What worked for YOU?

2

Replies

  • Caloric deficit. That being said, I find I'm more focused on maintaining a caloric deficit when I'm exercising on a regular basis, particularly if I'm training for something specific. Something clicks in my brain that makes me more determined to stick to my calories because I don't want to undo all the effort I'm making with my workouts.
  • icrushit
    icrushit Posts: 773 Member
    Habit. It has been the bedrock for any successful weight loss endeavours. Stripping away the bad habits like one would peel an onion, replacing them with better, and tackling another layer when I'm ready to do so, has worked a charm. Everything else has just been window dressing for me :smile:

    I should also note, whenever I've failed, and regained weight, it has also been through habit, where the bad has reached critical mass eventually, and the weight crept back on.
  • cosmichvoyager
    cosmichvoyager Posts: 237 Member
    yep. Keep going.

    Also, I see slow loss over a long time as the best option. If I get "diet fatigue" I stop and work on maintaining/not gaining/keep exercising/make healthy choices for a few weeks. I rarely lose more than a pound a week...most weeks it is much less but I realistically do not see myself sticking with this if I look at it as anything less than a total gradual committed change for my whole life.

    Portion control, I don't demonize food and I exercise most days. I am not focusing on appearance or vanity. It's enough for me that I no longer have high blood pressure, my cholesterol is basically at a healthy level, my feet don't hurt, I enjoy being active.

    If you hate your "diet" then you will never lose anything or keep it off. I am working on loving a new way to live--one where I think before I eat, cook more often and exercise regularly.
  • hosegirl
    hosegirl Posts: 157
    What worked for me is using the 21 Day fix containers. I stay with in the paramenters and I lose. I know it is measuring but it so simple.
  • beth0277 wrote: »
    I have tried so many things....Weight watchers, no sugar diet, "clean eating", low calories, low carbs, etc... I've never stuck to anything. The only times I have lost weight have been when I was eating far too few calories and I rebounded and gained it all back and then some. I'm starting my journey again, at the highest weight of my life, with at least 50 pounds to lose. I think the only thing that will truly work for me is a realistic calorie deficit. Still having treats, but making smarter decisions and staying within my calories.

    What is the one thing that made you stick with it? Wherever you may be in your journey. I realize what works for one most likely won't be exactly what works for another, but I'm interested in hearing your A-HA plan?

    It may be that you're not sticking with one thing long enough.

    I lost weight a few years back by lowering carb intake (not much though, I was eating/drinking like 300+g/day and lowered it just under 200g and did pilates and dance.

    Then I got serious, tracked my cals, added weights and went nuts. Looked great for a few months and then got sick (unrelated to diet/exercise lol).

    So I'm puffier now thanks to my med, but I still maintain working hard and eating well. I just have a different body now. Sometimes you just gotta go with what you've got as long as it truly is your best. :sunglasses:

  • RHachicho
    RHachicho Posts: 1,115 Member
    It was a whole host of things first I had to deal with the emotional issues around my eating. I comfort ate which means I basically dealt with any stressful situation by reaching for food. Usually junk food. I cultivated better coping mechanisms and slowly removed food as a crutch. If you rely on food to get you through the day then cutting back is impossible. You can't simply resist your only effective coping mechanism. So don't try until you have others. For me I got into painting and physical activity in a big way.

    And yes physical activity. A lot of people say you can lose weight without exercise. This is correct. However it is both the harder and the unhealthier way to do it. It is far better for your body to eat a sensible amount of calories and sweat it off than it is to simply try and starve the fat off. In fact quite a lot of solid research is coming to the conclusion that much of the health conditions we previously thought where linked to being overweight are actually more to do with a lack of activity. I believe that being skinny doesn't make you healthy and being a bit chubby doesn't really make you unhealthy either. Exercise is the big thing to get into if you want to be fit and healthy. Your body needs that stimulation. It's a system designed to adapt you to your environment. If you lift heavy weights it grows big muscles, Diet allowing. If you run long distances it grows efficient at distributing energy and optimizes your running gait. So tell me what would such a system optimize you to do if you do nothing? Yep that's right. Nothing. Regardless of calories or fat or anything a still body WILL atrophy. Obviously there is a limit. Nobody is saying the 500lb whale in that YouTube video is healthy. The human body can only take so much. The human body may be an adaptive system. But elastic stretched too far will simply snap.

    I believe by far the best approach is simply to eat a sensible diet and really push yourself physically. Set aside an hour or two a day for your bodies necessary stimulation. And don't just be happy with an hour on the elliptical. Those machines are bunk. They never did anything for me at all. Hit the weights. And run,walk or play a sport to get your cardio in. You will be surprised how quickly activity can escalate too. 8 Months ago I was 338lbs of pure fat and had difficulty getting off the ground on my own. My heart would sometimes beat so fast i thought I was going to have a heart attack. Now I lift heavy 3 days a week and run 10km 3 times a week and walk 2 hours to the gym on my lifting days. Oh and I weigh 226lbs. And look fairly muscly. Not like a bodybuilder. I've still got some flab and some loose skin and some of my muscles are still underdeveloped. But I look like a strong healthy guy. Not someone who lost all his muscle on a crash diet. This last month I officially came off my diet figuring it wasn't really reasonable to retain a deficit for more than 8 months straight. Time to give things a rest. I am eating 3500 a day now. I put on about 1.5lbs last month. And look better. And lost another inch off my waist.

    Scale weight is totally overrated.

    I am thinking of upping my running distance soon. 10km is getting easy.

    You can totally Do this. And you really really don't have to starve yourself. Diet's don't work in the long term they have a 95% failure rate. Being active is the magic ticket.
  • SonicKrunch
    SonicKrunch Posts: 192 Member
    What first worked for me was a switch in my thinking to food as fuel. As soon as I started believing that, everything changed. I no longer craved sweets because I knew my body didn't need it to stay fueled. Over time, I started to eat some enjoyable things(not that I wasn't enjoying what I had chosen as my meals, but I was enjoying a slice or two here of pizza or whatnot). Now I'm more trying to hit my macros since I've been failing a bit on my lifting progress.
  • 3laine75
    3laine75 Posts: 3,069 Member
    Owning the gains as well as the losses is what's working for me.

    Obviously it's not as simple as losing weight then purposely gaining some again, there's a lot of hard work to be done in the gym and the juggling match (not always successful) to get the macros on point but it certainly beats months of dieting, forgetting about it, noticing your clothes are too small then months of dieting again (effing up your body a tiny bit more every time).
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    What worked for YOU?

    1 - being realistic...Rome wasn't built in a day...nobody became fat overnight...but everyone seems to think they should lose a gazillion Lbs per week and look like they've been dedicated to a fitness lifestyle for decades, all in a matter of weeks.

    2 - Consistency in logging and hitting my calorie goals and consistency in exercising.

    3 - Getting more balanced and much better nutrition...I don't know that it actually helped with weight loss, but it has helped in a lot of other areas where my health is concerned, not to mention satiety on lower calories

    4 - Being reasonable with my calorie goals...1 Lb per week was pretty easy at a 500 calorie per day deficit...I didn't feel like I was killing myself or depriving myself of anything. Easy to stick to it.

    5 - Made sure I was moving more and getting regular exercise...you don't have to kill yourself here either...but you should be doing something regularly.

  • Patttience
    Patttience Posts: 975 Member
    A realistic calorie deficit definiltey has worked for me. But i have a few key things that work for me.

    Quit sweets.
    Address mood issues and stress by seeking counselling support.
    Not relying on exercise.
    Focusing my diet around vegetables fruit, lentils, beans and chickpeas and full cream dairy. Using nuts and seeds, cheese and mainly olive oil to keep my food tasting good so eating these foods in appropriate quantities. Eating a diverse range of foods (though i don't' eat meat, only fish).
    Cooking nearly everything from scratch.
    I still eat pasta, rice and bread but much less. A serve of past for me now is 50g. At the beginning of the year when i began my diet it was 80g. Prior to this diet, i ate pasta about 4 times a week, sometimes more. Now i eat it about once a week. A serve of rice is usually 1/2 cup cooked but sometimes one cup. Bread, I do not eat it every day and when i do it its often a pita bread to go with hummus and other bean type foods.

    Although quitting sweets has been so vital for me, the most important thing that everyone trying to lose weight and improve their diet needs to do is eat a lot more fresh vegetables. most people on this site so far as i can tell, do not eat near enough.

    I am almost at goal. I've eaten sweets about 6-8 times this year. That fits within my rules whereby i can eat them if i'm offered them outside the home. I don't really care now if i never eat them again. I"m so happy with my current diet. I've just stopped counting calories but you can look back through my diary.

    I've only just taken up a physical activity. Tennis because its social and interesting.
  • wmcmurray61
    wmcmurray61 Posts: 192 Member
    edited October 2014
    Portion control, (I eat what I WANT) tons of walking, lifting and bicycling as well as surrounding myself with supportive people. 7 lbs left to go until my current goal. 66 lbs lost. It took 18 months and I intend to keep it off for the rest of my life.
  • sazzet
    sazzet Posts: 56 Member
    I've been on and off diets all my adult life. I'm fed up!! So this is it! I have to make it work this time. My daughter lost weight, got fit and advised me to join a gym. I'm using her trainer. They both explained how the weight loss process works and how I can benefit from a mix of cardio and strength exercises. I am actually surprised at how it works. I guess learning about how it works is the first thing to know. The trainer told me not to worry about the scale, it's not what counts right now. He takes me for a round of cardio and strength exercises and i can feel the difference after 3 weeks. I go to him three times a week and work out for an hour and half. Half an hour is strength exercises. I am so determined to lose weight that the days I don't go to the gym, I am make sure to get at least an hour of exercise by either swimming or walking the treadmill.

    My daughter and I are testing what works for us in food. We eat clean. I was so fed up of people telling me do this diet or do that one. I just eat clean. Even saying clean doesn't say much. But i'll tell you what is working for me. The first week I ate vegetarian, beans, fruits and vegetables. The only fat I eat is olive oil and sesame oil in my stir fry. I eat a quarter to a half a pita bread for breakfast with either beans or mushrooms sautéed in olive oil and garlic. Oatmeal works too. I'm still trying out new things. Before going to my workout, I eat a banana and when I get back home i eat my carbs. The trainer told me to eat carbs right after workouts. That's when they are most useful. I just do it. LOL I also watch my portion size and log everything I eat on MFP. Most of the time I don't eat my exercise calories. After lunch I don't eat till dinner and for dinner I eat fruit making sure i log in everything. I don't eat past 8:00pm. If I am starving and I mean I really need to eat, I go for a few almonds and i even had a bowl of popcorn once. I cooked it in olive oil. It wasn't too bad either.

    I'm going vegan for a week and next week I'll go back to vegetarian. My daughter and I will be adding fish the week after. I just eat everything fresh and not processed. No sugar, no flour. You have to test what works for you, but stop eating processed food and soda.

    I weighed myself today and I'm down six pounds. Find what works for you and enjoy the food you eat. I love broccoli and sweet potatoes now. Get lots of fibers in your body and eat fresh. Eating healthy doesn't have to be a punishment, it has to be a lifestyle change in which you find alternatives to fattening food you enjoy. Try baked sweet potato chips coated in curry powder or stir fry with rice noodles, broccoli, bok choy, carrots and oyster sauce. How about a salad with cucumbers, avocado, lettuce, a tablespoon of olive oil, wine vinegar and sprinkled with crushed almonds. I made my daughter boiled eggs cut them in half and removed the yolk which i mashed with avocado, mustard, lemon and a bit of curry powder. I told her they were deviled eggs. She loved them!! I make my own falafel at home which i cook in a tbs of olive oil. i make my own pesto with nuts and basil, yum! I used to throw the broccoli stems but now I bake them with herbs till they are crisp, they are a delicious snack and full of fibers. I found seedless dates on the market, I sometimes take a tbs of this paste and and put a nut in and roll it in sesame seeds, it's great when you want something sweet and it's all natural. I'm creating my own healthy recipes. I'll be adding chicken breast and fish to my diet soon, I like vegan but i only used it to detox my body. I feel I need more protein to be healthy. That is just my opinion.

    Find what works with you and what won't bore you! Good luck!
  • soozey1
    soozey1 Posts: 102 Member
    Nothing worked for me until I did Osha Key's, 21 day detox diet. Cleaned out all my toxins holding me back. Weight loss is now a breeze, I have a couple of kilo's to go, but I am happy where I am and looking forward to the rest of my journey. I am stronger , slimmer and healthier than I was 20 years ago.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    consistancy.... i've got my best results when i have stuck to something for longer than a couple of weeks!
  • mizroxy13
    mizroxy13 Posts: 466 Member
    Ceci_O_K wrote: »
    Eat less, move more.

    This.

  • CJsf1t
    CJsf1t Posts: 414 Member
    I think nothing will work unless you are 100% on it. That said what also works is being consistent with watever you do. Count calories to T, exercise and drink lots of water. Also be kind to yourself if you cheat or fall off the wagon. Just get up and get going don't beat yourself up.
    This is what works for me :)
  • DAM5412
    DAM5412 Posts: 660 Member
    Conscious eating...knowing what I ate and how it affected my weight and health, as well as how it made me feel. I started with calorie restriction only. In two weeks I lost 8lbs. Once I felt that portion control was a sustainable habit, I started working out. First strength and body weight workouts, then a couch to 5k. In 3 months, I lost another 11 lbs and yes, felt great about that. But then I stalled for a month. From that point, I started eating low carb, for weight loss purposes but also for the health benefits for me. In 5 weeks I've lost 9 lbs and feel better then I ever have before. I am actually eating more calories and foods that I prefer, and not ever feeling hungry or depraved. I am learning as I go and modifying as needed, but throughout this entire 6 month period, it has been my recognition of the food I eat and how it affects me which has given me the most success.
  • jlgrebe
    jlgrebe Posts: 30 Member
    edited October 2014
    So here's a tidbit for y'all. Not so much a diet method, but just something to keep in mind.

    I had braces put on my teeth about six months ago and I lost almost 20 pounds in 4 months. It was not healthy and wasn't sustained because after a few months my teeth didn't hurt as bad and now I've gained back about six pounds. I basically lived on soft foods, ate next to nothing, had no energy, etc. (typical crash diet stuff).

    HOWEVER!

    One thing I have kept doing since my mouth has healed, is I cut EVERYTHING up with a knife and fork.

    I know this sounds time-consuming. I know it sounds silly. It seriously works. Imagine, for instance, not having the ability to shove food in your face in front of the TV, or while driving, or anywhere.

    Tortilla chips, crackers, bite-sized foods I break into pieces if they aren't fork-friendly. I never eat a chip in one bite anymore. Also, lots of water. When it kills you to try to even put mashed potatoes in your mouth, water is your friend. This whole braces thing really helped me realize what HUNGRY is, and what "I'm bored" is!

    Just FYI, I'm also someone who has tried everything and, prior to this new food-to-mouth revelation, the only thing that remotely worked for me was starving myself and diet pills (NOOOOOO!!!!!), and the weight would always come back.

    I encourage you to try this for, like, 30 days. It made all the difference in the world for me, and maybe it would be a small change that would help you out, too.

    Good luck!
  • TitikiOoh
    TitikiOoh Posts: 40 Member
    What worked for me was to be aware of what I was eating. To eat 3 meals, dessert, and up to two snacks a day. I logged everything and got a feel for both calories and nutrition in what I ate, but at the same time was my philosophy was one meal at a time so if I messed up with one meal didn't mean the entire day was ruined and I didn't skip meals because I ate to many calories. It ended up being surprisingly simple.

    No guilt, no shame.
  • ithrowconfetti
    ithrowconfetti Posts: 451 Member
    Logging in what I eat, and intermittent fasting. I do a fasting window of 20 hours, and a feasting window of 4 hours. Being able to pack away ridiculously satisfying meals of a variety of foods to match my recommended calorie intake within 240 minutes, keeps my cravings at bay, and has kept me going for many months.
  • ParamoreAddict
    ParamoreAddict Posts: 839 Member
    It wasn't any gimmick or specialized diet plan. I just knew that I needed to lose the weight and it all started with eating better. I started reading the bags of everything I ate. Noticing the calories, the macros, etc. The biggest hurdle of all for me is staying away from fast food. It takes a lot of discipline when you've been eating that stuff constantly for years. I've re-lapsed on my journey but dusted myself off and came back again. Will power, eating good food (my diary is open if you want to see what I eat) and exercise daily. That's been my plan. Works pretty awesome if I say so myself :)

    8830689.png
  • So far I have lost a total of 12 pounds and have about 55 to go. I have struggled with losing weight for a while now. In the beginning September after seeing an aquaintence who used to be over 300 pounds and then lost enough weight to weigh less than me along with a person I don't care much for whom is losing weight just for an event and I'm sure will gain it all back once the event is over I decided now was the time. I decided if the aquaintence can do it (even if she had weight loss surgery) I could do it on my own and keep off the weight, in turn showing the yo-yo dieter that losing weight is a lifestyle change and not something you do temporarily.

    I decided that I would set a goal of losing about a pound a week. So, far I have been able to do that. I don't deprive myself but still try to be healthy most days. I convinced myself that if I want it bad enough then there shouldn't be any excuses. I won't eat junk just because but either because it has been at least one week since my last indulgence or a special occasion. I gained my weight because I had a daily fast food habit where I had it once a day most days and two or three times a day on others. I would maybe skip a day or two and not eat fast food here and there but nothing worth weight loss. If I do get fast food now I try to make good choices or at least better. I also convinced myself that this is going to be a battle but the end result, even if it takes a while to get to it, will be better than feeling ugly and depressed because of my weight. A few months is nothing compared to the years of pain I have felt and would continue feeling if I didn't do something about it now.
  • lynn_glenmont
    lynn_glenmont Posts: 10,106 Member
    I've lost 45 pounds over 14 months, most of it in the first six or seven months, much slower since then. I'd like to lose at least another 20 to reach what's considered a healthy weight for my height. What's worked for me is
    1) having a reason to lose that was really important to me (averting several health conditions I seemed to be headed for)
    2) logging everything, even when I had to estimate because I was eating at a restaurant or hotel that doesn't post nutrition information -- and never saying "oh, I'm already over, what does it matter, I won't log it"-- for me it was important to know how much over, and to see that over several days or a week, I still had a deficit, even if it was small
    3) allowing myself to eat more when I was really hunger, because as long as I logged it, I could see that I was still 150 calories under maintenance, or whatever it might be
    4) gradually adding a variety of exercise activities that I enjoy (yes, you can lose without exercise, but I'm doing this to be healthy -- plus, I often find that exercise works as an appetite suppressant, although it frequently catches up to me a little bit the next day)
    5) not making any foods off limits - I still eat pizza and ice cream and drink alcohol when I want, I even have french fries occasionally, although I usually don't eat the entire serving, because it's the first few bites that taste the best, and knowing how many calories are in the whole serving, I generally don't feel like it's worth it. I guess that's something I do a fair bit now: not finishing all the food that a restaurant serves. If it's something that will taste good later, I may bring the leftovers home, and if not, I don't feel guilty about leaving it. In the long term, if more people did this, maybe restaurants would take the hint and make portions more reasonable.
  • lynn_glenmont
    lynn_glenmont Posts: 10,106 Member
    edited October 2014
    It wasn't any gimmick or specialized diet plan. I just knew that I needed to lose the weight and it all started with eating better. I started reading the bags of everything I ate. Noticing the calories, the macros, etc. The biggest hurdle of all for me is staying away from fast food. It takes a lot of discipline when you've been eating that stuff constantly for years. I've re-lapsed on my journey but dusted myself off and came back again. Will power, eating good food (my diary is open if you want to see what I eat) and exercise daily. That's been my plan. Works pretty awesome if I say so myself :)

    8830689.png

    Do you put your ticker in manually? Mine disappeared when they did that overhaul of the forums a while back.
  • ParamoreAddict
    ParamoreAddict Posts: 839 Member
    It wasn't any gimmick or specialized diet plan. I just knew that I needed to lose the weight and it all started with eating better. I started reading the bags of everything I ate. Noticing the calories, the macros, etc. The biggest hurdle of all for me is staying away from fast food. It takes a lot of discipline when you've been eating that stuff constantly for years. I've re-lapsed on my journey but dusted myself off and came back again. Will power, eating good food (my diary is open if you want to see what I eat) and exercise daily. That's been my plan. Works pretty awesome if I say so myself :)

    8830689.png

    Do you put your ticker in manually? Mine disappeared when they did that overhaul of the forums a while back.

    Yeah have to put my ticker back in manually with the bbcode every single time. It's a pain but def worth it. They better bring it back. Love showing off my weight loss total :)

    8830689.png

  • 50sFit
    50sFit Posts: 712 Member
    edited October 2014
    Here is what I do...consider:
    I address 2 areas that make up my health and fitness program.

    1. Food Intake - I eat clean as defined by lean meats, fresh fruits and veggies, nuts, whole grains, beans and raw dairy.
    If man makes it, I try not to eat it.
    2. Exercise - both cardio and strength...and I try to engage routines that employ training I enjoy like biking, swimming, calisthenics, hiking and MMA

    I train about 3 hours daily with an occasional day off. I eat around 4000 calories per day.
    That's it.
  • QueenE_
    QueenE_ Posts: 522 Member
    Cutting out pop completely, drinking water and walking.
  • rupert2011
    rupert2011 Posts: 24 Member


    For me: taking myself seriously. Considering myself worthy of looking fantastic. Which mean: not sabotaging myself. Not slipping into old habits. Doing this for me and forever because I want to treat myself the best way possible.
    [/quote]

    This

  • NewLIFEstyle4ME
    NewLIFEstyle4ME Posts: 4,440 Member
    bump
  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    Eating what I want in moderation
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!