No carb diet
micheledarley2012
Posts: 24 Member
I go to a weight-loss doctor and I had a lot of blood work done last week. It turns out that I am prediabetic, and have to go on a no carb diet. I had already limited my carbs for the first month I've been going there and had lost 8 1/2 pounds. Now, I cannot have any grains or carbohydrates, and no sugar whatsoever, which I wasn't having except for eating fruit anyway. To top it off, a medication that I'm taking is known to cause diabetes, but my weight-loss doctor is not really looking at that, and just telling me that I'm doing well dieting and I should keep it up and add more exercise. I'm frustrated because I've never had issues with blood sugar or insulin before and I feel like this woman is not listening to me. If anyone is on a carb free diet and has some foods they like that they could share with me I would really appreciate it. I have already given up all of the bad food, but I'm not really sure what to eat.
0
Replies
-
No carbs at all? So no vegetables? A zero carb diet would basically have to consist of all meat, as there really isn't anything else that is NO carb rather than low carb.0
-
Did the doctor gave you a list what you can eat? Maybe visiting a nutritionist that can make a plan together with you?0
-
Did your doctor give you any guidance as to how this is supposed to happen? Most low carb diets are comprised of veggies, fruits, meats, fats (oils), and some dairy, but carbs/sugar occur naturally in veggies, fruits, and dairy, so complete avoidance would be next to impossible. I think your assessment that she isn't listening to you is spot on - is there another doctor in the practice you can talk to? I've honestly never heard of a "no carb" diet prescription for some diagnosed as pre-diabetic.0
-
micheledarley2012 wrote: »I'm frustrated because I've never had issues with blood sugar or insulin before and I feel like this woman is not listening to me.
That says to me you need to find someone else to help you with your nutritional issues. If you aren't comfortable and have a good relationship with any medical professional you are taking advice from, it's time to find a new one. Maybe a registered dietician would be more beneficial.
0 -
Did your doctor give you any guidance as to how this is supposed to happen? Most low carb diets are comprised of veggies, fruits, meats, fats (oils), and some dairy, but carbs/sugar occur naturally in veggies, fruits, and dairy, so complete avoidance would be next to impossible. I think your assessment that she isn't listening to you is spot on - is there another doctor in the practice you can talk to? I've honestly never heard of a "no carb" diet prescription for some diagnosed as pre-diabetic.
I have full blown T2Dm and I have been prescribed a moderate carb diet. Are you sure that is what your doctor told you? No carb is extreme, even for people with diabetes let alone pre-diabetics. Did they give you a list of food to eat? You might want to get a referral to a Registered Dietician who can walk you through meal ideas.
0 -
Did your doctor give you any guidance as to how this is supposed to happen? Most low carb diets are comprised of veggies, fruits, meats, fats (oils), and some dairy, but carbs/sugar occur naturally in veggies, fruits, and dairy, so complete avoidance would be next to impossible. I think your assessment that she isn't listening to you is spot on - is there another doctor in the practice you can talk to? I've honestly never heard of a "no carb" diet prescription for some diagnosed as pre-diabetic.
I have full blown T2Dm and I have been prescribed a moderate carb diet. Are you sure that is what your doctor told you? No carb is extreme, even for people with diabetes let alone pre-diabetics. Did they give you a list of food to eat? You might want to get a referral to a Registered Dietician who can walk you through meal ideas.
Indeed i think so too.
0 -
Second opinion. There's nothing wrong with getting one.0
-
Yeah, I'd be seeking a second opinion, particularly as you feel she isn't listening. If she's telling you not to have any carbs whatsoever, I'd be concerned about her credentials.0
-
The weight loss doctor diagnosed you as pre-diabetic? Go back to your regular doctor.0
-
It would be near impossible to have a NO carb diet, wouldn't it?0
-
micheledarley2012 wrote: »I go to a weight-loss doctor and I had a lot of blood work done last week. It turns out that I am prediabetic, and have to go on a no carb diet. I had already limited my carbs for the first month I've been going there and had lost 8 1/2 pounds. Now, I cannot have any grains or carbohydrates, and no sugar whatsoever, which I wasn't having except for eating fruit anyway. To top it off, a medication that I'm taking is known to cause diabetes, but my weight-loss doctor is not really looking at that, and just telling me that I'm doing well dieting and I should keep it up and add more exercise. I'm frustrated because I've never had issues with blood sugar or insulin before and I feel like this woman is not listening to me. If anyone is on a carb free diet and has some foods they like that they could share with me I would really appreciate it. I have already given up all of the bad food, but I'm not really sure what to eat.
A no carb diet would be eating as a carnivore. Was it perhaps a no sugar diet or a low carb diet? That would be easier to do than no carb.
I eat low carb and have days with just one or two sugars. I haven't had a carb free day yet though.
I would clarify with your doctor what his expectations are and how he wants you to implement it.
