Do you weight yourself?
brain328
Posts: 74 Member
I have made a decision to no longer weigh myself. I feel that I am too dependent upon that number. I am eating right and working out and I am sick of being depressed because the numbers aren't moving the way I think they should, when I feel AMAZING. Thoughts? Do I really need to know how much I weigh?
0
Replies
-
Sounds like a good plan to me. Lots of people on here just go off of measurements. The scale can definitely be deceiving.0
-
ugh YES! i completely know the feeling (just this morning i saw the scale move the other way). i know i'm not going crazy calorie-wise and i exercise 5-6 times a week and my stomach looks slimmer and clothes are fitting better so yeah, i'm having to get into that mindset as well. clothes give it to you straight, the scale... not so much.0
-
No I don't anymore...I think it can be very discouraging when you feel like you're working hard and then you step on and hardly see a difference.0
-
I'm in the opposite camp. I weigh myself daily and track it. At first it was difficult to see the spikes and then have it take a week to get back down. However, after 4 months, I have a extremely helpful trend line that shows with the ups and downs there is a steady and progressive downward slope to my weight. So on those days when the numbers go up, I log them, just like I do my food, and then look at the big picture. For ME it is all the motivation I need to be successful today, every day!0
-
The numbers never go down fast enough, do they? There's a lot of people who go by how they look as far as deciding when to stop dieting. And, a lot of them have rocking avatar pics (a bunch of recompers in this category). If you need a more objective measurement, fitting into a smaller size feels great (and can can give you more choices and be easier on the wallet).
I think some of it has to do with personality. I need to be obsessive to lose weight, so I'll weigh myself up to 5 times a day on insecure days, and measure myself a few times. For me it's having more data points and seeing trends that makes it easier to not get upset over the numbers ie. my weight doesn't go down as much the week before my period, but goes down more when I start, I tend to be 2-3 pounds heavier before bed than first thing in the morning, my measurements are bigger after exercise, and I can gain 2 inches in my my waist just from bloating (easy come, easy go).
I really enjoy the scale victories, though. I've figured out all the 10% weight losses down to my goal (there's health advantages to losing 10% of original weight even if you aren't at goal weight yet). I consider every 5 pounds a victory. I'm about to hit 100 pounds (20 before joining MFP), 10 pounds in December, just went under 200 pounds for Christmas, and have almost lost 1/3 my original body weight. Seeing that weight loss is accountabilty, motivation, and a way of knowing how far you've come (even if sometimes it's just cyclical water weight).
The best approach to losing fat is what works for you. Congratulations on deciding to make healthy changes in your life, and best of luck to you0 -
Nope...not weighing very often anyway. Motivation ebbs & flows. I don't want to weigh myself on a day my motivation is low. I know I have a good plan, people are commenting on how much smaller I am, I feel great (decided to lose some pounds to see if it would help my knees during high impact exercise). I can't be tied to the number on the scale or the size of my jeans (although nice that has gone down too). I weigh about once a month. I also don't have a set goal weight. I will know it when I see it on my body, not the scale.0
-
All good plans. This is another case of "know thyself" (like keeping your favorite junk food in the house or not). I weigh daily for the most part. I am at maintenance, but I also weighed daily when I was losing. I was starting diet/nutrition from scratch, then, and weighing daily was good information for me. I could see what a sushi (soy sauce) dinner did for the scale. I could see what ovulation did (that was a surprise). I could see what PMS and ToM did...
Now, in maintenance, weighing daily lets me see if my maintenance strategies are working. When the scale goes up a few and stays there, then I look at how I'm eating. If it goes down and stays there, I look at how I'm eating. Data. Data. Data.0 -
This may work great for some, but for me it's all about the numbers whether weighing daily or tracking every bite of food. For many years I refused to even own a scale & always went off how I felt, and unfortunately (?) I felt pretty great and could still stuff myself into the same clothing even though I gained a LOT of weight. So I guess I am sort of the opposite, I think of the number on the scale as a reassuring friend.0
-
I weigh myself once a week. It's nice to track the progress. Any more often than that and it can be misleading (for me anyway). How my clothes fit seems to be the best way to measure progress.0
-
No you don't. I am only going to weigh myself once a month starting the first of the year. On the first of every month I will weigh myself and take my measurements. For the rest of the month I am going to work hard.0
-
I do but not very often. Maybe once a month.0
-
I weigh myself once a week. I don't see the point in doing it anymore often than that.0
-
There's an old saying "what gets measured gets done" and I believe it. I don't think it matters, in this case, weather you're measuring your body size or your weight but I do think it's important to have some data to measure. I find weighing once a week, and recording it, helps keep me motivated. If I have a week where the needle isn't moving in the right direction it just pushes me to be more digilent.0
-
I weigh in once a week , and measure every 2 weeks. I expect to see some improvement on at least one of them (scale, or measurements) - if I don't see ANY improvement in either, it's time to re-evaluate what I'm doing and see if I need to change something.0
-
seltzermint wrote: »This may work great for some, but for me it's all about the numbers whether weighing daily or tracking every bite of food. For many years I refused to even own a scale & always went off how I felt, and unfortunately (?) I felt pretty great and could still stuff myself into the same clothing even though I gained a LOT of weight. So I guess I am sort of the opposite, I think of the number on the scale as a reassuring friend.
I lost 60 pounds in 2011 and decided to stop logging calories.
2013 I stopped weighing myself.
I found out that I can gain 15 pounds and still fit into my clothes comfortably.
I need to weigh every day, or every week at least.
0 -
shadowloss wrote: »I'm in the opposite camp. I weigh myself daily and track it. At first it was difficult to see the spikes and then have it take a week to get back down. However, after 4 months, I have a extremely helpful trend line that shows with the ups and downs there is a steady and progressive downward slope to my weight. So on those days when the numbers go up, I log them, just like I do my food, and then look at the big picture. For ME it is all the motivation I need to be successful today, every day!
That trend line is very helpful.
No matter how many times I tell myself that it's how my clothes fit that's a true measure, I do really care about the scale weight. Can't help it.
I used to weigh every day and my whole day was made or ruined by what I saw. When I switched to once a week, it kept me really on goal all week, but if weigh day fell on one of those unexplainable up days, then I felt defeated and that all that work was for nothing.
Now I weigh every day again, but I put it in the chart and the trend line is reassuring no matter what the scale says that day.
0 -
tuesday and fridays are my days, they work perfect for me0
-
I weigh myself once every day in the morning. The numbers dont bother much that much, but i need this indicator. If i do not weigh myself, i feel great and end up gaining a couple of pounds easily lol. This happened on my 3 weeks vacation where i never tracked or weighed myself and gained 4 pounds. But the important this here is how you feel. If numbers bother you a lot, then reduce weighing to once a week or even month and go by measurements0
-
I weigh myself everyday to stay in check. I am not losing as quickly as I want to but I am losing inches so it is all good. I am only a few months into this so maybe down the road I will weigh and measure less often.0
-
This is such an excellent plan, in my opinion.
As a person recovering from eating disorders, I find it difficult to toss my scale, though I want to. I find it difficult NOT to weigh myself once (or more!) a day. This is my battle right now-- NOT weighing multiple times a day. I allow myself ONCE a day; that's it, no more at all. It seems so silly, but it IS a battle...
I hope to get to the point where I am weighing once a week or, heck, maybe even not at all!0 -
I grew up wrestling and always weighing in everyday, after 25 years away from the sport I haven't been able to break that habit. Its second nature for me.0
-
I weight myself daily for accountability. But, everyone is different.0
-
*weigh0
-
I seem to just forget lately and just go by what I feel in the mirror, and from time to time weigh myself0
-
I've decided not to weigh myself more than once every 2 weeks, if not less. I think the best motivation is when a friend/acquaintance asks me if I've lost weight. Sometimes, the number on the scale tells me that I weigh the same, but this helps me know that my weight is shifting and that exercise and diet are working in their own way! The best thing to focus on is how you feel about yourself and how you feel physically.0
-
I have made a decision to no longer weigh myself. I feel that I am too dependent upon that number. I am eating right and working out and I am sick of being depressed because the numbers aren't moving the way I think they should, when I feel AMAZING. Thoughts? Do I really need to know how much I weigh?
Just no .. you are doing the smartest thing you could do. The scale is the worst method to actually measure success. I wish more people would take that step. Me .. I weigh once a week and mostly to see my body fat%, muscle mass % .. but unfortunately that lbs thing is always in there too. But I have found that people get fixated on "I need to weigh 120 lbs" .. and it is terrible, cause the normal fluctuations can be devastating. You just have to watch the resulting threads in this forum that result.
Good job .. you are doing the right thing by not doing it. Measurements of body fat %, muscle mass % and physical measurements are much more telling.0 -
I recently made the decision to stop weighing myself too. I found myself getting too obsessed with the number and getting disappointed when it didn't go the way I wanted it too. My only goals right now are to eat healthy, exercise regularly, log everything, and occasionally do measurements. I'm trying to focus on how I'm feeling rather than seeing a specific number on the scale and I'm feeling a lot better.0
-
This is such an excellent plan, in my opinion.
As a person recovering from eating disorders, I find it difficult to toss my scale, though I want to. I find it difficult NOT to weigh myself once (or more!) a day. This is my battle right now-- NOT weighing multiple times a day. I allow myself ONCE a day; that's it, no more at all. It seems so silly, but it IS a battle...
I hope to get to the point where I am weighing once a week or, heck, maybe even not at all!
I commend you for battling with your eating disorder! I have had a number of friends get very ill due to them. I hope you get to where you are only weighing yourself once a week or once a month but I'm sure once a day is quite an accomplishment for yourself! Thank you for sharing I appreciate it
0 -
Kevalicious99 wrote: »I have made a decision to no longer weigh myself. I feel that I am too dependent upon that number. I am eating right and working out and I am sick of being depressed because the numbers aren't moving the way I think they should, when I feel AMAZING. Thoughts? Do I really need to know how much I weigh?
Just no .. you are doing the smartest thing you could do. The scale is the worst method to actually measure success. I wish more people would take that step. Me .. I weigh once a week and mostly to see my body fat%, muscle mass % .. but unfortunately that lbs thing is always in there too. But I have found that people get fixated on "I need to weigh 120 lbs" .. and it is terrible, cause the normal fluctuations can be devastating. You just have to watch the resulting threads in this forum that result.
Good job .. you are doing the right thing by not doing it. Measurements of body fat %, muscle mass % and physical measurements are much more telling.
Thanks! I just wish the machines to measure body fat %, etc. weren't so darn expensive!!0 -
Daily weight check for me .. Keeps me focused and allows me to adjust my intake if i'm gaining0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions