Has anyone else lost then stalled ? Please advise

njlindly
njlindly Posts: 6 Member
edited November 14 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi all

Im fairly new to MFP and was wondering if anyone could give me some advice on this.

Ive lost over 7 pounds in a month since using MFP on a calorie count of 1200 per week. I weigh in Friday mornings and have a cheat day on Saturday nights were I enjoy a bottle of white wine o:)

At last weeks weigh in I noticed that I had slowed down a lot and had only lost .04 of a pound for that week. I admit I was a little disappointed but was pleased it was still a loss. MFP then recalculated my calorie allowance to 1190 for this week.

My weigh in is soon rolling around again and I shouldn't have stepped on the scales for a sneak peek this morning but I did...and I havn't lost any, infact ive gained 0.3 pounds! I have two days to go so am thinking about ways I can get some calories off (e.g exercise)

I was wondering, I know that people can sometimes stall on a diet after a quick loss. Do you think that's happening to me? If not, what could be happening? If it is happening, do I wait it out and it will start back up again...? As you can see, im at a bit of a crossroads and would really like some advice from more experienced MFP users :)

I don't want to become draconian like having no sugar at all in my tea or coffee just to see results, as I want this to be a real lifestyle change and not a battle with the calorie counter, week after week.

Thanks all, and to whoever does read this, continued good luck on your own weight loss/gain/maintain journeys.

Nikki x :(:s

Replies

  • TimothyFish
    TimothyFish Posts: 4,925 Member
    Weight loss isn't linear. Also, people with a lower body fat percentage typically lose weight more slowly.
  • seanguard
    seanguard Posts: 20 Member
    I've also found myself in a very similiar position. I've been told by folks who I've inquired about this problem to be patient and keep pushing on. It'll start up again. I did seem to burn out some extra calories after my cheat meal this past weekend. Sometimes the cheat meal shocks the body into burning more calories off from what I've been told. I know this isn't exactly a straight forward answer but I too am looking for a solution. Hopefully we will find the insight we need to get past this.
  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    Weight loss isn't linear. And with 12 pounds to lose, it'll also be slow. Recalculate your goal to half a pound a week (you hit a glitch where it gave you less than 1200 calories that has since been fixed) and go from there to prevent muscle loss.
  • Sjsteph87
    Sjsteph87 Posts: 2 Member
    Hey Nikki,

    7lbs in a month is quite a loss! Well Done! :-)

    I have always found that the time it takes for the weight to come off really depends on how much I weigh at the time.

    When I first started losing I lost 5lbs in my first week! I then tended to lose between half - 2lbs a week thereafter and sometimes stayed the same if I had a bit of a naughty week. Although I still have 18lbs to go until I reach goal I have found that the closer I'm getting to goal the slower my weight loss is now going. I don't think this is because I'm doing anything different but I think it's more because my weight is now closer to healthy then at obese. I honestly think that when your body becomes 'healthy' so to speak then you're less likely to lose weight as quickly. It's your body's way of saying, "okay you're healthy now" or at least getting there.

    Look at the weight chart and if you really don't have an awful lot to lose then its always going to be slower then when you're someone who has tones to lose.

    Also, I've always been told that if you're changing your lifestyle then fat loss will always be slower because that's the whole point - the reason why people gain weight after they've been on a 'diet' is because they've probably lost quickly and so they've not had time to get used to their new lifestyle that they just slip into old habits.

    You mention that you have sugar in tea and coffee - It has now been scientifically proven that sugar (as opposed to fat) is actually the culprit when it comes to losing body fat so I would maybe look at your daily eating habits and cut small things out like sugar in your coffee and I bet you'll find that makes a massive difference.

    You're not stalling at all, you're perfectly normal! Just keep doing what you're doing! :smiley:

    Steph x
  • terbusha
    terbusha Posts: 1,483 Member
    I'd ride it out for another week or 2 before I'd make an adjustment. Like it was said above, weight loss is not a linear process. You're going to have good and bad weeks. That's why it's a good thing to watch the trend for your weight loss over a few weeks. How are you exercising?
  • nuttynanners
    nuttynanners Posts: 249 Member
    In your case, it seems as though you have very little weight left to lose. That seems to be the hardest weight to shed. There's no shame in plateauing for a bit. We all go through it. Allow yourself to plateau, but you can always look for ways to bust out of it!

    If I were you, I wouldn't eat fewer than 1200 calories a day. That's not fun. You should be able to eat more than that and still lose weight!

    Are you getting enough sleep? Are you severely stressed? Sounds silly but I know that these can affect your metabolism. High cortisol levels are the enemy.

    Also, do you eat before bed? 8pm is the absolute cut off for me. I find that going to bed a little hungry is actually beneficial to my metabolism. I also try to keep any carb-heavy meals at the beginning of the day, which seems to help.

    Another thing that helps is not to snack all day. I try to have 3-4 hours between meals, to give myself a little time to be hungry. That way I don't have high insulin all day.

    What do you do for exercise? I'd recommend getting in some strength training. Since you have little weight to lose, you will be able to see a dramatic difference in the toning and shaping or your muscles if you stick to a regular strength training regiment. There are plenty of good DVDs out there that require only hand weights and a mat. Or you can do exercises with your own body weight! Perhaps check out a gym in your area. Do you have a Planet Fitness or the like near you? Or see if you have a boutique gym where you could take a class (barre, etc.).

    Muscle burns more calories than fat at rest, so you'll get to eat more if you train your muscles :)

    It sounds a lot like your diet is under control. I'd say just ensuring that you have a healthy lifestyle and incorporating plenty of exercise will help you get those couple of pounds off!
  • njlindly
    njlindly Posts: 6 Member
    Thank you all for your replies and words of encouragement. I found this just after I made this post, I think what im trying to lose in BMI terms is 'vanity pounds.' Although to me, my slow weight gain over the past few months has led to me feeling sluggish, a bit depressed and bloated around the stomach which was the worst feeling. I did lose a lot to start with because I realized through logging on MFP how many calories I was taking in, by snacking little and often throughout the day.

    I found this interesting article about weight loss plateauing which gave me a new perspective than wondering how to exercise and cut back even more. Thought I'd copy and paste it incase anyone else finds it useful ;)

    Article


    So, you think you've hit a "plateau"? I'll come back to that word, but first of all, do not get discouraged. Having a stretch where your weight loss slows to nothing is a natural phenomenon. You’re consuming fewer calories than you used to, so your metabolism has slowed down to conserve them. Keep in mind that, as long as you stick with your workouts and healthy eating, you’ll typically start losing weight again after about three weeks. It’s also important to remember that while you may not be losing weight, you should be experiencing positive changes to your body like a smaller waist, more toned stomach, stronger arms and more. If you don’t want to wait for the plateau to end on its own, there are things you need to ask yourself if you want to jump start your losing streak.

    Question #1: Are You Keeping Track of Your Daily Calories?
    Truth be told, I mostly think of plateaus as a myth. My philosophy on weight-loss plateaus is that someone claiming to have hit one isn’t paying enough attention to detail. When you first start a diet and fitness program, you make drastic changes — maybe you gave up soda, started counting points, whatever — your body responded to that and you lost weight fast. To continue to lose weight, you’ll need to create a consistent calorie deficit, which means you’ll need to start paying attention to what really matters — how many calories you’re consuming and how many you’re burning. The only way to track this accurately is to count calories at every single meal. I know that it can be time-consuming and tedious, but this has been proven again and again by researchers. A study in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine showed that the more regularly a dieter kept a food log, the more weight they lost. That’s another reason why I don’t want to hear that you’ve plateaued if you aren’t keeping detailed logs. Try using a BodyMedia Armband or another kind of personal body monitors that can help you track how many calories you're burning in a day — plus some of these monitors have apps that will help you log and track all of the calories you're consuming in a day. It will help you realize how many calories you burn on a day-to-day basis.

    Question #2: Are You Trying to Lose Vanity Pounds?
    If you’re only trying to lose five, 10, or 15 pounds, you’re in a different place than someone who wants to drop triple digits. You’re not obese, you just want to look better — and this is what I refer to as vanity pounds. The human body doesn’t want to be carrying around excess weight, so it will respond to diet and exercise When you have a smaller amount of weight to lose, your body is already healthy, which makes it tougher to lose weight. What people in this situation often do is cut more calories or increase their time at the gym, but this method will not work. All that does is slow your metabolism down and send your body into starvation mode. The best quick fix is to give your body a little more food so it feels secure. Varying your calorie intake is my best advice for keeping your body from plateauing. For the next three days, vary your calorie intake between 1,800 and 2,400 calories. I know this may sound crazy, but trust me — I know what I'm doing. After three days, drop back down to your usual calorie allowance. Remember, never allow your daily calorie allowance to fall below 1,200 if you are a woman and 1,500 if you are a man. Falling below these daily allowances can do real damage to your metabolism and result in excessive loss of lean muscle tissue.

    Question #3: Do You Need to Change Up Your Workout?
    If you’re overweight (not trying to lose vanity pounds), tracking calories in and out every day, and still not shedding any weight, here’s what you need to do: Switch up your workout. You might not realize this, but your body will adapt to any type of exercise. The first time you go run a mile, it is probably going to be rough. But by the 40th time you run a mile, it’s a lot easier, right? As you get used to a type of exercise, it becomes less challenging and, as a result, less effective. That’s why it’s so important to mix it up. Alternate the amount of weight you lift — go heavy one week with fewer reps and lighter the next with more reps. Change the type of exercise you do for each muscle. One week, do push-ups, then chest flies, then chest presses. They all work the same part of your body, but in very different ways


  • mkakids
    mkakids Posts: 1,913 Member
    Sjsteph87 wrote: »
    Hey Nikki,


    You mention that you have sugar in tea and coffee - It has now been scientifically proven that sugar (as opposed to fat) is actually the culprit when it comes to losing body fat so I would maybe look at your daily eating habits and cut small things out like sugar in your coffee and I bet you'll find that makes a massive difference.

    Steph x

    This is absolutely 100% wrong. Sugar does not prevent you from losing fat!
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    mkakids wrote: »
    Sjsteph87 wrote: »
    Hey Nikki,


    You mention that you have sugar in tea and coffee - It has now been scientifically proven that sugar (as opposed to fat) is actually the culprit when it comes to losing body fat so I would maybe look at your daily eating habits and cut small things out like sugar in your coffee and I bet you'll find that makes a massive difference.

    Steph x

    This is absolutely 100% wrong. Sugar does not prevent you from losing fat!

    x2 excess calories do regardless of where they come from...*smh*
This discussion has been closed.