Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Does lacking specific nutrients cause specific cravings?
Tricia7188
Posts: 135 Member
in Debate Club
"Im on my period, mmm I'm craving steak. Must be low in iron"
Haha we've all heard this sort of sentence. I haven't ever had this personally happen to me, so I was just wondering if any of you have thoughts on this. Is it legitimate? It just seems to me that our bodies just wouldn't be that "smart" to know a steak is high in iron and therefore want it to correct our levels. .. but hey, never know! I'm not sure of other micro or macronutrients this could pertain to (protein, carbs maybe?) But iron is a big one because the strong correlation with red meat.
Also on a slightly different but related note, do you think a general nutrient deficit of ANY kind (low fat, low carb) cause any other specific cravings? There's been a picture floating around the internet of a list of foods someone could crave and then the nutrients your body may be lacking, causing the cravings.... Ya probably not. They were pretty random too, like "Craving pasta? Increase your Vitamin B"(or magnesium, or replace with any other micronutrient).
Pretty sure it's all a bunch of BS, which I wish it wasn't cause that would be fascinating and awesome!!! And that is why I posted this, so if anyone has legit info or personal experience I want to hear it!
Haha we've all heard this sort of sentence. I haven't ever had this personally happen to me, so I was just wondering if any of you have thoughts on this. Is it legitimate? It just seems to me that our bodies just wouldn't be that "smart" to know a steak is high in iron and therefore want it to correct our levels. .. but hey, never know! I'm not sure of other micro or macronutrients this could pertain to (protein, carbs maybe?) But iron is a big one because the strong correlation with red meat.
Also on a slightly different but related note, do you think a general nutrient deficit of ANY kind (low fat, low carb) cause any other specific cravings? There's been a picture floating around the internet of a list of foods someone could crave and then the nutrients your body may be lacking, causing the cravings.... Ya probably not. They were pretty random too, like "Craving pasta? Increase your Vitamin B"(or magnesium, or replace with any other micronutrient).
Pretty sure it's all a bunch of BS, which I wish it wasn't cause that would be fascinating and awesome!!! And that is why I posted this, so if anyone has legit info or personal experience I want to hear it!
0
Replies
-
-
Opps I don't know how to post pictures here haha. Google "Cravings chart" and you'll see all the glorious pictures1
-
I might look up and check later, but I don't think micronutrients besides salt have much evidence that they cause cravings. There is an odd correlation between iron deficiency and ice chewing, which is unexplained, especially as ice doesn't normally contain appreciable amounts of iron.
For macronutrients, there is actually a weight gain hypothesis based on the idea that protein is the macronutrient that controls appetite, known as the protein leverage hypothesis:
http://sydney.edu.au/science/outreach/inspiring/news/cpc.shtml
0 -
Cool!!! Veeeery interesting on the protein front!0
-
The only craving I get is for salty foods; I actually don't crave sweets. My doctor suspects it's because I have low blood pressure, and the fact that I eat way more sodium than is recommend could be why it's not lower. Don't know for sure, but that's the theory.
As for if you're body is craving iron you want a steak, maybe it's because you know that steak is a good source of iron, so maybe your body is craving something and your brain associates that something with a food that has it? I dunno, just throwing an idea out there.2 -
I have heard this before, but I dont know if it is true. I feel like I only ever crave food that I like, and that is the reason. It took a while of eating healthier to stop craving some of the junk that I used to eat.1
-
Same!! I feel like I could tell myself (based on the cravings chart) that oh I crave chocolate, must be low in _______ but really I just want it cause its delicious!!ChristinaOrr65 wrote: »I have heard this before, but I dont know if it is true. I feel like I only ever crave food that I like, and that is the reason. It took a while of eating healthier to stop craving some of the junk that I used to eat.1 -
The only craving I get is for salty foods; I actually don't crave sweets. My doctor suspects it's because I have low blood pressure, and the fact that I eat way more sodium than is recommend could be why it's not lower. Don't know for sure, but that's the theory.
As for if you're body is craving iron you want a steak, maybe it's because you know that steak is a good source of iron, so maybe your body is craving something and your brain associates that something with a food that has it? I dunno, just throwing an idea out there.
I always crave sweets over salty, but now eating more veggies I definitely don't shy away from the salt and I love the flavor so much more.
That does seem to be the rational for the meat/iron thing. I just don't see how our brains can make that connection and cause a craving for it. But maybe it can!
0 -
I'm going to change my opinion to more tentative until I can find the rat study mentioned here:
http://ocw.jhsph.edu/courses/criticalanalysispopulardietssupplements/PDFs/Lecture2.pdfDiet Composition and Satiety-II
{ Micronutrients:
z When made deficient in a
micronutrient, rats will select a diet
that corrects the deficiency
z Humans may overeat in general to
correct micronutrient deficiencies0 -
ChristinaOrr65 wrote: »I have heard this before, but I dont know if it is true. I feel like I only ever crave food that I like, and that is the reason. It took a while of eating healthier to stop craving some of the junk that I used to eat.
Every once in awhile I get horrendously strong cravings for Spagetti-O's. I don't know why because I hate them. To me they taste absolutely disgusting. In fact, just sitting here thinking about them is causing me to make the blech face.
0 -
Tricia7188 wrote: »
Most of the charts like that are bunk though. Quickly reviewing some of them can bring up things that don't make sense when analyzing either the food that is craved or the food that is suggest not matching the micronutrient.
In that chart I can off the bat spot the chloride one as bogus - you'd have to have malabsorption issues to ever have a chloride deficiency, so the idea that evolution would produce signals for it is doubtful. Similar with phosphorous.
Oily foods don't contain calcium - WTF? Really? The person making this chart is kind of insulting people with these kind of mistakes.
Carbs because of nitrogen? The only foods that contain nitrogen is protein. Why would you crave carbs for nitrogen?
That chart is put together by someone that has negative knowledge of chemistry and nutrition. Anyone who reads that has become less knowledgeable.1 -
The only time I ever craved steak, it turned out I was pregnant but didn't know it yet.
I had a craving for all.the.salt right before I got sick this week. Figure I needed it for all.the.snot that was to come.0 -
I wholeheartedly agree that cravings (and dislikes, for that matter) are associated with what your body needs (or could live without for now). For example, I tend to crave chocolate and salt on a "hormone funk" because of the magnesium that is so important for ladies' health. On the other hand, during her term with me, Dr. Pepper® repulsed poor Mom (tasted like blood), perhaps due to a flavoring that probably would have hurt me, but I don't know.0
-
Hahahahahha all the snot! Makes since to me lol!!hopeandtheabsurd wrote: »The only time I ever craved steak, it turned out I was pregnant but didn't know it yet.
I had a craving for all.the.salt right before I got sick this week. Figure I needed it for all.the.snot that was to come.
The prego craving thing is probably legit, but maybe it was just for more protein/general calories for the baby over the iron etc?
0 -
Bunk for sure. Or "woo" as I've learned here, love this word haha!Tricia7188 wrote: »
Most of the charts like that are bunk though. Quickly reviewing some of them can bring up things that don't make sense when analyzing either the food that is craved or the food that is suggest not matching the micronutrient.
0 -
I'm going to change my opinion to more tentative until I can find the rat study mentioned here:
http://ocw.jhsph.edu/courses/criticalanalysispopulardietssupplements/PDFs/Lecture2.pdfDiet Composition and Satiety-II
{ Micronutrients:
z When made deficient in a
micronutrient, rats will select a diet
that corrects the deficiency
z Humans may overeat in general to
correct micronutrient deficiencies
Interesting!!!0 -
There's an opinion that reducing salt in ready meals etc increases intake to meet the salt needs.0
-
The only craving I get is for salty foods; I actually don't crave sweets. My doctor suspects it's because I have low blood pressure, and the fact that I eat way more sodium than is recommend could be why it's not lower. Don't know for sure, but that's the theory.
As for if you're body is craving iron you want a steak, maybe it's because you know that steak is a good source of iron, so maybe your body is craving something and your brain associates that something with a food that has it? I dunno, just throwing an idea out there.
This makes sense to me.0 -
I might look up and check later, but I don't think micronutrients besides salt have much evidence that they cause cravings. There is an odd correlation between iron deficiency and ice chewing, which is unexplained, especially as ice doesn't normally contain appreciable amounts of iron.
For macronutrients, there is actually a weight gain hypothesis based on the idea that protein is the macronutrient that controls appetite, known as the protein leverage hypothesis:
http://sydney.edu.au/science/outreach/inspiring/news/cpc.shtml
This is interesting. I had been toying with a similar hypothesis and wondering if the satiating effect of protein could be the real driver behind the success or failure of low-carb and low-fat diets, since protein would tend to be increased as an effect of lowering one or the other macro, and if it's increased enough it could lead the dieter to eat fewer calories and lose weight.
If you wanted to make a lot of money, you could market a weight-loss book on the basis of limiting calories and maintaining a minimum level of protein...
Call it The Universal Law of Nutrition Plan!
0 -
I might look up and check later, but I don't think micronutrients besides salt have much evidence that they cause cravings. There is an odd correlation between iron deficiency and ice chewing, which is unexplained, especially as ice doesn't normally contain appreciable amounts of iron.
For macronutrients, there is actually a weight gain hypothesis based on the idea that protein is the macronutrient that controls appetite, known as the protein leverage hypothesis:
http://sydney.edu.au/science/outreach/inspiring/news/cpc.shtml
Along with that there is strong evidence that protein affects some hunger signaling in disordered eating. I've seen at least 4-5 articles on the subject.
And apparently carb-rich diet result in increase tryptophan availability which may result in further craving of carbs - although it wasn't clear to me if this was mostly in depressed people or not (the tryptophan mediated signaling might not occur if you are "full up").
0 -
When I was very anemic (but before it was diagnosed and treated) my body got *really* confused and I had cravings for sea salt. That was just plain weird.0
-
I'm a vegetarian but I know when I smell meat cooking and it seems amazing what time it is, very weird but a monthly occurrence none the less!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions