How much cardio vs. strength
RespectTheKitty
Posts: 1,667 Member
I do a lot of cardio. I do 45-60 minutes, 5-6 times a week on the elliptical or walking/jogging. I like doing a lot of cardio because I like a good calorie burn. But it has occurred to me that I might be doing too much cardio and not enough strength training. I only do what I could consider the bare minimum of strength training, mostly because I really don't like lifting. So I usually only do about 20-25 minutes twice a week for strength.
My trouble is, I only get a set amount of time for my workouts since I work out on my lunch hour. On the days I do strength, I'll cut my cardio minutes slightly to have more time for weights. My question is, what would your opinions be on the best way to split my time between cardio and strength? Would a shorter cardio session followed by a slightly longer strength session be better? How may times per week is best for doing strength? Keep in mind that I don't particularly like strength training, so I'd like to keep it short. What about 40 minutes cardio/15 minutes strength per day, focusing on different muscle groups each day?
I'm curious to hear what you all have to say. How do you split your cardio and strength?
My trouble is, I only get a set amount of time for my workouts since I work out on my lunch hour. On the days I do strength, I'll cut my cardio minutes slightly to have more time for weights. My question is, what would your opinions be on the best way to split my time between cardio and strength? Would a shorter cardio session followed by a slightly longer strength session be better? How may times per week is best for doing strength? Keep in mind that I don't particularly like strength training, so I'd like to keep it short. What about 40 minutes cardio/15 minutes strength per day, focusing on different muscle groups each day?
I'm curious to hear what you all have to say. How do you split your cardio and strength?
0
Replies
-
I guess if you do cardio because you like doing cardio, then keep on keeping on. But if you do that much cardio because you are trying to improve your physique, there are much more effective ways of doing that.
Strength training should be the focus, and any cardio should be short sessions (30 mins max) of HIIT cardio. I do 2 total hours of cardio a week (4 thirty minute sessions), always HIIT. If it were me, I would say swap the length of cardio vs. strength training.
When you say you don't like strength training, what is it that you don't like? Because its possible the type of strength training you're doing could be improved, and maybe you'd like that better. Also, maybe you'll like it better when you start seeing the results.
Good luck!0 -
I'll be honest... the reason I don't like strength training is because I feel like a dumba$$ when I lift. I feel like everyone is staring at me, whereas with cardio I can just put on my tunes and zone out.0
-
Following because I am in a similar situation and I would like to see what others say about this!0
-
If you strength train hard enough you will get some cardio out if it.
Weight training burns much more calories (for the time invested) than treadmills, ellipticals, and the like.
Warm up/cool down by jumping rope, stretching, yoga, kettebells, swimming; something that is full-body. And lift heavy.
Some research shows that stretching AFTER lifting is more beneficial than stretching before.
A program like Starting Strength, StrongLifts 5x5 or Wendler's 5/3/1 might be good places to start.
I am in and out of the gym in under 30 minutes and that includes warming up.
If you are self-conscious about people starting at you, then that is a different issue.
Maybe schedule some time with a trainer to build some confidence and learn to do basic lifts safety and correctly.
For the record, I recommend free weights over machines, but do what works for you.
Do not waste energy doing cardio BEFORE you lift either. If you want to jog, do that afterwards.
Just My Opinion. Good luck with your training.0 -
If you feel like a goof when you lift, I'd definitely recommend getting one or two short sessions with a trainer to work on form and help you find a few lifting sets you don't hate and work for your body and your goals. Also - circuits! Way more interesting and a better workout than just lifting, and you get some cardio too.
I'm lucky enough to have both a well equipped work gym and a trainer on staff, and a couple of 30 minute sessions left me feeling a lot more confident that I wasn't going to hurt myself and to use free weights instead of the silly machines. But I actually really enjoy doing a strength and cardio circuit type workout.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
You don't say what your goals are, but generally speaking cardio, as the name implies, is for cardiovascular health. If you want to improve your physique and body composition, you need strength training.0
-
Sorry, I should have specified -- I'm currently in the process of losing fat. I've lost 21 pounds so far by watching calories and doing cardio, and I have a ways to go still (about 40 more pounds). My main goal is to lose fat, but I don't want to neglect my muscle tone.0
-
RespectTheKitty wrote: »Sorry, I should have specified -- I'm currently in the process of losing fat. I've lost 21 pounds so far by watching calories and doing cardio, and I have a ways to go still (about 40 more pounds). My main goal is to lose fat, but I don't want to neglect my muscle tone.
Then cut back a little on cardio, get on a structured lifting program, continue your deficit and eat sufficient protein. You still get your cardio, but you are making sure to have less muscle loss. End result will be better physique/body composition.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This is all great advice. So it looks like I definitely need to up my strength training. I may still have one free session with a trainer at my gym left -- gonna use it!0
-
I'm 42, and I used to lift a lot. I have arthritis in my shoulder and some spinal degeneration, so every time I try to get back into lifting some sort of pain issue crops up again, which has really soured me on it of late. One thing that has never caused me pain is cardio. So, I focus on that - I currently get about 40-50 minutes of intensive cardio on a daily basis (plus walking 1-2 times per day as well). I can run a 10K in about 45 minutes currently, and am looking ahead to a half-marathon before the end of the year.
A lot of people here poo-poo people who do cardio-only exercise programs. If you're into getting that aesthetically sculpted physique, sure, weight training along with fat loss is awesome. Also, if you're an older adult, there's something to be said for progressive resistance training, as it tends to prevent injuries due to falls.
Aside from all of that, to my mind, the real issue is finding a kind of exercise you like and getting really good at it. I'm really good at running (I also have an exercise bike as well which I also use), so I do it a lot. I get the benefit of significant calorie burns (so I get to eat more.... wheee!) and I also have a resting heart rate that's trending into the high 40s at this point. I'm extremely fit right now - more so than I've ever been (current stats - six-foot two, 185 pound male. Notoriously inaccurate FitBit Aria has my body fat % bouncing around a 10% range).
I may try and take up weight training again in the future (probably with the help of a personal trainer who could help to work around my musculoskeletal issues). But I have zero issues with anyone who chooses a cardio-only program for whatever reason. In fact, my personal physician (who is also a pulmonologist) says that he thinks cardio should be the main priority of anyone doing exercise programs - as having a fit cardiovascular system is much more predictive of health and longevity than simply having muscle mass, which, aside from the value it has for looking pretty in a swimsuit and the above issue of how it may benefit older adults, really doesn't add that much to health or longevity.
At least, that's his opinion. Sounds good to me.0 -
-
If you're trying to lose weight, I'd cut back on the cardio. By A LOT, actually. Like @arditarose said, get on an actual strength program (Starting Strength and Stronglifts 5x5 are popular beginner choices), eat your protein and continue with your calorie deficit. Then if your weight loss stalls, grafually add a little bit of cardio.
Jeff Nippard had a podcast a few weeks ago with Lyle McDonald and they went deep into the details of weight loss and exercise for women specifically, and why cardio should be your last priority. It's on youtube, if you care to look it up.0 -
fatfudgery wrote: »If you're trying to lose weight, I'd cut back on the cardio. By A LOT, actually. Like @arditarose said, get on an actual strength program (Starting Strength and Stronglifts 5x5 are popular beginner choices), eat your protein and continue with your calorie deficit. Then if your weight loss stalls, grafually add a little bit of cardio.
Jeff Nippard had a podcast a few weeks ago with Lyle McDonald and they went deep into the details of weight loss and exercise for women specifically, and why cardio should be your last priority. It's on youtube, if you care to look it up.
Yeah, my advice would be to cut back a lot too but, I know some people like it...........
And that podcast is amazing. I listened twice lol.0 -
I'll definitely look that podcast up.0
-
Dude, you're a rail!!!!!0 -
arditarose wrote: »Then cut back a little on cardio, get on a structured lifting program, continue your deficit and eat sufficient protein. You still get your cardio, but you are making sure to have less muscle loss. End result will be better physique/body composition.
I second this. I have been doing this...20-30 minutes of cardio 2x/week, following a lifting program 45-60 minutes 5x/week and have lost 35 pounds doing so and more inches than I EVER have when trying to lose in the past.
0 -
I love strength training and it's what most of my workouts consist of now, but when I started out, I also did a lot of cardio just because I had no idea what I was doing in the weight room. I got started by scoping out what people were doing while I was on the elliptical. Then I started using the machines. Then I started checking out group fitness classes where I could learn the basic movements. Then I found a class instructor I really liked and asked her to show me around the weight room and give me some ideas on what to do, including starting weights and making sure my form was good. Now I have a decent foundation, but sometimes go to YouTube or Pinterest for ideas of other exercises to try.0
-
What is your goal? I think that would be the deciding factor of how much to do cardio vs strength.
For instance, winter months I am in the gym 4 days a week lifting heavy and only two days a week of cardio. Summer months it's the opposite. 4 days a week of cardio and full core workouts 2 days a week. Spring months is for cutting, so half cardio half strength. Fall is to gain speed, half cardio half strength, but focusing on HIIT and and complexes.
If you only want to look good in a swimsuit, maybe a little more strength training than cardio, but don't drop cardio altogether.0 -
Cardio and Strength are all a function of what your goals are... Bodybuilders do much less cardio than people who run Spartan races or do events based on endurance. Also... what are your goals for your body? To look good in a dress or pants?
