Running Shoes
MonkeyMel21
Posts: 2,396 Member
Hello, MFP.
I need to get a new pair of running shoes. I used aisics for several years till recently I felt like they just weren't lasting as long. I thought I would give Brooks a try, I got the Ravenna fitted for me after getting videoed while running. They are ok....but I feel like they wore out even faster than the aisics and just over all not truly impressed. I used to get saucony in high school but that's been about 10 years, lol. What do you all suggest? I run about half on the treadmill and half on the street. Not more than 10-15 miles a week (2-4 miles at a time). Also, I'm curious if there's a difference between buying online and buying at a running store (aside from actually getting to try them on)? I have $200 in reward points that I can use on Amazon. I see a wide variety of shoes on there but it seems like the prices change per color and size?? idk. Anyway, I need new running shoes, thank you, the end.
I need to get a new pair of running shoes. I used aisics for several years till recently I felt like they just weren't lasting as long. I thought I would give Brooks a try, I got the Ravenna fitted for me after getting videoed while running. They are ok....but I feel like they wore out even faster than the aisics and just over all not truly impressed. I used to get saucony in high school but that's been about 10 years, lol. What do you all suggest? I run about half on the treadmill and half on the street. Not more than 10-15 miles a week (2-4 miles at a time). Also, I'm curious if there's a difference between buying online and buying at a running store (aside from actually getting to try them on)? I have $200 in reward points that I can use on Amazon. I see a wide variety of shoes on there but it seems like the prices change per color and size?? idk. Anyway, I need new running shoes, thank you, the end.
0
Replies
-
Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.0 -
IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
+1
Getting your gait analyzed could save you some podiatry problems in the future by making sure you have the proper support for your feet.0 -
Oh OP, wait until the 15th of this month too. It's meant to be the Amazon Prime sale and you could save some more money.0
-
IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Yeah? They'll be the same exact shoe then?0 -
MonkeyMel21 wrote: »IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Yeah? They'll be the same exact shoe then?
Yes... they'll be cheaper online though.0 -
Nice, but I don't have Prime.IsaackGMOON wrote: »Oh OP, wait until the 15th of this month too. It's meant to be the Amazon Prime sale and you could save some more money.
And yes, I go to the running store every year when I get my new shoes, they just don't ever seem to offer me anything other than aisics, lol. Which would be fine if they started making the quality better.
0 -
MonkeyMel21 wrote: »
Nice, but I don't have Prime.IsaackGMOON wrote: »Oh OP, wait until the 15th of this month too. It's meant to be the Amazon Prime sale and you could save some more money.
And yes, I go to the running store every year when I get my new shoes, they just don't ever seem to offer me anything other than aisics, lol. Which would be fine if they started making the quality better.
If you put your debit/credit card details up for prime, but just use the trial... you'll be eligible for the Amazon Prime Sale. It's a 30 day trial and you can cancel whenever, no money is taken out until it's over.
0 -
IsaackGMOON wrote: »MonkeyMel21 wrote: »IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Yeah? They'll be the same exact shoe then?
Yes... they'll be cheaper online though.
Right. I just mean they won't be knock offs or lower quality.0 -
MonkeyMel21 wrote: »IsaackGMOON wrote: »MonkeyMel21 wrote: »IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Yeah? They'll be the same exact shoe then?
Yes... they'll be cheaper online though.
Right. I just mean they won't be knock offs or lower quality.
No. It's pretty hard to find knock offs on Amazon (at least that's how I've found it). When you come to buying them, it will say which vendor or store is selling it. Usually, it will be an official stockist of the shoe or the actual company.
But I assure you, 99.9% of the time you will not buy a fake... it's pretty hard on Amazon.0 -
IsaackGMOON wrote: »MonkeyMel21 wrote: »
Nice, but I don't have Prime.IsaackGMOON wrote: »Oh OP, wait until the 15th of this month too. It's meant to be the Amazon Prime sale and you could save some more money.
And yes, I go to the running store every year when I get my new shoes, they just don't ever seem to offer me anything other than aisics, lol. Which would be fine if they started making the quality better.
If you put your debit/credit card details up for prime, but just use the trial... you'll be eligible for the Amazon Prime Sale. It's a 30 day trial and you can cancel whenever, no money is taken out until it's over.
Ok, thanks!0 -
MonkeyMel21 wrote: »Hello, MFP.
I need to get a new pair of running shoes. I used aisics for several years till recently I felt like they just weren't lasting as long. I thought I would give Brooks a try, I got the Ravenna fitted for me after getting videoed while running. They are ok....but I feel like they wore out even faster than the aisics and just over all not truly impressed. I used to get saucony in high school but that's been about 10 years, lol. What do you all suggest? I run about half on the treadmill and half on the street. Not more than 10-15 miles a week (2-4 miles at a time). Also, I'm curious if there's a difference between buying online and buying at a running store (aside from actually getting to try them on)? I have $200 in reward points that I can use on Amazon. I see a wide variety of shoes on there but it seems like the prices change per color and size?? idk. Anyway, I need new running shoes, thank you, the end.
Yeah, Brooks completely changed (FUBARed) the Ravenna with the 2015/Ravenna 6 model. You don't want the new ones anyway.
However, Asics *also* changed their similar GT-2000 and I seem to be getting decent mileage out of it. (I am very hard on shoes). Before this, I haven't been able to wear Asics for about 7 years, so I don't have much comparison.
Other similar ones you could try: Saucony Guide, New Balance 870 or 890, Mizuno Wave Inspire, Adidas Supernova Sequence, Skechers GoRun Ride (these wore out very fast for me, but they are much cheaper than other running shoes, so could be worth it on a 10-15 mi/week schedule).
Also, IF you go to a running store and get fitted again, buy that pair of shoes AT YOUR RUNNING STORE. They did you a solid; return the favor.
Then order future pairs online. I like Running Warehouse, personally, or 6pm for last year's models cheap.
0 -
I buy the style recommended first from a local running store. Then go on line (Joe's New Balance as I am a New Balance guy when I am ready to purchase my next pair from any where between 30 and 40 bucks off including shipping. Love Joe's New Balance.0
-
IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
This is a terrible idea.
Support your local running store. LRSs do great things to foster running in your community--advocating for trail/path construction, pedestrian safety measures, crosswalks at traffic lights, supporting local races.
If you go in for a fitting and like what they put you in, buy the darn shoes. Sure, buy future pairs online, but don't fall in love with shoes and then give the employee who helped you the metaphorical finger.
Now, there is a good argument to be made for picking out running shoes based on looks rather than "professional fit"--I've always done better in shoes where I was just like, "Ooh, how pretty" than what a store put me in. BUT. If you choose to take advantage of a free service, buy the darn shoes.
If money is a big enough concern that $10-30 means you cannot pay your rent, I suggest checking out DSW or Kohl's online--they have very good selections of lower-end running shoes from reputable brands (Asics, Saucony, NB) that will be just fine for 10-15 mi/week.0 -
I just got new wheels myself. I ended up in a pair of Newtons, which I had never owned before and after two training sessions over the weekend, I love them. The thing is, I never would have bought these shoes without going to a running shoe store. Since I last bought shoes, I have worked with a running coach on my form and have lost about 40 pounds. Both of these impact how I run, and the runner/salesperson at the specialty running store (SRS) could see it in my form. Before I settled on the Newtons, I tried on 12 different shoes and actually ran around the block in 8 of those to get a feel for them. I went from an 8mm drop shoe to the Newton with a 3mm drop that fits my feet and my form very well.
The point of the story is that your running style is not a static thing. I always go to SRS to get shoes and every time, I learn something from other runners. If I went to Amazon, I miss out on that advice and education.
I will say that I did buy shoes on Amazon once, but I knew exactly what I wanted/needed. It was an circumstance where the SRS did not have a wide in the shoe I wanted and I could not come back in a week when they ordered it. So, I have done both, but strongly prefer the SRS.
I would use the Amazon credit to get other running gear and maybe some running books.0 -
i used nike pegasus but they get really crappy after 4 months0
-
Not real advice on what type of shoe lasts longest but I buy shoes from Amazon all the time and I've always gotten what I ordered with no issues!
I usually run in New Balance Minimus but they don't last long IMO. They are just the only shoes that I can run comfortably in for some reason.0 -
cheshirecatastrophe wrote: »IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
This is a terrible idea.
Support your local running store. LRSs do great things to foster running in your community--advocating for trail/path construction, pedestrian safety measures, crosswalks at traffic lights, supporting local races.
If you go in for a fitting and like what they put you in, buy the darn shoes. Sure, buy future pairs online, but don't fall in love with shoes and then give the employee who helped you the metaphorical finger.
Now, there is a good argument to be made for picking out running shoes based on looks rather than "professional fit"--I've always done better in shoes where I was just like, "Ooh, how pretty" than what a store put me in. BUT. If you choose to take advantage of a free service, buy the darn shoes.
If money is a big enough concern that $10-30 means you cannot pay your rent, I suggest checking out DSW or Kohl's online--they have very good selections of lower-end running shoes from reputable brands (Asics, Saucony, NB) that will be just fine for 10-15 mi/week.
+10000000
Where will you go when all the local stores are gone? Good luck guessing which shoe you need online.
I always get my new shoes locally. I then order a second pair online. I usually find I only save $20 anyway.0 -
OP, do you track the mileage on your shoes, to know how long they're actually lasting? Most models should hold up for 300-500 miles.
As for going to the running store, you can tell them you haven't been happy with Asics and want to try other brands. Everyone's preferences are different and the store employees should be able to pull a model from another brand that works for your gait for you to try.
If you know your gait, you can try some models of other brands until you find something you like by yourself. All the major brands' websites should list what kind of gait their shoes are for. Someone else mentioned getting a lower-end model, and I agree, since you don't run that much per week.0 -
+10000000
Where will you go when all the local stores are gone? Good luck guessing which shoe you need online.
I always get my new shoes locally. I then order a second pair online. I usually find I only save $20 anyway.
Yup.
I went to my local store, had them check my gait, got the shoes there. While I was at the checkout holding my wallet, the guy at the register saw my military ID and offered a military discount. Score.
I ordered 2 more pair online. It was worth it to pay a little bit more in person to the folks who took the time to ensure that I had a properly fitting running shoe. Amazon did not check my gait, nor did they make sure I had a proper fitting running shoe. Support your local shop.
0 -
hmrambling wrote: »
+10000000
Where will you go when all the local stores are gone? Good luck guessing which shoe you need online.
I always get my new shoes locally. I then order a second pair online. I usually find I only save $20 anyway.
Yup.
I went to my local store, had them check my gait, got the shoes there. While I was at the checkout holding my wallet, the guy at the register saw my military ID and offered a military discount. Score.
I ordered 2 more pair online. It was worth it to pay a little bit more in person to the folks who took the time to ensure that I had a properly fitting running shoe. Amazon did not check my gait, nor did they make sure I had a proper fitting running shoe. Support your local shop.
I had a similar experience. I paid for my shoes with my USAA CC and the girl at the register gave me a discount (even though I haven't been in the Army since 1993). I've been a customer there ever since. 0 -
brandiuntz wrote: »OP, do you track the mileage on your shoes, to know how long they're actually lasting? Most models should hold up for 300-500 miles.
As for going to the running store, you can tell them you haven't been happy with Asics and want to try other brands. Everyone's preferences are different and the store employees should be able to pull a model from another brand that works for your gait for you to try.
If you know your gait, you can try some models of other brands until you find something you like by yourself. All the major brands' websites should list what kind of gait their shoes are for. Someone else mentioned getting a lower-end model, and I agree, since you don't run that much per week.
I use them for working out/running for 6 months, then also wear them at work for another six months, then buy a brand new pair just for running/working out for the next six months, etc. I usually spend $100-110 once a year and that's not a big deal for me. I've gotten cheap New Balances before from Kohl's and gave them away after wearing them for a week.0 -
I love my brooks ghost 6. Getting ready to get a new pair. Already eying the amazon July 15 day. They don't last as long as I would like but I think it's because they are soft and comfortable.0
-
IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
This part, I'd agree with.Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Don't be a parasite.
fwiw your local running store will be able to help if the shoes you buy aren't right for you, many have a decent return policy. Some also have associated running clubs, coaching opportunities etc as well.
0 -
I agree with supporting local running stores. They have been a lifesaver for me. Everything from foot, to calf to energy help. My feet do well with Brooks, and they tend to last 9-10 months for me, running average of 9-10 miles per week.0
-
With the buy them on amazon instead, as good of an idea as that is, you have to be really careful with amazon. A lot of knockoffs.0
-
Where will you go when all the local stores are gone? Good luck guessing which shoe you need online.
I always get my new shoes locally. I then order a second pair online. I usually find I only save $20 anyway.
I like the shoes I guessed would work for me that I bought online better than the ones the running store that analyzed my gait put me in. It's not like they aren't human, and they don't always know best.
The last time I went to the running store for advice, I did buy the shoes from them. But I didn't so much have a gait analysis as insist that I wanted a neutral shoe in a "traditional" style as a backup to the minimal shoes I actually prefer. I was offered 6 choices, one of which the salesguy tried to trick me with a pair to "correct" my overpronation - but I could feel the difference, and I said Nope. When I came home with my new purchase, I checked online to see how much I could have saved, but I couldn't even find a better deal, anyway.
0 -
I love Asics0
-
Also, IF you go to a running store and get fitted again, buy that pair of shoes AT YOUR RUNNING STORE. They did you a solid; return the favor. Then order future pairs online. I like Running Warehouse, personally, or 6pm for last year's models cheap.
[/quote]
Agree with this, I don't think you save enough money to make that right.
I used to love Brooks, but the last pair I bought I did not lie, I am using Asics right now. I don't run a ton, but walk and wear them in the gym, so I am probably not a good bench mark for how long they will last. I end up doing a mud run once a year and get rid of the old and buy new then
0 -
me too! I made the mistake of going with some Nike Pegasus and haven't been impressed as I have been with every pair of Asics Ive had. I'd rather have a shoe that fits perfect and doest last as long over a shoe that lasts longer but ins't as good.VryIrishGirl76 wrote: »I love Asics
0 -
IsaackGMOON wrote: »Go to your running store. Ask them to analyse your gait etc. They'll give you a selection of shoes which fit you.
Don't buy them.
Go to Amazon.
Buy the shoes.
You'll probably save some money.
Better idea: go to the running store, get fitted, then shoplift them. Same difference. IOW, you're a shmuck.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions