No exercise & weight loss?
hiphop10
Posts: 135 Member
Has anyone ever lost weight and did no exercising?
0
Replies
-
I'm 22 pounds down and done precious little in terms of exercise. Weight loss has far more to do with diet than exercise, but exercise will help the process move along and keep things from getting all jiggly (that's the scientific term).0
-
I'm 60lb down in about 6 months with only calorie deficit but I do need to firm up so I wish I'd done weights at the same time.0
-
This summer I went from 212 to 181 without exercise while recovering from my second c-section.
Exercise has health benefits, help maintain muscle mass, give you a higher TDEE and can help achieve a desired look. To lose weight, you really only need a calorie deficit.0 -
Thank you. I'm older & find I am not as flexible as I use to be. That is what I should of done after my surgery is just do the calorie deficit. Now I'm healed & I'm trying to get back to working out again.0
-
caloric deficit = weight loss...
you don't need to exercise. Exercise is not the big component of weight loss. so ... "yes"
IOW: S2s nailed it (and good work, btw)0 -
During the beginning of my weight loss, I had just watched what I ate and reduced my soda & fast food intake. And in my first month, I lost 8 pounds. Since then, I now exercise. From June 22nd to last week, I have been primarily running. I had lost 22 pounds from completing C25k and doing 10 weeks of C210k.
As an outdoor runner, I haven't been able to really do much running lately.
I started Insanity this last week so I had a way to still lose weight until the end of the year. I lost 2 pounds & 3 inches, surprisingly0 -
Of course you can loose weight without exercise, though skin get flabby. let me put it this way, my friend decided to loose weight only by keeping calorie intake to a minimum, in about three months she'd lost about 17 kg but her arms and thighs got flabby. I was working out not restricting calories. Hardly lost anything weight wise in a year , though I lost inches ( sadly didn't take measurements) and got toned.
So, to sum it up, its best u use both methods at the same time.
Hope that helps.0 -
Yes, have lost weight in the past without adding activity. This time around, I started with just making sure I did the minimum - walking 20 minutes and standing for a total of an hour each day. It made a difference. I continue to add activity but don't live in a gym. The good thing about adding activity is it helps me sleep. Sleep helps my mental game in making good choices in everything. It's all about the balance.0
-
Has anyone ever lost weight and did no exercising?
Yes, you lose weight in the kitchen. Exercise certainly can help boost your metabolism - which burns more calories and enhances the side of the equation of (CICO) that supports running a deficit. You can also boost your metabolism in the kitchen with spices.
Either way works. Calories in vs. calories out with food selection only. Or, calories in vs. calories out in combination with some form of exercise. The latter, most would agree, would be a healthy approach to one's lifestyle. Even mild exercise such as walking, lawn work, etc... pays handsome benefits.0 -
Is yoga considered a workout? My boyfriend said it's not it's stretching. I feel it's both.0
-
I did it after my 2nd kid. You don't get to eat as much and you'll lose more muscle than if you did exercise (strength training). I looked about the same at 145lbs as I do at 155lbs with muscle.0
-
yoga is awesome. sure it's "stretching", but flexibility is an important of any wellness plan. while the "caloric expenditure" may not be there, it's hugely important to work on flexibility.
and it's active, it's social, it requires some level of commitment to it. Has many of the elements, if not all, of a programmed "exercise" routine.
how about this: for awesomeness, YES it's akin to a workout. for commitment etc, ABSOLUTELY. for caloric expenditure, not necessarily, but so what? it can be part of a programmed "active recovery" day and fit beautifully into the mix.0 -
ALL that is required for weight loss is a calorie deficit.
There are tons of other benefits to exercise, and to eating more nutritious foods and balancing macros for various goals. Those things can certainly help, and can make you fitter and healthier.
But ALL that is required for weight loss is a calorie deficit.0 -
Thank you. I'm older & find I am not as flexible as I use to be. That is what I should of done after my surgery is just do the calorie deficit. Now I'm healed & I'm trying to get back to working out again.
As the others have said you can do it just on food deficit, but its much better if you start to exercise because of how it complements diet and improves health. I wouldnt ignore these benefits.
Walking is exercise, it doesnt all have to be gym and you should take baby steps. Ask the hopsital for a decent phstio so they can assign you exercises that match your ability and take into account your health. Just walking ten minutes a day more can help a lot. When you feel comfy then you can start with the gym. many gyms are community ones where you might feel more comfy. Dont worry too much everyone is there for the same reason and it gets easier as your confidence grows. Everyone starts somewhere.
0 -
I've done it while injured. If there's a low impact activity you can do (like pool walking or just walking in general), try to add it in. There are major heart benefits from just taking walks (in fact, it's believed to be better to walk for 30 minutes a couple of days a week then do the same amount of running less times a week. With that, it's better to walk 15 minutes twice a day than 30 once.) Find a little way to add exercise if you can and focus on the food if that's what's going to work for you.
As a girl who had a hurt shoulder and two bad knees, let me tell you there's always something you can do!
If you cannot do high impact, think about yoga or swimming.0 -
Thank you. I'm older & find I am not as flexible as I use to be. That is what I should of done after my surgery is just do the calorie deficit. Now I'm healed & I'm trying to get back to working out again.
I am about that age.
I maintain a calorie deficit to lose weight and work out to try and hold onto muscle, which decreases with age. (Sarcopenia, if we wanna be fancy). Anyone's progress depends greatly on how they were before surgery. If you were working out regularly, then it will be easier to jump back in. If it has been some decades, of course it will take longer.
When I started (after decades of nothing) I was shocked that I could only do 3 minutes on an ellipical trainer. Over months that has improved.
You are starting and the best thing you can do is log everything you eat every day Even if you are over your calorie limit, just log. It will make you aware of your food triggers and what you might choose to change.
You can do this.
0 -
Without exercise you will suffered your body.. your body need nutrient that come from food. The best is you take appropriate calorie and burn it with exercise.... don't skip meal for weight loss.. eat every 4 hours in small portion and exercise a lot...0
-
Any movement is exercise... do as much as and as fast as you can but don't force yourself.. have a rest if you feel tired...0
-
Without exercise you will suffered your body.. your body need nutrient that come from food. The best is you take appropriate calorie and burn it with exercise.... don't skip meal for weight loss.. eat every 4 hours in small portion and exercise a lot...
Current science does not support meal timing having any impact on weight loss, except as it might affect satiety. For example, if you find that skipping breakfast and waiting til lunch time helps you not to overeat for the day, then do that. If you find that skipping breakfast sets you up to be starving by lunch time and you end up snacking all day and going over your calories, then don't do that. I personally find that eating breakfast causes me to be hungry again sooner than if I skip it. Check into intermittent fasting if you'd like more information on how that works, but regardless, the important thing is the number of calories you have from the time you wake up til the time you go to bed, no matter what time those calories are consumed or whether you eat them in all in one meal or spread them over 6, or anywhere in between.0 -
You know your body best... if you skip meal you body will send signal that you are fasting then reduce your metabolisme rate... not good for weight loss..0
-
great advice & supportive ty. I prefer to work out daily it makes me feel better for the rest of the day. I was working out every day until surgery & my doc told me no working out. I wish I had just did calorie deficit after surgery. It was not easy not working out..now I'm finally back to working out. I feel better, I lost 5 pounds right away! Along with calorie deficit. Now I'm stabilizing and have to keep at it as I have lots more to loose.
0 -
You know your body best... if you skip meal you body will send signal that you are fasting then reduce your metabolisme rate... not good for weight loss..
Unfortunately, this is also incorrect. There is no "starvation mode." It is a myth and has been thoroughly debunked.
If you would like to know more, read up on intermittent fasting. Read some actual studies, not some broscience blogs.
To be clear, I'm not an advocate of intermittent fasting, however, I have read the studies and have seen that it works quite well for a lot of people. Others do better with a steady stream of small meals and snacks. Meal timing can help you keep control of your calories, but it cannot, of itself, cause weight gain or loss.
0 -
Intermittent fasting is good as well, but make sure you can control your appetite during hungry... I worried after you starving a lot, you will consume more calorie then before... it will become worst when you metabolism is lower. That why some people get more weight after do diet program...0
-
SnuggleSmacks 2 - Gmemacho 00
-
Intermittent fasting is good as well, but make sure you can control your appetite during hungry... I worried after you starving a lot, you will consume more calorie then before... it will become worst when you metabolism is lower. That why some people get more weight after do diet program...
I appreciate your concern. For myself, I find that I am hungrier and eat more if I eat early in the day. Skipping breakfast helps me to not be hungry, and to eat less. I wait until I am actually hungry to eat, rather than eating because it's breakfast time.
Most people who gain back weight after a diet do so because they did not develop healthy habits during their diet...they merely cut out foods, and when they went back to including those foods, they had no strategy for eating in moderation. This is why it's best for most people to avoid diet plans which call for cutting out foods or food groups. Long-term success is more likely when one develops a good relationship with food instead of vilifying it and using it as a cause for stress, shame and guilt.0 -
SnuggleSmacks 3 - Gmemacho 00
-
Keep moving. Weight train or join a Pilates or yoga class. Keep those musc0
-
Muscles moving.0
-
I actually lost a lot faster when I was not lifting weights. The problem is, I ended up skinny fat and weak. That was my first time around on MFP. I ended up gaining it all back as well. And quickly at that.
You absolutely can drop weight in a calorie deficit only, but it will be worth the time to add some resistance training and cardio in now instead of later as long as the Doc says you are good to go.
0 -
I started MFP in August and with an Achilles injury was unable to exercise. I lost about 1 pound per week - In November got released to exercise and started losing closer to 2 # per week. I think it is possible - but slower - definitely feel better with the exercise.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions