Map My Walk
Kgerber777
Posts: 105 Member
I was just wondering if anyone else uses this app? When I use this app I feel like it says I burned a lot more calories than if I had used my treadmill (to tell me the speed I walked) and then entered the info via MFP. Just wondering if I am the only one? it may also be the treadmill I use not displaying an accredit speed (it is older so not out of the question)?
0
Replies
-
I do when I walk outside in the Summer - I really liked it because I got to challenge myself to beat my own time. Plus, with the accuracy of GPS nowadays, I'd go with the app.
0 -
I find it easier to walk/run faster on the ground than on the treadmill. I don't exactly know why.0
-
It takes elevation change in to account. I find it to be pretty accurate. I've been using it almost 2 years.0
-
I use Runkeeper to map my walks and hikes.0
-
Elevation0
-
I've been tracking my calories burned using a pedometer for years, and then tried Map My Hike (or walk, whatever), and felt that it overestimated my calories burned by A LOT, like over twice as many. I don't sync the app with MFP, I enter my exercise separately, and almost always enter about 1/3 of the calories the Map My XXX calculates.0
-
thanks for the info0
-
I use Mapmyrun, and i think it's the same thing. I hardly run anyways, I always walk, and you can use it for both.
I like it overall but it's frustrating that I walk in a straight line, yet it shows I'm walking in a wavy or zigazag-type pattern, which I know adds more calories to it. It synchs my workout to MFP, but I usually delete it and reenter it with a lower speed. For example when I walk fast, it's about 4 mph, but it says I walked 5 mph, which I know is not true. So I enter the minutes and the speed I know is correct.
But overall I still use it because I don't know of any other that would be better.0 -
I do much the same - I do wonder if Map My Walk calculates on my weight/height and whether MFP does too.
-For example, I walked to work this morning 4.1km in 41 minutes (3.7 miles per hour)
The route is up and down hills and I am carrying a fair bit of weight
MMW says I burnt 437 calories - seems high
If I search MFP I find Walking brisk pace for 41 mins @ 3.5mph = 301 calories
I hope MMW is right!0 -
I use MapMyRun (or mapometer) .co.uk for a couple of years, mainly to get the distance rather than calorie burn as I find them a little on the high side. However I suppose they are as accurate as any other method of calculation! I work on 80-100 cals per mile for running and 60-70 cals per mile for walking, both depending on how much effort I feel I've put in, how much I've sweated etc.0
-
I use MapMyHike to track distance, but use a HRM to track calories burned. The app does overestimate calories burned by quite a bit, at least for me. This is true for walking/hiking and also for cycling.0
-
I also use it and have found that there is a big discrepancy between MMW and MFP. I hope that MMW is accurate (It will make me feel a lot better). Sometimes I adjust the calories burned, but for the most part, I just let it sync with MFP.0
-
I use MMW to calculate speed, time and distance. I let it sync with MFP, and the calories burned seem way to high. I take the info, (s, t ,d) and plug it in to get MFP calories burned and then delete the 'synced' amount from MMW0
-
Kgerber777 wrote: »I was just wondering if anyone else uses this app? When I use this app I feel like it says I burned a lot more calories than if I had used my treadmill (to tell me the speed I walked) and then entered the info via MFP. Just wondering if I am the only one? it may also be the treadmill I use not displaying an accredit speed (it is older so not out of the question)?
All the MapMyFitness apps are inaccurate. If you email them they will send you a complicated way to recalibrate it, but they obviously haven't done anything to correct it.
Get a pedometer instead for steps or use an activity tracker, although activity trackers are pretty optimistic about how much you burn as well. The technology is still not really there.0 -
I thought this to be the case at first too. I started wearing my HRM when I went on the walks and found out that they were pretty darn close! Only about 5 calories plus or minus for difference.0
-
I use my hrm.0
-
I use mapmyrun, I just override the calories before I finish my entry. I don't want to eat my calories, or have them looking at me as an option lol, tried that, didn't work for me. Anyway, I just put a flat 10 calories per half hour, just a silly number, but a number. I find it tracks pretty accurately, I've not noticed the zigzag thing.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions