We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Should you eat gluten?!?!?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5829e/5829e526efb344ff7ae758ddc1651e6a2c2c5137" alt="gillexplores"
gillexplores
Posts: 151 Member
I wrote this a bit ago and thought I would share here if anyone was curious or struggling with this.
I have Coeliac Disease, and was diagnosed when I was 7, 13 years ago. My mother is also a Coeliac and it runs on her side of the family.
In the past 13 years (past 5 or so specifically), I have seen a huge improvement in the array of gluten-free foods available, mostly because the gluten-free diet has become so popular among people trying to lose weight. Great for me, but I want to clear some stuff up.
COELIAC (CELIAC) DISEASE
Coeliac Disease is an auto-immune disease affecting an estimated 1% (1 in 133) of North Americans. In patients with Coeliac Disease, gluten (the proteins found in wheat, barley and rye) damage the villi of the small intestine, causing the inability of the body to absorb the proper nutrients. Common symptoms are anemia, chronic diarrhea, constipation, cramps and bloating, weight loss fatigue, irritability, dermatitis. Personally, if I eat enough gluten, I vomit. If one has been eating gluten regularly, a blood test can be used to diagnose Coeliac Disease. However, it is not 100% accurate. Alternately, a bowel biopsy can be used.
After diagnosis and removal of gluten from the diet, the villi in the intestines can repair themselves and the body can once again begin to properly absorb nutrients.
For more info:
www.celiac.ca/?page_id=882
www.livescience.com/39726-what-is-gluten.html
NON-CELIAC GLUTEN SENSITIVITY (NCGS)
This one is a highly debated topic. Of the many people that claim to have issues with gluten, an estimated 0.6-6% of Americans "suffer from NCGS." These people have not tested positive for Coeliac Disease, but report many of the symptoms common of Coeliac Disease, such as bloating, nausea, diarrhea, and fatigue, among others.
Many people are quick to disregard NCGSm which is why many experts have taken an interest. A study published in February 2015 "tracked 59 [Italian] participants through a placebo phase, when each received a small amount of rice protein every day, and a study phase, when each received gluten. Three patients exhibited more symptoms during the gluten phase." ( www.healthline.com/health-news/is-non-celiac-gluten-sensitivity-a-real-thing-041615#2 ) This suggests that a very minuscule number of people are sensitive to gluten without being Coeliac. So, other possibilities for reported sensitivity to gluten? They could be allergic to wheat or in the early stages of developing Coeliac Disease. Alternately, they may be sensitive to fermentable oligo-, di-, and monosaccharides and polyols (FODMAPS), which are a group of small carbohydrates. These can be found in many legumes, grains, vegetables, fruits, sweeteners and milk products. "They draw fluid into the bowel and bacteria ferment the FODMAP molecules to produce hydrogen and methane gases." ( www.cdhf.ca/bank/document_en/32-fodmaps.pdf )
One other possible reason for an assumed intolerance to gluten is simply a placebo affect. Food is a powerful thing, and the ideas and views that people have of different foods greatly affects their reaction to it. Simply believing that gluten is bad for you might make it so.
In conclusion, should you eat gluten? Honestly, it's up to you. I'm not going to tell you to eat gluten or not (unless you are a Coeliac. In that case, avoid it!! I promise you will feel so, so much better). If you really want to know, try eliminating it from your diet for a month. If you feel significantly better, maybe try to eliminate it or at least limit your gluten intake. Alternately, if you are thinking of going on a gluten-free "diet" simply to lose weight, that alone will not work. Us Coeliacs still have plenty of gluten free ice cream, cookies, candies and burgers that we can eat. It is a conscious choice to eat healthy, nutritious foods that will ultimately lead you to lose weight and be healthy.
Hopefully this helped some of you. Happy healthy eating!
I have Coeliac Disease, and was diagnosed when I was 7, 13 years ago. My mother is also a Coeliac and it runs on her side of the family.
In the past 13 years (past 5 or so specifically), I have seen a huge improvement in the array of gluten-free foods available, mostly because the gluten-free diet has become so popular among people trying to lose weight. Great for me, but I want to clear some stuff up.
COELIAC (CELIAC) DISEASE
Coeliac Disease is an auto-immune disease affecting an estimated 1% (1 in 133) of North Americans. In patients with Coeliac Disease, gluten (the proteins found in wheat, barley and rye) damage the villi of the small intestine, causing the inability of the body to absorb the proper nutrients. Common symptoms are anemia, chronic diarrhea, constipation, cramps and bloating, weight loss fatigue, irritability, dermatitis. Personally, if I eat enough gluten, I vomit. If one has been eating gluten regularly, a blood test can be used to diagnose Coeliac Disease. However, it is not 100% accurate. Alternately, a bowel biopsy can be used.
After diagnosis and removal of gluten from the diet, the villi in the intestines can repair themselves and the body can once again begin to properly absorb nutrients.
For more info:
www.celiac.ca/?page_id=882
www.livescience.com/39726-what-is-gluten.html
NON-CELIAC GLUTEN SENSITIVITY (NCGS)
This one is a highly debated topic. Of the many people that claim to have issues with gluten, an estimated 0.6-6% of Americans "suffer from NCGS." These people have not tested positive for Coeliac Disease, but report many of the symptoms common of Coeliac Disease, such as bloating, nausea, diarrhea, and fatigue, among others.
Many people are quick to disregard NCGSm which is why many experts have taken an interest. A study published in February 2015 "tracked 59 [Italian] participants through a placebo phase, when each received a small amount of rice protein every day, and a study phase, when each received gluten. Three patients exhibited more symptoms during the gluten phase." ( www.healthline.com/health-news/is-non-celiac-gluten-sensitivity-a-real-thing-041615#2 ) This suggests that a very minuscule number of people are sensitive to gluten without being Coeliac. So, other possibilities for reported sensitivity to gluten? They could be allergic to wheat or in the early stages of developing Coeliac Disease. Alternately, they may be sensitive to fermentable oligo-, di-, and monosaccharides and polyols (FODMAPS), which are a group of small carbohydrates. These can be found in many legumes, grains, vegetables, fruits, sweeteners and milk products. "They draw fluid into the bowel and bacteria ferment the FODMAP molecules to produce hydrogen and methane gases." ( www.cdhf.ca/bank/document_en/32-fodmaps.pdf )
One other possible reason for an assumed intolerance to gluten is simply a placebo affect. Food is a powerful thing, and the ideas and views that people have of different foods greatly affects their reaction to it. Simply believing that gluten is bad for you might make it so.
In conclusion, should you eat gluten? Honestly, it's up to you. I'm not going to tell you to eat gluten or not (unless you are a Coeliac. In that case, avoid it!! I promise you will feel so, so much better). If you really want to know, try eliminating it from your diet for a month. If you feel significantly better, maybe try to eliminate it or at least limit your gluten intake. Alternately, if you are thinking of going on a gluten-free "diet" simply to lose weight, that alone will not work. Us Coeliacs still have plenty of gluten free ice cream, cookies, candies and burgers that we can eat. It is a conscious choice to eat healthy, nutritious foods that will ultimately lead you to lose weight and be healthy.
Hopefully this helped some of you. Happy healthy eating!
0
Replies
-
Very well said.0
-
What she said!0
-
I have no way of knowing if people without celiac disease who claim to be sensitive to gluten actually are or if it something else in the diet. Most people I know on FB post any and every study that shows it does not exist in non-celiacs. I think it possible that people have a range of sensitivities, but that a lot of people are on a fad bandwagon too.
When I went low carb a few years back, I stopped having acid reflux within a week. I went from always having Tums in my purse to never using it again just like that. People in the gluten/gliadin camp would say my dumping bread and pasta did it. But I also stopped sweets and soda...and sugar reduction has been associated with reducing acid reflux as well.
If people stop eating multiple things at the same time, pinning down the correlation is messy.
I know if I have bread or part of a candy or cake, I feel fine afterwards. I would have to eat it regularly again to get any problems.0 -
I agree with your points - however I would not recommend (to others) cutting out gluten unless you have diagnosed celiac disease. I've done a bit of research on this and if you do cut out gluten you can develop a sensitivity to it later on. Also many gluten free products are less healthy than their gluten free counterparts, so unless you have medical need for it, just continue to eat what makes you feel good.0
-
I don't think you should cut out gluten unless you have problems with it or if you just plain don't like things with gluten in them. I find gluten makes me feel ill, as well as dairy so I just don't eat them and it works out fine for me. No one really needs things like bread or cookies and cakes even if they are delicious0
-
kaylasaurus wrote: »I agree with your points - however I would not recommend (to others) cutting out gluten unless you have diagnosed celiac disease. I've done a bit of research on this and if you do cut out gluten you can develop a sensitivity to it later on. Also many gluten free products are less healthy than their gluten free counterparts, so unless you have medical need for it, just continue to eat what makes you feel good.
Interesting point! I hadn't heard that. And yes, I agree, I don't recommend it by any means. If they want to because it makes them feel better, go for it, but you're definitely right, a lot of the gluten free products are very processed and have a lot of added sugar to improve the taste.0 -
I have Celiacs disease so no Gluten for me. However, I think anyone should avoid Gluten unless they have a medical reason to do so.0
-
Seitan, pure gluten protein. A helpful choice for vegans.
0 -
My favourite product on the gluten-free shelves. 160 calories for four wafers.
0 -
Pollywog_la wrote: »If people stop eating multiple things at the same time, pinning down the correlation is messy.
It's also particularly messy because of two other factors:
1. Regression towards the mean. If you have a range of symptoms from mild to severe, you are most likely to start trying a new "treatment" when you're at the very most severe end, because the suffering motivates you to try a change. This often "works", not because the treatment did anything, but because when you are far above average in symptoms, you're likely to experience relief soon anyway because over time you tend to fluctuate around the average. And the human brain is a great post hoc fallacy machine - we naturally perceive a temporal sequence of events as a causal sequence of events even when it isn't.
2. The placebo effect. It's very powerful - how much benefit you get from a particular intervention is very much related to how much benefit you expect to get. Some of this is likely a confirmation bias - you better remember the data points that agree with your expectations and forget those that disagree.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.4K Getting Started
- 260.4K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 440 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.2K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions