So hungry all the time lately
MrsLannister
Posts: 347 Member
I've been doing a medically supervised weight loss program for about 6 weeks. As part of the program I was told to cut out most starches and focus on protein. I was doing great with it for about a month, and then everything went pear-shaped. For the past two weeks I've really struggled. I'm hungry all the time. I've been going way off plan and ended up gaining a pound this month, after being down about 3 - 4 pounds two weeks ago when I went off plan.
I met with my nutritionist yesterday and she just kept really pushing that I need to focus on protein. I don't think she believed me that I was getting a lot of protein. I had stopped logging and didn't bring in my previous logs from before I went off plan.
Today I am back on plan, but I am facing the same problem. I was okay most of the day, but immediately after dinner I started to feel like I was starving. It's been an hour since I ate and I feel like I could eat everything in the house. The hunger drives me crazy and it seems like I don't feel satisfied until I've stuffed my face with bread. I'm trying really hard to not do this tonight. I need to break that habit. But I don't even understand why I'm so hungry.
My nutritionist said I may be dehydrated, but I don't see how I could be, I drink more than two liters of water a day.
So, what helps hunger?
I met with my nutritionist yesterday and she just kept really pushing that I need to focus on protein. I don't think she believed me that I was getting a lot of protein. I had stopped logging and didn't bring in my previous logs from before I went off plan.
Today I am back on plan, but I am facing the same problem. I was okay most of the day, but immediately after dinner I started to feel like I was starving. It's been an hour since I ate and I feel like I could eat everything in the house. The hunger drives me crazy and it seems like I don't feel satisfied until I've stuffed my face with bread. I'm trying really hard to not do this tonight. I need to break that habit. But I don't even understand why I'm so hungry.
My nutritionist said I may be dehydrated, but I don't see how I could be, I drink more than two liters of water a day.
So, what helps hunger?
0
Replies
-
Are you eating enough FAT?0
-
I think so. My fat goal is 40% and I hit it almost square on the head today.
Carbs: 82 g
Fat: 68 g
Protein: 129g0 -
how many calories a day are you eating?0
-
~1500. Sometimes a little more, sometimes a little less, but I usually get within 50 calories of the goal.0
-
MrsLannister wrote: »~1500. Sometimes a little more, sometimes a little less, but I usually get within 50 calories of the goal.
is 1500 what they told you to eat or is that what you have been eating since you went off the program?0 -
Do you have medical problems that require you to be on this diet program?0
-
@ndj1979 They didn't give me a specific calories goal, just told me to cut starches and make better choices. 1500 is what I was doing when I was counting calories only and it was always fine for me. (I lost 83 pounds that way but started to gain it back when I stopped counting.) During the past two weeks I haven't been counting at all and have eaten way, way over that.
@zyxst I have to do a three month program to get approved for gastric bypass. I know some people here are very opposed to bariatric surgery, but studies show that it is the only thing that it that actually addresses the disease state of obesity. I can do okay on my own for a while, but I definitely need the additional support if I really want to lose it and keep it off.0 -
OP - I am going to give you the following advice.
1. ditch the clean eating it is necessary for nothing and impossible to define.
2. enter your stats into MFP and set it for one pound per week loss.
3. get a food scale and weigh all solids
4. make sure you are using accurate MFP database entries
5. log everything that you eat
6. realize that no foods are bad/clean/good/whatever; you can eat the foods you like on a daily basis like cookies, ice cream, processed foods, etc; however, make sure that the majority of your foods are nutrient dense
7. make sure you hit micros/macors
8. find a form of exercise you like and do it < not necessary but is good for overall health.0 -
So it sounds like you're eating about 1450 - 1500 Calories, and trying to keep yourself under 100g of carbs get about 130g of protein?
I guess the next question is, how big of a deficit is that for you? Are you exercising? How active are you? What is your current weight, height, age?
I mean, lets face it, if 1500 Cal represents a 50% cut on your TDEE, then yes, you will get hungry, I don't see how it can work otherwise.
But if it represents a 20% cut, or less, then it might be worth trying to troubleshoot the why's0 -
Maybe it's not hunger. Maybe you just really miss bread?? Just a thought.0
-
The OP paid someone to tell her to "make better choices?"0
-
@ndj1979 I did that for two years and it was fine, but I have to do this medically supervised weight loss program and these are the requirements.
@PAV8888 I'm 5'7.5" and 346 lbs.I'm fairly sedentary and work at a desk all day without a lot of opportunity to move around since I have to meet certain expectations and don't have the luxury of walking away outside of my normal breaks (customer service). My doctor wants me to get my BMI under 50 in three months. So that is about 20 lbs I need to lose in three months.0 -
SherryTeach wrote: »The OP paid someone to tell her to "make better choices?"
My insurance company pays them, actually.0 -
What helped me, in addition to the suggestions above such that said accurate logging and water in intake, is fiber.
I added unflavored psyllum power to my meals.0 -
I also upped my fat and protein intact. Before that I was so hungry all the time.0
-
OK: I looked through a couple of your diary entries... and they don't look that bad; in fact I've often made similar choices.
For what it's worth here are a couple of observations from my own experiences:
Swap the cottage cheese for greek yogurt. More protein and less calories for a larger quantity. Kirkland's Signature three pack of plain is not bad. I personally prefer the Oikos 0% 810g, but it runs more expensive.
I don't know how the sugars in the yogurt might affect things for you, depending on your reason for "lowish" carbing.
Nuts and seeds ARE healthy fats and kewl and all that. And I eat pumpkin seeds all the time too for the crunch. They do pack more calories (as does cheese), than say eating fresh fruits. But, again, if you are low carbing fruits and veggies may be an issue for you.
Similarly fish (frozen fish, Superstore if you're in Canada) tends to be low calories for good volume. You can even put some frozen fish fillets and some veggies in one dish and in the nuker and "presto" after a few minutes at 50-60% out comes a ready to eat "meal" (pour some spices, or carefully measured butter, or olive oil, or just lemon/dill/what have you on top to make it edible ;-)
Chicken breasts and pork tenderloin are also high protein/low fat/lower calorie cuts of meat. Pork tenderloin is probably the best "meat" price/calorie/satiety bargain I'm aware off right now.
So basically I would try to increase the volume to make you feel fuller, but I am not sure what limitations you are operating under.0 -
@PAV8888 Thanks for the advice. My only real limitation is no starches. I should have mentioned part of the reason for this is that I have PCOS with insulin resistance.
I go back and forth between yogurt and cottage cheese. My yogurt of choice is fage, but sometimes I want something with more texture and then I go for cottage cheese with sunflower seeds.0 -
I try to eat lighter meals in the morning, a bit more in the afternoon and a very filling dinner otherwise I am just like you and starving at night!
Odd question, but do you stay up really late and find this is when you are hungry? I often do since I am a night owl and find that if I am hungry at night, and I should have gone to bed already, if I drink a big glass of water and eat two spoons of Greek yogurt for some protein (save some calories for this) and just go to bed it solves my problem.
Also, I second recommendations to make sure you get lots of fiber. When I manage to get my 25-30 grams of fiber in a day I am much fuller. I never felt full using things like fiber you mix in a glass, it needs to come from foods for me to feel full.0 -
I actually don't stay up late, since I have to get up at 4 AM for work. Once challenge I face is that my "lunch" is at 8:30 am and then I don't get off work until 3:30 PM. even snacking on my break, that long stretch has been difficult. Today is different, though. Today is my day off and I ate steadily throughout the day, but was hungry within minutes of eating a fairly large dinner.0
-
Maybe it's not hunger, maybe it's stress or anxiety... Maybe it's loneliness. I'd think about what else is going on in your life and maybe your feeling it as hunger. From my own experience I find this to be true!0
-
Okay with your stats, thats not many calories. I agree, get plenty of fats and protein for satiety. Are you earning exercise calories?0
-
It seems like you are eating at about a 40-45% calorie deficit. That's extremely difficult and not necessary if you have 3 months to lose 20lbs.
If you aimed for about 1900 calories (about 30% deficit) you should feel better and be able to stick to it so that you will succeed in reaching your goal.
If you found even 20 minutes to take a walk several days a week, that would really help to use some of the calories back up and get you there even faster. But even without it, if you can stay at a deficit and not be miserable, you will be able to stick to it and more importantly, develop new habits that will follow you into your post surgery life, where your diet will likely be even more specific and require further commitment.
Creating a successful loss over the next 3 months will have more value to you than just the loss itself. It will give you the pride we feel when we accomplish a set goal and give you confidence that you can follow the healthier routine you will be advised after surgery.
I'm assuming going moderately low carb is a new thing for you too. And there are certain "addiction" feelings associated with carbs in general. It will trigger hunger feelings and cravings when we cut it way back. But they will lessen in time. I think if you eat at a smaller calorie deficit that you will find that easier. You can always cut back more later on if you feel up to it. And you will have to do that as you lose weight as you won't need as many calories for maintenance anyway.
I wish you the best of luck on your journey.0 -
I was going to mention that you might not need to be in as large a deficit for 20lbs in a few months; but I seem to recall that people with PCOS have a much harder time losing weight.
And it may in fact be carbs in general that have to controlled as opposed to just starches; but, I don't know enough about PCOS.
However the people in this MFP group certainly DO: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/3070-p-c-o-sis
0 -
MrsLannister wrote: »I actually don't stay up late, since I have to get up at 4 AM for work. Once challenge I face is that my "lunch" is at 8:30 am and then I don't get off work until 3:30 PM. even snacking on my break, that long stretch has been difficult. Today is different, though. Today is my day off and I ate steadily throughout the day, but was hungry within minutes of eating a fairly large dinner.
I totally understand, I used to work 7-3 and breakfast was at 5:30 since I took the bus to work and it took over an hour to get there. Lunch was usually 11 and dinner time was at 6:00 when my husband got home from his 9-5. I always needed to snack, but some days I was pretty hungry/hangry and waiting that long to eat certainly didn't always result in the best choices.
Have you tried weight watchers bread? I keep mine in the freezer to keep me from being bad and eating a lot of it, and one slice might satisfy the need for bread, but at only 10 carbs per slice a slice with peanutbutter could fit into the number of carbs you have for the day.
You are on a pretty restricted diet and a big drop in calories, but if that is what your surgeon/nutritionist want, stick with it otherwise it could put yourself in a position where they don't want to do the surgery. My best friend had weight loss surgery and her doctor put her on a liquid diet to help her lose weight before hand and she was pretty hungry to start, but she did say it got easier after the first week or two and she has no regrets about the process.
0 -
I will second the vote for pork tenderloin. There are so many ways to prepare it and there is no waste. My favorite is to slather on some Dijon mustard and then coat the loin with caraway and celery seed. Lay a few sprigs of sage on there and roast. Oh, it is delicious. . . very high in protein and very low in calories. For bread, I often eat multi-grain sandwich thins. They make a fine sandwich and toasted with a big or orange marmalade is sometimes my evening snack. High in fiber too.0
-
I'm going to try making "oopsie bread." I can't have any kind of regular bread, cracker, etc. Not even regular low carb bread. Nothing made with flour. The oopsie bread is just eggs and cream cheese, so it fits in fine with my restrictions.
I went ahead and bumped my calories up to 1750. We'll see how that goes for a while.0 -
Some of the things that have worked for me when I'm struggling with "just wanting to EAT" ...Drink heaps of water, chew gum, eat sugar free jelly, chromium (usually not one to push magic pills but I do actually think that this helped me).0
-
Sugar free Jello helps me tons when I feel hungry. One whole box is just 4 g of protein and is quite a bit if you eat it all in one sitting.0
-
You did mention having PCOS and that you are planning on having bariatric surgery, right? I sent you a link to the PCOS group here. You may also want to read this sticky thread: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1448249/diagnosed-living-with-pcos-read-me/p1
0 -
This content has been removed.
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions