Anybody doing whole Lent fast?!
Prayforya
Posts: 68 Member
So its 2 weeks into Lent and I know people usually "give up" something (i.e. meat, soda, etc). But is anybody else doing an actual Lenten fast? By that I mean no food from sun up (6a) to sun down (6p)?? Just water.
I'm wondering how that is going for anybody else? Especially if you work out too?! I know I'm not the only one...right?!
I'm wondering how that is going for anybody else? Especially if you work out too?! I know I'm not the only one...right?!
0
Replies
-
Nobody? Lol0
-
Heck to the NO! haha0
-
Only on Ash Wen and Good Fri.0
-
I did that two years ago. I made it 2-3 weeks. I definitely admire anyone who follows the Ramadan fasting now.0
-
Heck to the NO! haha
Hahaha!! So I've come to see!0 -
I am, but slightly adapted - I allow other sensible drinks between sunrise & sunset - I check the times daily.
So far, so good. It's really making me think about food differently, breaking the grazing habit! Yes I'm losing a bit of weight but that's not the primary reason for doing this. I don't fast on Sundays.
I'm a progressive Christian so I'm not doing it for tradition's sake either, pleased to find someone else who is going down this road.0 -
I have no problem with intermittent fasting, but to eat nothing from 6am-6pm, and for me then to have to squash my caloric intake into 4 hours before I go to bed would just not make sense for me. I have training goals I want to achieve and unless I wanted to train at 2am, which I don't, this would just not work for me. Just the thought of having to consume all my calories between 6pm-10pm and then go to bed makes me heave.0
-
My denomination doesn't celebrate Lent so I have never heard of the Lenten fast before. It sounds very difficult, but also like an experience that would mean more to me (if I did it) than other giving-up-for-Lent goals I've heard of. I hope it goes well for you!0
-
No way I would die Just on Ash Wed and Good Fri. Definitely the no meat on Friday though!0
-
I have done my best here so far and have been successful.. but again there are only two fasting days during lent ash Wednesday and good Friday.. all other Fridays are for abstaining from meat... you can by choice fast from good friday till easter to mark the suffering of Jesus.. I gave up the normal snacks, ice cream etc.. but also gave up time as in attending adoration more and daily mass more often0
-
My father used to do a whole lent fast. no food whatsoever all week, and one meal on sunday. he would drink tomato soup and hot chocolate throughout the week to keep him going but no actual food and no actual sit down meals. he had an entirely different wardrobe during those 40 days. as a kid you don't forget when your big, muscular Dad slims down rapidly and isn't eating. it was inspirational and I have friends who still talk about it when lent rolls around. he is now over 70 so doing that to his body is not possible.
Good luck with your fast. it sounds like you are dedicated and that is what this season is all about.0 -
No, but I did pack a tofu lunch today0
-
I give up wine for Lent every year, that is torture enough for me. I have no problem not eating for 12 hrs, so I don't see the point.
0 -
courtney_love2001 wrote: »No way I would die Just on Ash Wed and Good Fri. Definitely the no meat on Friday though!
This. I gave up coffee for lent. It was an addiction to me and I don't even crave it anymore.0 -
I forgot lent this year I am not catholic but I have always enjoyed the idea of breaking what we think are addictions for a period of time to remind myself that I control me. I usually give up all added sweetener or coffee. Im a little sad I didn't do it this year!0
-
I've never head of this kind of Lenten fast. I've heard of that for Ramadan.. But I thought Lent was more about no meat, nothing decadent, etc. if you're going to do it all. The Canadian Council of Catholic Bishops has listed only Ash Wednesday and Good Friday as official fast days.0
-
I've never head of this kind of Lenten fast. I've heard of that for Ramadan.. But I thought Lent was more about no meat, nothing decadent, etc. if you're going to do it all. The Canadian Council of Catholic Bishops has listed only Ash Wednesday and Good Friday as official fast days.
This. And even then, what Catholics define as a "fast" consists of just one meal a day, and it doesn't specify which meal or what time of day that should be. So technically you could go to Golden Corral, eat 4000 calories and still be within the guideline.0 -
I'm not Catholic and have never participated in lent in my life. I knew a guy when I was around 14 who fasted for lent (he was older). He originally would eat popsicles during the week, but started feeling like that was "cheating" so he cut that out and literally ate nothing all week. To my knowledge, he didn't eat on Sundays either, but I'm betting he probably had at least something once a week. By the end, he was skin and bones and very sickly looking. I don't know how he did it!!!0
-
I give up alcohol and sweets but I could not fast sun up to sun down. I admire those who can. I eat no meat on Fridays.0
-
I do, but not "only water" for the day.
I fast and have two small meals during the day and one larger meal in the evening. The two smaller meals must equal less than the one dinner meal when they are added together. Any beverage is okay, including a glass of milk. But not something that is supposed to replace a meal like a protein smoothie (which I have with my breakfast meal). No meat from birds or mammals, but I haven't had those in 20 years anyways as I am always a pescotarian (fish+vegetarian). So that one is easy for me.
Lent fasting is not really about "giving up" things, but taking away worldly distractions and focusing on God. Anyone who has health reasons not to fast is certainly excused (and can do other things during Lent). I didn't fast for 8 years as I was pregnant/breastfeeding almost continually during that time. I still refrained from desserts, attended extra prayer services and mass times, and spent the time of Lent examining my heart and growing closer to God.
Hope that helps. God bless you!
P.S. (It doesn't matter that Lent is partly over. Start when you can.) Also, Sunday afternoon we have family meal in the afternoon- around 2-3 p.m. with my whole family and my in-laws. That day is somewhat exempt. Just don't go crazy and eat all day long. That isn't the spirit of the fast.
As for dieting and loosing weight, yes, I am trying to do that, too. Lent helps me refocus my junk food cravings to being prayerful instead. Healthy habits I start in Lent follow me for months afterwards (although I usually regress later on... and gain weight... I struggle with Depression and my weight yo-yos with how I am feeling. I have gained, lost, gained, and am working on re-losing 60 lbs. in the last 5 years! So frustrating).
0 -
My weight is already low so adding fasting will put me in a stretcher and unable to function or do my workouts. I have almost a 12 hours fasting time between dinner and next day breakfast and that is all that I can handle. I don't eat red meat too much and I like fish so eating it on Fridays is not a problem, so probably doesn't count as a deed during Lent. Oh well!0
-
I'm Eastern Orthodox. We eat basically a vegan diet during Lent (or we're supposed to -- I haven't been very good at it in recent years): nothing with a backbone, no dairy, no olive oil or wine (because both were traditionally kept in animal skins). There's no Ash Wednesday; we have Meatfare Sunday, which is the last day to eat meat, followed by Cheesefare Sunday, the last day to eat dairy and clean out the fridge.0
-
Holly_Roman_Empire wrote: »I've never head of this kind of Lenten fast. I've heard of that for Ramadan.. But I thought Lent was more about no meat, nothing decadent, etc. if you're going to do it all. The Canadian Council of Catholic Bishops has listed only Ash Wednesday and Good Friday as official fast days.
This. And even then, what Catholics define as a "fast" consists of just one meal a day, and it doesn't specify which meal or what time of day that should be. So technically you could go to Golden Corral, eat 4000 calories and still be within the guideline.
Different councils recommend different things. I looked it up this year (because my memory is terrible) and it said one regular meal (which I would interpret as <4000 calories, more like 500-700 since that's what I eat for a meal typically) and two small snacks that when added up do not equal a meal. I turned it into a really small meal and a regular meal without snacks.0 -
The purpose of Lent is not to lose weight. It's a religious observance that, (in great generalities), by self denial, prayer and atonement you are better purifying yourself to prepare for the arrival of God (Easter). Not only are you supposed to be following a straighter and narrower path regarding food and drink, you should all be involved in prayer/meditation/contemplation, and also atonement, giving to others, the poor, the hungry, etc. This concept has varied over the centuries depending on who wrote it, it's not actually in the Bible.
Its based on pagan ritual like much of the traditions of Christianity. I'll let you go research that on your own. Maybe that's a good thing to do for Lent, discover why you're doing it.
And maybe the self sacrifice and giving to others the excess of your life is a general goodness one should do on a regular basis, something I always thought Christianity was supposed to encompass.
0 -
I'm Catholic, so we are all into Lent, but I've never heard of doing that. Is it some rip-off of Ramadan?0
-
The meaning of lent is to lose thyself, to defeat the Fleshly desires of this world, total oblation of the inner self, to find thyself dwelling in the Oneness of God. A journey to purity.
As far as Ramadan goes, the muslim way did not come about till nearly seven hundred years after Christ Jesus, and the building of his church, which, that in fact is the Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. The one true faith that Christ Jesus formed, this side of heaven.
May God bless all of you abundantly throughout this Lenton journey, and may all receive total absolution on devine mercy sunday.
it is real, God given, may you seek this out today.0 -
chandanista wrote: »My denomination doesn't celebrate Lent so I have never heard of the Lenten fast before. It sounds very difficult, but also like an experience that would mean more to me (if I did it) than other giving-up-for-Lent goals I've heard of. I hope it goes well for you!
I'm Catholic and have observed Lent (not "celebrated Lent" -- it's a time of penitence and reflection in preparation for Easter) my whole life, and I have never heard of dawn-to-dusk fast as part of Lent. That sounds like Ramadan. For all of my life, the requirement for days of fasting during Lent (which are only Ash Wednesday and Good Friday) have been one full meal, plus two smaller meals that together do not equal a full meal. And even historically when fasting was observed throughout Lent, and it was only one meal (no smaller meals), there was no dawn-to-dusk component to it that I ever heard of (i.e., you didn't start gorging yourself when the sun went down), which is probably why the definition of "fast" allowed for having one meal.0 -
starwhisperer6 wrote: »I forgot lent this year I am not catholic but I have always enjoyed the idea of breaking what we think are addictions for a period of time to remind myself that I control me. I usually give up all added sweetener or coffee. Im a little sad I didn't do it this year!
Don't be sad. Since you're not doing it as a religious observance, you could do it any time--now, next month, for the six weeks before your birthday, etc.
You might want to think of a different name for it, since appropriating the name of what is for some a solemn religious observance for your own period of self-improvement might be offensive to some people.0 -
No, and I'm not sacrificing any goats or sons, or stoning any adulterers either.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions