Getting frusterated! :(
Replies
-
Just to say I dont always agree with him but ndj asked the most pertinent question and it went unanswered for ages. If you arent losing then look for the reasons why starting with the idea to check your logging and that you really are at an accurate deficit. Start with the preumption that you are eating more than you are burning or else you will be defying the laws of thermodynamics. That means a food scale.
If all thats in order, you then look at exercise burns if you are eating back.
If thats accurate then you need to look at things which mean weight loss isnt linear, water retention, salt, tom.
If thats in order then learn to be patient , 2 weeks isnt really enough of anything.
A combination of all the above factors could easily slwo your weight loss, you just have to be methodical, break it down and examine, then remedy each aspect.
If you are doing everuthing right then keep on for a decent sustained period.0 -
I lose weight once a month. My weight loss cycle is closely tied to my other....cycle. Hormones. Maybe stick to what you are doing with a little careful weighing of food for two more weeks and see if your weight loss pattern is hormone related.0
-
You should weigh everything in grams on a food scale. Measuring cups are highly inaccurate for solid and semi-solid food, like popcorn, cereal, peanut butter, etc..
0 -
Just to say I dont always agree with him but ndj asked the most pertinent question and it went unanswered for ages. If you arent losing then look for the reasons why starting with the idea to check your logging and that you really are at an accurate deficit. Start with the preumption that you are eating more than you are burning or else you will be defying the laws of thermodynamics. That means a food scale.
If all thats in order, you then look at exercise burns if you are eating back.
If thats accurate then you need to look at things which mean weight loss isnt linear, water retention, salt, tom.
If thats in order then learn to be patient , 2 weeks isnt really enough of anything.
A combination of all the above factors could easily slwo your weight loss, you just have to be methodical, break it down and examine, then remedy each aspect.
If you are doing everuthing right then keep on for a decent sustained period.
food scales, bringing people together since the digital age began ...
0 -
Measuring cups is not accurate for solid food. What you fit in a cup may not be the same as what the food label indicates according to weight for a cup. When you get the food scale, you'll see this.
In general: you are not going to lose weight every week. Some weeks you'll stay the same, some will go down. Why? Because the body is not a perfect machine and because many factors affect water weight. Such as TOM/hormones, sodium, stress, new workout routine, etc.
You have the Fitbit & Aria. Continue to weigh in daily if you want, but make sure you're consistent. What not to do: sometimes weigh in the morning before eating, sometime at 1pm after lunch, sometimes right before bed. That will give you messy data. Keep your weighins consistent such as after waking & using the bathroom, before eating/drinking anything. Over time you'll see a trend to form. Such as certain weeks you seem to gain or hold steady, other weeks you see a drop.
You are most likely at a deficit since you're aiming for 1400 calories in and are showing 2400 out. So trust the science and the next weighin, or the one after, or the one after: you'll see further results. But getting the food scale will help you to be more accurate. You just can't get it right with cups alone. And even single serving items like bread, buns, etc. can be off by 10-20% and still meet FDA guidelines for accuracy.0 -
PS-I've used my Fitbit for about a year and a half now. 9.5 months to lose my weight and 7.5 months of maintenance. Have found it very accurate. No device is perfect, but if its off its probably by no more than 5-10%. Which would mean you'd still be in a deficit and more time will allow you to see the trend.0
-
StaciMarie1974 wrote: »Measuring cups is not accurate for solid food. What you fit in a cup may not be the same as what the food label indicates according to weight for a cup. When you get the food scale, you'll see this.
In general: you are not going to lose weight every week. Some weeks you'll stay the same, some will go down. Why? Because the body is not a perfect machine and because many factors affect water weight. Such as TOM/hormones, sodium, stress, new workout routine, etc.
You have the Fitbit & Aria. Continue to weigh in daily if you want, but make sure you're consistent. What not to do: sometimes weigh in the morning before eating, sometime at 1pm after lunch, sometimes right before bed. That will give you messy data. Keep your weighins consistent such as after waking & using the bathroom, before eating/drinking anything. Over time you'll see a trend to form. Such as certain weeks you seem to gain or hold steady, other weeks you see a drop.
You are most likely at a deficit since you're aiming for 1400 calories in and are showing 2400 out. So trust the science and the next weighin, or the one after, or the one after: you'll see further results. But getting the food scale will help you to be more accurate. You just can't get it right with cups alone. And even single serving items like bread, buns, etc. can be off by 10-20% and still meet FDA guidelines for accuracy.
wait, so you think OP is netting negative 1000 calories per day? Or am I missing something????0 -
Just to say I dont always agree with him but ndj asked the most pertinent question and it went unanswered for ages. If you arent losing then look for the reasons why starting with the idea to check your logging and that you really are at an accurate deficit. Start with the preumption that you are eating more than you are burning or else you will be defying the laws of thermodynamics. That means a food scale.
If all thats in order, you then look at exercise burns if you are eating back.
If thats accurate then you need to look at things which mean weight loss isnt linear, water retention, salt, tom.
If thats in order then learn to be patient , 2 weeks isnt really enough of anything.
A combination of all the above factors could easily slwo your weight loss, you just have to be methodical, break it down and examine, then remedy each aspect.
If you are doing everuthing right then keep on for a decent sustained period.
food scales, bringing people together since the digital age began ...
The beginnings of a bro-mance
0 -
You guys are wonderful! Thank you for all the great advice! I was very trusting of f0
-
ood labels, but I have ordered the scale to see if that's where I'm going wrong!
I will jeep you all posted and let you know if weighing vs. measuring helps!0 -
Not what I said. OP is burning 2400 per day and likely eating under that.
Aiming for a 1000 daily deficit but not using a scale: means probably eating more than 1400. Would be unlikely to overestimate enough to think you're eating 1400 and actually be eating 2500.
wait, so you think OP is netting negative 1000 calories per day? Or am I missing something????
0 -
CarolineLeclair wrote: »Lol! No, i didn't weigh those, but yes, I did measure them with measuring cups! If I measure the popcorn (for example) in cups, do I need to weigh it too?
Not sure I understand why.... Would I use the weight over the measurement?
I do have all my fitbit settings adjusted like it says above!
I was told to trust fitbit ad it was quite accurate.
Weight is more accurate than measuring by volume, especially for items that can be compressed or have air pockets. Here's an explanation with a really helpful video. After I saw this I got a food scale:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/8722120 -
StaciMarie1974 wrote: »Not what I said. OP is burning 2400 per day and likely eating under that.
Aiming for a 1000 daily deficit but not using a scale: means probably eating more than 1400. Would be unlikely to overestimate enough to think you're eating 1400 and actually be eating 2500.
wait, so you think OP is netting negative 1000 calories per day? Or am I missing something????
OK but you said 1400 in and 2400 out which is a net negative of 1000 ....0 -
I do have to agree that my deficit seems big enough to me that I should still be losing weight.... Rather than maintaining. Even if my measurements are leas accurate than weighing... Back to why I'm frustrated! I feel my calories burned are quite accurate as I live a very busy and active lifestyle.
BUT... I will follow the advice given and will start "tweeking" things here and there to see if it helps!0 -
I said she is aiming for 1400 in. And I said she is most likely at a deficit. Aiming means 1400 is the intended intake. Deficit means eating below TDEE. So in this case, actual probably is less than 2400 and as I also mentioned: a food scale will improve accuracy so one can know they are eating what they think they are.StaciMarie1974 wrote: »Not what I said. OP is burning 2400 per day and likely eating under that.
Aiming for a 1000 daily deficit but not using a scale: means probably eating more than 1400. Would be unlikely to overestimate enough to think you're eating 1400 and actually be eating 2500.
wait, so you think OP is netting negative 1000 calories per day? Or am I missing something????
OK but you said 1400 in and 2400 out which is a net negative of 1000 ....
0 -
Its been 2-3 weeks without a loss. Water weight. As mentioned is the likely cause. Need more time to see trends over 30-60-90 days.CarolineLeclair wrote: »I do have to agree that my deficit seems big enough to me that I should still be losing weight.... Rather than maintaining. Even if my measurements are leas accurate than weighing... Back to why I'm frustrated! I feel my calories burned are quite accurate as I live a very busy and active lifestyle.
BUT... I will follow the advice given and will start "tweeking" things here and there to see if it helps!
0 -
I think everyone at some point hits a plateu sounds like your case you need to change it up a bit0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5sovhvLAig
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QPr5CYi9Lo
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions