Does anyone use jawbone/bodymedia?
Francl27
Posts: 26,371 Member
I'm considering getting the Up3 when it comes out, has anyone maintained for a while using a Jawbone or Bodymedia? Just curious about how accurate they really are.
0
Replies
-
I have maintained for years with the BodyMedia Fit. You can't buy it from the site anymore, only from secondary market (ebay, etc.)0
-
I've used the BMF on/off for over 4 years now (4+ months dieting and almost 4 years maintenance) and swear by it. Jawbone bought BMF over a year ago and you can no longer buy them (unless through 2ndary like Evileen said). Also think you might be waiting a looooong time for the Up3........Jawbone doesn't give anyone an answer as to when it'll be released (which it was suppose to have been already).
I am currently testing out the Fitbit Charge HR and am very happy w/it. Only device I've tried (have Garmin Vivofit and Fitbit Zip) that is reasonably accurate (compared to BMF).0 -
lisab64mfp wrote: »I am currently testing out the Fitbit Charge HR and am very happy w/it. Only device I've tried (have Garmin Vivofit and Fitbit Zip) that is reasonably accurate (compared to BMF).
Thank you for this reply, I have been dreading the day that they will stop supporting my BodyMedia. I keep looking at the Fitbit Charge HR, but hate that it will be around my wrist. I like being able to "hide" my BodyMedia in my bra during the Summer months
0 -
Thanks for the replies, I'll probably wait for reviews and buy it then.0
-
I got the Body Media Fit and used it for about 6 months. It gave me lots of excellent information about my calorie burns and sleep patterns, but I got tired of paying the monthly fee. I eat and workout about the same as I did when I was wearing it so I know I'm on track.0
-
I just cancelled my BodyMedia when I realized that it too was nothing more than a glorified pedometer. Sure it has sensors for skin temperature and galvanic skin response but apparently they do not factor much into the caloric burn calculation. I came to this conclusion after doing a very strenuous workout on a stationary bike to the point of my shirt being drenched and it registered it as moderate activity whereas walking at a brisk pace without breaking a sweat registers as vigorous activity. When calling to inquire about the accuracy they suggested swinging my arm or moving it to my leg. I requested a call back 2 weeks ago and I have not gotten one. Seriously considering a class action suit for misrepresenting the accuracy of the device at 95%. Save yourself some money. Buy a $20 pedometer and set daily step goals for yourself. (Incidentally, the research sited by BodyMedia states that tracking your movement improves weight loss, not using their device.)0
-
I just cancelled my BodyMedia when I realized that it too was nothing more than a glorified pedometer. Sure it has sensors for skin temperature and galvanic skin response but apparently they do not factor much into the caloric burn calculation. I came to this conclusion after doing a very strenuous workout on a stationary bike to the point of my shirt being drenched and it registered it as moderate activity whereas walking at a brisk pace without breaking a sweat registers as vigorous activity. When calling to inquire about the accuracy they suggested swinging my arm or moving it to my leg. I requested a call back 2 weeks ago and I have not gotten one. Seriously considering a class action suit for misrepresenting the accuracy of the device at 95%. Save yourself some money. Buy a $20 pedometer and set daily step goals for yourself. (Incidentally, the research sited by BodyMedia states that tracking your movement improves weight loss, not using their device.)
Ok that's good to know. One of the reasons I'm waiting to buy the Up3 is that I don't know if it will have a monthly subscription or not... and I refuse to pay for that.
I do have a fitbit, but considering that more than half of my workouts are Les Mills Combat or stationary bike, it's pretty useless frankly... there's not a lot of steps in those... so that's why I was looking at the Up3.I had the same issue with inconsistent and illogical reports with my fitbit too (like burning more calories on days when I had less steps and less 'active minutes' than others).0 -
I used the armband while doing Fitness Blender online videos or running. Each video gives a general calorie range you're likely to burn, and the Fit had me right in the middle of the range almost every single time. It seemed to agree with my Runkeeper account when I went running too. And I was losing pretty steadily, so I found the results to be good. But like you, I can't stomach a monthly charge when the data really isn't going to change that much if I'm doing and eating the same things for the most part.0
-
I love my Jawbone UP24. I've had it about 7 months or so. It definitely keeps me on track, I like the sleep details as well.0
-
I love my BodyMedia and still think it's one of the most accurate fitness trackers out there. Perhaps csverdin had a defective unit. True that it doesn't always measure 'steps' accurately in a spinning class -- but I can definitely see the caloric burn register when viewing the data, as well as with any other serious workout. I feel it's the sensors that make this stand apart from other units, although I've only compared it with a couple of wrist devices in addition to a HRM. I don't mind paying the monthly fee because I think it's worth it.0
-
cjgaudette wrote: »I love my BodyMedia and still think it's one of the most accurate fitness trackers out there. Perhaps csverdin had a defective unit. True that it doesn't always measure 'steps' accurately in a spinning class -- but I can definitely see the caloric burn register when viewing the data, as well as with any other serious workout. I feel it's the sensors that make this stand apart from other units, although I've only compared it with a couple of wrist devices in addition to a HRM. I don't mind paying the monthly fee because I think it's worth it.
I totally agree with you. Worth every penny!
0 -
I'll put in another vote for the Bodymedia. I actually have an older "Bodybugg" and it's fantastic. It proved to me what I already knew: my BMR and TDEE are MUCH less than the calculations on height, weight, age, and gender estimate. Thanks, hypothyroid and PCOS diagnoses. Now I have an accurate view of my caloric expenditure and deficit. SO worth $7/month!!!0
-
I love my BMF! Maintained for 2 years now with it. Very accurate even with lifting.0
-
I love mines as well ... it's the most accurate activity tracker for me ...0
-
I have one but haven't used it for awhile because I HATE that it goes on my arm. I don't want people seeing this thing (summer coming and short sleeves and all). Someone said they put it in the bra?? What?? How?? I lost the most weight ever when I was using it and eating back every one of my calories lol0
-
I used to use BMF but got annoyed with it being on my arm. It made me really uncomfortable and I never got used to it being there. The tracking was fabulous, though. I have a FitBit now, but am planning on getting the Up3 if they ever get them manufactured and out.0
-
I just cancelled my BodyMedia when I realized that it too was nothing more than a glorified pedometer. Sure it has sensors for skin temperature and galvanic skin response but apparently they do not factor much into the caloric burn calculation. I came to this conclusion after doing a very strenuous workout on a stationary bike to the point of my shirt being drenched and it registered it as moderate activity whereas walking at a brisk pace without breaking a sweat registers as vigorous activity. When calling to inquire about the accuracy they suggested swinging my arm or moving it to my leg. I requested a call back 2 weeks ago and I have not gotten one. Seriously considering a class action suit for misrepresenting the accuracy of the device at 95%. Save yourself some money. Buy a $20 pedometer and set daily step goals for yourself. (Incidentally, the research sited by BodyMedia states that tracking your movement improves weight loss, not using their device.)
I got a BodyMedia Fit as an incentive through my wellness program at work. So glad I didn't buy it outright. Apparently washing the dishes by hand burns as many calories as a 90 cycling ride (14mph avg speed). On the advice of others, I put my BMF on my calf when cycling, BMF still thinks a bike ride at 80-95% max heart rate is moderate activity. I used the "activity manager" for the 3 month free trial period to get a "baseline" TDEE. I am very disappointed with the product and don't recommend it to anyone.
If you want an activity tracker, get that $20 pedometer and invest in a good heart rate monitor (HRM) - I have a Polar FT4 ($60-$80) - and you will probably be better served than if you buy to $120+ BodyMedia. Disclaimer - don't know much about the Jawbone, but if their product is like the BodyMedia, I doubt I would be impressed.
0 -
-
kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »
I didn't even know it was delayed... Still don't even know if it will require a subscription or not.0 -
I purposely bought my UP24 in a large so I could wear it on my ankle instead of my wrist because I have a recumbent bike. Works great.0
-
kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »
I didn't even know it was delayed... Still don't even know if it will require a subscription or not.
I remember someone in December was supposed to get one a little after Christmas & then Jawbone delayed it.0 -
I loved my BodyMedia. I too, think it's the most accurate tracker for many activities. I don't love the arm-band. I've had a fitbit and now a Garmin vivofit (given to me by work). I find both to be pretty useless for anything other than running and steps. If the Garmin wasn't free I'd hate it.
At least the BodyMedia is smart. No, it doesn't track every activity perfectly, but at least it knows when you're asleep (you don't have to tell it), can track yoga and weightlifting pretty well, and actually knows that house cleaning and other activities where you're standing more than walking actually do burn calories. My Garmin tracks me as inactive when I'm doing things like housework and I know better.
I've been using the BodyMedia numbers I established when I used it for a couple years now with great success. If I went by the Garmin I'd be scrawny and starving since it consistently gives me 200-300 calories less per day.
0 -
I have UP24 and love it. Got it at Xmas and totally addicted. I lift 6 days a week with a 2 mile run before each session. I find it pretty accurate. I'm working on a recomp, so now I'm eating at maintenance calories which is about 1650-1700. I find it accurate since I did not gain weight after increasing my calories from 1350. Was seriously worried that I'd pack on weight.0
-
I love my Jawbone UP24...Its comfortable, and accurate based on reading the history of days I was not so active vs. really active. Also, I like that the app is easy to use.0
-
Just got my UP24 a few days ago, I love the tracking, and sync with fitnesspal.. I even like the smart coach, with it's tips and motivation.0
-
Bumping since BodyMedia is no longer supporting their devices - what does everyone plan to change to?
@evileen99 I remember we talked in another thread about loving the BMF and buying a backup unit - what are you planning to do?0 -
@PeachyPlumPeachyPlum wrote: »Bumping since BodyMedia is no longer supporting their devices - what does everyone plan to change to?
@evileen99 I remember we talked in another thread about loving the BMF and buying a backup unit - what are you planning to do?
I don't know. I don't want a wrist unit as I have a very small frame and the friends' bands that I've tried on just don't fit right, so that leaves me looking at clip ons. I won't get a Jawbone because I'm so mad that they wouldn't keep supporting B odyMedia devices (seriously, they would have made more money off of me by taking my subscription fees than they would if I just bought a device). I'm looking at the Misfit Flash because it's so cheap, but you get what you pay for.....I will probably end up with a FitBit but am not too happy about any options as most if my workouts are not step based so none of them will be as accurate as the BodyMedia.0 -
I'm looking for something with the same level of accuracy and reliability as the Bodymedia Fit. Any suggestions? So upset that Jawbone ended our ability to use a PAID service
0 -
this is helpful for me as well. I'm too broke now, but come summer i'm going to be looking at getting either a jawbone, or the under armour health box (I'm waiting on reviews to decide) but i've already ruled out fitbit.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions