Former chubber - dropped 8 stone. Bulk or cut? Help!
Ben2055
Posts: 96 Member
Hi, so 2 years ago i used to weigh 20st ( 127kg ) i now weigh 12st (76 kg) i done this by mixing cardio eating at a deficit. Last 6 months ive been lifting more.
My PT at my gym advised me to clean bulk for 3 months untill end of feburary and then cut again for the summer.
Here are my stats:
Weight .. 76kg
Height .. 5ft 10
Body fat: See picture, got it tested by PT
http://imgur.com/z5B83rA
Pictures:
http://imgur.com/a/ClhuH
Should i bulk or keep cutting?
My PT at my gym advised me to clean bulk for 3 months untill end of feburary and then cut again for the summer.
Here are my stats:
Weight .. 76kg
Height .. 5ft 10
Body fat: See picture, got it tested by PT
http://imgur.com/z5B83rA
Pictures:
http://imgur.com/a/ClhuH
Should i bulk or keep cutting?
0
Replies
-
The other option is find your maintenance calories and recomp - lose fat and gain muscle at the same time. At age 21 and with what sounds like limited history of lifting you are primed to gain muscle pretty easily.
What are your ultimate goals?
Can't see your pictures at work - what is your BF% estimate?0 -
The other option is find your maintenance calories and recomp - lose fat and gain muscle at the same time. At age 21 and with what sounds like limited history of lifting you are primed to gain muscle pretty easily.
What are your ultimate goals?
Can't see your pictures at work - what is your BF% estimate?
Hi mate thanks for the repy do neither links work?0 -
-
Links should work now. First is few pictures this morning. Second is a body fat test from a pt0
-
the links work he just cant see them at his work.
i agree with his advice and monitor your results0 -
Im more inclined to either bulk or cut
what wouldnyou say woukd be the next step going forward? Im going for an aesthrtic type body. In the long run haha 0 -
Im more inclined to either bulk or cut what wouldnyou say woukd be the next step going forward? Im going for an aesthrtic type body. In the long run haha
My work firewall blocks your links.
Well worth a read.....
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10049766/bulking-a-complete-guide-for-beginners/p10 -
Hi, so 2 years ago i used to weigh 20st ( 127kg ) i now weigh 12st (76 kg) i done this by mixing cardio eating at a deficit. Last 6 months ive been lifting more.
My PT at my gym advised me to clean bulk for 3 months untill end of feburary and then cut again for the summer.
Here are my stats:
Weight .. 76kg
Height .. 5ft 10
Body fat: See picture, got it tested by PT
Pictures:
Should i bulk or keep cutting?
0 -
Looks like your links are either blocked or broken.
That said, I agree with your PT. Bulk for a few months and then cut. You will look awesome by the time next summer comes around if that is your thing...0 -
not sure I agree with the 6% calculation your PT did, but based on your pictures I would put you at sub around 10% or lower body fat.
Yes, you can run a bulk and would benefit from it.
I would suggest a surplus of 250 calories and get on a structured lifting program.
what does your PT mean by "clean bulk"…?0 -
not sure I agree with the 6% calculation your PT did, but based on your pictures I would put you at sub around 10% or lower body fat.
Yes, you can run a bulk and would benefit from it.
I would suggest a surplus of 250 calories and get on a structured lifting program.
what does your PT mean by "clean bulk"…?
Hey mate! Yeh i was unsure about that number as i thiught i wiuld be shredded at 6% but he does it for competitive bodybuilders so i guess hes reliable.
I need more mass dont i? Then when i cut back id be in better shape? Umm i beleive he means eating at a surplus but eating clean foods. So defintely bulk correct?0 -
I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?0 -
arditarose wrote: »I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?
Well...i have but its been pretty poor. Over last 2 months ive implemebted a structured program off arms chest shoulders and back and abs. With an hiur cardio each day.
So when i say lifted; i havent had a well structed lifting program0 -
arditarose wrote: »I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?
Well...i have but its been pretty poor. Over last 2 months ive implemebted a structured program off arms chest shoulders and back and abs. With an hiur cardio each day.
So when i say lifted; i havent had a well structed lifting program
Okay. First things first then. Get on a well structured lifting program and at least out of a deficit.
0 -
arditarose wrote: »arditarose wrote: »I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?
Well...i have but its been pretty poor. Over last 2 months ive implemebted a structured program off arms chest shoulders and back and abs. With an hiur cardio each day.
So when i say lifted; i havent had a well structed lifting program
Okay. First things first then. Get on a well structured lifting program and at least out of a deficit.
Okay! So i definetely am not too fat stilll tht i need to cut correct?0 -
arditarose wrote: »arditarose wrote: »I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?
Well...i have but its been pretty poor. Over last 2 months ive implemebted a structured program off arms chest shoulders and back and abs. With an hiur cardio each day.
So when i say lifted; i havent had a well structed lifting program
Okay. First things first then. Get on a well structured lifting program and at least out of a deficit.
Okay! So i definetely am not too fat stilll tht i need to cut correct?
If I were you, I would not keep cutting. No. Great work.0 -
arditarose wrote: »arditarose wrote: »I think your choices she be bulk or maintain (recomp), not bulk or cut. You've done great work and you could benefit from at least a deficit break.
You said you've been lifting for 7 months? What is your program like?
Well...i have but its been pretty poor. Over last 2 months ive implemebted a structured program off arms chest shoulders and back and abs. With an hiur cardio each day.
So when i say lifted; i havent had a well structed lifting program
Okay. First things first then. Get on a well structured lifting program and at least out of a deficit.
Okay! So i definetely am not too fat stilll tht i need to cut correct?
It is likely that you will gain some fat along with muscle during your bulk. This will be mostly governed by your genetics but the size of your surplus can also have a big impact.
Therefore to achieve your desired physique it is usual for for a short-ish cut after the bulk is completed.0 -
Ok ill do a 3 month bulk then cut after and carry on the process ubtill i acheieve my desired physique:)0
-
I would put you at around 11-12%. I would think you could do a successful recomp or a bulk. Whichever you prefer. With newb gains, I would probably suggest a recomp for a few months, but mainly cause it would be my preference. No other real reason.0
-
Ok guys thankyou for all your help and input! Im gonna start a clean bulk for 3 months and a structured lifting program with my PT then cut again for may/june!0
-
not sure I agree with the 6% calculation your PT did, but based on your pictures I would put you at sub around 10% or lower body fat.
Yes, you can run a bulk and would benefit from it.
I would suggest a surplus of 250 calories and get on a structured lifting program.
what does your PT mean by "clean bulk"…?
Hey mate! Yeh i was unsure about that number as i thiught i wiuld be shredded at 6% but he does it for competitive bodybuilders so i guess hes reliable.
I need more mass dont i? Then when i cut back id be in better shape? Umm I believe he means eating at a surplus but eating clean foods. So defintely bulk correct?
FYI clean bulk has nothing to do with eating clean. It just means eating in a small - 250 per day surplus - so that you minimize fat gains.
yes, I would say that you would benefit from a bulk. I would look into a structured program like strong lifts, all pro beginner routine, or something like PHUL or Wendlers if you are more intermediate lifter.0 -
-
Brilliant! Okay mate ill do that. Thankyou!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions