Don't Cheat Yourself.......

i rather agree with you. i count walking and practicing (i play viola) because those are things i do hours and hours a day and i find myself tired and hungry after a good "work out" in those areas, haha. i like to reward myself for being determined and productive. and like, the other day i did 3 hours of community service cleaning and organizing some heavy stuff at a CCA resale store--it was hard work, so i counted it (and the cals burned was over 400 as i recall). but i would hesitate to count anything like cooking, sweeping, "child care--preparing food, etc," showering, brushing your hair, brushing your teeth, blinking, smiling...hahaha.

My gardening is done in place of my "workout" it's far from a daily activity it's above and beyond so I track it. No way I could work, do the garden and fit time in for the gym all in the same day.
I also DO eat my exercise calories, when I have them, because I am keeping my deficit at the level that MFP set for me to have safe sustainable loss, which it gives even if I don't do any exercise at all.

I think it's legit to count those calories if they dramatically increase your activity level from your normal daily routine. If your normal activity level involves only walking from your bedroom to your kitchen to your car, then from your car to your desk, then reversing all that at the end of the day...then yes, I think a day of mopping/dusting/straigtening up should count. If you are normally on your feet all day (like a waiter or a cashier), then your BMR is probably higher already and you shouldn't eat it back, even if you do log it.

And I do think you should eat back your exercise calories...remember the MFP recomended number is already a deficit from how many calories you'd need to eat to keep your weight the same. Too much of a deficit (adding an exercise deficit to the already exisiting deficit) won't help lose wright more quickly, it will just keep your bofy from repairing itself after exercise and you won't be able to exercise as efficiently.

Unless you are standing right there watching the person clean or garden or whatever how do you know how hard they might be working?When I count my cleaning its because im on my hands and knees scrubbing floors base boards ect.moving the couches to vacum ect ect so you dont think that burns calories?Also when I had a garden there was tons of dig,weed pulling lugging around heavy bags of soil.
This topic is once again

I agree, I cleaned my pool today took almost 3 hours of vaccuming,scrubbing walls
in and out to back wash pump, I counted it as 60 minutes of leisurely swimming
burned 398 calories, I think that is a pretty good guess (i only clean the pool 1-2x a year
hubby usually does it). I never count light house work, shopping ect, I will be cleaning out
a room of shelves,boxes ect and carrying them up stairs to another room this evening
so I can move all my excercise equip downstairs I will be counting that as well.

What people log as exercise is necessarily dependent on several things - what their activity level is set at, how frequently they do those activities, the intensity of the activity, and the person's general fitness level.

If someone's activity level is set at sedentary, they will need to log most things - because that activity level does not account for very many calories burned. If it is set at very active, they should not log much in the way of non-purposeful exercise.

If something is a once a month activity, and is reasonably strenuous, it should be logged - because it is something your body is not adapted to and you will burn more calories doing it, than if it were something you did every day.

Obviously, wandering around carrying a feather duster for 5 minutes is not something to log. But a vigorous cleaning may be.

Finally, someone who is fit and weighs 120 lbs will burn much less than a similar person who is not yet fit and weighs 300 lbs. The person who is not fit and heavy, NEEDS to log more things, because the amount of calories they burn doing a simple task (walking for 15 minutes) is much higher and it is much more likely to be a strenuous exercise for them. And many people simply pick something that is similar to the activity they did, because they couldn't find an entry for the exact thing they did. And a lot of people will try to use a very conservative estimate - as in, I cleaned for 4 hours today, my heart rate was certainly in the moderate zone - why would I not log that? But I might say I did 2 or 3 hours, to try to avoid overestimating. But not logging it at all can be just as detrimental as logging something frivolous.

Accuracy is important in logging. But all of the numbers we use are estimates. And sometimes we just have to go with the best number we can get. However, I think one of the important things to remember is that UNDER logging your exercise is just as bad as overlogging it. You should attempt to be just as accurate in your calorie burns as you are with your calorie intake. Not logging something may be "cheating" just as much logging it, depending on the individual circumstances.

ETA: As mentioned, MFP is designed for you to eat exercise cals. It creates a built in deficit, based on your loss per week goal, regardless of exercise. If you don't replace those cals, you make that deficit larger. A larger deficit does not necessarily mean faster/more weight loss - it usually leads to feelings of deprivation, low energy, poor workouts, binges, quitting and weight regain. Might help to read these:

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/186814-some-mfp-basics

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/61706-guide-to-calorie-deficits

I somewhat agree. unless the type or amount of cleaning or gardening is out of the ordinary. everyday clean, weed pulling now. but say cleaning out a garage ( a very cluttered messy one per sea) or like the gardening i did the other . chopping, dragging and stacking big branches off the half of my maple tree that fell during a storm the other day you better believe i counted that.

I think most of the calories burned you named is legit and accurate. Gardening takes a lot of work as does food shopping. I literally walk 45 min if not more food shopping and yes i break a sweat sometimes when there is no air conditioning and i do NOT sit so yes in that instance i count it as calories burned. It's the same as if i were to walk outside for 15 minutes and that IS exercise. Now food prep, etc i would probably not log.. light cleaning if i am bending and walking a lot i would count it. Just my opinion

I count them if they are a good variation from my everyday lifestyle. If it's approximately what I would do in a normal day, I don't count it. But them again I have my calories calculated for almost no exercise. That being said, I definitely count my big grocery shopping trips. I found it to be a workout even before I began logging. Shopping for a family of 6 with 4 growing kids (and a big dog) is no easy feat. Sometimes I do more work to accomplish the shopping (walking the isle, lifting large/heavy items, lifting all items placing them in my cart, pushing that heavy heavy cart, taking all the items out, lifting heavier bags than my weights, putting them back in the cart, taking the bags back out of the cart and into my car, lifting the bags back out of the car and carrying them into the house, and then putting it all away). This can be almost a 3-4 hour workout somedays and that doesn't include if I follow it up with any food prep (cleaning & slicing fruits & veggies, bagging up snack sized portions, etc).

I do understand what you are saying but we have to realize that it is hard to judge the exercise logged without really having witnessed it. So some are reasonable logging and admittedly some are not.

I’ve seen some light cleaning entries blow away my weight training and cardio workout. Seriously???

I think your frustration with this lies with people who clean every week as a normal function something they have done since day one and they are calling it exercise even though their body is used to the pattern and considers it normal function. However the comment above .....

high burns ... one day i cleaned my house from top to bottom and burned about 2k cals in less than 2 hours but then i mopped scubbed moved furniture and ran around my house until i felt like i was gonna pass out. i have an HRM which separates me from those who use the presorted defaults in the database. but i logged it as cleaning. so sometimes the workouts are blanket statements and the burns are more important.

besides you're not doin it right? so to each their own.