HELP? Ideas to motivate unhealthy teen daughter?
mjbrowne
Posts: 172 Member
I have a non-sporty, non-comptetive 15 yr old daughter who is beautiful and talented. However, she basically reads, plays her guitar and sings. As her father's family as history of early onset diabetes, her level of activity (NONE) and food intake (TONS) has me worried. Her BMI is 30.6, which is JUST over the "obesity" level.
I have lost 30 lbs over the past 15 months and achieved a fairly active lifestyle. I try to encourage her to walk / jog with me, but she declines. I have removed most of the unhealthy snacks and she will eat things like hummus, veggies and laughing cow cheese. However, she just eats a lot of "healthy" food at one time and frequently.
If I say the wrong thing or push the weight / inactivity issue or question her 2nd (or 3rd) plate, she gets upset and emotional.
Have any of you dealt with this? Ideas? Tricks? Thank you!!
I have lost 30 lbs over the past 15 months and achieved a fairly active lifestyle. I try to encourage her to walk / jog with me, but she declines. I have removed most of the unhealthy snacks and she will eat things like hummus, veggies and laughing cow cheese. However, she just eats a lot of "healthy" food at one time and frequently.
If I say the wrong thing or push the weight / inactivity issue or question her 2nd (or 3rd) plate, she gets upset and emotional.
Have any of you dealt with this? Ideas? Tricks? Thank you!!
0
Replies
-
If you've suggested she try to get healthy and have done it in an encouraging manner and she's declining, she has to live with those consequences. Girls especially could potentially become very scarred by their mothers insisting they be healthy, lose weight, etc. If you want to keep talking to her, I would just say you emphasize you're getting healthy and you want her to be healthy and live a long time as well. My mother never pushed me to lose weight but my dad mentioned it to me one time when I was 16, I broke down crying, and then ended up starting to eat healthier and losing the weight because I disgusted myself. My parents have always been overweight and I never wanted to be like them so I've always exercised because of that. All this to say that everyone is different but you shouldn't push it too much or she could start to resent you.0
-
Put up full length mirrors. One in the bathroom scared me! It was actually directly across from the toilet! You may not have to say anything with a few of them strategically placed around the home.0
-
yeah. I was kind of always a chubby kid and my mom would give me "helpful hints" on exercising and losing weight and it just made me feel fat and unloved and I would go on crash diets that never worked. Now at 23, I'm the lowest weight I've been in the last 8 years, and it was because no one was pushing me to lose weight. I wanted to do it for myself. The most you can do is do your thing being healthy, but don't push it on her or it'll just give her self-esteem issues or make her think that you don't accept her. I know, because that's what my mom did.0
-
This might be a little bit of extra work but my mother used to only keep the serving size amount of almonds in the can at one time so my dad wouldn't over eat them he would just think he finished off the can. Then she would put another serving size in there for next time. Also try switching to small salad plates and small bowls, so she can only fill them up so much or the food looks bigger on the plate so it tricks her brain. I do this for myself I even have small forks and spoons too. Makes me eat way slower.0
-
dont push too hard..
my mom did- she would tell me I couldnt have something so I would sneak and have 3.
I started my first fad diet at 15 - pills, shakes, gym rat you name it and lok where it got me - 34 years old and still fighting the if they dont see me eat it it doesnt count monster...
all you can do is provider her the tools to be healthy..... how about friends of hers... maybe get someone else to help to get her more active. its hard to hear it coming from Mom if the issue is pushed too hard... I ended up with a lot of self doubt issues....
its tough but good luck.. and like I said just provide her the tools....0 -
This might be a little bit of extra work but my mother used to only keep the serving size amount of almonds in the can at one time so my dad wouldn't over eat them he would just think he finished off the can. Then she would put another serving size in there for next time. Also try switching to small salad plates and small bowls, so she can only fill them up so much or the food looks bigger on the plate so it tricks her brain. I do this for myself I even have small forks and spoons too. Makes me eat way slower.
love this idea- - I have actually switched to small utensils... hubby thinks I am nuts eating with a kids fork but it works!!!0 -
I do not have children of my own, but my nieces and nephews are very close to. One of my nieces, who is 12 years old now, was on the verge of becoming obese. She would even sneak to the kitchen in the middle of the night and eat. When I realized that was happening, I just sat her down and had a talk with her and told her how concerned I was. She’s young, so I tried to keep it as innocent as possible, trying not to cause her a complex when she gets older. For every 5 lbs lost, I take her shopping, because that’s what she likes. If your daughter is not into clothes, maybe try rewarding her with things that she enjoys.0
-
As a parent I think it's important to encourage healthy eating/exercise, etc....especially since our schools do not really talk about nutrition and the school lunches are a joke and laden w/ empty calories, sodium and is basically warmed up fast food.
I had a similar problem with my son (16 y/o). I had his doctor talk to him about his weight and what a healthy weight is, etc... I did talk to the doctor prior and explained I wanted my son to start a food journal and exercise more and advised that he was on that border line of being overweight. Once he went to the doctor and the doctor saw what his weight was at that time - compared it with last years weight he had a VERY long talk with my son about his eating/exercise habits. He also explained WHY he didn't want my son to gain any weight for the next year - he didn't talk to him about losing weight, but did talk to him extensively about food journaling, exercising, eating more fruits/veggies, water consumption, etc....
(My family also has a history of diabetes, btw.)
There is a way to discuss nutrition & weight with your teen. Especially when you have diabetes that run in your family, it's important to instill those healthy eating ideals early in life.
Another thing I did was we purchased the Wii Fit for our family and we ALL participate at least a few times a week. I plan on getting a gym membership for the summer so I can take my son with me. He was a bit upset at first that we were really pushing him to exercise but now he comments on how much better he feels after he works out and eats a healthy meal.
I also have been teaching him how to cook and how to cook his favorite recipes a bit healthier. He's WAY more open to trying different foods/veggies/etc....0 -
My 17 year old son won the battle of childhood obesity. Bless his heart, he was so heavy at one point... high blood pressure, weight, BMI, etc was at dangerous levels!
I never pushed him with "activities", but made the choices available (he took karate lessons for a while & enjoyed that... and joined the marching band for a couple of years, and enjoyed that).
I DID, however, made available healthy food choices at home... and even when we went out. We have obliterated McDonald's from our diet! (Sorry Micky D's!) Also, when I would go for a run... I'd invite him to go follow me on his bicycle to keep me company! Not for HIS workout, but for MINE.
He is now in the Show Choir at school (he's always loved music)... he also is on the football team, runs track and takes an advanced physical conditioning (weights) class at school.
I think the KEY is to most of all... lead by example in all you do! :flowerforyou:0 -
dont feed her crappy food?
teens are weird. i was one, once :P
there was no way id get motivated by my parents back then unless they told me i cant do something0 -
I'm the same way... my younger brother is overweight, and Im trying to get him started in watching what he eats and get him working out. I bought him new running shoes (because he always would wear converse), shared with him this MMA Diet pamphlet i found, and signed him, my husband and myself up for a Warrior Dash in September... its something that's supposed to be out there as a fun thing. Its working... we went shopping the other day and he didn't pick up soda or chips or any over possessed foods, lots of veggies and organic foods. Its all about adjusting your way of "Marketing" the diet idea to the individual.
Being healthy is a family thing. If your cooking healthy food, and only have healthy snacks in the house. Try to limit what your cooking to one serving per person... and make sure shes not confusing hunger for thirst. (My 3 year old does this every 15 minutes hes hungry.. no hes thirsty, hes just confusing the two) But showing her by example that she can have everything she wants to eat, but in moderation as well.
But being a girl, and 15 puts you in a tricky situation. Pushing too hard she might rebel, or choose maybe to take your words too much to heart and give her self a bad body image... and that just starts down a bad path. 15 year olds change sooo much... dont overly stress because she may find something in HS that inspires her to be more active and shed the weight. Just remember how you were at 15... VASTLY different then how you were at 18, and 21, and 25 and so on... so don't get too caught up on her BMI levels or if shes balking at stuff because her body is still growing, and so are her tastes.
To jump start the "its okay to be active" plan family outings. Try new things like walking/running a 5k for something that she or both of you support. Try new sports like rock climbing or yoga or even softball, soccer or volleyball. Try these things together or separate (you might find a sport you like and didnt know it too!) See about going to the YMCA, our Y has a Gym just for women, and the girls can go in there and not have to work out in front of boys...also with it getting hot, the outdoor pool will burn tons of calories. If you also encourage her to keep singing, and playing guitar, and not shut her off of things she likes to do shows that your not stopping her or trying to "change her" just letting her get more involved in what the family should do for activities will help.
Good Luck!0 -
I have a 10yr old son what I do is everyday that I go out for a jog I make him come with me and he bike rides.0
-
I do not have children of my own, but my nieces and nephews are very close to. One of my nieces, who is 12 years old now, was on the verge of becoming obese. She would even sneak to the kitchen in the middle of the night and eat. When I realized that was happening, I just sat her down and had a talk with her and told her how concerned I was. She’s young, so I tried to keep it as innocent as possible, trying not to cause her a complex when she gets older. For every 5 lbs lost, I take her shopping, because that’s what she likes. If your daughter is not into clothes, maybe try rewarding her with things that she enjoys.
I would briber her to work out, rather than to lose weight.
At this point, you have already got her to eat healthier foods - don't worry so much about how much. Focus on food choices and exercise.0 -
You've already done the two most important things that you can do in my opinion....set a good example and removed most of the unhealthy food from the home. Kids have such huge appetites at this age and I think that emotional eating can develop at this time, too. My oldest child is 15, and I know how obstinate they can be. They also do not fully realize the consequences of their actions, and it is our job as parents to guide them. With this in mind, I am going to go against what the others have said...I think that you should do whatever you can to lead her in the right direction, even if it seems pushy. Don't ask her to join you for a walk, say "We're going for a walk." Have her help you with outdoor work, chores, washing the car...anything to get her moving. As far as food goes, can you insist on fresh fruit or veggies at every meal? I try to do this with my oldest son...I'll tell him to have an apple before other snacks, etc. It's a fine line, because I want him to be in control of his own body and I want to respect him...but his health is ultimately my responsibility. I don't know if you can do to motivate her, but as a parent you can insist on certain habits and lifestyle changes. Good luck, and congratulations on your success!0
-
WOW! I'm feeling the love! Thanks everyone for the ideas and support. I was raised by a mom who was always on some kind of diet and remember sititng in the lunchroom in 9th grade eating my 2 TBS of peanut butter and carrot sticks for lunch. So, I have a severe internal struggle on how much or how little to say. I was 20+ overweight from age 11 on..until this past year. I just didn't have the family history of DM, high cholesterol,and high blood pressure that she does. And, I LOVED sports, played basketball after school and hit the gym after work. I just know it will be WAY harder if she does develop borderline levels and REALLY has to count carbs and calories to prevent insulin dependent DM. We have seen DR..had fasting labs this morning to check everything..I also spoke w/ Dr privately with my concerns and I leave the room so they can speak alone (female Dr and my daughter). I really like the smaller plates / bowls ideas AND the "serving of almonds" in the can idea. That would work for both of us. (I have a sweet tooth, so rarely keep sweets in house..try to sub in cocoa dusted almonds and choc PB2).
Again, thanks for all of the tips and encouragement. I know from personal experience SHE has to want to make the changes. I can just be an example and plan family (we are very close knit ) outings around active things like hiking, swimming, etc. We usually play music together (we have a full band room downstairs) but now that summers here, we need to alternate music w/ outside stuff. She said she'd try yoga with me..so if I play up work outs as a bonding thing..we'll laugh, giggle AND burn some calories! Thanks again!!0 -
one of these posts made me think of something. they mentioned letting their son take karate lessons, because thats what he liked.
maybe she doesn't walk with you because thats not what SHE likes. maybe thats what YOU like. if i were you, i would definitely talk to her about it, and not in a secretive, sneaky way. tell her like it is. you love her, and that's why you want her to treat herself well. let her in on your own healthy life, so she can be a part of it, but don't force her to do it the way you do. you walk for exercise, maybe she would prefer horseback riding, hiking, or zumba. let her join you in her own way.
good luck!0 -
I would invest in a Wii Fit game, they are fun fort the whole family and the two of you can do it together.
She's at the age too where she doesnt want to do much out with mom and she's feeling depressed about herself weight etc.
It's the time for mom to understand, and never say anything about her weight or exercise.
Just ask her, I'm thinking on buying a Wii would you use something like that if I get it because I dont want to spend the $$$ on myself. Then, if she says yes, you do it together.0 -
Okay...as a teenager who is unhealthy i need to put my view onto this. I suggest making healthy meals and encouraging activities...games, the wii is amazing ....or ride bikes or anything that she might like that gets her moving..suggest to her that her health is important..but DO NOT force her to do it and DO NOT make negative comments about her habits to her. I struggled to lose weight for years and it did not work...why? because other people wanted me to lose the weight...i was not focused on doing it for me....now this year i desided that i needed to get into shape so I started this weight loss program for me...i have lost 27 pounds in 8 weeks. She will come around when she is ready...what you need to do is encourage and be a good example. (p.s. Wii games are still amazing)0
-
This is a very good post for me too. I have a 10 yo daughter who is getting a little heavy in her belly just recently. Some of it might be due to bloating but some it is due to lack of activity (consistent daily activity) and not so much eating unhealthy food. It also could be a growth spurt... my kids tend to grow "out" and then "up". But I can tell that my "helpful suggestions" of getting outside and doing some exercise (by just playing or whatever) is not really making an inpact and maybe even making things worse. She was very upset that she went up another pant/short size and I told her that she is growing still so this is to be expected, and not something to try to prevent. I have also mentioned that she should try to seek a balanced diet, and NOT trying to skip meals. (She has mentioned how she will skip a meal if I mention that her serving size is way above what it should be or as a way to get back at me for making a comment about what she is eating.) Since the boys are naturally thin, I also make a point of telling her that everyone had a different body type and that the boys (our boys) can eat pretty much anything they want and it's not fair but they stay thin. I did tell her that the boys have to be concerned about eating more protein than they do or they wont have the muscles/strength that they want. Another words, the boys will have their own health issues to contend with. I try to tell her that she and I have a similar, athletic body type and we're never going to be "thin" or "skinny" but that's okay because we have a natural athleticism and strength and those things will help us to stay healthy and active. It's a tight rope Im walking here and I know it. I want her to be happy (and grateful) with the body that God gave her but also be mindful that it can be difficult at times in our culture to stay active and eat healthy in such a way that we are treating our bodies like the temple. Sometimes I personally feel that I have to be almost obsessive in my routine to get the results that I want (in running or just weight loss) for my own body. I really dont want her to have to think about it so much as I do (She's a child!) but on the other hand, I want to educate my child so that she is knowledgable of the choices that she is going to have to make in order to maintain a healthy lifestyle... without being unhealthy and obsessive about it.0
-
I was kind of like that as a teen. Maybe there's a sport she would like or a class she might like. Like kickboxing or archery or maybe even dance. I was always too shy and insecure to try anything, but as an adult, I've loved them! I always wished I would have started valuing fitness earlier.
I think since you're the parent, it's perfectly acceptable to push her to try classes. However, I would shy from telling her it's because she is being unhealthy or getting fat, though, because that can make her pull away more and hurt her feelings. Maybe if she has some friends who like to do a certain sport or activity, they could all join together?0 -
I bought my daughter wii games Dance,Resort, Fit and Zumba . She likes it so much. especially on weekends my both kids like to play wii rather than watching TV. She is also doing Tae Kwon Do. But does not likes to play sport. Last summer I enrolled in 1 week basketball and 1 week soccer camp to just try which one she will prefer, because it was only for week not the whole season she agreed to signing up.0
-
the trick is to find an activity she will enjoy, shes in to music so try a dance class like hip hop or zumba somthing that can tie into her intrests if she interested in performing then being good at dance can help that goal. also as a whole preforming is looks based, just motivate her using her intrests0
-
We have Wii Fit, Xbox Kinect and tons of games (3 or 4 dance games, Zumba, work out games, personal trainer games,sports, etc). We do alot of the dancing games together. I wear my HRM so I can log the cal burned for myself and she DOES seem proud of herself when she's broken a sweat. I've tried her in every sport possible throughout the years. I do have a weight set and cardio equipment in storage. We are looking for a larger house, and I plan on setting up a "game room" with work out equip and Wii with plenty of room for us to "play". Also install stereo system and TV. It will benefit both of us.
Her friends are mostly "music geeks" (self-proclaimed). I have big butt and thighs (very muscular build) and spent most of my life thinking I was just "thick" (Cherokee Indian heritage) and was ok with my overweightness. Unfortunately, she carries it in belly and neck..not in hips and thighs. Poor girl has some genes working against her! I never mention the weight or pounds part of it..i just that I want her to be active. We actually like hanging out with each other, but I WILL stop suggesting "my" activities and ask her what SHE wants to do..as long as we move! Also-husband, my son and "bonus" daughter are SKINNY and eat whatever and however they want..so it does make it hard on daughter and myself.
I like the idea of not "hinting" and just sitting down and having a heart-to-heart straight talk. Maybe just put it out there and then leave it alone..wait for HER to be ready when she wants advice or help. Continue to provide healthy food and active things around our house.
Thanks again for the wonderful ideas and advice!!0 -
I hear what you're saying about getting rid of the junk food around the house, and inviting her to exercise etc. But please keep in mind that a 15 year old GIRL is going to take things very very personally. You need to approach this very carefully. Don't just drop hints and ask her to exercise with you. To a 15 year old, you might as well just tell her she's fat and worse... she's going to read into it.
Most 15 year olds I know want to be treated like an adult. So, I say asking her to set up a time that's convenient for HER to have an important talk. (Calling her into the livingroom and declaring it's time to talk is just taking power away from her.). Once you set up a date, try talking to her in a non threatening way.
Tell her, "I've been learning a lot about becoming healthy. I've only got a few more years until you're fully grown that I might get to teach you anything I'm learning. I think you're beautiful and perfect, and I always will. I just want to brainstorm a little about activities you might like to do to help you develop a healthy lifestyle that will follow you for the rest of your life.
As a parent, I want to do right by you. But I want you to have your own voice in this, so that you can be empowered."
Giving her the chance to have herself heard, and to help brainstorm activities makes it more HER decision, and one that will likely stick.
Sorry, but anything you plan for her, or suggest, might just get thrown out the window. She's definitely at that age where things are only cool if it's their idea.
Best wishes that your ideas will be received well!0 -
Why not try get her to join a fun class. Does not have to be a sport maybe the likes of zumba which is great.0
-
Very tricky area....Maybe you could ask her to go on a walk with you b/c you just want to spend some time with her? As for the extra helpings at dinner time, just make enough for each person... ?0
-
This just came in a Weight Watchers email:
Get the kids off to a healthy start and boost your own weight-loss by making fitness a family affair
TV and video games are sometimes stiff competition for physical activity.Try these activity boosting tips to get your kids off the couch and out of the house this fall.
Do it together
Kids love it when their parents join the game. So walk with them to the park, throw a Frisbee, fly a kite or kick a ball around. You're more likely to keep at an activity if it's something you enjoy. Let them tag along as you play ball, fish, hike, camp, surf or cycle. Kids enjoy making things, so set them a concrete goal, such as building a go-cart or clubhouse. This not only gets them moving, it brings about a sense of achievement.
Make it routine
Rather than trying to work "quality fitness time" into your family schedule—which can often get bumped as more urgent tasks take priority—add movement to everyday activities. If your children's pocket money is conditional on performing chores, for example, make the chores more activity-based (walking the dog, washing the windows or car, raking leaves or running errands). Don't drive them to social engagements; encourage them to walk or ride their bikes instead.
Make outings more active
Even so-called passive entertainments such as museums and theme parks can involve physical exertion (Disneyland, for example, extends over 185 acres, including parking; that's a lot of territory for little legs to cover!) The kids want to go to the movies? Walk at least part of the way to the theater. It's raining? Opt for energetic indoor pursuits such as bowling. Or turn up the stereo and have a dance contest.
Keep it simple
You don't need a garage full of sports equipment to have fun. The more structured an activity, the more likely a child's fickle attention span is to switch off. They'll get at least as much entertainment out of a ball (soccer, handball, basketball), a length of rope (skipping), a piece of chalk (hopscotch, sidewalk art) or nothing at all (leapfrog, hide-and-seek, tag).
Don't make an issue out of it
Nothing is guaranteed to turn kids off faster than nagging or harping on the benefits of exercise. It really doesn't matter which activities they participate in, or even how good they are at them as long as they keep it up. The key is making fun options available, while reducing less healthful ones, such as computer games.
Turn off the tube
According to a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association children lose weight if they simply watch less TV. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that viewing be limited to one to two hours of "quality programming" per day, by contrast with the current average of over four hours daily; that adds up to almost 12 years parked in front of the TV by the age of 70!
Not only does TV take away from more active pursuits, but the average U.S. child has also viewed 360,000 advertisements before graduating from high school; many are for fatty snack foods, reinforcing unhealthy habits.
Make it safe
Many parents, frightened of strangers or busy streets, are tempted to keep their child safely indoors. But by tacitly encouraging inactivity, they're actually courting dangers of a different sort, since lack of exercise is linked with significant health problems later in life, including obesity, diabetes, cardiovascular problems and osteoporosis.
If you want to safeguard your children, go with them to the park or playground; always supervise potentially risky activities such as swimming. You don't always have time to oversee playtime? Check into the activities offered at playgroups, neighborhood centers or summer camps, then choose a program run by responsible adults.0 -
When I noticed that my 13-year-old daughter was getting a little "pudgy," I started getting her to exercise with me. We make it a competition. For instance, yesterday I walked the dog for thirty minutes. That's 6 laps around my block. I bet my daughter that she couldn't ride her bike twice that far in the same amount of time. She took off like a rocket, and barely beat me. Then, because it was 95 degrees outside, I told her that her body needed to "cool down a bit," so I motivated her to walk slowly up and down our street until the 30 minutes was up. This morning I asked her how long she thought it would take her to go up and down the stairs 10 times. Again, she took off running. It won't take long before she figures out she's exercising, but I am hoping by then she will start to notice a difference in her body and will want to exercise with me.0
-
I hear what you're saying about getting rid of the junk food around the house, and inviting her to exercise etc. But please keep in mind that a 15 year old GIRL is going to take things very very personally. You need to approach this very carefully. Don't just drop hints and ask her to exercise with you. To a 15 year old, you might as well just tell her she's fat and worse... she's going to read into it.
Most 15 year olds I know want to be treated like an adult. So, I say asking her to set up a time that's convenient for HER to have an important talk. (Calling her into the livingroom and declaring it's time to talk is just taking power away from her.). Once you set up a date, try talking to her in a non threatening way.
Tell her, "I've been learning a lot about becoming healthy. I've only got a few more years until you're fully grown that I might get to teach you anything I'm learning. I think you're beautiful and perfect, and I always will. I just want to brainstorm a little about activities you might like to do to help you develop a healthy lifestyle that will follow you for the rest of your life.
As a parent, I want to do right by you. But I want you to have your own voice in this, so that you can be empowered."
Giving her the chance to have herself heard, and to help brainstorm activities makes it more HER decision, and one that will likely stick.
Sorry, but anything you plan for her, or suggest, might just get thrown out the window. She's definitely at that age where things are only cool if it's their idea.
Best wishes that your ideas will be received well!
RIGHT ON!!! THANKS!!!! :happy:0 -
Maybe you could find some activity that she likes to do that doesn't feel like exercise that you guys could do together - like taking a martial arts or a dance class. Buy both of you guys rollerblades or find a place that will give horse riding lessons. Maybe learning to scuba dive together or something else that is fun that can help her get more active & had good bonding time for you guys. If she finds something she loves to do that is healthy & active - it could stick for a lifetime. Good luck! :flowerforyou:0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions