What Foods Keep You Full The Longest?
Replies
-
amusedmonkey wrote: »To answer the Op in a different way...
There are foods that make you "hungry" vs foods that don't.
By default foods that lead to Slow Energy Release (proteins, grains and beans) will stop you becoming hungry as quickly, as they don't lead to a spike of insulin and (ultimately) fat storage. My go to foods for this are Buckwheat, Amaranth, Oats, Quinoa, Nuts and Beans.
In contrast, any food that causes an instant spike in energy (i.e sugar) in normal people, causes a spike in insulin production. This tells your body to burn what it can then work to store the rest as fat.
So 100 calories of slow energy release food is far better for you than 100 calories of sugar. One helps your diet, the other doesn't.
Interestingly, artificial sweetener has another detrimental effect. When you drink or eat something with a sweet "taste", your body sends a message to the pancreas to tell it to produce a pile of insulin in anticipation of receiving sugar soon. When no sugar arrives (because it was sweetener) the body panics a bit when the extra insulin makes your blood sugar drop. The body will often then start sending urgent signals to say "for the love of god eat something!!!".
All this to say, artificial sweetener (if taken excessively) can make you hungry as all hell. So watch the amount of diet soda you drink if you want to feel "full" longer
It really isn't that dry and cut. Hunger depends on a lot of factors, including psychological. That's why the feeling of "fullness" is so individual. For me, for example, a sugar free soda does not produce any hunger, but chicken without starches does, and the fast release starchy potato keeps me full for several hours. And then there is this insulin misconception... If you are eating at a deficit you will not be storing fat, no matter how much your insulin spikes. And then there is also the texture, mouthfeel, and stomach feel. Rice is more filling to me than quinoa despite being a fast release carb, and cooked oatmeal is more filling to me than baked despite being the same grain.
Here is an anecdote from not long ago that shows how big of a role psychology plays. The other day we had a grill party. I forgot to stock on my favorite bread, and the bread that was available was the kind that I don't like. 1100 calories of kebab and stubbornness later I regretted not taking that 15 minute walk to buy my choice of bread. I had to throw a potato in the smoldering charcoal and wait for nearly an hour to eat it, by which point I was still hungry, until I had the potato. A meal like that usually takes me from hungry to full in no more than 600 calories and keeps me full for hours when I have bread with it, but because it felt "incomplete" without the bread it did not satisfy me physically or emotionally.
What keeps you full and what doesn't is very individual. That's why experimenting with different foods and forming your own personalized "feel full" list is very important.
According to the show there are a lot of misconceptions that are (so they tried to prove) responsible for the erm... widening of society in the last few decades. It focuses on USA mostly, but I expect that's because it was an American funded documentary.
Though I'm not from the US, I found it really interesting anyway and informative from a "understanding the basics" stand point. I'm not sure if it's still available to watch but it was called Food Matters on Netflix.
0 -
Thanks everyone for the great ideas! I have tried many of these already. I am going to try Egg drop soup, Whole Wheat tortillas and Buckwheat.
Here is to feeling full for a while!0 -
Lentil soup. Plus very low calorie! I'm full on around 50 calories worth of lentils, plus 30 calories from a chicken stock cube and water and blend0
-
A meal at least one hot element often satisfies my hunger and keeps me feeling full longer than a cold meal, even when the cals and macros are the same.0
-
I find that nuts keep me the fullest. I'm addicted to cashews.0
-
PIZZA. Haha jk.0
-
I wish.. eggs NEVER make me fullPhoebeJeebies wrote: »Eggs!
0 -
unfortunately my answer to this is a big bowl of Pasta.. urgh0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Turkey chili has been my go-to lunch for a while. I make big batches, weigh 10 oz and freeze it. I will have some oyster crackers but that's about it. I am full for hours.0
-
Whole-milk yogurt! I eat it a lot as it helps me stay full between lunch and dinner.0
-
MIXED NUTS0
-
Egg salad0
-
Chicken
Spinach and eggs
Tuna
Salmon
Popcorn
0 -
eggs! gosh, I love eggs.0
-
Gotta go with oats0
-
Chicken breast and shrimp/prawns together, with a microwaved russet potato and microwaved veggies can hold me over for about 4-5 hours.
I'm surprised to see so many people listing eggs on this thread. For me, eggs don't hit the spot if I eat them without a grain/bread and veggies.
I'd rather just have the chicken and shrimp with a grain/bread and veggies. More volume and more protein than 2 eggs.0 -
I feel it is having either vegetables or salad with my main meal. I feel completely full and do not need or want anything all evening0
-
Cooked broccoli and protein (any source).
Also, pizza lol. On the weekends I'll have a few pieces and they'll stay with me a while (fullness wise).0 -
Roasted chicken thighs. I started buying thighs because they're so cheap. One for lunch keeps me full longer than anything. They're higher calorie than other proteins, but they're so rich and fatty that I feel satisfied for a long time.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions