Macdonalds - USA and UK - Why the difference?
suziecue20
Posts: 567 Member
I've just been looking at the calories for Macdonalds food and find that a bigmac in UK is 508 cals and in USA 570 cals. The difference is even greater with the fries - UK large portion = 444 cals and USA large portion = 570 cals. I always thought Macdonalds food was the same worldwide but obviously not. What is the difference in the bigmac - just overall bigger bun and patty or richer sauce, more lettuce or what? and why?
0
Replies
-
Interesting. Where I live a big mac is 499 and large fries are 685. Wonder what they put in our fries!
Energy 685 kCal Cholesterol 0 mg Protein 9 g
Total Fat 35 g Sodium 570 mg Vitamin A 0 ug
Saturated Fat 14.2 g Carbohydrate 84 g Vitamin C 0 mg
Trans Fat 0.2 g Dietary Fibre 7 g Calcium 0 mg
Sugars 0 g Iron 1.8 mg0 -
I think the portion sizes are bigger in the US. If you Google "portion sizes McD's worldwide" there's a picture showing the different sized cups. A medium US drink is bigger than a large drink in Japan for example. There are also some interesting pictures on how the portion sizes have increased in the last fifty years!0
-
Bread is also slightly different think , and an Aussie large fries is no where near the size of a U.S. Large0
-
Yes, this^^.
When i visited the US, the portions were so big!
I didn't mind it for the 4 weeks i was there, but i'm glad i live in the UK. Lol0 -
I'm in Australia, and am aware of there being discrepancies between countries, so I make sure I add "Australia" when searching MFP for the kilojoule count AND looking up the nutrition info on the Australian website.0
-
suziecue20 wrote: »I've just been looking at the calories for Macdonalds food and find that a bigmac in UK is 508 cals and in USA 570 cals. The difference is even greater with the fries - UK large portion = 444 cals and USA large portion = 570 cals. I always thought Macdonalds food was the same worldwide but obviously not. What is the difference in the bigmac - just overall bigger bun and patty or richer sauce, more lettuce or what? and why?
Portion sizes are bigger in the USA then the uk that's where the difference will be x0 -
avilancaster871 wrote: »suziecue20 wrote: »I've just been looking at the calories for Macdonalds food and find that a bigmac in UK is 508 cals and in USA 570 cals. The difference is even greater with the fries - UK large portion = 444 cals and USA large portion = 570 cals. I always thought Macdonalds food was the same worldwide but obviously not. What is the difference in the bigmac - just overall bigger bun and patty or richer sauce, more lettuce or what? and why?
Portion sizes are bigger in the USA then the uk that's where the difference will be x
Yes, fair enough but why? does every US citizen have a bigger appetite than citizens in every other country?
0 -
suziecue20 wrote: »avilancaster871 wrote: »suziecue20 wrote: »I've just been looking at the calories for Macdonalds food and find that a bigmac in UK is 508 cals and in USA 570 cals. The difference is even greater with the fries - UK large portion = 444 cals and USA large portion = 570 cals. I always thought Macdonalds food was the same worldwide but obviously not. What is the difference in the bigmac - just overall bigger bun and patty or richer sauce, more lettuce or what? and why?
Portion sizes are bigger in the USA then the uk that's where the difference will be x
Yes, fair enough but why? does every US citizen have a bigger appetite than citizens in every other country?
Once when I was a kid I asked my dad why portion sizes were so much bigger in the US. He said it's because in the US value for money is very important, more so than in the UK or elsewhere. When you go to a restaurant what costs them money isn't the food itself - it's the chefs, waiters, building, furniture, etc. The actual food costs next to nothing. So to give the illusion of better value for money, they give you more of what costs them nothing - food. So bigger portions become associated with better value for money, so the portions kept getting bigger to compete with other places that looked like they were giving better value for money, until now it's just the norm.0 -
I live in Wales in the UK (I'm English though) and the Welsh people are heavily into 'value for money'. Macdonalds portions are the same as rest of UK though lol0
-
suziecue20 wrote: »I live in Wales in the UK (I'm English though) and the Welsh people are heavily into 'value for money'. Macdonalds portions are the same as rest of UK though lol
Maybe just not as much as the Americans! Haha. Or it just manifested itself in different ways. Or you just get given the same portions as the rest of the UK. Or that isn't the reason at all and my dad was wrong/just saying it to shut me up lol.0 -
Anyway when I have a big mac I can legitimately log it as a 'skinny big mac' lol0
-
mcdonalds as far as im aware is very similar world wide. but the sizes differ. large for me is medium for you for example.
I think some european countries have less sugar in their bread.0 -
Perhaps, we feed our cows more corn in the US than they do in the UK.0
-
I always thought it was down to the each countries food regulation, like the UK/Europe has a lot more legislation over food and what can/can't go in it etc
Although it could just be down to the 'taste' of each country, eg is Americans prefer a sweeter bun it'd have more sugar in it and so more calories, but the UK prefer it more plain. I'm sure that they focus group each menu item to suit each countries preferences. Like in Japan you can get McRice burgers.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
American portion sizes are larger I've found whenever I visit I always share a meal lol0
-
My sister and I have noted regional and national differences both in food and beauty product formulations. Butter in Ontario for instance is brighter yellow than in Western Canada. I suspect it has to do with what the locals consider "normal".0
-
My sister and I have noted regional and national differences both in food and beauty product formulations. Butter in Ontario for instance is brighter yellow than in Western Canada. I suspect it has to do with what the locals consider "normal".0
-
Large mcdonalds fries here are 510 calories, not sure on big macs0
-
Well that makes no sense as cattle are nearly all free range here in Alberta. Maybe there's a little carotene supplementation to the butter back east?0
-
Australian burgers are getting smaller!
0 -
McDonald's tailors their food to suit the country. Sometimes it's obvious, like the meals listed here: foodnetwork.co.uk/article/crazy-meals-mcdonalds-menus-around-world.htmlhttp://
Sometimes it's more subtle, like a burger having mayo in the US and not in the other country. Plus, the food sourcing is different depending on country and the laws for nutritional labels differ, too. You'd need to dig a bit deeper to know exactly where the difference lies in this case.0 -
-
suziecue20 wrote: »I've just been looking at the calories for Macdonalds food and find that a bigmac in UK is 508 cals and in USA 570 cals. The difference is even greater with the fries - UK large portion = 444 cals and USA large portion = 570 cals. I always thought Macdonalds food was the same worldwide but obviously not. What is the difference in the bigmac - just overall bigger bun and patty or richer sauce, more lettuce or what? and why?
Look at the macros for the answer.
Also bear in mind we use different labelling and analytical conventions. Fibre / fiber probably has different calorific values for example, UK carbohydrate doesn't include Fiber, etc.0 -
McDonald's tailors their food to suit the country. Sometimes it's obvious, like the meals listed here: foodnetwork.co.uk/article/crazy-meals-mcdonalds-menus-around-world.htmlhttp://
Sometimes it's more subtle, like a burger having mayo in the US and not in the other country. Plus, the food sourcing is different depending on country and the laws for nutritional labels differ, too. You'd need to dig a bit deeper to know exactly where the difference lies in this case.
I was just talking to my brother about how I would totally try everything on the Indian McD menu. McSpicy Paneer? Veg supreme McMuffin? McAloo Tikki? Yum!0 -
Large Fries - US first, UK 2nd
US Large French Fries - 5.9 oz (168 g), UK 160 grams so pretty similar.
0 -
I'm from the UK but was in NYC last week. My boyfriend had a McDonalds twice. The big mac looks the same but the large fries and drinks are alot bigger! There is a better selection of drinks too lol. I had a grilled chicken sandwich which i've never seen in the UK (but then again I haven't been in a few years!) and wish they would introduce over here.0
-
suziecue20 wrote: »avilancaster871 wrote: »
Yes, fair enough but why? does every US citizen have a bigger appetite than citizens in every other country?
No. I just don't order the bigger sizes.0 -
Bigger portion sizes. That caught me out when I was in the states as asked for a large coffee and regretted the monster I received. I was wired for the whole trip!0
-
Different portion size, different ingredients. I know the values are different between the US and Canada as well. Some higher, some lower. The differences are based in what would be allowed in their products from country to country, the tastes of the culture, and the like. Frankly, I find there is a noticeable taste difference between Canada and the US when I eat at McDonalds.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions