do I really need a HRM??
lipt8611
Posts: 60 Member
I've been a runner for a few years and concentrate more on my endurance and ability rather than my calorie loss. Now that I've accomplished my goal (finished my first half-marathon!) I know my endurance is where I'd like it to be.
After reading so much about HRM on here (haven't noticed them at my gym, really) I feel like I could benefit from one. Last night I talked to my fiance about it, who has always been a fan of gadgets, and he told me I should get one. Money isn't NECESSARILY the issue (not to say that I throw money around but I could afford one right now) but is it something I will truly benefit from? In the long run? Is it accurate? I know machines at the gym should not be trusted for the number they spew out. Is this something I should wear all the time or just when working out?
Sell me on these, please
After reading so much about HRM on here (haven't noticed them at my gym, really) I feel like I could benefit from one. Last night I talked to my fiance about it, who has always been a fan of gadgets, and he told me I should get one. Money isn't NECESSARILY the issue (not to say that I throw money around but I could afford one right now) but is it something I will truly benefit from? In the long run? Is it accurate? I know machines at the gym should not be trusted for the number they spew out. Is this something I should wear all the time or just when working out?
Sell me on these, please
0
Replies
-
My running gadget covet is a Garmin Forerunner 305. It does more than heart rate. It has GPS so it can tell you speed, distance, pace. It's a runners dream toy. I'm saving up my pennies.
0 -
I'm interested in this as well, since I'm a bit skeptical about some of the calorie figures MFP is telling me for exercise. I would only want to wear it during fitness sessions! Money isn't really an issue either for me.
Do they compensate for the type of activity you are doing? For example, if I am cycling and I get the same heart rate as when I am jogging, does this work out as the same amount of calories burned? (even though they are different exercises, and cycling is easier than jogging?)0 -
I really love mine! I've had it for a few weeks now and it's really accurate. I can pause it and it shows how long i work out and where my hr is. It also calculates my perfect hr goal which is really helpful.
The calories burned is important for me. I do not have the same amount every day and i try and eat back half of them (I stop eating when i have enough sodium). It has helped me lose another 5lbs so far so i am all for it :-)0 -
My running gadget covet is a Garmin Forerunner 305. It does more than heart rate. It has GPS so it can tell you speed, distance, pace. It's a runners dream toy. I'm saving up my pennies.
Ooooo, I like the look of that!0 -
Think of it like a new running outfit. You don't *need* it, but if it motivates you and makes you feel like you're better equipped then it's a good thing. :-D
It might push you to up your intensity with each run, too.
I dunno from personal experience as I have yet to get one. :-)0 -
The Garmin 310xt looks even better since you can wear it while swimming! Rather expensive though!0
-
I got a Polat FT4 last week and I LOVE it...now I'm able to SEE how hard I'm working and if I need to get my HR up. AND I workout longer bc I like seeing the calories burned go up 0
-
I got a Polat FT4 last week and I LOVE it...now I'm able to SEE how hard I'm working and if I need to get my HR up. AND I workout longer bc I like seeing the calories burned go up
I have the Polar FT4 also and absolutely love it! And to answer your question OP, in my opinion, you can NEVER go wrong getting an HRM!0 -
The Garmin 405CX rocks. GPS + HRM easy to use. Connects wirelessly to computer based and web based software. It is not nearly as bulky as the other Garmin products and even fits my rather girlish wrists.
http://www.amazon.com/Garmin-Forerunner-405CX-Sport-Monitor/dp/B0025UHKNS/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1302797738&sr=8-10 -
Yes you do... I am using the Timex HRM. You can enter and update your weight, with weight, heart rate, and time of activity you can get a accurate calorie burned count. MTP's calorie counts are off. If you can afford one, get one..0
-
thanks for the input! next question- what about the chest strap? does that get annoying and sweaty when you move around?0
-
To be honest I don't even notice mine.thanks for the input! next question- what about the chest strap? does that get annoying and sweaty when you move around?0 -
I have the polar ft4 also- I love it!!0
-
Particularly as a runner, I think you'll really like the feedback that an HRM gives you. I have a Polar RS300X with a foot pod (bought together on Amazon for $149 combined), and it has been tremendously helpful as I have gotten back into running (currently training for another half marathon after a couple of years of not really running much). I love knowing how many calories I have burned-- but I also love knowing my pace, distance, heart rate, and more at any point in my run. Now, I actually watch my heart rate instead of my pace while running-- I keep it right around 160, which has been the perfect balance of working hard enough to increase speed and burn more calories while knowing that I'm not going so hard that I can't finish a long run, which has really improved my speed and endurance. This particular model can be purchased with a GPS instead of a foot pod, so you can get it with whichever you prefer (or neither). I don't really notice the chest strap at all while running unless it loosens and starts to slip-- but even then, all you need to do is tighten it slightly and keep going.0
-
I don’t know if you “NEED” a HRM, but it sure helps out. If you just like to go out and jog for X miles or hours, that’s fine too. I use to jog a lot without one, but then there was a sale on WOOT for one with chest strap for $20. Couldn’t pass it up. Got it a couple of days later, set it up for my details and went jogging. The first thing I noticed is that it told me to slow down. Basically it was trying to keep my heart rate a certain level. With the pace I was doing it was getting too high. So I listened. At first I thought I am not working out hard enough. But as time went on I got better. Meaning that I was able to jog faster, for longer strides and further total distance.
For example, before I would jog about a 9 minute mile pace. That would usually last only about a mile. Then in the 2nd mile, it would be about a 13 minute pace. This was because I spent so much energy on the first mile that I could no longer sustain it.
After using the HRM, I found that it was making me do a 12 minute mile pace. That’s a jogging pace of 5 MPH. Doesn’t sound that fast I know. But I could sustain that pace for miles and mile. So at the end I got a better cardio work out.
As time went on, I noticed that I had to run faster to stay “in the zone”. I was then noticing that I was doing 11 minute miles, then 10:30, then 10 minute miles. So that told me that my heart was getting “better” and I was able to jog faster and sustain that speed for much further distances. Although I haven’t reached that 8 minute mile pace, I know I have gotten a lot better since getting the HRM.
And now my resting heart rate is in the high 30’s to low 40’s. I even went to the Doctors to have my heart rate checked to make sure it wasn’t too low. I never notice the chest strap when I jog, even from day 1.0 -
bump.
0 -
I too have an RS300x with foot pod that I got last week. As a beginner runner, I have only been on a treadmill. I want to start running outside as the weather improves, and to prepare for my upcoming 5K, but have grown accustom to the metrics a treadmill provides. So, I purchased this HRM so that I can still get HR, distance, and calories burned when I'm off the machine.
I am still getting used to it, but it has shown me how inconsistent the machines at the gym are. The strap is only noticeable when I first put it on, and I soon forget I'm wearing it. The foot pod is light-weight, and does not interfere with my running. Jus as you do not "need" a scale to lose weight, you do not need a HRM to accomplish your goals, but it sure does help.
Polar RS300x with Foot Pod:
0 -
Yes, you NEED a HRM! Ok, that may be a bit of exaggeration but I could not live without mine. I am a numbers gal and I like the instant feedback. There are some days I feel I'm running or biking hard but the HRM tells me the bottomline. And I know that it is accurate because it is calibrated to ME not some AVERAGE number. So I know for certain I really earned those extra calories and it is safe to eat over my goal number. Otherwise I wouldn't feel good about doing that, I wouldn't eat enough, and I wouldn't lose weight! So its a good thing all around!:happy:0
-
To be honest I don't even notice mine.thanks for the input! next question- what about the chest strap? does that get annoying and sweaty when you move around?
I notice mine, but it's not a bothersome notice. It's a positive recognition. This thing has honestly become a beloved friend. The chest strap is kind of wet and nasty when I finish working out, but I find that fact reassuring in that I worked out hard like I should be. I have started wearing the watch part all day as a constant reminder to watch the calories and choices I'm putting in. I've had it a few weeks and the "newness" has not worn off. It's pushing me constantly.0 -
I don't run, but I wear mine when I do Insanity, and I don't even notice it. I'm too busy feeling like I'm about to die to even think about the chest strap! lol :laugh:thanks for the input! next question- what about the chest strap? does that get annoying and sweaty when you move around?0 -
its not needed you wont benefit....its just a tool to see what you might be burning, no gadget is accurate even if it cost a million dollars....I use mine to log here but I could care less...if im sweating and felling my muscle working Im doing great...0
-
YES! i LOVE my HRM. Honestly, machines give you inaccurate calorie output, especially elliptical machines! My HRM is a MIO petite and it takes into account your age, height and weight to help calculate accurate calories, its just like a watch.
I've always wanted a chest strap one though, and am thinking of investing in one soon! if you want to be accurate with your burn --you need a heart rate monitor.0 -
I'm interested in getting one, too,but money is somewhat of an issue. Are there decent HRM's for around $65 or less that anyone recommends? Also, do the HRM's tell you what your normal, daily calorie burn is (w/o exercise), to help you determine how many calories you should be netting each day?0
-
To be honest I don't even notice mine.thanks for the input! next question- what about the chest strap? does that get annoying and sweaty when you move around?
I notice mine, but it's not a bothersome notice. It's a positive recognition. This thing has honestly become a beloved friend. The chest strap is kind of wet and nasty when I finish working out, but I find that fact reassuring in that I worked out hard like I should be. I have started wearing the watch part all day as a constant reminder to watch the calories and choices I'm putting in. I've had it a few weeks and the "newness" has not worn off. It's pushing me constantly.
I agree with all said here! I have the Polar Ft4 also, and I love it! It's quite surprising what exercise burn more calories than you thought, or way less than you hoped. As for the chest strap, the research I did pointed out that it's pretty much a necessity for accurate readings. It does dig in a few places, but it tucks nicely under the sports bra, so you barely notice it.0 -
YES! i LOVE my HRM. Honestly, machines give you inaccurate calorie output, especially elliptical machines! My HRM is a MIO petite and it takes into account your age, height and weight to help calculate accurate calories, its just like a watch.
I've always wanted a chest strap one though, and am thinking of investing in one soon! if you want to be accurate with your burn --you need a heart rate monitor.
I have a MIO petite also, and I dont' feel it's accurate at all! I did 55 minutes of bootcamp this morning and it says I burned 64 calories! Also, after I go on a 5 mile run, I'm lucky if I've hit the 100 calorie mark! I guess I need to make sure it's set up properly and re-enter my age, height, ect.0 -
Hi,
I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that there is a big difference between needs and wants. Do you NEED a HRM to lose weight and get fit? No....I've lost (and kept off) 60+ pounds for almost five years, and I've never worn one. Do you WANT one to help you track your level of fitness? Perhaps. It's your choice......a WANT, perhaps, but not a NEED.
Just my opinion,
Kaye0 -
I'm interested in getting one, too,but money is somewhat of an issue. Are there decent HRM's for around $65 or less that anyone recommends? Also, do the HRM's tell you what your normal, daily calorie burn is (w/o exercise), to help you determine how many calories you should be netting each day?
I wore mine all day right after I got it (on a non-exercise day) to establish a base line and compare it to MFP's estimate of what my typical day should be.0 -
I would suggest getting one with a chest strap as they are better to calculate an accurate HR.
Don't know if this will help you any but...........Here is a link that was posted in another thread with a lot of information on HRM's.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/Azdak/view/the-real-facts-about-hrms-and-calories-what-you-need-to-know-before-purchasing-an-hrm-or-using-one-214720 -
I have a Polar F4 Red Berry! I couldn't live without it! I use it when I'm doing any type of workout (except swimming). It tells me when I am below my target heart rate and makes me work a lot harder than I sometimes feel like working. I also wear the watch part throughout the day (it is super cute!) as a reminder that I have a new lifestyle that I need to stick to. I love having an accurate calorie count, more accurate than MFP or a machine's guess anyway. If you can more accurately track your calories out then you can be more on spot with your calories in. I would suggest one. It just helps to keep you aware of what you are REALLY doing.
And my chest strap kind of bugged me at first, but I don't even notice it anymore!0 -
You have to follow the directions to get an accurate calorie count with the MIO petite. I played some with my new MIO yesterday and didn't get the right calorie count...I went back & read the directions and followed them and to my surprise...it worked earlier today. It's pretty accurate on the HR as well. I've manually taken my HR then taken it with the MIO and it's pretty well right on with what I got (varying only a few beats difference.)YES! i LOVE my HRM. Honestly, machines give you inaccurate calorie output, especially elliptical machines! My HRM is a MIO petite and it takes into account your age, height and weight to help calculate accurate calories, its just like a watch.
I've always wanted a chest strap one though, and am thinking of investing in one soon! if you want to be accurate with your burn --you need a heart rate monitor.
I have a MIO petite also, and I dont' feel it's accurate at all! I did 55 minutes of bootcamp this morning and it says I burned 64 calories! Also, after I go on a 5 mile run, I'm lucky if I've hit the 100 calorie mark! I guess I need to make sure it's set up properly and re-enter my age, height, ect.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions