Stomach rumbling? Hungry? How do you tell the difference between...
Options
![rprussell2004](https://dakd0cjsv8wfa.cloudfront.net/images/photos/user/30f1/b284/68bd/0c2c/7600/6b2e/3ea1/90d943edf3383806ebe157eb6ee589ec97d6.jpg)
rprussell2004
Posts: 870 Member
...between "stomach grumbling because it EXPECTS food in it" hungry, and "genuinely need sustenance of some kind" hungry?
I mean, I don't want to STARVE myself, but if it's just out of habit - even autonomic habit - I don't feel much point to it.
I mean, I don't want to STARVE myself, but if it's just out of habit - even autonomic habit - I don't feel much point to it.
0
Replies
-
I did the 5:2 diet for a couple of weeks just to mix it up. It helped me know what hunger felt like again. Go a day with no food and you will know what hunger feels like vs. what desire feels like.0
-
-
IMHO you can get a good gauge of hunger about 20 minutes after you eat. If your stomach is rumbling and you really feel hungry after that time, eat a small snack. You shouldn't have to feel like you are starving.0
-
Interesting question. I just eat when I plan to rather than when I'm hungry. I know how much I need to maintain, get fat or lose fat so I eat according to whatever goal I'm aiming for. You get used to being hungry after a while.0
-
Sometimes my stomach rumbling is actually telling me I am thirsty. But with that said, if your body is used to getting food at a certain time of day everyday, it will get used to a new or different schedule fairly quickly.
If after I drink something (water) and it is still rumbling I eat a light snack. After exercise I do need to eat at least 1 hour after.. This rumbling is real hunger..0 -
I will drink a few ounces of water, chew a piece of gum - check back in after 20-30 minutes and see if I still feel rumbly.0
-
I'll be honest - I have a hard time with this! When I'm home, I tend to "graze" all day long. If I'm not eating, my stomach thinks it's hungry. When I start eating in a more healthy manner (ie - not all the time!), I have to plan my food and nutrition. I make sure I get enough calories and hit my goals (mostly with protein and fiber - I never have a problem hitting the carbs and fat goals. I think that's part of my problem :-)). And for about 2 weeks, my belly thinks it is starving. I want to eat all the time. But I've never died, never passed out, so one thing I've learned is that I can't trust my belly to tell me when I'm hungry when I begin a healthy eating routine. But after about 2 weeks, my body adjusts, and I can start looking for hunger cues. Some things that I look for is not a grumbly tummy, but energy levels, shakiness (if I've done some heavy cardio and don't have enough to fuel my body, I can get a little shaky), and my general mood. Listening to my belly tends to just make it bigger...
- Good luck!!!
-0 -
I don't trust my stomach's hunger signals after a lifetime of being overweight. I know my calorie target and eat to that regardless of what my stomach wants me to believe.0
-
I'm still learning to differentiate hunger and habit because I don't trust my brain when it says it's hungry. So if I think I'm hungry I drink a bottle of water. If I'm still hungry in 15-20 minutes I'll eat something. I also have to eat a lot slower than I used to, to give my brain a chance to tell me I'm full rather than eating to the point of being stuffed.0
-
dopeysmelly wrote: »I don't trust my stomach's hunger signals after a lifetime of being overweight. I know my calorie target and eat to that regardless of what my stomach wants me to believe.
Pretty much this. ^^
0 -
dopeysmelly wrote: »I don't trust my stomach's hunger signals after a lifetime of being overweight. I know my calorie target and eat to that regardless of what my stomach wants me to believe.
Agreed. I keep seeing people complaining about being hungry - well yeah! If you're hungry, you're doing SOMETHING right. When my stomach growls I growl right back.0 -
shadowofender wrote: »I'm still learning to differentiate hunger and habit because I don't trust my brain when it says it's hungry. So if I think I'm hungry I drink a bottle of water. If I'm still hungry in 15-20 minutes I'll eat something. I also have to eat a lot slower than I used to, to give my brain a chance to tell me I'm full rather than eating to the point of being stuffed.
incredibly helpful, i am going to try your water and wait 15-20 minute tactic. according to my brain, i am always always always always hungry. thanks for your suggestions.
0 -
i read on one of my fb pages i follow that said if you're not hungry enough to eat an apple, you're not really hungry..so i've been trying to go with that mindset.0
-
Often, the stomach rumbling feeling can be dehydration. If you're certain you're eating enough calories, try drinking water and waiting 20 minutes to see if the feeling subsides.
I remember telling this to my dad (who has always struggled with weight) and he said "no, when I feel hungry it's because I'm hungry". I asked him if he'd ever tried drinking water when he felt that way and his answer, of course, was no. :laugh:0 -
When my stomach growls, I'm know I'm hungry. However, letting myself get stomach growling hungry triggers migraines for me. For a lot of people, waiting too long can also trigger overeating. So I plan my meals and snacks that fit my calorie goals at regular intervals. When it's time to eat, I eat, unless I'm really just *not* hungry.
If you think you're eating out of boredom, I know a lot of people who chew gum to help with that. Sometimes it's just the chewing action that your body wants. Gum is a good distraction.0 -
Do the apple/carrot test.
My mom always made us do the apple/carrot test. For me it was carrots, for my brother it was apples.
Basically pick a food that you don't really like but WILL eat. If the idea of eating that food is completely a turn off, you aren't hungry.
if the food is an option and you would eat it, then you are hungry.0 -
Original_Sinner wrote: »Do the apple/carrot test.
My mom always made us do the apple/carrot test. For me it was carrots, for my brother it was apples.
Basically pick a food that you don't really like but WILL eat. If the idea of eating that food is completely a turn off, you aren't hungry.
if the food is an option and you would eat it, then you are hungry.
This is my new tactic, thank you! I have lots of trouble with deciding if I'm really hungry (it's easier when I'm on my work rotation, but when I'm home for two weeks I just want to stuff my face) and I can think of several occasions where I was "hungry", looked at the fresh carrots and cut celery, and decided that wasn't what I wanted to I turned to the oreos. Now I'll pay more attention to that moment.0 -
I never really got to the point where I was having hunger pangs and growling stomach...I just ate to my calorie goal and planned out my day so that I wouldn't be hungry. IMO, if you're hungry you're doing it wrong.0
-
I try drinking a lot of water and seeing if I feel the same. Also, I've recently been incorporating peppermint tea in when ever I start to feel hungry - because sometimes I can't tell if my mind is tricking my body because I'm just thinking about eating and want to eat when I'm bored, or if I actually need it. Peppermint tea is an appetite suppressant so see how that works!0
-
But with that said, if your body is used to getting food at a certain time of day everyday, it will get used to a new or different schedule fairly quickly.
This. When I first started I felt like I wanted to eat at times I had usually eaten, but it would go away if I ignored it long enough. Usually exercise would actually help. Sometimes I just ate something low calorie to have something to eat (carrots, celery), and that helped me get that it wasn't really an issue of hunger. That was something I only really had to do for the first week.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 402 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 998 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions