Suggested calories vs BMR?
Mommieof2SNS
Posts: 24
So MFP gave me a daily goal of consuming 1200 calories but when I punch in my number for my BMR is says 1500. What's the difference?
0
Replies
-
BMR = Basal Metabolic Rate....in other words the calories your body burns before you do anything.
MFP Goal = Number of calories to consume based on how many lbs per week you said you want to lose and estimated TDEE without exercise...MFP will add calories in as you log exercise so that your daily deficit doesn't get too large
TDEE = Total Daily Energy Expenditure.....BMR + daily Activity + exercise
You need to eat below your TDEE to lose weight.0 -
oh ok so if i go say 100 calories over my daily intake but I exercise I'm fine?0
-
If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.0
-
is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?0
-
Use this calculator to find out how many calories a day (even on days you dont workout) you should be eating. With this you would not eat back your exercise cals as it is already figured in.
http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/0 -
Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
0 -
thank you. I dont think I've been eating enough and I stay hungry throught the day even while doing the small 6 meals throughout the day.0
-
I'm guessing you chose "lose 2 pounds per week" when you set it up. Set it to lose 1 pound per week. and see if it doesn't give you more calories.0
-
If you eat too low and exercise you will lose weight, but that weight might not be fat, more than likely muscle and water. So, yeah, up those calories according to the calculator and see what happens. You should not be hungry! This is a lifestyle not a punishment.0
-
yeah initially i chose to lose 3 pounds a week and it changed somehow to lose 2 pounds a week. i'll try putting 1 and see what happens.0
-
Pickles175 wrote: »If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.Pickles175 wrote: »Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
Why do you believe that?0 -
i just did the calculator and it said my bmr is actually 1615. @Pickles1750
-
3 pounds a week is not healthy! 1 pound is more sustainable. If you are going to go by the mfp method, with the number they give they expect you to eat back your exercise calories.0
-
Pickles175 wrote: »If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.Pickles175 wrote: »Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
Why do you believe that?
Because your bmr is how many calories your body needs to burn just to stay alive and function (say if you were in a coma and did nothing else). Why would you eat below what your body needs to function?
0 -
What did it give you for daily calorie goal?0
-
Pickles175 wrote: »Pickles175 wrote: »If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.Pickles175 wrote: »Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
Why do you believe that?
Because your bmr is how many calories your body needs to burn just to stay alive and function (say if you were in a coma and did nothing else). Why would you eat below what your body needs to function?
Well it doesn't matter if you do as long as you get your nutritional spread. The body will still stay alive and function, if eating below BMR lets you hit a safe goal of weight loss then it's no big deal
Why, what do you think is going to happen if she eats fewer calories than her BMR?0 -
i read it wrong. BMR: 1532 TDEE: 26430
-
Some people would never create a deficit if they only ate above their BMR. That said, BMR is not the data point from which a deficit gets calculated.0
-
Pickles175 wrote: »Pickles175 wrote: »If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.Pickles175 wrote: »Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
Why do you believe that?
Because your bmr is how many calories your body needs to burn just to stay alive and function (say if you were in a coma and did nothing else). Why would you eat below what your body needs to function?
Well it doesn't matter if you do as long as you get your nutritional spread. The body will still stay alive and function, if eating below BMR lets you hit a safe goal of weight loss then it's no big deal
Why, what do you think is going to happen if she eats fewer calories than her BMR?
If she eats below her bmr she will not lose fat, but water and muscle. The scale may go down but she wont be fit and toned. I want to lose fat and not just weight. I want to be healthy. I dont want to feel hungry, exhausted and moody. I dont want my hair to fall out. All these things can happen if you eat below your bmr for too low. Your body will function, yes, but not in a healthy way.
0 -
Pickles175 wrote: »Pickles175 wrote: »Pickles175 wrote: »If your bmr is 1500, you should never have net calories below that number.Pickles175 wrote: »Mommieof2SNS wrote: »is that all calories consumed through the day including the ones i get back from working out?
Yes, by the end of the day your net calories should be a number higher than bmr.
Why do you believe that?
Because your bmr is how many calories your body needs to burn just to stay alive and function (say if you were in a coma and did nothing else). Why would you eat below what your body needs to function?
Well it doesn't matter if you do as long as you get your nutritional spread. The body will still stay alive and function, if eating below BMR lets you hit a safe goal of weight loss then it's no big deal
Why, what do you think is going to happen if she eats fewer calories than her BMR?
If she eats below her bmr she will not lose fat, but water and muscle. The scale may go down but she wont be fit and toned. I want to lose fat and not just weight. I want to be healthy. I dont want to feel hungry, exhausted and moody. I dont want my hair to fall out. All these things can happen if you eat below your bmr for too low. Your body will function, yes, but not in a healthy way.
Yeah
It doesn't work that way0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions