Ok, someone please tell me why diet soda isn't good for you.......
Replies
-
Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.0
-
They main thing wrong with diet soda, IMHO, is the horrible, horrible, disgusting, vomit-inducing taste. Other than that...hey, whatevs.
0 -
-
beertrollruss wrote: »Women should be mindful of caffeine consumption. Caffeine inhibits iron absorption.
So does calcium. Should we stay away from that too?
0 -
I've no issue with artificial/non-nutritive sweeteners. But to even mitigate that-- seltzer with lime. There's just something about a cold, effervescent drink after a long run or ride during middle of August that just hits the spot.0
-
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Science.0 -
Previously on this topic sciencedirect links were listed that, if you read them, tells you that artificial sweeteners affect insulin production and therefore blood sugar that will affect some people in different ways. This also affect the gut microbiome.
The basic premise for artificial sweeteners is that sugar is bad and artificial sweeteners are not bad, nobody said anything about them being good for you.
If you drink standard or diet soda in small quantities who is worried? Drinking 2 litres a day - well then you have a problem either way.0 -
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Pour hydrochloric acid on anything and see what happens. Our body makes this so it is constantly inside it. Your point is?
0 -
Bone density and strength are more dependent on the stress on them and not because of soda. If one is getting enough calcium (and it doesn't just have to be through dairy product) along with physical exercise to strengthen bone density, soda consumption shouldn't matter much. It SHOULD matter if soda is all that your grandson wants to drink.Need2Exerc1se wrote: »My grandson's orthopedist said absolutley no soda because it is bad for bones. I'm not sure if that is only for growing bones though.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
Given the choice, soda would usually be his drink of choice. But he's a child and not free to choose. He eats a balanced diet and drinks a lot of milk.
I'm not saying you are wrong, I'm just sharing what the professional in the field said. Obviously if the kid is seeing the orthopedist it's for a problem. But the advice was no soda for kids.0 -
I've no issue with artificial/non-nutritive sweeteners. But to even mitigate that-- seltzer with lime. There's just something about a cold, effervescent drink after a long run or ride during middle of August that just hits the spot.
I'm with you. Love my seltzer, especially in summer. Best gadget I got as a weight loss tool (besides my kitchen scale) is my Sodastream. Cheap fizzy water plain or with a little lemon or lime. I fizz up 2 liters daily and drink them over the course of the day.
0 -
I drank diet soda for 19 years before having a single cavity. Also, I don't take very good care of my teeth anyway, so don't argue that I brush my teeth several times each day and that cancels out the acid.0
-
It is nice to see a reasonable discussion about this topic, I will admit I drink too much of it, the acid is not good for my teeth or digestive system but I try to supplement it with water. I enjoy the taste of my Vanilla Zero Coke. I eat pretty healthy I exercise on a regular basis. I have quit smoking 20 years now and no illicit drugs or alcohol 23 years now. All the other studies out there are pick and choose, or they expose rats to large amounts and aspertane and say see what this does to you. The same can be sad if you induce insane amounts of water in your system or pretty much anything.0
-
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Pour hydrochloric acid on loads of things and watch what happens. And you have this crap on the inside of your body.0 -
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Pour hydrochloric acid on anything and see what happens. Our body makes this so it is constantly inside it. Your point is?
Oh, I didn't see your reply
x 0 -
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
You didn't really think that one through, did you.0 -
I've no issue with artificial/non-nutritive sweeteners. But to even mitigate that-- seltzer with lime. There's just something about a cold, effervescent drink after a long run or ride during middle of August that just hits the spot.
I'm with you. Love my seltzer, especially in summer. Best gadget I got as a weight loss tool (besides my kitchen scale) is my Sodastream. Cheap fizzy water plain or with a little lemon or lime. I fizz up 2 liters daily and drink them over the course of the day.
I love the Sodastream, too. I drink straight from the bottle all day! I prefer lemon to lime, but really, if I want a drink, 9 times out of 10 it's just plain fizzy water! Very refreshing.
Protip-- pick up a bottle of 100% cranberry juice. (NOT 100% juice cranberry cocktail! The 100% unsweetened cranberry) I love to put about a quarter cup or less of it in a pint glass and fill the rest up with seltzer. It's VERY low calorie (not no calorie, but at those small amounts you are essentially looking at 10 cal or less) , tastes fantastic, and has all kinds of micronutrients. Plus it's a very pretty color and you feel like you're having a cocktail. Knudsen's is one brand, but it can be spendy. If you are on the East Coast, the Nature's Promise label (at Stop and Shop or Giant stores) has a version that is less expensive. Trader Joe's has the best inexpensive version I've found.0 -
if yu are a newcomer I apologise for what yr post kicked up. on mfp there is a huge debate about the words "good" "bad" and the difference in the value of different calories. Its not you!
Please do not attack me for posting this. Thank you.0 -
I've no issue with artificial/non-nutritive sweeteners. But to even mitigate that-- seltzer with lime. There's just something about a cold, effervescent drink after a long run or ride during middle of August that just hits the spot.
I'm with you. Love my seltzer, especially in summer. Best gadget I got as a weight loss tool (besides my kitchen scale) is my Sodastream. Cheap fizzy water plain or with a little lemon or lime. I fizz up 2 liters daily and drink them over the course of the day.
I love the Sodastream, too. I drink straight from the bottle all day! I prefer lemon to lime, but really, if I want a drink, 9 times out of 10 it's just plain fizzy water! Very refreshing.
Protip-- pick up a bottle of 100% cranberry juice. (NOT 100% juice cranberry cocktail! The 100% unsweetened cranberry) I love to put about a quarter cup or less of it in a pint glass and fill the rest up with seltzer. It's VERY low calorie (not no calorie, but at those small amounts you are essentially looking at 10 cal or less) , tastes fantastic, and has all kinds of micronutrients. Plus it's a very pretty color and you feel like you're having a cocktail. Knudsen's is one brand, but it can be spendy. If you are on the East Coast, the Nature's Promise label (at Stop and Shop or Giant stores) has a version that is less expensive. Trader Joe's has the best inexpensive version I've found.
I haven't done that. Will definitely go for it! Thanks. My local grocery has some at the same price as Trader Joe's. Then again, I live in Wisconsin which produces twice as many cranberries as any other state (including Massachusetts) so local brands are readily available and cheap.
I like to get it and add it to apple cider, then heat it up with cinnamon sticks and cloves. Hot cider that isn't sweet. Yummy! (1 part pure cranberry juice to 3 parts cider)
0 -
if yu are a newcomer I apologise for what yr post kicked up. on mfp there is a huge debate about the words "good" "bad" and the difference in the value of different calories. Its not you!
Please do not attack me for posting this. Thank you.
Why on earth would you feel the need to apologize for MFP? This had been a very thoughtful, polite discussion. Have you even read the thread?
0 -
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Vinegar will also clean a corroded battery terminal. Is it bad to put that in your body, too?
0 -
I have 1 can every day - it's my treat for getting my water in and it deters me from drinking wine/beer instead. When I lost weight in 2012 I cut it out completely, cold turkey, treat drink was a Powerade Zero, but both are about the same things health wise. I added it back in "as a treat" about a year ago. I quit the first time because I was in this "OH, I need to cut out real soda, so I'll switch to diet" Then about 3 weeks later I'd be back to drinking real and it wasn't working. I now don't like real soda.0
-
if yu are a newcomer I apologise for what yr post kicked up. on mfp there is a huge debate about the words "good" "bad" and the difference in the value of different calories. Its not you!
Please do not attack me for posting this. Thank you.
Why on earth would you feel the need to apologize for MFP? This had been a very thoughtful, polite discussion. Have you even read the thread?
^^^Yep. Actually pretty decent diet soda thread.
And the please don't disagree with me disclaimer....SMH.
0 -
if yu are a newcomer I apologise for what yr post kicked up. on mfp there is a huge debate about the words "good" "bad" and the difference in the value of different calories. Its not you!
Please do not attack me for posting this. Thank you.
Why on earth would you feel the need to apologize for MFP? This had been a very thoughtful, polite discussion. Have you even read the thread?
^^^Yep. Actually pretty decent diet soda thread.
And the please don't disagree with me disclaimer....SMH.
I'm just offended by the textspeak.0 -
There are actually a lot of things about it that are bad for you. The artificial sweeteners are terrible for you! They trick your body...it tastes the sweetness and expects calories, and when it doesn't get them it increases hunger signals, which can cause you to overeat. It also causes bloating and digestive problems in many people. There are just so many weird chemicals in it. Why put that into your body? It interferes with weight loss, as well, if that is one of your goals. Here is an article about it if you wanna read more... http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20739512,00.html0
-
KirbySmith46 wrote: »Go pour some soda on some corroded battery terminals and watch what happens. And you put this crap on the inside of your body.
Put lemon juice or vinegar on it. Same thing happens. And you put that crap inside of your body.0 -
moon_childxo wrote: »There are actually a lot of things about it that are bad for you. The artificial sweeteners are terrible for you! They trick your body...it tastes the sweetness and expects calories, and when it doesn't get them it increases hunger signals, which can cause you to overeat. It also causes bloating and digestive problems in many people. There are just so many weird chemicals in it. Why put that into your body? It interferes with weight loss, as well, if that is one of your goals. Here is an article about it if you wanna read more... http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20739512,00.html
Ridiculous post is ridiculous.0 -
Zero cavities drinking "loaded" soda all my life! Now that's an accomplishment!
I still go for loaded if I want to drink my calories (which I do not)..
Artificial sweeteners give you gas! Weight the pros and cons and decide if you want gas over fat gain...0 -
LoupGarouTFTs wrote: »
She does not fear vinegar. Three syllables. So good.
Not to be a language geek, but . . . pesticide, herbicide, and sucralose all have three syllables.
Don't I know it. But vin-e-gar are natural syllables.
0 -
LoupGarouTFTs wrote: »
She does not fear vinegar. Three syllables. So good.
Not to be a language geek, but . . . pesticide, herbicide, and sucralose all have three syllables.
Don't I know it. But vin-e-gar are natural syllables.
I stand corrected! LOL
0 -
it will mess up your teeth... that's all I got tho, I drink it all da time0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions