A Little disappointed-What could I do better?
chief3202
Posts: 41 Member
Hello everyone! I am a first time poster and enjoy reading some of the wonderful success stories. I am a 48 year old male and I am 6'"1 tall.
On December 11, 2015, I decided to change my life style because I started having some minor health problems. I was 291 pounds and developed high blood pressure and plantar fasciitis. I am under doctors care and receiving treatment. Plantar fasciitis has a long healing process and made me not want to move. I can barley walk on some days and I became bored. I was eating a few dozen of oreo cookies a day and my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months.
I was watching television and surfing the channels, coming across the TLC channel series 600 lb life. Some of these stories made me think, "DO I LOOK THIS OVERWEIGHT?" I looked into the mirror and it clicked in my mind that I have a weight problem. My belly was shaped like a pear and I had a double chin that I really never payed attention to.
The next day I started my weight loss journey. I spoke with my son who is 23 about weight loss because he suffered from being over weight. His weight was 400 lbs and he went on the paleo diet a year ago. He lost 170 lbs and his accomplishments inspired me to ask how he met his goals.
I began the paelo adventure on December 12, 2015 and did my first weigh in on January 12. I lost 13 pounds. According to my son, I should of dropped 20 pounds or more of water weight. 2 more weeks went by and I just lost 5 more pounds, weighing in at 274. There are no calorie counting with the paleo diet and supposedly one can eat until full. I thought the food amount was excessive and the food seemed to contain tons of salt, making me drink a gallon of water daily. I ate the good fruit carbs and eliminated all junk carbs, especially oreo cookies..
I joined myfitnesspal and followed the calorie counting. It was recommended that my calorie intake was 1750, but I reduced to 1500 because I cannot exercise daily due to the plantar fasciitis. I went over my calories a few times, but did not exceed the original 1750. Additionally, I worked out doing cardio exercise and burned a 1000 calories as of today.
I weighed in this morning and only lost 1.5 pounds using calorie counting method. I was disappointed with my 1.5 lb loss because all of the water weight is gone, and I have minimal carbs intake. I was looking for bigger numbers then 1.5 pounds. I know its early in the game, but I thought I had an advantage from the Paleo diet and expected calorie counting to by more successful.
Can anyone recommend what I am doing wrong, and give advice on some changes? Is this all the weight that I can expect to lose weekly? Some days I am starving and others I am fine. I am pushing myself hard to exercise more, but the plantar fasciitis pain is unbearable and refrains me from doing more in the workout.
Thanks, and I hope to explore a journey like my son has..
Dean
On December 11, 2015, I decided to change my life style because I started having some minor health problems. I was 291 pounds and developed high blood pressure and plantar fasciitis. I am under doctors care and receiving treatment. Plantar fasciitis has a long healing process and made me not want to move. I can barley walk on some days and I became bored. I was eating a few dozen of oreo cookies a day and my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months.
I was watching television and surfing the channels, coming across the TLC channel series 600 lb life. Some of these stories made me think, "DO I LOOK THIS OVERWEIGHT?" I looked into the mirror and it clicked in my mind that I have a weight problem. My belly was shaped like a pear and I had a double chin that I really never payed attention to.
The next day I started my weight loss journey. I spoke with my son who is 23 about weight loss because he suffered from being over weight. His weight was 400 lbs and he went on the paleo diet a year ago. He lost 170 lbs and his accomplishments inspired me to ask how he met his goals.
I began the paelo adventure on December 12, 2015 and did my first weigh in on January 12. I lost 13 pounds. According to my son, I should of dropped 20 pounds or more of water weight. 2 more weeks went by and I just lost 5 more pounds, weighing in at 274. There are no calorie counting with the paleo diet and supposedly one can eat until full. I thought the food amount was excessive and the food seemed to contain tons of salt, making me drink a gallon of water daily. I ate the good fruit carbs and eliminated all junk carbs, especially oreo cookies..
I joined myfitnesspal and followed the calorie counting. It was recommended that my calorie intake was 1750, but I reduced to 1500 because I cannot exercise daily due to the plantar fasciitis. I went over my calories a few times, but did not exceed the original 1750. Additionally, I worked out doing cardio exercise and burned a 1000 calories as of today.
I weighed in this morning and only lost 1.5 pounds using calorie counting method. I was disappointed with my 1.5 lb loss because all of the water weight is gone, and I have minimal carbs intake. I was looking for bigger numbers then 1.5 pounds. I know its early in the game, but I thought I had an advantage from the Paleo diet and expected calorie counting to by more successful.
Can anyone recommend what I am doing wrong, and give advice on some changes? Is this all the weight that I can expect to lose weekly? Some days I am starving and others I am fine. I am pushing myself hard to exercise more, but the plantar fasciitis pain is unbearable and refrains me from doing more in the workout.
Thanks, and I hope to explore a journey like my son has..
Dean
0
Replies
-
Take the 1.5 per week, that is an awesome amount per week. You did not put on your weight overnight0
-
So you've gone from 291 to 272.5 since 12/12/15, right? And 1.5 of that was in the past week. That 1.5 is a good rate of loss. I'm not sure why you are disappointed with it. My best suggestion is to adjust your expectations so that they are more reasonable.
You should not have reduced your calorie intake to 1500. Your MFP goal already assumes no exercise so you essentially are dinging yourself twice for that by taking 250 calories off your goal. 1500 for a 272.5 pound 6'1" tall man is unnecessarily low and explains your days when you feel starving.
The Paleo diet gives you no advantage over any other form of eating. It can tend to be lower in carbs, which means you lose more water weight to start, but once that is accomplished the same old calories in vs calories out is what makes the biggest difference. If you aren't already, start weighing your solid food on a digital kitchen scale, use a measuring cup for liquids, and make sure you log all food using verifiable nutrition info such as that from the USDA or food packages that you have in hand.
Best of luck to you. Keep up the good work.0 -
1.5 pounds per week, especially when you're limited in your physical movement is AWESOME.
You gained 21 pounds in 6 months. That is about .8 pounds per week. To be able to lose weight at about twice the rate you gained it, is very good.
Your son has good intentions but is not necessarily accurate in telling you that you should be losing at a certain pace. The key things to keep in mind: you said you wanted to change your lifestyle. If what you're doing is something you can continue for a while, then that is what you need to focus on. Day by day, week by week making progress. Being healthier now than you were a month ago. Looking forward to be healthier still in another month, and then another.
You're off to a great start!0 -
How much water weight one loses during the initial stage depends upon how much water someone retains. It varies by individual. You can't compare yourself to your son. Your son's starting weight was 400lb...yours was about a 100lb less...makes sense...at least to me...that you might possibly have as much water weight to lose.0
-
You're not doing anything wrong if you're losing an average of 1.5 lbs /week. That's a healthy sustainable loss.
I do agree with jemhh that 1500 calories for a man of your size is unnecessary though. Even if you're sedentary it wouldn't be appropriate for you. If you really want to tighten up, then log your food everyday and weigh your solids on a digital food scale.
Also, readjust your expectations. I know you want to see big losses asap, but it's better to expect less and end up losing more than you were expecting than to expect more and fall short.0 -
Thanks everyone for the input. I have been weighing all intake foods. I think I am doing it correct except for non-label products. For example, I purchased a large package of chicken breasts from Sams club and it has no nutrition label information. I weigh a chicken breast and it displays 8 ounces. I google chicken breast calories and the USDA calculator displays 374 calories. I take this number and search myfitnesspal food diary and click the one that matches the calories like the USDA. Is this method correct?
Thanks
Dean0 -
You are doing great! If you lose 1.5 pounds a week you will be around 200 pounds by the end of the year. That isn't a bad thing at all. Along the way you will be feeling so much better.0
-
Thanks everyone for the input. I have been weighing all intake foods. I think I am doing it correct except for non-label products. For example, I purchased a large package of chicken breasts from Sams club and it has no nutrition label information. I weigh a chicken breast and it displays 8 ounces. I google chicken breast calories and the USDA calculator displays 374 calories. I take this number and search myfitnesspal food diary and click the one that matches the calories like the USDA. Is this method correct?
Thanks
Dean
You can search for 'usda chicken breast raw' and just use that entry.
I have to add though... Paleo is one way of losing weight, but it all comes down to calorie deficit, and you have to ask yourself if it's sustainable. If you have no intention of going low carb all your life, you might want to consider how you're going to deal with that long term.0 -
There are no calorie counting with the paleo diet and supposedly one can eat until full.
This is absolutely untrue. Paleo is aimed at health not necessarily weigjt loss. You still need to control the calories you ingest. Check mark sissons site for mire info. It is perfectly possible to gain weight doing paleo- i did during my first attempt.
You need to be in a deficit and it doesnt matter how you get there. You need the info to ensure you have that deficit.
0 -
It sounds like you are doing great and should not be disappointed with your rate of loss. You did not gain it all over night, and you are not going to lose it all over night, it helps to view this process as a marathon not a sprint.
My one suggestion would be to get a food scale and weigh all your solid foods to get an accurate picture of your intake. I would also suggest using correct MFP database entries and cross check them against this site, http://nutritiondata.self.com/0 -
"my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months." SKYROCKETED, your words.
291-270= 21. 21 pounds a great (skyrocketing) gain in 6 months
21 pounds divided by 6 months = 3.5 pound gain per MONTH
3.5 pounds divided by 4.33 weeks to a month = 0.8 pound gain per week. This is a skyrocketing gain.
Now you're upset because you ONLY lost 1.5 pounds in a week?
Lose a pound to a pound and a half per week. It's sustainable, it's livable, it's doable and it'll help you create a lifestyle that you will be able to keep, and, more importantly, you will WANT to keep.
You didn't put the weight on overnight. You can't take it off overnight and expect to remain/get healthy.
Welcome to life, One day at a time, One pound at a time.
Keep at it and the results you want will be yours.
0 -
You are doing fantastic. Also bear in mind you aren't your son in your 20's we are all different.
Weight loss is not linear and you will find you have times of great losses and not so great ( btw 1.5 is brilliant)
Expect weight loss to slow nearer your goal weight and up those cals to what mfp says to eat.
Slow and steady wins the race and keeps it off
Re: paleo if it works for you long term and you think you can keep it as a permanent change good for you . But remember it is a tool a health / lifestyle choice and CICO is still key as is sustainability in the long term.
Good luck and all the best0 -
OMG, there is a little light at the end of my tunnel. My today's weigh in is 268.2. I lost 4.3 pounds this week. I did a lot of cardio at the gym. My wife took photos of my stomach on December 12 2015 (291lbs) and today. The results of the total weight loss so far is 22.8 lbs done in 2 months. I still have a long journey, but I am excited with the results!! It is wild to see the comparison of both photos and the reduction of fat in my stomach. Thanks all!!0
-
OMG, there is a little light at the end of my tunnel. My today's weigh in is 268.2. I lost 4.3 pounds this week. I did a lot of cardio at the gym. My wife took photos of my stomach on December 12 2015 (291lbs) and today. The results of the total weight loss so far is 22.8 lbs done in 2 months. I still have a long journey, but I am excited with the results!! It is wild to see the comparison of both photos and the reduction of fat in my stomach. Thanks all!!
High five0 -
OMG, there is a little light at the end of my tunnel. My today's weigh in is 268.2. I lost 4.3 pounds this week. I did a lot of cardio at the gym. My wife took photos of my stomach on December 12 2015 (291lbs) and today. The results of the total weight loss so far is 22.8 lbs done in 2 months. I still have a long journey, but I am excited with the results!! It is wild to see the comparison of both photos and the reduction of fat in my stomach. Thanks all!!
Congrats! Just keep swimming...0 -
"my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months." SKYROCKETED, your words.
291-270= 21. 21 pounds a great (skyrocketing) gain in 6 months
21 pounds divided by 6 months = 3.5 pound gain per MONTH
3.5 pounds divided by 4.33 weeks to a month = 0.8 pound gain per week. This is a skyrocketing gain.
Now you're upset because you ONLY lost 1.5 pounds in a week?
Lose a pound to a pound and a half per week. It's sustainable, it's livable, it's doable and it'll help you create a lifestyle that you will be able to keep, and, more importantly, you will WANT to keep.
You didn't put the weight on overnight. You can't take it off overnight and expect to remain/get healthy.
Welcome to life, One day at a time, One pound at a time.
Keep at it and the results you want will be yours.
I
this post. 
Anyway OP. You are doing fantastic. It sounds like you are doing everything right. Just keep going and be patient. One of my inspirations for getting going was a dojo mate who lost something like 80 pounds in a year. He was doing the paleo thing. Ity isn't for me but his advice to use MFP and just worry about calories has been really helpful and I am having success. Keep in mind that weight loss does go in fits and starts. It will slow down and sometimes you will gain a little for a week or two. Just keep at it.
0 -
"my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months." SKYROCKETED, your words.
291-270= 21. 21 pounds a great (skyrocketing) gain in 6 months
21 pounds divided by 6 months = 3.5 pound gain per MONTH
3.5 pounds divided by 4.33 weeks to a month = 0.8 pound gain per week. This is a skyrocketing gain.
Now you're upset because you ONLY lost 1.5 pounds in a week?
Lose a pound to a pound and a half per week. It's sustainable, it's livable, it's doable and it'll help you create a lifestyle that you will be able to keep, and, more importantly, you will WANT to keep.
You didn't put the weight on overnight. You can't take it off overnight and expect to remain/get healthy.
Welcome to life, One day at a time, One pound at a time.
Keep at it and the results you want will be yours.
Thank you @pondee629 for the calculation.
OP: I will repeat this. You gain weight 0.8 pound a week. You called it skyrocket gain
You are losing 1.5 pound a week. You are not happy.
I believe you are doing a great job. Be patient, persistent and manage your expectations for weight loss.
it is not linear.
Good luck in your healthy journey0 -
Um, they have to put labels on food in Sam's club, that sounds suspect. Do you live outside of the USA???Thanks everyone for the input. I have been weighing all intake foods. I think I am doing it correct except for non-label products. For example, I purchased a large package of chicken breasts from Sams club and it has no nutrition label information. I weigh a chicken breast and it displays 8 ounces. I google chicken breast calories and the USDA calculator displays 374 calories. I take this number and search myfitnesspal food diary and click the one that matches the calories like the USDA. Is this method correct?
Thanks
Dean
0 -
likequeenliz99 wrote: »Take the 1.5 per week, that is an awesome amount per week. You did not put on your weight overnight
0 -
UPDATE: I just went to the doctors and was weighed in. My numbers were wrong, but the loss was MORE. 266.2 pounds. HOLY CRAP! I lost 8 lbs this week. I know I have a long way to go to reach my goal of 220, but I am excited of my accomplishment. Good bye Oreo's for ever. (lol) Thanks everyone.0
-
UPDATE: I just went to the doctors and was weighed in. My numbers were wrong, but the loss was MORE. 266.2 pounds. HOLY CRAP! I lost 8 lbs this week. I know I have a long way to go to reach my goal of 220, but I am excited of my accomplishment. Good bye Oreo's for ever. (lol) Thanks everyone.
Wow, that's awesome! Great job. 0 -
UPDATE: I just went to the doctors and was weighed in. My numbers were wrong, but the loss was MORE. 266.2 pounds. HOLY CRAP! I lost 8 lbs this week. I know I have a long way to go to reach my goal of 220, but I am excited of my accomplishment. Good bye Oreo's for ever. (lol) Thanks everyone.
WTG man, keep it up! Whatever you are doing is clearly working0 -
No matter what that scale says on any given day, just don't quit!
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10040017/thinking-of-starting-today-you-might-want-to-check-this-out-pics-inside/p1
0 -
Hello everyone! I am a first time poster and enjoy reading some of the wonderful success stories. I am a 48 year old male and I am 6'"1 tall.
On December 11, 2015, I decided to change my life style because I started having some minor health problems. I was 291 pounds and developed high blood pressure and plantar fasciitis. I am under doctors care and receiving treatment. Plantar fasciitis has a long healing process and made me not want to move. I can barley walk on some days and I became bored. I was eating a few dozen of oreo cookies a day and my weight skyrocketed from 270 to 291 within 6 months.
I was watching television and surfing the channels, coming across the TLC channel series 600 lb life. Some of these stories made me think, "DO I LOOK THIS OVERWEIGHT?" I looked into the mirror and it clicked in my mind that I have a weight problem. My belly was shaped like a pear and I had a double chin that I really never payed attention to.
The next day I started my weight loss journey. I spoke with my son who is 23 about weight loss because he suffered from being over weight. His weight was 400 lbs and he went on the paleo diet a year ago. He lost 170 lbs and his accomplishments inspired me to ask how he met his goals.
I began the paelo adventure on December 12, 2015 and did my first weigh in on January 12. I lost 13 pounds. According to my son, I should of dropped 20 pounds or more of water weight. 2 more weeks went by and I just lost 5 more pounds, weighing in at 274. There are no calorie counting with the paleo diet and supposedly one can eat until full. I thought the food amount was excessive and the food seemed to contain tons of salt, making me drink a gallon of water daily. I ate the good fruit carbs and eliminated all junk carbs, especially oreo cookies..
I joined myfitnesspal and followed the calorie counting. It was recommended that my calorie intake was 1750, but I reduced to 1500 because I cannot exercise daily due to the plantar fasciitis. I went over my calories a few times, but did not exceed the original 1750. Additionally, I worked out doing cardio exercise and burned a 1000 calories as of today.
I weighed in this morning and only lost 1.5 pounds using calorie counting method. I was disappointed with my 1.5 lb loss because all of the water weight is gone, and I have minimal carbs intake. I was looking for bigger numbers then 1.5 pounds. I know its early in the game, but I thought I had an advantage from the Paleo diet and expected calorie counting to by more successful.
Can anyone recommend what I am doing wrong, and give advice on some changes? Is this all the weight that I can expect to lose weekly? Some days I am starving and others I am fine. I am pushing myself hard to exercise more, but the plantar fasciitis pain is unbearable and refrains me from doing more in the workout.
Thanks, and I hope to explore a journey like my son has..
Dean
Dean, you didn't put that weight on in three months, how can you expect to take it off in just three months? I'm saying this as someone who was in the same place as you in July of last year at 6'2" and 290 pounds. I was able to get down to 249 by the end of November. Your 1500 calories seems really low. Mine is 2110 for 249 pounds, lightly active and desiring to lose 1.5 pounds per week. Just go with the flow. As long as you're losing you're not gaining. As for salt, be sure to cook your own food, don't eat prepared or frozen food, and pay attention to the MyFitnessPal sodium limit of 2300 mg/day.0 -
Weight loss isn't linear. It's hard to keep in mind, espically when the number on the scale doesn't vary much, but it is true. My numbers always go up and down over time, but when I started looking at the trend and it was going down, I was able to stop worrying about it as much. So keep an eye on your trending weight, and as long as you can draw a line from start to finish and it's going down, you're fine. Congrats on the weight you've lost so far! ^_^
Also, you don't have to say goodbye to Oreos, they still love you. You just can't love as many of them as you have in the past. XD0 -
You'll be able to work those Oreos in soon enough!
Once you reach your goal weight, your foot has healed, and you get into weight training perhaps, you'll be able to eat tonnes.0 -
-
ernestrodgers82, nice job! Thanks for the encouragement ewhip. Those pictures of your weight loss is awesome! I cannot wait to post my pictures when I hit my goal. I know a plateau will be coming soon, but I am determined to get the job done. I weigh myself in every Friday and I will post next weeks numbers hoping for great results again. Have a great weekend everybody and thanks for all the kind and inspiring words.
Dean0 -
Hello everyone!
Today's weigh in showed that I gained a pound and I can explain why.
My wife wanted to have a romantic valentines day and we made reservations at McCormick and Schmick's. I was not allowed to take my scale with me (lol), and no accurate nutrition information was posted online. The waitress was dumbfounded. Not one employee could provide me with nutrition information about the food, except that "there is a lot of calories" in everything we serve.
My wife is very skinny and tall with a beautiful physique. She supports my diet project, but she is is like the devil making me take the apple. (lol) I ordered tilapia fish and lobster bisque soup. I took the first bite, and I could taste the grease. I knew in my mind that the calories were coming back and I felt uncomfortable. Of course I ate the entire meal, but who wouldn't for just spending $125 on a meal. We enjoyed ourselves and I stuck to drinking water instead of alcohol.
The following Monday, I weighed myself and found that I had gained 4.5 pounds. I was completely shocked and disappointed in myself for gaining that much weight within 2 days. I made a commitment and focused on going to the gym everyday this week and increased my workouts. It was very difficult for me with an injured foot, but I stuck to it bringing my weight back to 267.7. I am satisfied with today's weigh in, but it cost me a doctor's visit because my foot severely flared up to the point where I can hardly walk.
Have a great day everyone!
Dean0 -
I would kill to be able to lose 1.5 a week at this point. I'm 4 lbs. away from my ultimate goal weight, and I have to keep it to .5 lbs. a week or I feel miserable and hungry all the time. Enjoy the ability to melt that much off per week while you still can. Progress gets slower and slower as you get closer to goal.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions