We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Bmi and how you choose your goal weight!

13»

Replies

  • GrandadMike2014
    GrandadMike2014 Posts: 13 Member
    I chose my new goal weigh based upon BMI and when I get there I am going to do what all the trainers down our gym do.....Ignore it and pile on the muscle so that I end up Obese !!!
  • Smallc10
    Smallc10 Posts: 649 Member
    I chose mine based on where I have been before, but as I've been weight lifting and seeing my body changing with that... I'm not as concerned with getting to my 'goal' weight as I am with getting to my goal size! (6)
  • queenjaquita
    queenjaquita Posts: 7 Member
    I have a goal and then a dream. :) I'm 5'4 and I decided on 135 lbs because that was what I weighed when I got married and I think I looked good at that weight and was able to maintain that weight for several years. I then have my dream of 122 which I was when I was in my early 20's when "I didn't have to worry about my weight" and is in the middle of my BMI healthy range. I have set up mini-goals with non-food rewards (new make-up case, jewelry, new shoes) in order to keep myself motivated and on track.
  • Chellellelle
    Chellellelle Posts: 595 Member
    edited January 2016
    I chose mine based off the higher range of BMI for my height, my frame/build size and what I have weighed before. I'm 5'8" with a large build.

    BMI says a healthy weight range for me is 122 to 164 pounds. If I weighed 122 pounds I would look like a skeleton because of my build. I'm very tall and broad.

    When I weighed 185 pounds I was very lean, muscular and looked great.

    I could have lost a little more body fat, but probably not a lot so I would put myself at probably 170 for an Ultimate goal weight.
  • DoNotSpamMe73
    DoNotSpamMe73 Posts: 286 Member
    Well I'm 5ft 7 (170cm) so my goal weight is 60kilos(132lb). Officially my BMI is 53-72kg(116-158lb) but I think of it as 57kg or above. BMI isn't definite with no scientific basis from the 30's but is a good start. I'd aim for anywhere in the lower middle especially if you are muscular, exercise often &/or busty.
    The middle or lower end is great because it is flexible eating/exercise habits reduce stress. For a lot of heights I'd go for about 65 kilograms and work from there.
  • Danimri84
    Danimri84 Posts: 262 Member
    I chose mine pretty much as a shot in the dark. I started at 249 three years ago and got down to 178. Then gained pretty much all of it back. I'm still shooting for 165. I'm 5'7", have a large build, and I'm incredibly busty. When I got down to my lowest before, I was wearing a size 13 junior in pants and jeans and L/XL shirts and was pretty close to happy.
  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    I picked a number, found out it was 6 pounds above healthy BMI, so I dropped it 15. Then I dropped it another 10, so now it's almost right in the middle.
  • kportwood85
    kportwood85 Posts: 151 Member
    My goal right now is 150. Which is still 5 pounds in to overweight. In high school I weighed about 125-130 and you could see all my bones. I think I'll stick with 150 until I get there, and then re-evaluate. I'm not stuck on that number. Just a first big goal.
  • brigitukas00
    brigitukas00 Posts: 12 Member
    As I been all shapes and sizes , size UK 4,6,10,12 ...I chose ideal body calculator less 9 kg from Bmi highest range ( healthy highest range )
  • motterotter
    motterotter Posts: 701 Member
    I chose 10 percent off my current bw because 20 percent does not sound doable right now
  • bbeaukay
    bbeaukay Posts: 15 Member
    I was 130 when I was in the military, I wasn't super skinny, but had curve where it counted. :) I am 164 ish now and know that's what I want to get back to. I have tried half hearted for years.. I'm tired of looking at my body knowing what I had and can have again.
  • Kristin2626
    Kristin2626 Posts: 24 Member
    BMI doesn't work for me, at least I do not think so. The top for a 5'8" woman is 165-ish and I have tried to weigh 155, but was told I was way too thin and was always wiped, no energy, etc. 165, it's hard to say, because I was so used to being inactive when I weighed that last -- I felt ill in the 140s and 150s so I gained until I felt a little better. I have felt the healthiest at the 180-190 range, which is obese. I am really not sure what is "right" but focusing on BMI just makes me feel terrible, both physically and self-image-wise.

    So I bought calipers for $8 on Amazon and I am going off my body fat %! Striving for 20% and for a weigh goal, I am only trying to reach 175 (overweight, not obese, according to BMI).
  • ObsidianMist
    ObsidianMist Posts: 519 Member
    my goal weight is the weight I was at for years before suddenly gaining 30 pounds.
  • tomteboda
    tomteboda Posts: 2,171 Member
    Kristin2626 wrote: »
    BMI doesn't work for me, at least I do not think so. The top for a 5'8" woman is 165-ish and I have tried to weigh 155, but was told I was way too thin and was always wiped, no energy, etc. 165, it's hard to say, because I was so used to being inactive when I weighed that last -- I felt ill in the 140s and 150s so I gained until I felt a little better. I have felt the healthiest at the 180-190 range, which is obese. I am really not sure what is "right" but focusing on BMI just makes me feel terrible, both physically and self-image-wise.

    So I bought calipers for $8 on Amazon and I am going off my body fat %! Striving for 20% and for a weigh goal, I am only trying to reach 175 (overweight, not obese, according to BMI).

    At 5'8" the cutoffs are:

    OBESE: 197+
    OVERWEIGHT: 165 - 198
    NORMAL: 122-164

    So you are not obese between 180-190. More importantly, the BMI has a linear error on height. The taller you are, the more inaccurate it is. @Shammah71 linked a great tool, a BMI calculator that takes into account the fact that volume and mass do not have a 1:1 relationship. On that tool, at 180 you'd have a BMI of 27.4. Interestingly, that was under the cutoff for overweight before 1998. Moreover, people with the highest longevity are those in the "overweight" category.

    20% body fat is a pretty small amount for a woman. It falls under the % recommended for a trained athlete incompetition, as opposed to just a fit person (American Council on Exercise and Fitness "Fit Life") I am not trying to talk you out of your goal, if that's very important to you, go for it. However, its not necessary to be at 20% body fat as a woman to be physically fit.

    Weight is a lot more complex than the BMI metric.
  • Merkavar
    Merkavar Posts: 3,082 Member
    I chose high end of BMI rounded to nearest 5kg.

    There was no weight I wanted to get back to, been over weight since time immemorial.

    In my opinion start with BMI and as you near goal weight readjust it up or down.
  • tracie_minus100
    tracie_minus100 Posts: 465 Member
    My original goal was 159.8, which puts me just inside a healthy BMI. It's a goal of mine to have that damn healthy BMI.
    I'm less than 10lbs away from that now and I think I'm going to keep going past that, to somewhere around 145-150.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories