Thinking of joining weight watchers... Need some input...
Jen0414
Posts: 466 Member
I am considering joining weight watchers for the supoort and to be held accountable..
Any information would be great to help me make my decision.
Thanks in advance..
Any information would be great to help me make my decision.
Thanks in advance..
0
Replies
-
Not dissing WW, but how about you log your food/exercise here and find someone on here to help you? It's free and pretty much the same thing - only difference is no meetings and no weighing in in front of strangers.
Bluntly, YOU will be the only one in each situation that gets yourself to the gym and knocks the doughnut that will put you over your calories out of your hand. Having a support system is great but they can't be there every step of the way. YOU need to be ready for all the pitfalls and not depend on others.0 -
If anyone has anything relevant to say it would appreciate it.
Kristen I don't know if you were trying to tell me something I didn't already know but your comment was rude and uncalled for.0 -
I agree with Kristen. You asked for info on How to help make the decision. She gave it; not rude.0
-
I wasn't trying to be rude. I was being honest. There's a difference. But you can do whatever you want. Spend your money whatever way you want. It's your life. Are you really only look for opinions that are like yours? What help is that? Why don't you listen to someone who's been in your shoes? Lost a ton of weight with THIS app because I figured out that the only one I can depend on is me.
Good luck, OP.0 -
My husband tried it. Work paid for it for about 3 months and he did lose some weight but gained it back shortly after his time ran out. If the meetings help you stay on track and you find some buddies to stick with after you finish the program it may be worth it. I saw it as being fairly expensive for much of what you can get for free here.0
-
To answer your question, OP - I did WW a long time ago when they had their Fat & Fiber plan. I do not particularly care for it, and here's why: first off, the scale is NOT the end-all, be-all of weight loss. WW will note any weight gain no matter how miniscule. Bodies fluctuate ALL the time, and .25 lbs is barely a blip but WW will note it. I disagree with that approach because it just makes a person feel like a failure.
Secondly, with all of the free apps (like this one) there is really no need to PAY to lose weight. This community is very supportive; however, I would suggest that you keep an open mind and try not to take things personally (as you did with kristen6350's response) because the written word does not reflect intonation so what you read as being snarky was probably not meant as such.
If you would like support and feedback, feel free to friend request me.
0 -
I have lost a ton of weight on MFP too but I have gained it back and need support.
I am at a period in my life where I need that extra support even if it's only for awhile.
I know that I am the person responsible for "not eating that donut" and getting my butt to the gym. But I need that extra support system right now.0 -
I used to really enjoy WW. I like the meetings and weekly devoted time to focus on health topics and strategies for success. I liked the sharing of successes and sharing of struggles with an in person group. I like the positive reinforcement of stickers and awards and the group celebrating milestones. The in-person positive reinforcement was valuable to me for a time. However after trying weightwatchers multiple times and losing between 25-35 pounds each time, I never reached my goal and ultimately I couldn't make it a permant lifestyle change. The last time I joined, I resented spending the money on it and realized that I wasn't going to be a "lifer". So I stopped going. now I've been on myfitnesspal 9 months and lost 37 pounds. I haven't gotten the same levels of external positive reinforcement here as at weightwstchers, but I am starting to believe that the changes I've made to my diet are sustainable ones that I can use for a lifetime. At the end of the day, the external support that WW gave me wasn't enough to keep me going, but I was successful when I enjoyed it. at the end of the day you need to do what works for you, the only thing that will lead to our success is making long term sustainable changes to our habits around food and exercise. There are lifetime members at weightwstchers who have lost weight and kept it off, maybe you'll be one of them.0
-
If you feel it will help, then try it. Most of the MFP community will say that it's not worth it but if your they type of person that needs that environment to succeed, go for it. You have recognized that you need to try something different & that's good.
Good luck! 0 -
As a former WW member, I say don't waste your time and money on it. There were a lot of reasons why I switched from WW to MFP, but one of the top reasons was that their database and tracking app are horrible. Most of the items that I scanned were not in their database, and many were not even if I searched for them manually. They don't give you information on there like they do on here, they just list the points value. It can make it hard to figure out what may have caused a gain (like sodium consumption) and their only explanation they give is "it just happens", which can be very frustrating. I started double tracking on here to get that information and two weeks later I cancelled my WW membership. It just wasn't worth paying for something when I can get a better product (MFP) for free.
0 -
I know right now you aren't my biggest fan. I need to give a bit of background then ask you to think about something.
I lost 50lbs in 2012 (193-143), using MFP for the last 20. From the summer of 2012 to the fall of 2013 I managed to maintain it within 5lbs. At that point I quit MFP because I thought I had it all figured out. I knew how to keep it off. In December 2014, I weighed in at 167. I had went back to all my "bad" habits pretty much forgetting everything MFP taught me. EVERYTHING. Even down to the eating out of a full bag of chips on the couch at night. I hadn't gotten on the scale for more than a year because I knew if I did I'd have to go back to doing the "right" things. The fun would end. So, after that weigh in and re-gaining 3 pants sizes, I re-remembered and stuck to all those things that MFP taught me - I'm now down 14lbs of that 20ish I had to relose. It's all about doing all those things you learned for the rest of your life. Not just while you are "dieting".
I think you need to ask yourself, honestly, why you re-gained it? Were you doing things that weren't sustainable? Did you have extreme goals? Or did you just become complacent like I did? I've always said all this is totally mental. Getting your brain in a place where all of it makes sense and owning up to our mistakes. No one is perfect. We all fall down, it's about getting back up and believing we can do it.
Now, if you feel that WW is better than MFP, I urge you to try it. I wish you the best of luck in life. I'm seriously not a malicious person. Not a mean bone in my body.0 -
As a former WW member, I say don't waste your time and money on it. There were a lot of reasons why I switched from WW to MFP, but one of the top reasons was that their database and tracking app are horrible. Most of the items that I scanned were not in their database, and many were not even if I searched for them manually. They don't give you information on there like they do on here, they just list the points value. It can make it hard to figure out what may have caused a gain (like sodium consumption) and their only explanation they give is "it just happens", which can be very frustrating. I started double tracking on here to get that information and two weeks later I cancelled my WW membership. It just wasn't worth paying for something when I can get a better product (MFP) for free.
I have had luck in the past with WW, and weighing in every week made me very aware of my food choices on the weekend. BUT, I absolutely agree about the WW database and tracking app. It was very disappointing and I too double tracked to see if it made a difference. Hands down the free MFP is soooo much better.0 -
I've done WW online in the past, and had success with it. This was years ago, before MFP and smart phones existed. At the time, the idea of tracking food intake in an online tool was still fairly novel, and I found it to be helpful. And at least initially, knowing that I was paying for it was motivation to make the most of it. It worked; I lost 20 (or was it 25?) pounds. Fast forward some years, past pharmacy school and my first baby, and I had stopped doing WW. I had a lot of weight to lose, and I decided to start back up with WW again. I found myself dissatisfied with it the second time around. At that time, there was no WW app for Android phones. Very disappointing. (I'm assuming there is one now). And I found the food database to be clunky and cumbersome. It could be better now. I also found myself wanting to have/track more nutritional data other than just points. I wanted to see the actual fat/protein/fiber/calorie amounts. And, since by that time there were some good options for FREE meal/fitness tracking online, I really didn't want to pay for WW anymore. So I began the search for something that was free, had a great database, allowed tracking of multiple various nutrients, was easy to use, and had an Android app. That's when I found MFP, and it's been everything I wanted.
Having said all of that, I do think that some people really benefit from the accountability aspect of WW if you go to meetings and such. My mom did that for years in the 80's and 90's, and it was great for her. The bottom line is that if you think it'll help, give it a try. I have no idea what their program is like right now, as it changes often, but I do think their plans have usually been fairly reasonable.0 -
I did WW about ten years ago when it was Winning Points, I believe it was called. So I tracked everything manually and on the calculator. I lost 30 lbs so I have nothing negative to say about the program but I never went to meetings. I used the At Home Kit. It did teach me to make better choices to be able to eat more throughout my day which is always my goal. Points, calories, same thing but at that time using a calculator or slider made my life easier. I have only ever used their message boards for the forums so I can't speak to their App.
When I needed to lose weight this time I did consider signing up and using the App but figured I would try the MFP route because it is free and it worked. I know you say you need the extra support and if that is meetings then to you that cost is worth it. If that is what it takes to jump start you again then go forward. But I would say if you go the MFP route there is great support here not only in the forums but especially on your friends list. If you are honest with your logging the results will come. Good luck.0 -
I have lost a ton of weight on MFP too but I have gained it back and need support.
I am at a period in my life where I need that extra support even if it's only for awhile.
I know that I am the person responsible for "not eating that donut" and getting my butt to the gym. But I need that extra support system right now.
Then you've answered your own question. If you think it is what you need, by all means, try it. But Kristen's answer was not rude at all. People who do WW also gain back the weight, so it is not some magic answer. It can't hurt to try it. I started that way, but I got more out of MFP. Get a supportive friends list going and possibly join a group, and you might be able to get what you need for free.
0 -
Weight loss is a long, hard journey and it's not one that comes with a perfect formula that works for everyone.
And what works for us today might not work for us 3 months from now etc.
Looking for another form of support doesn't mean you are saying that it's any better than MFP just that it may be what helps you better at this point in time.
The two may even work together for you.
As long as you are still striving to find what works for you then I give you huge props for not giving up.
If you think that WW might be able to help to get you back on track now then I say you should go for it.
We all need to remember that we are here for the same reason - hopefully to lose weight and be healthy AND to support one another.
- Good Luck Jen!!!
0 -
I did WW from November-January. I didn't find the meetings helpful and had a hard time getting to them every week. But it was me, excuse after excuse. I know people who WW has worked for. It just wasn't for me.0
-
As a former WW member, I say don't waste your time and money on it. There were a lot of reasons why I switched from WW to MFP, but one of the top reasons was that their database and tracking app are horrible. Most of the items that I scanned were not in their database, and many were not even if I searched for them manually. They don't give you information on there like they do on here, they just list the points value. It can make it hard to figure out what may have caused a gain (like sodium consumption) and their only explanation they give is "it just happens", which can be very frustrating. I started double tracking on here to get that information and two weeks later I cancelled my WW membership. It just wasn't worth paying for something when I can get a better product (MFP) for free.
I have had luck in the past with WW, and weighing in every week made me very aware of my food choices on the weekend. BUT, I absolutely agree about the WW database and tracking app. It was very disappointing and I too double tracked to see if it made a difference. Hands down the free MFP is soooo much better.
I totally agree with this! I hated the app and logging points.0 -
I did WW a few years back when they still had the points system (I have no idea what they do now). I was not a fan. I didn't feel it taught me anything about nutrition; but it did teach me how to cheat the system by eating all the "free" foods (fruits, veggies...which aren't actually free and very little protein because the points were high). My total points added up to about 1050 calories a day. That was far from sustainable to me. I lurked here for a while, saw how the successful people did it, befriended them, and I lost 30 pounds here. FOR FREE.
You may not like the answers you get, but that second post was spot on.0 -
I was a ww member for about a year or so and didn't really like it that much. As someone already said, the focus really is on the scale, which is disheartening because that scale isn't always telling the whole story. I left and came here and I've lost more weight here than I did at ww.0
-
I found it helpful to get started and quickly got repetitive for me. I got tired of the constant selling as well. My weight failures are directly tied to quality of my mental health. I'm addressing the latter and re-addressing the former. A friend's wife has been going on and off for 20+ years and loves it. I think of it as a viable tool in my tool box. I very well may need it again and I glad its there. Right now the MFP and water aerobics (add weights later) are working.0
-
I tried the online WW started in January and although I did lose weight during that time the online program didn't do anything that MFP didn't do (except its not free like this program). I have never been to the meetings so I cant say anything about those. I did find that logging on here is easier than on the WW program. I hope this helps.0
-
I think if you feel that the support and accountability is helpful, then it might be the thing for you to get you started. I needed the accountability to give me the jump start I needed. I didn't do WW, but I did do a "Biggest Looser" type program at my gym and used MFP along with it. We had weekly weigh in, and beginning, middle and end measurements. So you could do both. There was someone else in my program who was doing WW, biggest looser AND MFP at the same time. The accountability helped me to get started, but I knew I would be on my own after 10 weeks. I lost 7 pounds in the 10 weeks then I was able to continue on my own until I hit goal. So the accountability got me started so that I developed the good habits I needed to continue. I hit goal last May and haven't gained it back. My sister has been doing WW and lost 28 pounds so far. Good luck with whatever you decide. Only you know what would work for you. I agree that eventually we have to figure out how to do it on our own, but if something will help you to get there, why not try it? MFP app was key to my success.0
-
I have done WW about 3-4 times, each time successfully for a short amount of time. I agree with all of the above: difficult app/database, poor focus on nutrition, focus on scale and selling products...plus every year or two they change the system which means you end up buying new books or "tools" over and over. My other issues were, if the friends you make there as your support quit, it makes it difficult to continue yourself because you aren't necessarily relying on you (my personal experience...when friends quit, I quit) and if the leaders change...not all leaders are created equal. I had a spectacular leader my very first time, but I got pregnant and had to stop going. After the baby, we moved, and I have never found another leader anywhere near as good.
Have you found a group on here that is active? That has really helped me!0 -
I am aware mfp is free and what it has to offer. I was just wondering if people found weigh watchers meetings helpful.
I'm aware that only I can get myself to the gym and monitor what I eat. I just wanted some insight on what people thought about the meetings.
Thanks for the information.0 -
The question to ask is why do you think a once a week one hour meeting/weigh in is going to the big thing that instills the change in you to do what you already know you need to do?
is it worth paying for that, or can you dig deep and do it yourself?0 -
So about the meetings...they are prescribed topics. The leaders follow an outline with discussion points. I guess that is so every meeting in the country is covering the same topic in a week. Topics range from recipes, to education about the program, exercise, hydration, etc. and meeting attendees have open discussion on the topic. Whether the meeting is beneficial really depends on the leader and the group of people attending.0
-
If you're asking the mfp community for opinions on weight watchers, you're likely going to get negative opinions since most people on here have either never done weight watchers, or have done it, but switched to mfp because they didn't like it.
my mother has done weight watchers and likes it, but has never been on mfp. *shrug*0 -
As far as the meetings go, that was another reason why I left. They were getting too cheesy for me. At the time they were focusing on one topic a month. The last month that I attended it was all about how to use table settings as a weight loss aid. Four whole weeks of discussing how cloth napkins and plate chargers would make the meal more special and help a person slow their eating down. Other topics were geared toward whatever they had on sale that month.
If you are just looking for support, it might be a good idea to look into something like TOPS. There is a $32 a year membership fee plus monthly dues. The monthly dues vary, but it's an average of about $5 a month. Either way it's a heck of a lot cheaper and gives you the freedom still use MFP and whatever plan you choose on your own.0 -
I am aware mfp is free and what it has to offer. I was just wondering if people found weigh watchers meetings helpful.
I'm aware that only I can get myself to the gym and monitor what I eat. I just wanted some insight on what people thought about the meetings.
Thanks for the information.
I initially found the meetings and weekly weigh ins motivating and helpful, although some of it depended on the day. Some meeting days were definitely better than others, so you may want to try different times/days. I actually missed it when I first switched to MFP, but I really preferred calorie counting over points. I did both for a while and finally picked one.
I thought I saw in commercials that they even have coaching now. There's nothing wrong with trying it out.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions