Does alcohol really count the same as other calories?
Replies
-
well, I am a social, late evening, night out kinda drinker, so what I have found is that when I go out and drink, the extra hours being up, talking, walking from place to place, etc, probably make up for the beers I drink. A trip to the IHOP on the way back will definitely kill any chances though... (IHOP salad at 2:30 AM anyone?)0
-
This is so interesting @Hornsby... I feel like I am the exact same way! Sometimes I don't even track my alcohol consumption (gasp!) and it really makes no difference in the end.
I'll join this group too! admittedly, I don't drink all that often, maybe once every couple of months, but at least 4 to 5 glasses of prosecco a time, without making any extra room for it in my daily calorie allowance. Every time, I weigh at least a half pound less the next day and never put on an ounce of extra weight on that week.
Drinking alcohol does tend to send me running to the bathroom every 30 minutes though - maybe I don't even give it the chance to settle in my body or something, lol.
0 -
Booze makes me hongry. It's my gateway to fried everything.0
-
Interesting discussion. Maybe it is just negated by the fact that you get more activity. On a normal night I would go to bed around 10ish and prior to that I usually spend time reading or watching tv. When I go out drinking I'm up and about until 1-2ish probably moving/standing a lot more and walking from place to place as well as dancing. I suppose the extra activity and 3-4 hours of waking time would cancel out some of the drinking. Although on the flip side, after a night of drinking I often have a day of sleeping in, lying around and crappy food so maybe not so much0
-
I've wondered about this too. I don't drink anymore, but when I was at my thinnest (120-25) coincided with when I used to routinely get LOTS of extra calories from wine, and yet it never seemed to matter for my weight. I've always kind of assumed I must have adjusted my eating somewhat to account for it, but I'm actually not sure that explanation stands up. Closer to the time I decided to stop I do know I'd not be hungry at all/able to eat the day after I'd had lots to drink, but that wasn't always the case.0
-
It wouldn't surprise me if something about heavy alcohol intake signaled adaptive thermogenesis to crank up the furnace, so to speak. "Lots of readily burnable fuel comin' in daily! Fire on all cylinders!" I know a lot of heavy drinkers and many claim that beer calories don't seem to count the same as food.0
-
It's an interesting question. My discretionary calories often go to a nice wine. Much more often than they go to anything else.
I lost while doing that. I've maintained all these years while doing that.
0 -
Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight0
-
fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
I see what you did there.
0 -
fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
They call it a beer belly for a reason.
0 -
FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
They call it a beer belly for a reason.
Is there a wine belly?0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
They call it a beer belly for a reason.
Is there a wine belly?
I don't believe I've heard that term used before. Although, I'm sure those who don't practice moderation might have one 0 -
As I told you in another thread about this topic (where you mentioned drinking a fifth of whiskey and a 12 pack of beer in the same day on multiple occasions), you need some help.0
-
FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
They call it a beer belly for a reason.
Is there a wine belly?
I don't believe I've heard that term used before. Although, I'm sure those who don't practice moderation might have one
Is there a nachos belly?
0 -
there is a Buddha's belly restaurant0
-
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »fearlessleader104 wrote: »Alcohol = empty calories = you can have as much as you want and you won't gain weight
They call it a beer belly for a reason.
Is there a wine belly?
I don't believe I've heard that term used before. Although, I'm sure those who don't practice moderation might have one
Is there a nachos belly?
I want nachos.0 -
-
Thanks for the breakdown. I guess I am curious because from what I have read, if you drink alcohol, that will be the first thing your body burns as it is the preferred source (Is that correct)?
No, that's not correct, really. Your liver does process alcohol before other sugars because alcohol is a toxin (not "preferred", rather, a poison) and the liver prioritizes filtering out toxins. While it's busy doing that, anything else you ate sits on standby.
The truth about alcohol
By the way, 10 beers every day fits nobody's definition of moderation except, apparently, yours.
0 -
FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »
99% of people use statistics for hyperbole.0 -
I'm not seeing where he says he has ten beers a day? Did I miss something?Thanks for the breakdown. I guess I am curious because from what I have read, if you drink alcohol, that will be the first thing your body burns as it is the preferred source (Is that correct)?
No, that's not correct, really. Your liver does process alcohol before other sugars because alcohol is a toxin (not "preferred", rather, a poison) and the liver prioritizes filtering out toxins. While it's busy doing that, anything else you ate sits on standby.
The truth about alcohol
By the way, 10 beers every day fits nobody's definition of moderation except, apparently, yours.
0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
I'm not seeing where he says he has ten beers a day? Did I miss something?Thanks for the breakdown. I guess I am curious because from what I have read, if you drink alcohol, that will be the first thing your body burns as it is the preferred source (Is that correct)?
No, that's not correct, really. Your liver does process alcohol before other sugars because alcohol is a toxin (not "preferred", rather, a poison) and the liver prioritizes filtering out toxins. While it's busy doing that, anything else you ate sits on standby.
The truth about alcohol
By the way, 10 beers every day fits nobody's definition of moderation except, apparently, yours.It's not all that odd for me to drink 10-12 beers each day.0 -
I have been wondering the same thing. I drink a fair bit - sometimes a lot and sometimes very little for a time -- and until a few months or so ago I tracked really, really carefully (less so now and experimenting with not really tracking, but not oblivious to overall intake). Over long periods (1 year+) my overall energy balance has tracked very closely with expected loss / maintenance / gain. But in short-term snapshots (more than a day; recently as long as a week) where I might expect some movement based primarily on excess calories from alcohol (especially beer, with added carbs to boot), it hasn't quite held true to form. Small sample size, N=1, etc. I've not been as rigorous as I would like in terms of tracking alcohol now having seen this thread, but I am re-reading Martin Berkhan's "cheating" CI/CO article on drinking to see if my drinking habits may dovetail with the body's challenge on metabolizing alcohol and fat creation. (leangains.com/2010/07/truth-about-alcohol-fat-loss-and-muscle.html for those who haven't seen it).0
-
well alright then.FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »
I'm not seeing where he says he has ten beers a day? Did I miss something?Thanks for the breakdown. I guess I am curious because from what I have read, if you drink alcohol, that will be the first thing your body burns as it is the preferred source (Is that correct)?
No, that's not correct, really. Your liver does process alcohol before other sugars because alcohol is a toxin (not "preferred", rather, a poison) and the liver prioritizes filtering out toxins. While it's busy doing that, anything else you ate sits on standby.
The truth about alcohol
By the way, 10 beers every day fits nobody's definition of moderation except, apparently, yours.It's not all that odd for me to drink 10-12 beers each day.
0 -
-
As I told you in another thread about this topic (where you mentioned drinking a fifth of whiskey and a 12 pack of beer in the same day on multiple occasions), you need some help.
Think again my friend, I've never said anything of the sort. Maybe you were drinking when you read that?
0 -
If you are drinking 10-12 beers every day you're an alcoholic. I was there a year or two ago, and i am 10 years younger than you.
I'd suggest AA0 -
Thanks for the breakdown. I guess I am curious because from what I have read, if you drink alcohol, that will be the first thing your body burns as it is the preferred source (Is that correct)? So if you have a high TDEE can you and burn say 150 calories per hour doing nothing, can you "beat the system" so to speak?
Pretty much no. Your body doesn't prioritize anything at all, there is really no "using up" of one thing before another. Alcohol gets converted into sugar, same as carbs/sugar and fat. It uses a different enzymatic pathway to get there than carbs or fat do, but in the end it is simply turned to glucose for fuel.0 -
Sevendust912 wrote: »If you are drinking 10-12 beers every day you're an alcoholic. I was there a year or two ago, and i am 10 years younger than you.
I'd suggest AA
People really are great at reading on this forum.
0 -
Sevendust912 wrote: »If you are drinking 10-12 beers every day you're an alcoholic. I was there a year or two ago, and i am 10 years younger than you.
I'd suggest AA
People really are great at reading on this forum.
You said
"It's not all that odd for me to drink 10-12 beers each day"
Not sure how you expect people to interpret that.0 -
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions