Fitbit... Are they worth it??? Which do u reccomend???
lisachuter
Posts: 6 Member
Hi like the title says realy, just wondering if these fitbits are worth getting?? And if so which would reccomend plz ? Cheers x
0
Replies
-
Absolutely get a fitness tracker of some sort for motivation. I got mine last month and I love it (I have a fitbit Charge HR), I used to be a right exercise phobe but now I'm going to the gym 3 times a week and doing couch to 5k too.
I think having one gives you a better idea of your calories in vs calories out as opposed to what MFP gives you.
I log my food in MFP though as they sync to each other.0 -
I have the FitBit Charge HR as well and I love it. You can add friends on the app and set different challenges...definitely makes for some extra motivation to move. And it feels awesome to meet all the daily goals as well. Have had it since last June.0
-
My biggest fear is when I saw an article stating that about half of those purchasing the device stopped using it after a number of months. I hate throwing good money away, espeically if I al already posting my exerercise in MFP everyday already.0
-
I say no cause too many people over complicate fitness. If your training is on point, your nutrition is on point and your sleep is on point then maybe. but its just one more thing to worry about IMHO0
-
I have had my Fitbit charge since September and wear it all day everyday. I only need to charge the battery once a week. I usually do that overnight. Otherwise I like that sleep tracking it does. My wife has the charge HR which is worth the money if you need a heart rate monitor as well. It also syncs your steps to MFP very easily.0
-
I bought a Misfit Flash -- paid about $20 on Amazon -- and bought a different band for it (French Bull, Vine pattern, also on Amazon). Not only is it much cheaper, but you can swim with it (waterPROOF), and you don't have to recharge it continually, because it operates on a battery that lasts six months. I love it, and it synchronizes with MFP. It was tricky to set up the synchronization, but I found instructions on the MFP/Misfit user group that worked. The data isn't as sophisticated as FitBits, but it tracks steps, calories, distance, and sleep. It also tracks other types of exercise (swimming, yoga, etc.) so you get "credit" for everything you do. There is a small learning curve, but I think it is SOOOO worth it and it is SOOO much less expensive than other trackers. It has great reviews in all kinds of publications and on websites. Check it out online.0
-
I fall the middle of everyone's opinions here. I've had a Fitbit Flex for a few years now and it has helped me a lot. I'm at the point now where I am doing activities that my fitbit is not registering (rowing, lifting) therefore it appears I am not doing enough exercise in a day. If i'm not actively logging these activities on MFP. It has turned into a negative thing if I am not running everyday. I think it just depends on the person you are and the type of activities you do.0
-
I've had my fitbit (charge) for over a year and I absolutely love it. I wear it every day. I compete in weekly challenges with my fitbit friends and it's hugely motivational for me. It has helped me be much more active and really be mindful of how much time I spend sitting at my desk job. I would recommend it whole heartedly!0
-
I loved the functionality but I will NEVER waste my money on their products again after my Charge disintegrated afer a couple months because of the shoddy rubber band design. Not sure what they were thinking and maybe it's been corrected but after feeling ripped off by a cheap design on a $200 product I've switched to Garmin.
As for the functionality, it's up there with the best but I think the VivoActive is better than the current top offering of the Fitbit in any event. I have a VivoActive and love it but I do think Fitbit is more accurate on calories burned for me but I'm only interested in the activity tracking and GPS features.0 -
My biggest fear is when I saw an article stating that about half of those purchasing the device stopped using it after a number of months. I hate throwing good money away, espeically if I al already posting my exerercise in MFP everyday already.
Just let customer service know. They send you a new one in case of loss or damage.0 -
I have the fitbit surge and I love it. it tracks sleep patterns and syncs with MFP and WW. i can program the exercises that I do and l love not having to wear the chest strap. i get into the challenges and love seeing the badges. Good investment!!!0
-
I say no cause too many people over complicate fitness. If your training is on point, your nutrition is on point and your sleep is on point then maybe. but its just one more thing to worry about IMHO
I would have said the same thing till I actually got an activity tracker. It's amazing what you can do with the extra informaiton if you are motivated to use it.
0 -
I have the Fitbit Charge HR. I love it. It's amazing to see how many steps you actually get in a day. I bet it's probably less than what you would guess!0
-
I bought my Charge HR in October. I love it. It definitely makes me more motivated to reach particular targets, and it is fun trying to compete against other people. I love all the statistics it gives me - and I knew when I bought it that I would be motivated by that. Depends on what motivates you I guess, but it works for me.0
-
I have a vivofit by Garmin and I really enjoy it. I’m a data kinda guy, love to analyze data and the web interface allows that. Prior to an injury that I suffered in mid summer I was running a lot, I was running on the beach and on hard surface and I was able to look at the differences as well as how running in the AM differed from running in the PM all kinds of stuff! And I love stuff! :-)
It also has a sleep monitor mode which I know is not a true indicator of my sleep patterns but it really does indicate when I have periods of deep sleep and light sleep.
I also can look at a workout and interpret based on knowing what I was doing at a particular time interval which exercises get my HR higher than other exercises. Which given my age, schedule, and the lack of spare time, comes in very handy.
I would suggest reading up on the ones that interest you first before making a decision.
Good luck.
V/r,
DW.
0 -
lisachuter wrote: »Hi like the title says realy, just wondering if these fitbits are worth getting?? And if so which would reccomend plz ? Cheers x
Apple watch > all. I had a fitbit, a HRM ... Apple watch is by far the best device I've owned that tracks fitness and your heart rate.0 -
I love my Flex, and have absolutely no regrets. Got it for Christmas, and it only comes off my wrist long enough to charge, once every 4 days or so. Someone up thread mentioned throwing away good money, which makes sense if you are one of those people that can't commit...but if you're the type to stick to something, and really want to see changes, this is for you. I was shocked at the numbers, they told the real truth about how much I move my body every day, and since getting mine, I've managed to move my numbers from Sedentary to Active. I was also shocked to see my sleep numbers, and have managed to increase my sleep from 4-5 hours each night, and now I'm getting 7-8. My whole day is better because of it. I challenge myself every single day, all day long!0
-
A vote for Fitbit Charge HR! Suits me down to the ground, especially now I have the teal one (and it was so great being able to move from a large to a small band).
I did no research before I got my first one though, FitBit Flex. I'd never really heard about trackers for general activity until the all-knowing Amazon floated an advert in front of my nose the very evening I was plugging my stats into MFP and finally taking weight loss seriously. It was on offer and seemed like it could be fun, so I went for it. I moved to Charge HR for updates on progress without syncing with my phone and I am smitten. I was at a loss without it for 4 days a couple of weeks ago (which probably means I need some sort of FitBit rehab).
I couldn't comment on the range of fitness wearables available now, but I am fully sold on the usefulness of them. You burn far more calories in all the time you are not exercising than when you are, so increasing your amount of 'non-exercise' activity (just walking around basically) makes a huge contribution to your calorie burn. It's a little wrist-based reminder to get up off your backside and walk the long way home!0 -
I bought my husband a Fitbit Charge and he uses it everyday. I also have one but just bought an apple watch so I use that instead. My husband said it best when he said it may not be 100% accurate but it gives him an indication of his activity level and lets him know when he needs to step it up a little. JMO anyway.0
-
I absolutely LOVE my charge HR. It is brilliant. I can't recommend it enough if you need a little extra motivation.0
-
My biggest fear is when I saw an article stating that about half of those purchasing the device stopped using it after a number of months. I hate throwing good money away, espeically if I al already posting my exerercise in MFP everyday already.
0 -
Fitbit Charge and Fitbit Charge HR have a ton of hardware issues. The band falls apart over time. You check into this if you plan to buy this Fitbit device. Other Fitbits that doe not use this actual deisgn are better.
I use a garmin vivosmart and love mine however I have preordered the Fitbit Blaze for my husband but this hardware design is not the same as the Charge.0 -
I love my Fitbit. I have had a Fitbit Flex since September 2013.
Its considered an older model now but I like that the actual fitbit device and the band are 2 separate items. If one breaks, the other piece is still useable. I like switching out bands from time to time (can't do that with the new one's). And I have a nickel allergy. So I can replace their metal clasp with a plastic one bought off ebay for a few dollars. I believe this is the only model I can do that with too.
I love the features of counting stairs and heart rate, which the flex does not have. That is the only downside.0 -
I have a Fitbit Zip, the lowest Fitbit model, that clips on to your waistband or goes in your pocket. I bought it because my skin is so sensitive I can't even wear a watch so I was pretty sure I couldn't wear one of the wrist Fitbits either. I've had mine almost a year and I really like getting feedback about how active (or not) I've been. It really does motivate me to get up and move and try to beat yesterday's steps and active minutes.0
-
Tedebearduff wrote: »lisachuter wrote: »Hi like the title says realy, just wondering if these fitbits are worth getting?? And if so which would reccomend plz ? Cheers x
Apple watch > all. I had a fitbit, a HRM ... Apple watch is by far the best device I've owned that tracks fitness and your heart rate.
I freaking LOVE my Apple Watch. It's helped me lose 70 lbs. It's funny--I'm a musician and the other night I showed up for a rehearsal--the conductor was already there. I hadn't seen him in a couple of years but noticed he was wearing one too, and he had lost 80 lbs.
I know a lot of people who have bought Fitbits and had them stop working in less than a year. They don't seem to be made very well. And yes, you can call customer service and get them replaced, but the replacements break too. I stay far away from Fitbit based on all the people I've seen get frustrated by the product.
But in general, yes, wearables like the Fitbit, the Apple Watch, and all the others can be FANTASTIC tools if you use them correctly and don't expect them to work miracles. What I don't like about Fitbit is that they have perpetuated this myth that if you just get your 10,000 steps in every day, you will be healthy and lose weight. That is 100% not true. You can eat back 10,000 steps worth of burned calories in minutes. You can also walk 10,000 steps and have over half of them not be truly good calorie burning activity.0 -
I have a polar loop, but also have had a fitbit. For me, my hatred of technology and ensuing complications, makes it not worth it. Honestly, I prefer my hrm for exercise, and my $10 pedometer for steps. btw, both the loop and the fitbit give steps for rocking in a rocking chair for what that's worth. My fave chair, so throws me off quite a bit--4000 steps per movie.0
-
rachelr1116 wrote: »I have a Fitbit Zip, the lowest Fitbit model, that clips on to your waistband or goes in your pocket. I bought it because my skin is so sensitive I can't even wear a watch so I was pretty sure I couldn't wear one of the wrist Fitbits either. I've had mine almost a year and I really like getting feedback about how active (or not) I've been. It really does motivate me to get up and move and try to beat yesterday's steps and active minutes.
Me too, which is why I bought the One. And I love it. I'm a numbers and data geek so I get a real kick out of seeing all the stats and graphs. And it definitely motivates me to get up and move more to try and beat my previous day's totals.0 -
I have my Fitbit for over 2 yrs, I really like it as it makes me get up and move consistently and I like how it calculates my total daily burn which has been pretty accurate for me It contributed to helping me lose my final 5lbs and maintaining my goal weight since then.
(had the Flex first and now the One - I like that the One is discreet and clips inside my bra so its hidden from view)0 -
I've got the Flex and love it, I find it's really motivating.0
-
Wow u guys are great thankyou for ur opinions and recommendations ...... Oooopsy ive just orderd my fitbit charge hr in plum cheers xx0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions