Do you eat the calories you are burning from exercise?
LilaIoannidou
Posts: 8 Member
Well, do you? 
0
Replies
-
Some, yes. I try to keep weight loss at about 1-2 lbs a week max. So If I'm losing more, I up my calories. I'm burning close to 4-5K cals a week in wilful exercise.
Fuel your efforts.0 -
Not always and not all of them.0
-
Depends. While I was losing weight, I aimed to "eat back" about 50% of my calories burned which seems to be fairly common around here. The rationale is that you are fueling your body for activity, while also accounting for a margin of error in calculating calorie burn.
Now that I'm maintaining, I generally eat back 75% or more of my calories.0 -
The short answer is yes. If you are using MFP as designed, you are expected to eat calories back. That should ideally bring you back to the deficit you signed on for.
However, calorie burns are estimates. Activity level is a range (not 1 number). Food logging, some people are not terribly accurate.
Find out what works best for you. I try to eat 100% of eat my calories back (by my estimate). Because the closer you get to goal, the more likely you are to lose lean muscle mass. I want fat loss, not weight loss.0 -
Yes, but I don't add them back and eat them that day. I estimate my total maintenance calories based on my activity level. I think it's undermining your fitness goals not to take activity into account. My maintenance if sedentary is about 1650 calories, but I'm not sedentary, so eating as if I were would be a bad and unhealthy idea.0
-
The short answer is yes. If you are using MFP as designed, you are expected to eat calories back. That should ideally bring you back to the deficit you signed on for.
However, calorie burns are estimates. Activity level is a range (not 1 number). Food logging, some people are not terribly accurate.
Find out what works best for you. I try to eat 100% of eat my calories back (by my estimate). Because the closer you get to goal, the more likely you are to lose lean muscle mass. I want fat loss, not weight loss.
+1!0 -
Yes, yes I do. It's the biggest perk of exercising.0
-
No, but I increased my calorie goal to account for that fact. (so in a way - yes I do, but I don't log them and then eat them.)0
-
I am currently trying to lose body fat and weight, so I eat back about 50% of my calories Monday thru Saturday. On Sunday I try to do a double workout which I turn into a refeed. I will usually end of eating back all of my calories on that day. Once I reach my initial body fat goal, 18%, I will switch up. My plan is to eat back all of my calories from working out, pushing to hit 13% body fat.0
-
Yes I do. Granted I have an activity tracker that adjusts my calories up or down as needed in the form of an exercise adjustment. I tried not eating them once and it resulted in constant fatigue, my mood was crap (really irritable), and my workouts suffered. Week 1 went okay but week 2-3 is when I really started to feel it. At the time MFP had my goal at 1370 calories before exercise/activity adjustments and I was working out about 8 + hrs a week.0
-
Yes. For all the good reasons above.
Why would I want to be thin, unhealthy, weak as a kitten, sick all the time, with a low bone density and fuzzy head when taking a bit longer to lose the weight by eating back those needed calories would help alleviate all those problems?
Cheers, h.0 -
I eat a portion of them back. This is a big part of the reason I do cardio - I like to eat
How I used to do it is take whatever MFP gives me for a calorie burn, and change it to 75% of that. This worked for me for some time.
However, since I've started running/training more frequently, I've seen a decrease in weight loss. I recently changed my logging to 50% of the MFP calorie burn to see if that helps.0 -
Most of the time yes. I go by what my Fitbit gives me and almost never log exercise manually though. If I logged all of my martial arts workouts my calorie adjustments would be far too high and I would probably eat back 1/3-1/2 of that. I just don't log them.
0 -
I joined my fitness pal, I always workout at least 6 times a week, run/ elliptical 45 minutes and circuit hard core for 45 min every other daily. But my question is what activity level am I ? I have 2 choices, ' active' or 'highly active'. Then my friend said NOT to input my estimated calorie burn. I could easily burn 450 in one workout session then I walk a ton for my sales position. I'm unsure what my settings should be, I'm 145 and I want to be 134 before my wedding may 200
-
LilaIoannidou wrote: »Well, do you?
If I'm hungry0 -
I do because the mere thought of maintaining my weight on 1200 calories for the next 30-40 years is pathetic.0
-
-
Thank you for your input? Any other advice on " activity" level you selected and inputting calorie burn or one over the other?0
-
Well if I input
" active" only
Loose 2 pounds / week
Add- 400 activity calorie burn
Then my consumption is 1600 calories per day IF I input exercise0 -
It depends. If I'm hungry, I'll eat them. If I'm not, I don't.
I probably eat about 1200-1300 calories a day tracked, so my exercise calories really act for a buffer for inconsistencies in logging (ie underestimating what has been eaten).0 -
I have not been eating my calories back. That is a great question. I'm on a 1,500 caloric diet which consist of 47% comimg from carbs, 22% from protein and 30% from fat. I've lost nearly 5 lbs which put me on target to lose 25 lbs before my trip to Greece this summer. The nutritionist stated I only needed to eat one carb to refuel after discussing the type of exercises I would be participating in. I was extremely sleepy around 2 pm today. I wonder does that have anything to do with me not eating those calories that I burned during exercise.0
-
ncboiler89 wrote: »
If I don't eat exercise calories, yes. If I stopped walking and went back to sitting at the computer for 16 hours, sleeping the remainder 8, and moving as little as possible. My current maintenance using Fitbit TDEE is 1950-2100, depending on if I did a workout or not.0 -
Yes. Sometimes I'll eat 50% sometimes I'll eat 100%, but it just really depends on how I feel.0
-
It depends. After hard workouts, absolutely. I'm a triathlete, I just completed my first half-marathon, and I hope to do a lot of cycling this summer. I train for endurance, and my body needs that fuel to rebuild and repair. For shorter, less intense workouts, I don't.
Because my Garmin 910 measures my heart rate, it seems to do a really good job of estimating calories burned. If anything, it's a little stingy. That helps keep me from eating too much post-workout.0 -
Yes - I would waste away if I didn't.
Beside I like both exercise and food.0 -
I eat back half. I tried not to at first, but that was a silly mistake. I was tired and hungry. Work hard, eat a little more- it's glorious! 0
-
I totally eat my excersize calories. I call it "buying calories"0
-
No, cause I want to lose weight fast.0
-
If you're attempting to lose weight then NO. Why would you eat back calories when you're trying to be in a deficit. Use cardio as a tool. If you're eating 1500 calories and losing weight without cardio then you don't really need to be on the cardio grind.0
-
If you're attempting to lose weight then NO. Why would you eat back calories when you're trying to be in a deficit.
Because as long as you set up your calculations correctly MFP already sets you at a deficit guaranteed to help you lose weight in a sustainable and healthy manner of up to 2lb/week which is what most Drs recommend for people with a lot to lose.
I eat back some of my calories, usually about 50%, because the tools are not always accurate, but sometimes more if I'm feeling hungry.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions