Problems with candy - substitute ideas?

jaykal001
jaykal001 Posts: 24 Member
edited November 12 in Food and Nutrition
This came to me last night as I really had an urge for some candy. For some people it seems to be cake or junk food, mine has always been candy. What are everyone's thoughts on cutting this back? I've been essentially cold turkey on candy for 4 weeks, and it's certainly tough, but it prompted a couple questions.

1) When you have a craving for something like candy, what is something you turn to as a substitute?

2) If you decide to splurge, what candy is better than others? (Is a PB cup better because it's a bit more filling?)

Replies

  • martyqueen52
    martyqueen52 Posts: 1,120 Member
    Quest makes a peanut butter cup which can be bought at GNC, called "Quest Cravings". The peanut butter inside it is a little dry, but it had 20g of protein in it, which is really good.

    I personally love them.

    jelly beans aren't bad either. Like 33 of them is 120-140 calories. Or just fit whatever you like into your daily caloric allowance and don't restrict yourself which will lead to a massive binge at some point.
  • nikkohli
    nikkohli Posts: 311 Member
    I like the dole chocolate covered frozen strawberries. I think 4 of them is 60 cals. They are expensive though!!! Like pp said, I would try and fit it in--I have a few squares of dark chocolate at night and it is a satisfying end to my day. I also really like Sour Patch Kids--I think a pack is about 150 cals.
  • Jolinia
    Jolinia Posts: 846 Member
    I would say raisins, but I may or may not have been known to chow down on the entire family size pack.

    My favorite candy that I will buy on very rare occasions and give all but one or two away before I eat them are chewy Gin gins.
  • Timorous_Beastie
    Timorous_Beastie Posts: 595 Member
    Sometimes, I go for a protein bar. You're not really saving any calories, but if I'm going to have ~200 calories in chocolate, I'd rather they come with 15-20 g of protein than 2.

    Sometimes, I just have the candy. I'm ok with a couple pieces of "fun sized" bars. It's more the taste I crave than being hungry.

    I've realized I love sweet tasting fruit. If I'm actually hungry for a snack, I'd rather blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, grapes or kiwis. I prefer to leave it on the counter, so I'll see it and eat it. It's too easy to ignore in the fridge. Then they grow little furry coats and need to be tossed.
  • crystalewhite
    crystalewhite Posts: 422 Member
    I recently made some vanilla honey and I drizzle that over fruit. I've actually got some raspberries with it at my desk this morning. It's still has about 75 calories but at least it's got some fiber and vitamin C.
    There are also starburst in my desk for later if needed, but there is only about half a serving. I try to eat them slowly so they are a little more satisfying.
  • chouflour
    chouflour Posts: 193 Member
    When I first started losing weight, I kept track of servings of sweets, with a target of no more than 7 a week. I had the best results when my choices were dark chocolate with nuts or peanut butter. Justin's peanut butter cups, Trader Joe's dark chocolate with hazelnuts, etc.

    I like fruit when my mouth wants something sweet at the end of a meal. Lately I've been craving coco-roons, which are totally not a good choice for me. I need to take something else to the office instead.
  • AndreaWhite611
    AndreaWhite611 Posts: 54 Member
    Raspberries with a decent helping of lite cool whip (yes, i realize its not health food) have been doing it for my sweet cravings lately.
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    candy? Just eat it.

    Or replace it with meat. You don't need candy, so sack up and knock it off, or eat it, while making it work, or eat it while realizing you may not care about your goals.

    That's three options right there.
  • goddessofawesome
    goddessofawesome Posts: 563 Member
    Honestly I don't get cravings for candy.

    With that said though if I do crave something I don't immediately give in. I will wait and see if after 10-15 minutes the craving subsides, which typically it does. If it doesn't then I will have a small portion of whatever it is I am craving (typically it's cheese or nuts).

    Also, I like the jelly bean idea. Sweet and not a lot of calories for the portion.
  • Brimixed
    Brimixed Posts: 186 Member
    I find if I deny myself the real deal... I'm just going to splurge later. I get those mini bites and just have one as I'm walking out the door to do something else (that way I'm not tempted to eat more!).
    Also try...
    -dessert gum
    -dark chocolate (healthier option)
  • kaylajane11
    kaylajane11 Posts: 313 Member
    You can buy Ghirardelli chocolate squares at most grocery stores. They have lots of different flavors/fillings and the squares are individually wrapped. I recently bought the dark chocolate mint ones, which taste like a peppermint patty and are only 70 calories each.
  • astrose00
    astrose00 Posts: 754 Member
    I used to OD on candy but haven't had any since starting to lose weight. I just stay away from it because it's too easy for me to abuse it. I don't "need" it and think sometime I ate it because I was just bored. A piece of fruit should easily suffice. I have probably subbed my candy addiction for sugarless gum. Not calorie fee but it would be really hard to abuse it to the point where my weight loss suffered. It keeps me occupied and actually burns calories! I hear 11 calories an hour! If I could manage to eat only a few pieces it would be a negative calorie food. I LOVE Orbit Peppermint gum. Yum!!!
  • I'm not sure what your macro's are like (aka if your getting enough protein, which for a lot of people causes sugar cravings) or maybe its a purely habitual thing. For me it is a bit of both. If its been a while since a meal, even though its still not super healthy, I will have a protein bar (pure protein and detour and oh yeah! make bars that basically taste like candy bars, just make sure to stick to one around 200 calories)

    If it is after a meal, and I know that I just had a decent amount of protein, I will have a piece of dark chocolate (1 large lindt chocolate square=50 calories) by itself or with a few berries. Or really just any portion controlled sweet. Another solution, get some nice flavoured tea and sip that after your meal. Add a sweetner and you basically have around a 0 calorie sweet drink.

    I'm not really sure the reason behind the wanting sweets so I'm just doing my best to help you out
  • beemerphile1
    beemerphile1 Posts: 1,710 Member
    Cut out soft items like candy bars and limit your self to hard candy. Hold it in your mouth til it dissolves.
  • jaykal001
    jaykal001 Posts: 24 Member
    dbmata wrote: »
    candy? Just eat it.

    Or replace it with meat. You don't need candy, so sack up and knock it off, or eat it, while making it work, or eat it while realizing you may not care about your goals.

    That's three options right there.

    I do appreciate the sentiment, however the reason I asked was be it's a struggle.
    If it was easy to just quit it, we'd all be skinny, lol. We all struggle with different things, if we didn't we wouldn't be here.
  • jaykal001
    jaykal001 Posts: 24 Member
    I'm not sure what your macro's are like (aka if your getting enough protein, which for a lot of people causes sugar cravings) or maybe its a purely habitual thing. For me it is a bit of both. If its been a while since a meal, even though its still not super healthy, I will have a protein bar (pure protein and detour and oh yeah! make bars that basically taste like candy bars, just make sure to stick to one around 200 calories)

    If it is after a meal, and I know that I just had a decent amount of protein, I will have a piece of dark chocolate (1 large lindt chocolate square=50 calories) by itself or with a few berries. Or really just any portion controlled sweet. Another solution, get some nice flavoured tea and sip that after your meal. Add a sweetner and you basically have around a 0 calorie sweet drink.

    I'm not really sure the reason behind the wanting sweets so I'm just doing my best to help you out

    I love fruits and veggies, eat plenty of chicken, PB, etc. I'm not worried about protein being too low. I know that I've got 25 years or horrible habits to correct, so i'm tweaking and adjusting what I can while i form new habits. What I've been trying with on-and-off success is trying to only have candy if it still fit in the daily 'budget' and if I had gone to the gym.

    The physical part is easier than fighting a mind who's led you wrong for so long!
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    jaykal001 wrote: »
    dbmata wrote: »
    candy? Just eat it.

    Or replace it with meat. You don't need candy, so sack up and knock it off, or eat it, while making it work, or eat it while realizing you may not care about your goals.

    That's three options right there.

    I do appreciate the sentiment, however the reason I asked was be it's a struggle.
    If it was easy to just quit it, we'd all be skinny, lol. We all struggle with different things, if we didn't we wouldn't be here.
    No.

    You choose to make it a struggle.

    Which is more important, your goals, or your candy?
    You have three options:
    1. Eat it and anything else can sod off.
    2. Replace it with something else completely.
    3. Eat it in moderation.

    Two of those are compatible with goal setting, one is easier than the other. Which of the three do you choose?
  • Roxiegirl2008
    Roxiegirl2008 Posts: 756 Member
    I get the individually wrapped minis and I have one of those per day or a tooties roll pop. It makes it easy for me since they are individual then I am less likely to eat a ton of them.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    edited February 2015
    Define 'candy'.

    Personally, I found energy and protein bars 'healthier' alternatives for candy bars (same calories, but they fill me up more). Or a square of dark chocolate. Otherwise, vitamin gummies, once a day, lol. I like candy bars but I very rarely eat them because they don't fill me up for the calories, but if I'm really craving something specific, I'll have a small one (like I have a PB cup in my near future, although I bought some Reese's spread to put in my oatmeal tomorrow and that might just do the trick).
  • wizzybeth
    wizzybeth Posts: 3,578 Member
    I started getting butterscotch discs and root beer barrels. I make them last a long long time, as opposed to my previous obsession, m&ms, swedish fish, or jujyfruits..which disappear in seconds, lol. Or I chew gum.
  • NK1112
    NK1112 Posts: 781 Member
    My downfall is candy also and I know if it is in the house I will eat it, and then I won't be able to stop with just a piece ... I'll eat all of it. So I abstain from it as much as possible. For me, unfortunately, when that craving just won't go away for days on end, I buy 2 candy bars or a 70% dark chocolate bar ... and eat it.
  • 3laine75
    3laine75 Posts: 3,069 Member
    Just less candy.

    If you can fit it into your cals and macros, have it that day. If not, don't (or do, it's up to you).

    As to which candy - snicker has 5g protein, but that's not why it's awesome :smiley: Again, depends on the day, if I have enough left, I'll have a snicker, if not a milky way or whatever.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Oh chewy caramels are awesome too... About 28 calories, and it takes a while to chew them and get them off your teeth, lol.
This discussion has been closed.