Shoulder presses--are they bad?

MuseumMonkey
MuseumMonkey Posts: 43
edited September 26 in Fitness and Exercise
I was doing dumbbell shoulder presses with squats last night and my brother told me to stop because they're bad for my shoulders. I suspect sabotage!

I was using 10-lb dumbbells, being careful about my form, not locking my elbows or clanking the weights together above my head, not bringing the weights down behind my neck. I've done them before and haven't had any pain--I actually find them pretty easy.

What do y'all think?

Replies

  • Jillk1023
    Jillk1023 Posts: 121 Member
    i do them all the time, gonna bump this so i can read the responses.
  • 150is
    150is Posts: 25 Member
    No shoulder presses are a great workout! I do those once a week with my weight training.
  • beckystephens
    beckystephens Posts: 117 Member
    The shoulder socket is the most mobile and unstable joint on your body. It is important to strengthen the muscles and tissues around it. Just make sure u are using correct form and not coming down farther than a 90 degree angle. They are a definite part of my shoulder day!
  • taso42_DELETED
    taso42_DELETED Posts: 3,394 Member
    I think you're brother is misinformed or something. With good form, it's an excellent exercise.
  • NikkisNewStart
    NikkisNewStart Posts: 1,075 Member
    I'm not an expert and also do these... but if they've gotten easy... it means you've gotten stronger and it's time to bump up the weights, sista! Good for you!
  • 4theking
    4theking Posts: 1,196 Member
    Its a great exercise. Just be sure to warm up properly.
  • the_texreb
    the_texreb Posts: 138 Member
    Shoulder presses are horrible for your body......if you do them wrong, repeatedly. Other than that, I love them. They are the cornerstone of shoulder day for me.
  • JPayne53
    JPayne53 Posts: 235 Member
    I incorporate them into my weekly routine usually 25lbs each arm and feel no pain if done correctly, shoulder presses are a regular exercise used by many and not anything I've read to stop doing... maybe it was the combination of the squat and the shoulder press.. if your focus is primarily on the press your squat form maybe compromised and vice versa.. if his comment was directed strictly to the shoulder press.. I'd get some more info from him and ask exactly what the concern was..
  • I incorporate them into my weekly routine usually 25lbs each arm and feel no pain if done correctly, shoulder presses are a regular exercise used by many and not anything I've read to stop doing... maybe it was the combination of the squat and the shoulder press.. if your focus is primarily on the press your squat form maybe compromised and vice versa.. if his comment was directed strictly to the shoulder press.. I'd get some more info from him and ask exactly what the concern was..

    It's something I've seen people doing, and read about. My focus was actually probably more on the squats! It just seemed like a good way to work multiple muscle groups. I find squats easy too and this seemed like a good way to add resistance there as well. Alas, the 10lb weights are the biggest ones I have at home right now.

    His comment was specifically that it would cause shoulder problems. But like I said, I suspect sabotage! The "concern" was probably that his sister is going to be too built. I'm just fairly paranoid in general and wanted to check on the off-chance that he could be right.
  • baldzach
    baldzach Posts: 1,841 Member
    Shoulder presses are horrible for your body......if you do them wrong, repeatedly. Other than that, I love them. They are the cornerstone of shoulder day for me.

    This. I messed up my rotator cuff the first time I did shoulder presses because I was doing them wrong. If your form is good, they're a must-have exercise in your routine. Now I've messed up my shoulder again, so hopefully eventually I'll be able to do shoulder presses again one day soon (it was kettle bell swings, not shoulder presses, that did it this time).
  • JPayne53
    JPayne53 Posts: 235 Member
    I incorporate them into my weekly routine usually 25lbs each arm and feel no pain if done correctly, shoulder presses are a regular exercise used by many and not anything I've read to stop doing... maybe it was the combination of the squat and the shoulder press.. if your focus is primarily on the press your squat form maybe compromised and vice versa.. if his comment was directed strictly to the shoulder press.. I'd get some more info from him and ask exactly what the concern was..

    It's something I've seen people doing, and read about. My focus was actually probably more on the squats! It just seemed like a good way to work multiple muscle groups. I find squats easy too and this seemed like a good way to add resistance there as well. Alas, the 10lb weights are the biggest ones I have at home right now.

    His comment was specifically that it would cause shoulder problems. But like I said, I suspect sabotage! The "concern" was probably that his sister is going to be too built. I'm just fairly paranoid in general and wanted to check on the off-chance that he could be right.

    Ha! Who cares if your "built"... the fastest area a woman will TONE is in her shoulder/ collar bone area.. I find it very sleek and sexy myself.. but the combination is a good one when done correctly for a multi muscle group exercise just make sure focus is both in the squats and the press, I find working out in front of a mirror helps in this area.. Keep on pressing.. You go girl!
  • I know we don't really "bulk." Just sayin', that's what he thinks...I think. A bit more muscle on my shoulders wouldn't hurt, though--I haven't really lost that much weight, but my shoulders and collarbone area were the first places it came off. They're pretty skinny!

    ETA: yes, mirrors are good. Not having one in my basement, I look at my reflection in the TV...
  • lunamare
    lunamare Posts: 569 Member
    LOL! I do that too with the TV. It's very helpful when you're checking form.

    I herniated a disc in my neck goofing around with my daughter. I also pulled just about every muscle in my right arm/neck/shoulder. So, I stopped doing alot of shoulder exercises for awhile. I do them now but I'm very cautious about my form and I don't use alot of weight. Baby steps is how I think of it. If the weights start getting heavy I have to concentrate on not shrugging my shoulder to compensate for the weakness. Tthe PT told me a trick for this, pull my shoulderblades together and down. By focusing on pulling them together I can't shrug my shoulder. I thought it was a neat trick.
  • bmontgomery87
    bmontgomery87 Posts: 1,260 Member
    As long as you have good form you're fine.

    I hurt myself doing a variation of them, because i was going too heavy and didn't have good form at the time.

    Start small, learn the right way to do them, then work up.
This discussion has been closed.