Best wishes.0 -
What special qualifications does this "weight-loss doctor" actually have? Is she actually qualified to know how to manage pre-diabetes? I'm not sure I'd trust a doctor recommending a "no carb" diet.0
-
micheledarley2012 wrote: »I go to a weight-loss doctor and I had a lot of blood work done last week. It turns out that I am prediabetic, and have to go on a no carb diet. I had already limited my carbs for the first month I've been going there and had lost 8 1/2 pounds. Now, I cannot have any grains or carbohydrates, and no sugar whatsoever, which I wasn't having except for eating fruit anyway. To top it off, a medication that I'm taking is known to cause diabetes, but my weight-loss doctor is not really looking at that, and just telling me that I'm doing well dieting and I should keep it up and add more exercise. I'm frustrated because I've never had issues with blood sugar or insulin before and I feel like this woman is not listening to me. If anyone is on a carb free diet and has some foods they like that they could share with me I would really appreciate it. I have already given up all of the bad food, but I'm not really sure what to eat.
Like a real MD doctor who went to medical school?
0 -
If you've actually gotta go no carb. I would suggest looking up something called a Ketogenic diet. It's all about high fat, extremely low(25g max) - no carb.0
-
If you completely omitted carbs, I'd say you'd be swapping your current problems with another kind, in the toileting department
0 -
Maybe talk with your primary care doctor. Pre diabetics have an A1c level of 5.7-6.4. That measures the sugar that clings to red cells. I would question a no carb diet. High protein diets that are very low in carbs are hard on kidneys. Ask if a Mediterranean style diet might be safer.0
-
I think you need a second opinion. This is too extreme. I'm prediabetic and I was told to eat moderate carb, not NO carb. You'll end up malnourished by trying to avoid all carbs. I second the idea of talking to your regular family doctor. I should elaborate, I saw an endocrinologist, and she said that moderate carb was the way to go. Moderate to low-ish... the key is that you never eat a carb without a protein. Always pair them together.0
-
I can't believe your doctor said "no carb". Are you sure it wasn't low carb? That is common with a pre-diabetes disgnosis. Sometimes people will causally say things like "cut the carbs". This is generally meant as reduce them significantly, or even cut out added sugar. I really think there was some miscommunication here.0
-
Thank you for all of the replies!
She wrote no carb on my new diet plan which says Mediterranean diet on it. She is actually part of a very large practice that is part of our local hospital and very well respected. I do think I'm going to call and ask for a new doctor as she makes me feel so uncomfortable. I'm going to see the dietitian in two weeks and hopefully that will help me get some tips on cooking and such. I also want to have my primary care doctor look at my blood work, because he takes the same medication I do and has done bloodwork on me for the last eight or nine months and I want him to see the blood sugar and insulin information.
0 -
You'd better ask for clarification. Low-carb and literally-no-carb are two completely different beasts.0
-
Yeah you definitely need to clarify with this doctor. A quick glance of your Mediterranean meal plan does in fact include carbs.. It seems like quite the contradiction0
-
Based on what the diet actually calls for, my guess is that as she wrote that she accidentally wrote the wrong word. Just like people misspeak, they can miswrite. She wrote no grains. Maybe she meant to write no added sugar as well. The sheet does say no concentrated sweets and no grains. But you need to ask her to clarify.
But if she actually makes you uncomfortable, switching might be good. Although I will say from personal experience, sometimes the first visit to a new doctor is awkward and then a very good relationship can form.0 -
I would ask her to clarify what she meant by no carbs. The diet she gave you says plant foods, which fruits and vegetables are carbs. Maybe they meant something different.0
-
Ok a lot of misinformation on here. No carb- low carb does not equate or lead to kidney damage.
What you need to look up and read is the "ketogenic diet".
The body does not need carbohydrates. In the ketogenic diet FAT is used as the primary fuel source ( instead of carbs).
A common macro split for a keto diet would look like this. 65-75% fat, 5% or less carbs, 20-35% protein ( depending on lbm).
The Ketogenic diet has been shown to reverse type 2 diabetes all together as well as alzheimers and helps prevent cancer.
It is frankly a better fuel source for the body.
Give your Dr the benefit of the doubt and look into it.0 -
That diet is definitely not 'no carb', so either she is confused, or she wrote the wrong word. I know sometimes if I'm writing and talking at the same time, I will write the word I'm saying and not the one I meant to write. So maybe she did that. But do ask to see a new doctor and speak to your primary care physician.0
-
That is not low carb, there are plenty of carbohydrate rich foods in that list.0
-
I am going with mis written word.
The rest of the guidelines shown on that piece of paper sound reasonable so I think it is probably just a mistake.0 -
Yes, talk to your regular doctor or a dietician.
Eat lots and lots of greens (spinach, romaine, swiss chard, kale, cabbage), olives, broccoli, cauliflower, squash, zucchini, cucumbers, pickles, asparagus, green beans, mushrooms, avocados, coconuts.
You do need some fat in your diet: eggs, nuts, avocado, coconut.
0 -
I think what she meant are no sugary carbs, no grainsand breads or pancakes waffle. Bc there are carbs on that list like beans and fruit and vegetables.0
-
Fruits and veggies have carbs in them. I would ask for some clarification from the dietician.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions