Graphic Images for Cigarette Packs Revealed.
Sunshine_Girlie
Posts: 618 Member
Just signed online and ran across this article about the new cigarette warning labels. Have you had a chance to check it out?
http://beta.news.yahoo.com/fda-unveils-graphic-images-cigarette-packs-130408193.html
Do you think this will really encourage smokers to stop smoking or do you think the FDA is wasting their time? I know quite a few people who have tried to stop, but they can't. It doesn't matter if their children beg them to, they just can't kick it. I know it breaks their hearts, but it's an addiction and not as easy for some people. I can't say that I know for experience, but just from the people I know who are smokers, they have tried pills, patches, hypnosis, and none seem to work. Who knows. Maybe this will be what it takes.
http://beta.news.yahoo.com/fda-unveils-graphic-images-cigarette-packs-130408193.html
Do you think this will really encourage smokers to stop smoking or do you think the FDA is wasting their time? I know quite a few people who have tried to stop, but they can't. It doesn't matter if their children beg them to, they just can't kick it. I know it breaks their hearts, but it's an addiction and not as easy for some people. I can't say that I know for experience, but just from the people I know who are smokers, they have tried pills, patches, hypnosis, and none seem to work. Who knows. Maybe this will be what it takes.
0
Replies
-
Just signed online and ran across this article about the new cigarette warning labels. Have you had a chance to check it out?
http://beta.news.yahoo.com/fda-unveils-graphic-images-cigarette-packs-130408193.html
Do you think this will really encourage smokers to stop smoking or do you think they're FDA is wasting their time? I know quite a few people who have tried to stop, but they can't. It doesn't matter if their children beg them to, they just can't kick it. I know it breaks their hearts, but it's an addiction and not as easy for some people. I can't say that I know for experience, but just from the people I know who are smokers, they have tried pills, patches, hypnosis, and none seem to work. Who knows. Maybe this will be what it takes.0 -
Roughly half the package here in Canada is graphic labels, and well... they "work" in that people will refuse certain packages as they don't want to look at the diseased heart or whatnot, but no they still buy the pack with the bar chart instead etc.0
-
As a smoker, I think its a waste of money and time. Unless someone wants to quit, these pictures wont help....because every smoker knows the risks of smoking and most I am sure have seen pics similar to this and they are still smoking.0
-
People who are addicted are not going to just drop the digusting habit. I hope though it will stop young kids from thinking its cool and start lighting up.
I quit 11 years ago and I enjoy not smelling bad and the nasty taste in my mouth.0 -
Pictures like this have been in the UK for quite a while. It didn't make any difference to me at all.0
-
smoking has declined in canada. but whether or not that is because of graphic images is up for debate. it could just be because people are educating themselves more. i don't really know.0
-
Having smoked for 20 some-odd years, my experience was that I had to quit dozens of times before I finally set them down for good. As far as I'm concerned, every little bit helps. If these ads can push someone to just try to quit, it might get them just a few steps closer to kicking tobacco permanently. Given the health risks posed by cigarette smoking (my mother died of complications from lung cancer), I'm all for it.0
-
Having smoked for 20 some-odd years, my experience was that I had to quit dozens of times before I finally set them down for good. As far as I'm concerned, every little bit helps. If these ads can push someone to just try to quit, it might get them just a few steps closer to kicking tobacco permanently. Given the health risks posed by cigarette smoking (my mother died of complications from lung cancer), I'm all for it.
it might potentially stop someone from starting as well!0 -
People who are addicted are not going to just drop the digusting habit. I hope though it will stop young kids from thinking its cool and start lighting up.
I quit 11 years ago and I enjoy not smelling bad and the nasty taste in my mouth.0 -
I really do believe that people think these things won't happen to them. For example, I've been smoking for a while. But what I do is get a pack, take about three weeks to smoke it, then don't buy another one for a few months. You can imagine how invincible this makes me feel...so for a person like me, they would probably say, I'm not a chain smoker or anything, nothing nasty is gonna happen to ME!
Btw, yes i am trying to kick the habit. It is almost impossible to exercise on a regular basis and smoke! And I really love exercise. I am NOT willing to give it up for anything!0 -
I don't think they'll work, tabacco co. Are going go have to pay more for packaging and so the consumer will pay more. In that sense it may deter some maybe. If i were a smoker I would just get a cigarette case like the ones in classic movies when smoking was still cool and I would toss the nasty looking carton.0
-
I dont look at the pack! I enjoy smoking & its the only thing I havent had to give up so a new pack or a higher price isnt going to bother me. We are all going to die of something, might as well go peaceful.0
-
They already do this in canada where cigarettes are a lor more expensive and plenty of canadians still smoke.0
-
I think the FDA is smart enough to know that these package changes are unlikely to make a dramatic difference in current smokers' habits. I am assuming the real goal is to keep people from starting to smoke in the first place. Assuming people will quit something just because they know it's bad for them is silly. I think they'll deter some young people from starting and *hopefully* encourage some to quit.0
-
I'm a smoker and I could care less what the package looked like. What really makes me mad is how the government, media, whoever it is, is picking on smokers. What about alcoholics? Are they going to start putting pictures of diseased livers, people puking, or other drunken events of the like on the bottles? What about people who abuse household products? Are they going to begin putting photos of obese people on fast food wrappers? Where will it stop? It's no wonder other countries think we're so damned stupid, because our own government finds it necessary to put PICTURES on cigarette packs!!! It's not a f*cking pop-up book. We know what the risks are.0
-
I don't think the pictures will motivate established smokers to quit unless they're already trying. I do think they might scare kids and prevent a few of them from lighting up in the first place though. My son is younger, but if he was 12 or 13 and got his hands on a pack of cigarettes, I'd be happy to have those pics on the label.0
-
This won't help much. I agree with the guy at the end of the video who suggested that the government raise the taxes on cigarettes to worldwide levels or to the level they were taxed in the 1950's. This would bring in billions in tax revenues & save the same in health care costs when people who can't afford it quit. That would be MUCH smarter and more effective!0
-
smoking has declined in canada. but whether or not that is because of graphic images is up for debate. it could just be because people are educating themselves more. i don't really know.
We've had these graphic labels in Canada for few years now.
EVERY DAY I was opening up a new pack. Of course I looked at those pictures. Did it stop me RIGHT THEN. nope.
But day after day, looking at the pictures, looking at the heart, the lungs. the teeth, the limp d!ck, the babies.
I was a 25 year smoker. I used to smoke 750 smokes a month.( I challenge any smoker to stop saying how much they have each day, and change it to how much they have each month)
I quit 4 months ago. Did the graphic images cause me to quit. Not totally.
Did they help me, influence and educate me more. Yeppers!0 -
I'm a smoker and I could care less what the package looked like. What really makes me mad is how the government, media, whoever it is, is picking on smokers. What about alcoholics? Are they going to start putting pictures of diseased livers, people puking, or other drunken events of the like on the bottles? What about people who abuse household products? Are they going to begin putting photos of obese people on fast food wrappers? Where will it stop? It's no wonder other countries think we're so damned stupid, because our own government finds it necessary to put PICTURES on cigarette packs!!! It's not a f*cking pop-up book. We know what the risks are.
I was about to go there. I was thinking about people who are overweight and choose to eat foods that will just worsen their health, alcoholics, people on meth, and so on. What gets me to stay away from alcohol is when a drunk driver hit my parents. They're alive, yes, but it placed a scar on my mind that I will never forget. I have never seen my parents as hurt as they were then. The man who hit them said he wasn't even drunk, but it's enough to scare me. The situation even helped some of my friends put the bottle down.
I think things that hit closer to home are what really make the difference.0 -
When will they start putting pictures of fat people on Pizza, hamburgers, soda and candy bars?0
-
I'm a smoker and I could care less what the package looked like. What really makes me mad is how the government, media, whoever it is, is picking on smokers. What about alcoholics? Are they going to start putting pictures of diseased livers, people puking, or other drunken events of the like on the bottles? What about people who abuse household products? Are they going to begin putting photos of obese people on fast food wrappers? Where will it stop? It's no wonder other countries think we're so damned stupid, because our own government finds it necessary to put PICTURES on cigarette packs!!! It's not a f*cking pop-up book. We know what the risks are.
Couldn't have said it better myself.0 -
here are the ones that didn't make the cut
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/21/rejected-cigarette-warnings_n_881527.html#s2958860 -
What really makes me mad is how the government, media, whoever it is, is picking on smokers.0
-
Maybe, just maybe, it will stop a few kids from lighting up in the first place. If they don't start, there's no need to quit. That would be nice, even if it was just a few. Maybe.0
-
I don't know. I remember as a kid when they would bring in the emphysema-ridden lungs in the big glass case and make us look at them and explain that this was what smoking did to your lungs. I still smoked for several years.
People aren't really going to look at them. I never really looked at my packs when they didn't have them, I would only be encouraged further not to look at it or read their warnings.
As for kids ... I don't think they're going to care, mostly. They're told how awful smoking is from day one, shown all sorts of images and they still smoke. Cost is the only thing to make it even slightly prohibitive, and personally I don't think that's fair to adults who should have the choice.0 -
I think the only way to make people stop smoking is to hike the price. The kids won't be able to afford it. It seem to be part of the solution from what I have seen here in Canada.0
-
I think the only way to make people stop smoking is to hike the price. The kids won't be able to afford it. It seem to be part of the solution from what I have seen here in Canada.
In Ontario we have an "Ontario smoke free act".
Vendors aren't allowed to sell to anybody under 19, and check ID if they are under 25.
They also have to cover up their smokes behind the counter, and not be in view.0 -
Everyone who's ever gone to school has seen pictures like that, so why is putting the pictures on the pack going to do anything? Kids are already well-aware of the risks involved by the time they're like 8 years old.0
-
It just seems like a bunch of government employees trying to justify their jobs -- let's come up with some gross pics to put on cigarette boxes.
I used to smoke & knew the risks and effects but didn't care. Not only that, who sits there staring at their pack of smokes? I don't think smokers care less what's on the pack.0 -
It just seems like a bunch of government employees trying to justify their jobs0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions