be something I'd consider worth it, proper fitting for you means you're going to be comfortable using it and therefore should continue with use.
  • michelletyler38
    michelletyler38 Posts: 469 Member
    Okay, I’m trying to decide if I should fork out the $100 for shoes plus the $50 for inserts for a pair of running shoes. I wouldn’t call myself a runner, but I want to be. Over the weekend I ran a 5k (first time I ran in a month), and my shins are killing me. OKAY – the shoes I ran in are YEARS old. Typically, I don’t have any issues. When I run, I will run on pavement/streets in my neighborhood. If and when I run, I’ll run about two miles but hope to start doing three miles at least three times a week.

    I went to get fitted for running shoes at lunch. I was told I had “neutral” feet. So, WTH? Can I just go buy a pair of running shoes from Academy and pay about $80 and call it a day?

    I’ve got two friends on MFP…and I know… they will tell me to fork out the money. BUT, just wanted stranger’s opinion. 

    I got fitted for shoes & bought them from the place & it was only $90. Just let them know your budget & they should work with you.
  • TashaP2011
    TashaP2011 Posts: 142 Member
    Very worth it!!!!!
  • missie21
    missie21 Posts: 103 Member
    Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo worth the money ...... good luck :wink:
  • eirhtug
    eirhtug Posts: 4
    Look at fivefinger shoes. They are suppose to be the best thing for your feet. The most natural fit.
  • reeldancer
    reeldancer Posts: 156 Member
    ante up. money well spent. but i am unsure why you need an insert as well.
  • 100% worth it!
  • cheermom11
    cheermom11 Posts: 393 Member
    Fork it over :tongue: You won't regret it.
  • tlynnweb
    tlynnweb Posts: 201 Member
    I'm going to play the opposite team here and tell you it's not worth it. I went two different times and was told two different things at the same exact store. I have run in Saucony's for awhile and have no pain what-so=ever! I went to get fitted b/c I wanted to make sure I was in the best shoe. They recommended Brooks to me which gave me extreme leg/back pain. I went on Amazon.com and bought the same Saucony's I've had for $50! I say if you really want to know what they say, go and just buy shoes on your own--they will rip you off!
  • Happy2rwe
    Happy2rwe Posts: 3 Member
    If you go to a running store they will fit you for free and you should be able to save some money. I have some fitted shoes and spent under a hundred bucks.
  • pilotgirl2007
    pilotgirl2007 Posts: 368 Member
    I never went to get fitted until a few years back I decided to go to fleet feet. Turns out they fitted me in the same kinds of shoes that I was buying for myself. I say that since you don't have major pronation problems just find a shoe that is comfy, that is specific for running (ie asics, saucony, etc) make sure it fits your foot properly (not too much room in the toe box but not smooshing your toes either) then take them for a quick jot down the isle a few times and see how they feel. If they feel good then give them a shot.

    Most places will let you take them back if you don't wear them outside so wear them around the house and run around the house to make sure they don't rub or anything before you decide to break them in outside.
  • StacLegg
    StacLegg Posts: 346 Member
    agree, 110% worth the money!!!! =)
  • croutson
    croutson Posts: 9 Member
    I just started running again too. I used to run all the time when I was younger, but now I actually enjoy the feeling after a good run. I I did just put up about $100 for a new pair of running shoes. Money very well spent! They're perfect for my wide but small feet, they're light and super flexible. If you're serious about running, then I encourage you to do it! Running shoes are like any piece of equipment, they need to be taken care of and replaced so that you get the optimum performance or each run. Good luck!
  • chuckyp
    chuckyp Posts: 693 Member
    Went out and bought a pair of running shoes once and screwed my knee up for months after running with them once. And they were good Nikes too, but not right for me. Exchanged them for a pair of Asics which I just replaced after 17 years. (yeah a lot of years but not a lot of miles). This time to be safe I went to Runners Den in Phoenix and got fitted. They looked at the wear on my old shoes and watched me run and fit me into a nice pair of Brooks shoes which are working out very well. It's not worth a potential injury and having to run for 5 months in a knee brace to save yourself $20.
  • babalee
    babalee Posts: 20 Member
    I would not get the inserts without a medical professional's opinion.

    I love my local running store and have purchased many pairs of shoes from them. They "fitted" me many years ago. I found that I actually needed "less shoe" than they suggested...

    If I were you, I would get fitted and make sure you are allowed to "test run" them at the store. If you like them and they feel great, buy them.

    Your shins could be hurting for different reasons. Are you warming up properly? Do you need to stretch after running? (I don't recommend stretching before running).

    Good running shoes are worth the money if they are the right shoe for you.
  • SassyStef
    SassyStef Posts: 413
    this is what I did because I didnt wanna fork it over either lol I went got fitted tried some on, ask question looked at socks and said ok thank you lol and they gave me a 15% off coupon for my next shop.
    So, after I did some online shopping for the shoes they recommended online to see if I could get them cheaper (which I didnt find them) I went back and bought them at the discounted price :)

    Totally worth it you will not regret it!! It is ok to invest in you healthy habits because we always invest in the unhealthy ones :smile:
  • pilotgirl2007
    pilotgirl2007 Posts: 368 Member
    I'm going to play the opposite team here and tell you it's not worth it. I went two different times and was told two different things at the same exact store. I have run in Saucony's for awhile and have no pain what-so=ever! I went to get fitted b/c I wanted to make sure I was in the best shoe. They recommended Brooks to me which gave me extreme leg/back pain. I went on Amazon.com and bought the same Saucony's I've had for $50! I say if you really want to know what they say, go and just buy shoes on your own--they will rip you off!

    Saucony's are my favorite shoes! I did get a pair of mizuno's for trail running and they were like a dream but they are a little light on the arch support.
  • LoganScottsMom
    LoganScottsMom Posts: 112 Member
    I'm going to play the opposite team here and tell you it's not worth it. I went two different times and was told two different things at the same exact store. I have run in Saucony's for awhile and have no pain what-so=ever! I went to get fitted b/c I wanted to make sure I was in the best shoe. They recommended Brooks to me which gave me extreme leg/back pain. I went on Amazon.com and bought the same Saucony's I've had for $50! I say if you really want to know what they say, go and just buy shoes on your own--they will rip you off!

    That's what I'm wondering. Since I wasn't told that I have this major arch or anything.... shouldn't regular shoes be okay? Seriously, the shoes I ran in are probably four years old. If I buy new shoes every 6 months like I should, wouldn't that be enough?
  • In my opinion, getting properly fitted for running shoes is one of the best things you can do for yourself. Even if you have a "neutral" stride, a reputable running store will be able to discuss your options with you and help you make the best decision - and if you tell them you have a particular price point in mind, they should be able to either help you stick to it or explain why the extra money is worth it in certain situations.

    Also, your needs WILL change over time, so going back and getting re-evaluated every so often (especially if you are having new/different pain) is a good idea.
  • I say worth it! Most running stores will fit you for free, then you decide which shoes you want to buy - I've bought shoes from around $80 - $100, not much more than an "over the counter" pair.
    Be on the look out for coupons from Groupon and the like. I saved $50 by buying a $100 certificate for half off - SO worth it!

    For whoever recommended Vibrams: that's what I use now, but you still need to get them fitted. They don't work for every foot shape, especially if you have a second toe longer than your big toe, for instance.
  • LoganScottsMom
    LoganScottsMom Posts: 112 Member
    I would not get the inserts without a medical professional's opinion.

    I love my local running store and have purchased many pairs of shoes from them. They "fitted" me many years ago. I found that I actually needed "less shoe" than they suggested...

    If I were you, I would get fitted and make sure you are allowed to "test run" them at the store. If you like them and they feel great, buy them.

    Your shins could be hurting for different reasons. Are you warming up properly? Do you need to stretch after running? (I don't recommend stretching before running).

    Good running shoes are worth the money if they are the right shoe for you.

    Okay -- I didn't stretch afterwards either.
  • GameOn2011
    GameOn2011 Posts: 73 Member
    You'll only have to do it once, that's all I did. I KNOW what I lke in a running shoe now and I can usually find a decent pair at the sporting goods store!

    Shinn splints...running to far too fast...stretch those calves!
  • rybo
    rybo Posts: 5,424 Member
    If you already know you have a neutral foot, why the inserts?
    You could go to another store to see what they say, and just go from there. If you only beed a neutral/cushioned shoe, then look up the models of shoes that are built that way, try a bunch on & pick one.
  • cmorros
    cmorros Posts: 7 Member
    I've been a long distance runner for over 20 years, and about 5 years ago I finally splurged for the "good" shoes. Definitely worth it!!!! Be sure you ARE fitted by a RUNNING professional, not just some salesperson at the sporting goods store. If you have one in your area, go to a running specialty store (for instance Road Runner Sports) and spend the time to get properly fitted. Good running shoes will run up to $140, but worth it (And don't be surprised that your running shoe size is 1 to 1.5 sizes bigger than your regular shoe - and they SHOULD be bigger. Otherwise you'll get blisters and black nails on your toes.) Good running shoes will DRAMATICALLY decrease any injuries to your toes, feet, ankles, shins, knees etc! Also, you need to replace your running shoes every 400-500 miles and/or at least every four-six months ... the cushioning breaks down (even when you're not wearing them - just sitting in the closet the cushioning begins to dimish). Also, don't wear your running shoes for anything but running - that also lessens the time you should wear them. (But once you've bought your next pair of dedicated running shoes, you can now wear your "old" running shoes when not running - they are the most comfortable shoes you'll own!)

    Once you're fitted, take a jog around the store in the shoes, and keep trying on different shoes until you find the one that feels great out of the box. Running shoes do NOT need breaking in ... they should feel great the first time you lace them up.

    As for inserts, you shouldn't need them unless you have some sort of diagnosed foot/ankle/knee problem. The cushioning and arch support in the shoes should be more than adequate. Having said that, if you have any recurring pain in your feet, go to a podiatrist and get custom fitted orthotics if prescribed. And if you do get orthotics, be sure to tell the fitter than they are going in your running shoes - they'll use a different lining appropriate for sweat. (I do have a diagnosed neuroma and use custom orthotics for all my shoes - that's how I know the difference. I have one for dress shoes and another for my running shoes.)

    I hope this advice from a stranger is helpful! Good luck - and have fun running!
  • Kolohe71
    Kolohe71 Posts: 613 Member
    Okay, I’m trying to decide if I should fork out the $100 for shoes plus the $50 for inserts for a pair of running shoes. I wouldn’t call myself a runner, but I want to be. Over the weekend I ran a 5k (first time I ran in a month), and my shins are killing me. OKAY – the shoes I ran in are YEARS old. Typically, I don’t have any issues. When I run, I will run on pavement/streets in my neighborhood. If and when I run, I’ll run about two miles but hope to start doing three miles at least three times a week.

    I went to get fitted for running shoes at lunch. I was told I had “neutral” feet. So, WTH? Can I just go buy a pair of running shoes from Academy and pay about $80 and call it a day?

    I’ve got two friends on MFP…and I know… they will tell me to fork out the money. BUT, just wanted stranger’s opinion. 

    Shin pain is usually indicative of over or under pronation (rolling out or in) of your foot. "Neutral" usually refers to the height and shape of your arch.

    Definately get the custome fit though. This will help with these problems. However, inserts shouldn't be required for a Neutral foot. So try on and go for a short run in what ever shoes they recommend before you buy. If they won't let you run in them, go to another store that will.
This discussion has been closed.