I personally feel that diet is HUGE for everyone... and water intake is also HUGE... and Sleep as well...
What I have found works for me (my goal is to look and perform like an athlete not a bodybuilder)... So I do cardio before a weighted workout.... never by time (I dont say I did 30 minutes on the treadmill).. I say I ran 3 miles in 21 minutes... then I go workout.. When I workout I do circuits... usually 3 exercises per circuit... 1 push..1 pull... and 1 core or ab... I will do 3 circuits... and then jump back on the treadmill and do 1 or 2 more miles jogging... Usually this takes about an hour and a half.. and I sweat the entire time...
Now... this will NOT build huge muscle... but it will make strength and endurance...
Lots of cardio will eat away muscle mass... Lots of muscle will make your cardio bad... You need a happy medium... Test out different regimens0 -
chunky_pinup wrote: »arditarose wrote: »Then cut back a little on cardio, get on a structured lifting program, continue your deficit and eat sufficient protein. You still get your cardio, but you are making sure to have less muscle loss. End result will be better physique/body composition.
I second this. I have been doing this...20-30 minutes of cardio 2x/week, following a lifting program 45-60 minutes 5x/week and have lost 35 pounds doing so and more inches than I EVER have when trying to lose in the past.
Yeah, that's a similar breakdown to what I did when I started and the body composition results were insane. I eventually eliminated the cardio all together but admittedly I liked a little when I first started, so I could eat a bit more.0 -
JZ_Evolution_Mark2 wrote: »Lots of cardio will eat away muscle mass...
Is there any real proof of this? I hear everywhere that "cardio is catabolic" - but as long as a person isn't literally in starvation mode, I don't see why long-distance runners and intensive cardio-only folks don't metabolize carbs then fat like everyone else.
Humans are designed to be long-distance runners and always on their feet. If it was easy for lots of constant movement to waste away our muscles, I can't see how we would have survived as a species.
0 -
JZ_Evolution_Mark2 wrote: »Lots of cardio will eat away muscle mass...
Is there any real proof of this? I hear everywhere that "cardio is catabolic" - but as long as a person isn't literally in starvation mode, I don't see why long-distance runners and intensive cardio-only folks don't metabolize carbs then fat like everyone else.
Humans are designed to be long-distance runners and always on their feet. If it was easy for lots of constant movement to waste away our muscles, I can't see how we would have survived as a species.
Long-distance runners? Maybe long-distance walkers is a better phrase. We are probably better designed to sprint to a big stick or rock to throw. Always on their feet? Yes. Smarter at figuring out how to hide from predators.
I prefer a sprinter to a marathoner any day. Sprinters seem to be lean and hold onto lots of muscle very well. Marathoners seem to be very lean.
0 -
I'm close to 50 and think more about what's sustainable over a lifetime, and life is a marathon, not a sprint. Jogging added muscle to my legs, yoga added muscle to my arms and back, and both of these feel like they support my health without tearing me up. Yes I do lift too, some. And sprint, sort of, some. But the bulk of the exercise I do is more gentle and sustainable, stuff I can do for years and years and years. I remember in Jazzercise we had not one, not two, but three ladies over 80 years old in the class, dancing and having fun.
What you enjoy is what you will keep doing. Exercise has to fit into your life.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I typically do cardio before my weight routine because I like the high it gives and puts me in a good mental state to lift. I do about 40 minutes of intervals on the AMT machine and then fitness model workout (one body part a day) afterwards. I need the extra amount of time for cardio because I'm so used to it now. Everyone is different. Most would say to cut back on cardio and focus on strength training but it all depends on the results you're trying to achieve. My recommendation, if you're loosing weight, you should focus more on strength training to retain muscle mass or even build some because muscle is what burns the most fat but if you enjoy doing cardio, do what you enjoy because that's what's going to keep you going back for more.0
-
I'm actually going to ask my trainer this tomorrow. Currently I swim laps 6 times a week for 45-60 minutes and its been doing well by me in my weight loss journey; however, I do feel like I've plateaued so I hired a trainer who does resistance training with me in the pool. I would like to start doing cardio outside of the pool and doing some weights; but I'm not sure how much or what to do... I'll share his thoughts as soon as I can... but really want to follow this thread as well
0 -
RespectTheKitty wrote: »I'll be honest... the reason I don't like strength training is because I feel like a dumba$$ when I lift. I feel like everyone is staring at me, whereas with cardio I can just put on my tunes and zone out.
I used to think the same thing...and then I found out, no one is watching. Strength training takes focus. Don't let the other people in the gym intimidate you. Most everyone is into their own thing.0 -
And I think you'll find that the stronger you get, the easier the cardio gets.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions