Meal replacment shakes?
jaorti95
Posts: 65 Member
Does anyone know by expirence a really good meal replacment shake? I wanna give it a try, I've heard good things about it but don't know what to take.
0
Replies
-
I prefer to chew my food and always found meal replacement shakes left me hungry afterwards.0
-
On the days I work I pack a Quest shake. Full of protein. Better than eating breakroom snacks!0
-
I've always enjoyed the vanilla vegan Orgain shakes. They're like dessert. I keep them on hand for when I don't have time to eat. They're a life saver.0
-
i get mine through the gym. It's a chocolate whey protein. I make it with 8 oz. of fat-free milk, 2 tablespoons of powdered peanut butter and ice -- then zip it in my blender. What a wonderfully nutritious morning treat -- and it easily holds me over until lunch.0
-
Asher_Ethan wrote: »I prefer to chew my food and always found meal replacement shakes left me hungry afterwards.
This. Satiety factor is low0 -
I have a nutribullet to make smoothies. Spinach or kale with some nuts, seeds and whatever fruit you like topped up with almond milk or coconut water. Really filling and super healthy0
-
Thank you everyone !0
-
I use a shake similar to Soylent, they're called Super Body Fuel. I know a lot of people would never 'give up' 'real food' for shakes. But the shakes are meant to give you a full day's nutrients, and as someone that would otherwise eat a lot of fast food, I feel like it gives me greater control over my calories. I do plan to consume them long term. They are probably more expensive than homecooked meals, but cheaper than fast food and cheaper than medifast. If you don't think you want to consume meal replacement drinks long term I don't think it's a good crutch for weight loss. But you might have other reasons you'd be okay with consuming them long term. For me it gives me a handle on calories I otherwise don't have. If I was capable of making home cooked meals and turning down fast food, I wouldn't be overweight (or AS overweight anyways).0
-
I usually only use shakes when I don't feel well and know that I just need calories.
My personal favorite is Raw Meal from Garden of Life. They redid the formula this past summer to increase the protein content, lower the fat content, and make it a little thinner in consistency. I think it tastes pretty good! It's also all sourced from raw fruits and veggies, which makes it really good for you. Orgain shakes, like someone else mentioned above, are also really good. They're expensive, though, since they come pre-mixed.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
0 -
You've got to be careful they don't have more calories than an actual, filling meal.0
-
blues4miles wrote: »I use a shake similar to Soylent, they're called Super Body Fuel. I know a lot of people would never 'give up' 'real food' for shakes. But the shakes are meant to give you a full day's nutrients, and as someone that would otherwise eat a lot of fast food, I feel like it gives me greater control over my calories. I do plan to consume them long term. They are probably more expensive than homecooked meals, but cheaper than fast food and cheaper than medifast. If you don't think you want to consume meal replacement drinks long term I don't think it's a good crutch for weight loss. But you might have other reasons you'd be okay with consuming them long term. For me it gives me a handle on calories I otherwise don't have. If I was capable of making home cooked meals and turning down fast food, I wouldn't be overweight (or AS overweight anyways).
I can relate to you. Have you used a product called total soy?
0 -
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
But it does help weight loss? That's my main forces for now then I wanna tone. I first just wanna see what helps in the beginning for me you know?0 -
The fundamental issues with meal replacement shakes as I see it are
Short term fix for long term issues
Overpriced for what they are
Satiety factor
No learning curve for long term maintenance
Play with water weight rather than fat
Basically are low cal, low carb glop with additives
Many are sold in MLM schemes (spits)
Yes I've tried them before, yes I convinced myself they were tasty, yes they work for the weeks you use them, yes weight just springs back and you are in a worse position than when you first tried it0 -
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
But it does help weight loss? That's my main forces for now then I wanna tone. I first just wanna see what helps in the beginning for me you know?
Eating at a calorie defecit helps weight loss
These are low calorie so the answer is yes...but not long term
You don't separate progressive resistance exercise from weight loss...you do them together otherwise you lose more muscle than you need to
(Also you may wish to avoid using the word tone because you can't tone muscles...what marketing literature calls tone is adequate musculature, from progressive resistance, and low body fat from calorie control. Muscles don't tone they just get bigger or smaller)0 -
Meal replacement shakes don't "tone" ( hate that word anyways). Fat loss and progressive overload lifting does.0
-
Optimum Nutrition 100% Whey Gold Standard or Almased.
Prefer Almased at this point because I can't deal with fake sweetener and I find Almased more satiating. Best blended up with ice and almond milk in a powerful blender.
You might also try Quest protein bars. You can just throw one in your purse. Drink a lot of water with it.
I wouldn't commit to a large amount of anything at first.0 -
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
But it does help weight loss? That's my main forces for now then I wanna tone. I first just wanna see what helps in the beginning for me you know?
At the end of the day, calories is what it comes down to for weight loss. If drinking a meal replacement shake helps you keep your calories in check, you will lose weight. It's no different than anything else. Drinking it in addition to a full day's worth of calories and you won't lose weight. There's nothing special about most shakes. Some have a lot of protein that can help with feeling full and maintaining muscle mass as you are losing weight. But it always comes down to calories in / calories out.0 -
I use something similar to Soylent as well, Space Nutrients. I just use it to supplement when I don't feel like making something and to keep me from eating out so much. Although I do go some days where that is all I eat. It is pretty decent. It works for me because I hate cooking, don't mind drinking my food, and it is super easy. I eat it for the convenience, not weight-loss.0
-
I have a nutribullet to make smoothies. Spinach or kale with some nuts, seeds and whatever fruit you like topped up with almond milk or coconut water. Really filling and super healthy
I make smoothies as well. Protein powder, some sort of fat, veggies and/or fruit, various liquid.0 -
Does anyone know by expirence a really good meal replacment shake? I wanna give it a try, I've heard good things about it but don't know what to take.
Ask yourself why you'd want to do this, given the variety of food options out there that are tasty, high in nutrients and digestible fibre.
Meal replacements don't aid weight loss no more than eating 2 macdonalds a day would. Calories in vs calories out, I could lose weight literally eating junk food if I want, as long as I stay under my calorie goal.
Work on eating proper food and exercise/strength training.0 -
I mix and match protein bars and meal replacement shakes quite a lot. But it's not because I can't/won't make something. It's because I'm not usually hungry in the morning, but I do my best to put some calories in to help jump start the day. I also find it is convenient when I need calories but don't want to fill up.
Protein shakes are also good but I use those more as a protein boost than a meal.
Just log them accurately and move on with your day. I don't consider it something that will prevent me from keeping weight off later because I will always use them in some fashion in my lifestyle.
I think the consensus on here is "do whatever is right for you, as long as it's not dangerous or unhealthy".0 -
I have tried many, my favorite tasting plant based is from Arbonne chocolate protein shake 0
-
The fundamental issues with meal replacement shakes as I see it are
Short term fix for long term issues
Overpriced for what they are
Satiety factor
No learning curve for long term maintenance
Play with water weight rather than fat
Basically are low cal, low carb glop with additives
Many are sold in MLM schemes (spits)
Yes I've tried them before, yes I convinced myself they were tasty, yes they work for the weeks you use them, yes weight just springs back and you are in a worse position than when you first tried it
So you didn't lose much weight?0 -
Optimum Nutrition 100% Whey Gold Standard or Almased.
Prefer Almased at this point because I can't deal with fake sweetener and I find Almased more satiating. Best blended up with ice and almond milk in a powerful blender.
You might also try Quest protein bars. You can just throw one in your purse. Drink a lot of water with it.
I wouldn't commit to a large amount of anything at first.
Thank you!!0 -
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
Um, say what now?0 -
LEAN BODY FOR HER CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA ICE CREAM. It is so good. I swear by this stuff. Tones me, keeps my muscle and slays the fat on my body. I LOVE it. You can order online. I like to mix mine with almond/soy or reg milk in a blender with crushed ice and peanut butter. You can throw spinach in it or vitamin capsules and you will never taste it. SO YUMMY. Please Do yourself the favor and get it
If this is true, why does anyone exercise?!? This sounds much easier than hitting the weight room.
Hint: If it sounds too good to be true...it is.
0 -
The fundamental issues with meal replacement shakes as I see it are
Short term fix for long term issues
Overpriced for what they are
Satiety factor
No learning curve for long term maintenance
Play with water weight rather than fat
Basically are low cal, low carb glop with additives
Many are sold in MLM schemes (spits)
Yes I've tried them before, yes I convinced myself they were tasty, yes they work for the weeks you use them, yes weight just springs back and you are in a worse position than when you first tried it
So you didn't lose much weight?
Not sure if joking
I think at the time I probably lost about 5-10lbs ...but within a month of stopping it went back on plus some..it was a prime yo-yo phase with no learning curve
In 9 months calorie counting I lost 48lbs and have been maintaining at 53-55lbs below my staring weight for the last 10 months0 -
I've been drinking Premier Protein and it is pretty tasty! They were bought at Sam's Club.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions