Argh! misleading nutrition labels
Options
Replies
-
It's funny since the old serving sizes are mandated by law for the most part too, based on the amount that's supposedly proper to eat. I get the argument for both, although by bottle for a drink is clearer especially if someone reads it carelessly.0
-
Pop tarts are my nemesis. I even knew when I bought them that a serving is one pop tart and has 200 calories, but who the hell eats one pop tart, and why must they package them in pairs in a non-resealable sleeve?
NSV: I actually had one pop tart with my coffee today. The other is still at home in a ziplock bag.
0 -
I don't understand why everyone throws such a fit over a can of soup being listed at having two servings. Growing up, my family always split a can of soup between at least two people. Sometimes three. I still always split a can with someone else when I eat soup.
That said, we always had something with the soup, like a salad or half sandwich or something. My parents always said that a can of soup had too much sodium for one person, so it was better if you shared it with someone else and ate something less salty with it. Maybe everyone else is just only eating soup, and nothing else? I don't know. This argument just confuses me.
Edit: Same deal with poptarts. Growing up in my famil, you were a pig if you are both poptarts in the foil pack. We always ate one and either gave the other to someone else or put it in a sandwich bag for later.0 -
Strawblackcat wrote: »I still always split a can with someone else when I eat soup.
Am I the only one who just pictured someone hanging out with a friend in the club like "hey girl...wanna split a can of soup?"
0 -
My biggest pet peeve with serving sizes is with cereal. It drives me up the wall that every cereal is basically 3/4 cup serving size. It's a ridiculous expectation.0
-
that's not misleading...they say 2 servings on the label...you just need to learn to read nutritional labels and pay attention.0
-
abetterluke wrote: »My biggest pet peeve with serving sizes is with cereal. It drives me up the wall that every cereal is basically 3/4 cup serving size. It's a ridiculous expectation.
I don't care for cold cereal, but oatmeal is like 44 g dry, and that seems perfect for me. I also find the serving sizes for pasta and rice quite reasonable.
The problem with listing larger sizes because the US has proportion distortion and people eat too much on average (given the total calories consumed on average), is that people who read labels get their idea of what is a normal serving in part from what is listed. That's why the current situation has federal regs governing how big a serving that is listed can be based on what's supposed to be a normal serving.
I don't think it's too hard for people to see how many servings are in a container. I've always checked that when I was bothering to read labels.
I do think it's misleading if a sandwich or cookie is sold as "2 servings," but I haven't seen that and I suspect restaurants aren't permitted to do that. (Pret does sell their dressings in 2 serving packets, which is annoying, but not as annoying as wasting the calories on those dressings to start.)0 -
andrikosDE wrote: »Come on America, join the metric world, you can do it.
I love metric, but it'll take me a while to get used to telling people that 14,651 kJ = 1 pound of fat.
Osric0 -
OsricTheKnight wrote: »andrikosDE wrote: »Come on America, join the metric world, you can do it.
I love metric, but it'll take me a while to get used to telling people that 14,651 kJ = 1 pound of fat.
Osric
0 -
I've been buying a prepared manicotti from Costco. According to the label, there are 7 servings in the package. There are 5 manicotti in the package. I guess I'm supposed to eat 5/7 of a manicotti and serve someone else the stubs.0
-
Strawblackcat wrote: »I don't understand why everyone throws such a fit over a can of soup being listed at having two servings. Growing up, my family always split a can of soup between at least two people. Sometimes three. I still always split a can with someone else when I eat soup.
That said, we always had something with the soup, like a salad or half sandwich or something. My parents always said that a can of soup had too much sodium for one person, so it was better if you shared it with someone else and ate something less salty with it. Maybe everyone else is just only eating soup, and nothing else? I don't know. This argument just confuses me.
Edit: Same deal with poptarts. Growing up in my famil, you were a pig if you are both poptarts in the foil pack. We always ate one and either gave the other to someone else or put it in a sandwich bag for later.
But what did you eat WITH the pop tart?
0 -
sheldonklein wrote: »I've been buying a prepared manicotti from Costco. According to the label, there are 7 servings in the package. There are 5 manicotti in the package. I guess I'm supposed to eat 5/7 of a manicotti and serve someone else the stubs.
0 -
sheldonklein wrote: »I've been buying a prepared manicotti from Costco. According to the label, there are 7 servings in the package. There are 5 manicotti in the package. I guess I'm supposed to eat 5/7 of a manicotti and serve someone else the stubs.
And now all of the "fair division" things I had to learn in math come into play... Ha!
0 -
I don't know what happened to corn since the usda first determined an ear of corn was 90 grams. Any ear of corn I've weighed is at least 2.5-3 times that. Kind of like how bananas are always "large" or larger.... I think an update to the usda definitions/weights would be nice. Who eats just a third of a corn on the cob?0
-
sheldonklein wrote: »I've been buying a prepared manicotti from Costco. According to the label, there are 7 servings in the package. There are 5 manicotti in the package. I guess I'm supposed to eat 5/7 of a manicotti and serve someone else the stubs.
LMAO
0 -
I don't know what happened to corn since the usda first determined an ear of corn was 90 grams. Any ear of corn I've weighed is at least 2.5-3 times that. Kind of like how bananas are always "large" or larger.... I think an update to the usda definitions/weights would be nice. Who eats just a third of a corn on the cob?
Generally, nutrition data refers to the edible portion of the item, I thought. I wonder if that was really meant to be the entire cob, or just the corn on it?
0 -
I made a brownie package once. The listed serving size was 1/88th of a package. Made absolutely no sense to me then, but today I might just look by weight0
-
sheldonklein wrote: »I've been buying a prepared manicotti from Costco. According to the label, there are 7 servings in the package. There are 5 manicotti in the package. I guess I'm supposed to eat 5/7 of a manicotti and serve someone else the stubs.
Feed the stubs to the homeless0 -
Or those Trader Joe's wraps that have 2 servings. Almost bought one until I realized that... ugh.
Or those waffles I love that not only state 8 servings in a package (4 waffles), but when you weigh them, each waffle is close to 3 servings. It's lovely how your 140 calories waffle turns into a 340 calories waffle.
So yeah... that's why I read labels and weigh everything now.0 -
Pandapotato wrote: »andrikosDE wrote: »Come on America, join the metric world, you can do it.
How would metrics change the fact that they are counting an individual sized bottle as two servings?
It would help in the following way:
If all nutrition labels were equalized to 100g (ml for fluids) you can now figure out in your head that:
chips are ~5-5.5 kcal per gram
nuts are 6-7 kcal per gram
lean meats are 1.2-1.4 kcal per gram
cereals are 3.5 kcal per gram
etc
etc
etc
It gives you a very good compass of what to expect rather than trying to bend your brain with all the asinine serving quantities.
What is a serving size?
YOU decide.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 395 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 960 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions