Help running lots, losing nothing!

bigbeff
bigbeff Posts: 83 Member
edited November 13 in Fitness and Exercise
hi,
I am currently training for a marathon and am running about 25miles a week... This will go up, and I do spinning once a week. I know I'm eating too much to lose, that's under control with clean eating lent. I'm not putting on, I'm stagnant!! But I could do with some weight training to complement my running, will probably only fit in twice a week, but I don't know where to start. Help?

Replies

  • cheshirecatastrophe
    cheshirecatastrophe Posts: 1,395 Member
    Honestly, I would not recommend starting a serious or even semi-serious lifting program while training for a marathon. Your legs are going to be stressed enough as you build mileage. Don't make it worse--that's a quick way to injury.

    Maybe do some bodyweight work (bodyweight squats, lunges, etc) for the duration of your training plan, then after your month or so recovery from the race, look into one of the 3-day-a-week lifting programs. Bodybuilding.com also has some "weightlifting for runners" plans which, well, look pretty similar to the basic start programs (Stronglifts, Starting Strength, etc).

    Yoga or Pilates a couple times a week could also work on strength and flexibility that would ultimately benefit your running.

    As for "losing nothing"--as you said, that's a question of eating enough to cancel out the increased calorie burn from your training. Tracking carefully, not just depending on limiting the kinds of things you eat, is probably your best weapon against the tendency of marathon trainees to gain weight over the course of their plan. :)
  • CA_Underdog
    CA_Underdog Posts: 733 Member
    edited February 2015
    I know I'm eating too much to lose, that's under control with clean eating
    In most cases a calorie is a calorie, whether we call it "clean" or "dirty". Sounds like you know you're overeating, and that's the first sign to addressing the problem.

    I do strength training and am beginning to transition to running. My plan is to continue training three times a week, but now do running then strength training. That way tired legs will not contribute to any running injuries, no more gym days, and I don't need double warm-ups / stretches. ;)

    As for strength programs--Stronglifts (simpler) and NROL (more complex) are popular and also reasonably good starter programs with progression built right in.
  • bigbeff
    bigbeff Posts: 83 Member
    Thanks for the advice. I'll have a look into strong lifts. I might talk to trainer about starting program now, because legs are working very hard currently and I don't want to cause injury! 7 weeks until big day!!
  • Just watch your food and calorie intake. After running, don't eat like you ran 21K even though you just ran a 10K.

    I trained for a marathon last year. Come race day, I lost 34 pounds! I just do some core/plyo training in between run trainings.
  • Lois_1989
    Lois_1989 Posts: 6,410 Member
    I am a bit new to this so I don't mind if you ignore me, but I have read and re-read New Rules of Lifting for Women and I'm sure in there he was saying that strength training while training for a marathon is a bad idea. Something about the muscle fibers for endurance are short and strength fibers are long so doing both at the same time isn't good. HOWEVER I have absolutely no experience with this so by all means take advice from someone who has.
  • jonsmithkidd
    jonsmithkidd Posts: 1,204 Member
    Just keep an eye on logging your calorie intake. Have you got MFP calorie goals set up to lose or maintain?
  • cheshirecatastrophe
    cheshirecatastrophe Posts: 1,395 Member
    edited February 2015
    Weight lifting is very beneficial to runners, especially glutes, hips, core stuff.

    However.

    Don't start it 7 weeks out from a marathon, one month out of taper. You are peaking. This is the maximum amount of stress you're putting on your body. Don't add a whole massive new component at this point. Run the race, do awesome, recover, then look into lifting.

    I'm curious what training plan has you only running 25 mpw, seven week out, though?
  • BerryH
    BerryH Posts: 4,698 Member
    Based on the experience of myself and friends, unless you're just starting with weight loss, it's almost impossible to lose a significant amount of weight when marathon training, if at all. Fuelling yourself for running and recovery is more important just now. Losing will still work is you stay under your MFP calorie limits, but be realistic about your burns. A 10 mile run won't necessarily burn twice as much as two separate 5-milers as you become more efficient. How are you measuring your calorie burns? MFP is over-generous with running calories in my opinion. Since I switched to using FitBit, I only get about half as many extra for a long run, but a good TDEE calculator should give you similar reliable results.
  • WhatMeRunning
    WhatMeRunning Posts: 3,538 Member
    edited February 2015
    Let me tell you from experience that if you do not properly replenish the calories burned from long endurance runs you will regret it. You will hit the wall by running out of glycogen stores on one day, and find yourself starving the next and wanting to eat everything in sight! You need to nourish that level of effort, that sort of distance is not for casual dieters, but for someone more athletic who must eat.
  • I tried to lose weight while training for a marathon.After a week I had no energy.I agree with the others.You need the fuel!
  • SonicDeathMonkey80
    SonicDeathMonkey80 Posts: 4,489 Member
    bigbeff wrote: »
    hi,
    I am currently training for a marathon and am running about 25miles a week... This will go up, and I do spinning once a week. I know I'm eating too much to lose, that's under control with clean eating lent. I'm not putting on, I'm stagnant!! But I could do with some weight training to complement my running, will probably only fit in twice a week, but I don't know where to start. Help?

    "Clean eating" isn't a magic bullet to lose weight, and neither is running. It's all about CICO.
  • JustWant2Run
    JustWant2Run Posts: 286 Member
    edited February 2015
    I'm marathon training right now, running over 40mpw, and I lost 6.3 lbs in the past 4 weeks. It's doable if you don't use your running as an excuse to stuff your face with everything in sight. I'm eating 60% carbs and losing. I'm not hungry and I'm recovering well.

    It's all about making good filling choices instead of eating junk food. Stay away from the cookies and ice cream and pizza and eat yogurts and fruits and veggies instead.

    ETA: I use the formula (Bodyweight in lbs) x (0.63) x (miles ran) to get a more realistic net calories burned number than what Garmin or MFP is giving me.
  • lbetancourt
    lbetancourt Posts: 522 Member
    I did exactly the above, "stuffed my face with everything in sight" when I trained for a marathon last year. good times.
  • Roxiegirl2008
    Roxiegirl2008 Posts: 756 Member
    I just finished my marathon and during my training for that race I was very mindful about what I was eating. After really long runs I could have eaten everything in sight. I choose foods that were more filling (as Training2BeFast mentioned) and I tracked everything. I still managed to loose weight. On long run days I would eat back about 2/3 my calories but with things that I knew were really filling. Almond butter and English muffin was a go to snack for me. I never once hit a wall and finished my marathon well under what my goal was and I experienced little cramping (if any) and most of my long runs were really great.

    As far as weight lifting goes, I was doing weight training well before starting to train for my marathon. It did help get my legs stronger but again my trainer had me start well before my race.

    Good luck and enjoy the ride! It is a great one!
  • AllanMisner
    AllanMisner Posts: 4,140 Member
    I actually gained weight when I was training for a marathon. This happened because I was eating more than I needed to fuel my body (who wants to bonk on the long runs?).

    What you eat and the quantity of what you eat will determine fat loss/gain. If you’re eating at a slight deficit, you’ll begin to lose fat (and maybe some muscle). But training for a marathon on a deficit will be very, very hard (especially on the longer runs). If you’re going to eat at a calorie deficit, you’ll need to work hard on nutrient timing and making sure you’re eating very nutrient dense food.
  • 3dogsrunning
    3dogsrunning Posts: 27,167 Member
    Everyone has pretty much covered what I would say - if you don't have your calories under control, you aren't going to lose weight. Running, especially high mileage, is notorious for increasing appetite. And "clean eating" is not required.

    I just wanted to add that while I do agree with strength training, I've done Stronglifts and it's a great program however I didn't find it a good compliment to running. I found it difficult to balance increasing mileage. At the moment I am upping my milage and had to put SL on hold.
  • CA_Underdog
    CA_Underdog Posts: 733 Member
    edited February 2015
    3dogsrunning, what was the obstacle for you? I regularly do strength training and am adding in running. My plan was to run first, lift after, to preserve good running form.

    (I also like that it keeps my heavy training at 3 days per week!)

    I suspect my squat and deadlift will suffer a little, in terms of my max weight, but I imagine I'll still see progress there and especially in my upper body.
  • 3dogsrunning
    3dogsrunning Posts: 27,167 Member
    3dogsrunning, what was the obstacle for you? I regularly do strength training and am adding in running. My plan was to run first, lift after, to preserve good running form.

    (I also like that it keeps my heavy training at 3 days per week!)

    I suspect my squat and deadlift will suffer a little, in terms of my max weight, but I imagine I'll still see progress there and especially in my upper body.

    Not strength training but Stronglifts particularly.
    SL has you squatting 3 days a week and increasing weight each time. And I was trying to run 3-4 times a week which leaves me little time to recover and even having to run on the same day.
    I never ran before SL but even swimming before impacted my workout. Running after, my running suffered.
    My priority right now is not on increasing my lifts. I do plan to do a strength training program once I find one but not continuing with Stronglifts.

    I have done strength training in the past successfully while training for a half marathon. I planned my easier run to overlap a lifting day. I spaced my heavy leg day and my long run.
  • christyprunner
    christyprunner Posts: 70 Member
    So hard to lose while training for a marathon... I have tried and failed MANY times. Sometimes you under eat, sometimes you over eat. It's a hard balance when you are constantly hungry yet a 5 mile run is only 500 extra calories. That's not a whole lot. But runners sometimes think it's equivalent to eating much more than that.
  • JustWant2Run
    JustWant2Run Posts: 286 Member
    edited February 2015
    So hard to lose while training for a marathon... I have tried and failed MANY times. Sometimes you under eat, sometimes you over eat. It's a hard balance when you are constantly hungry yet a 5 mile run is only 500 extra calories. That's not a whole lot. But runners sometimes think it's equivalent to eating much more than that.

    5miles is ~402 calories for me. Easy to overeat and not lose if you are not logging the correct calorie burn.
  • Walter__
    Walter__ Posts: 518 Member
    Eat less.
  • SueInAz
    SueInAz Posts: 6,592 Member
    Eating less than you burn is the key to avoiding weight gain while training for a race.

    I lift and run on alternating weekdays, rest one weekend day and run the other. I've had no problems with lifting and running on a regular basis. However, I stuck to strictly upper body strength training during the last 6 weeks or so of my HM training plan. I found that working my legs the day before a long run made running too difficult since I started out with my legs already feeling tired. So if you want to lift, do it. Just don't do leg workouts the day of or before a long run or if you find that it's impacting your running at all.
  • loratliff
    loratliff Posts: 283 Member
    edited February 2015
    My weight loss is different since I've started running—a few weeks of no losses and then a big loss. In those seemingly plateau weeks, though, I still notice inches gone and flab firming up; are you sure you're not experiencing the same?

    Also, wearing a HRM has helped me track calorie burn more efficiently. I usually still only eat back half of my exercise calories and even then, that's only if I truly am hungry.
  • briebee7
    briebee7 Posts: 224 Member
    Personally I am taking a maintenance approach rather than trying to lose weight while marathon training. I am logging every day to make sure I am not over eating while being careful of not being in too large of a calorie deficit heading into my long runs. I focused quite a bit the last couple months on getting as close to goal weight as possible though knowing that I didn't want to try to lose weight during training.
  • briebee7
    briebee7 Posts: 224 Member
    Oh like others have said, the quality of calories really make a difference. I have been extra hungry the last few days and when I look back on my diary this last week I realized I have been slacking on my protein intake.
  • bigbeff
    bigbeff Posts: 83 Member
    Thank you all. I think you told me what I need to know. I'm not going to focus on losing weight for next months. I'm going to focus on correct fuelling and healthy choices completing this marathon in under 5hrs! And then think about it :)
This discussion has been closed.