Talk to me about fitbits

ajc1309
ajc1309 Posts: 255 Member
edited December 1 in Health and Weight Loss
I'm really wanting one but I have no idea which to get. What's the difference between them all? I'm hoping that getting one will motivate me as all I want to do these days is eat. Especially since I work between a subway and mcdonalds so it's so easy just to go in a have lunch at one of them. :(
«1

Replies

  • kristieshannon
    kristieshannon Posts: 160 Member
    I love mine. I have the flex. It's really motivating to set and then meet step goals each day. It also gives you other day such as calorie burns, sleep times, and exerercise tracking. I know there are more expensive models that track heart rates and more, but the flex has been great for me.
  • heatherheyns
    heatherheyns Posts: 144 Member
    The kind you want depends on what you want out of it. The charge hr is a nice choice because it does the heart rate and displays important information. A flex doesn't do heart rate, but is slimmer. An Alta will do what the flex does, but have a nicer display. A surge is more for running, since it has built in GPS. The new Blaze has hr and a nicer display. They all measure steps and estimate calorie burn. Best buy will often have a display set up so you can try on the different models and see what you feel like fitd the best ( some think the Blaze or surge are too bulky and uncomfortable).
  • I_Will_End_You
    I_Will_End_You Posts: 4,397 Member
    I have a Fitbit One. I like it because it's small and I can clip it on my body, or just put it in my pocket. I don't like the ones you have a wear on your wrist all of the time. With the One, I can almost always find a way to wear it and don't have to worry how it looks with clothes. It seems pretty accurate, and is definitely a motivator for me to be more active.
  • BeYouTiful94
    BeYouTiful94 Posts: 289 Member
    It depends on you and your lifestyle and what you want the tracker for. I have the Charge HR. It's nice to see my daily activity and it keeps me motivated to get up and get those last few hundred steps, or to take the stairs instead of the elevator so that I can reach 10 floors for the day, etc. I also like that I can look at my relative HR during cardio and such. Disclaimer, it's not the best for any cardio or exercise that isn't steady state. It'll give wacky readings. All HRM Fitbits will.

    The One is good if you don't want to wear a big ole wristband all around. It's easy to hide. The Flex is nice because it's thin and has lots of colorful band choices. The screen doesn't show anything but dots (one for each 2000 steps until you reach the 10,000, I believe). Flex also doesn't have an altimeter so it won't track stairs. Charge is like the Charge HR but without HR. Tracks steps, stairs, sleep, exercise, calories, etc. Charge HR, of course, adds in HR monitoring, and also tracks resting HR. Surge does everything the Charge HR does but adds in GPS. It's more for runners. Blaze does everything the HR does and has a fancy screen. Blaze and Surge are both huge. The Blaze seems more like it was Fitbit's stab at a smart watch. Alta does everything the Flex does and is just as small, but has nice bands (bracelet-like, more professional looking), and the screen actually shows stats such as the number of steps and all that (not just dots). All Fitbits except the One (and Zip if they still have that) become super sketch when pushing things (like a basket at the grocery store or a baby stroller or something) because they go off of stride and that messes with the stride. One is much better equipped to handle that. One and Flex might have to be hooked up to update as far as the app and site go, even though the screen or dots will reflect daily activity. That's a maybe. I know my mom always has to plug up hers (she had a One and now has a Flex) for it to show on her phone and whatnot. The others all do Bluetooth for sure. Charge and Charge HR cannot change bands. The color and size you get is what you get. Flex and Alta have a plethora of bands for any mood. Not sure about Surge or Blaze.

    Also, visit Fitbit.com to find their comparison chart. It'll tell you more, though I understand that you wanted some personal experiences as well
  • maxit
    maxit Posts: 880 Member
    I use the One - I don't like things on my wrist, have no need for HR, and it has worked consistently for 2 years. I don't have to plug it in anywhere to sync - my phone app works fine, as does the blue tooth app for my computer.
  • BeYouTiful94
    BeYouTiful94 Posts: 289 Member
    maxit wrote: »
    I use the One - I don't like things on my wrist, have no need for HR, and it has worked consistently for 2 years. I don't have to plug it in anywhere to sync - my phone app works fine, as does the blue tooth app for my computer.

    Oh cool! I wasn't too sure on that one. For some reason, my mom always had/has to plug hers into some dongle thing on her laptop, and she has an iPhone 6+.

    Then again, she may just be charging it and I thought she was updating ... :D
  • kshama2001
    kshama2001 Posts: 28,052 Member
    edited April 2016
    After reading a ton of reviews for the different models on Amazon, I settled on the One and love it. I do find it motivational.

    I was sad when I saw it was sending about half the calories as what MFP had been calculating for walking, but I wasn't surprised as that goes along with what a lot of people say about the MFP burns being inflated.
  • thunder1982
    thunder1982 Posts: 280 Member
    I think @BeYouTiful94 has summed it up pretty well for you in terms of what does what.

    I have the surge (cause I wanted built in GPS) but it is bulky and the rubber band has worn in some areas and split underneath. Works fine though and I got an extended warranty so I am not too worried about it. Love that I can read a short text without going & getting my phone which make sup for some of the bulkiness.

    One other thing to keep in mind some people still get reactions to the rubber. I actually have 'burn' marks from the old force which doesnt exist now. If I dont regularly wash the strap of my surge I get a small rash near the strap holder where skin & other gunk collects. I think because of the rubber the skin etc sticks to the rubber in the crevices. A quick wash and its gone overnight. Mind you I also live in a tropical environment so more sweating than other locations.

  • forthemovies
    forthemovies Posts: 14 Member
    I got the Alta, simply because it's more stylish than the Flex. Have really increased my activity since getting it and love that it calculates my TDEE as the day goes on!

    I keep the Bluetooth off a majority of the time since I have no use for getting text/call notifications on my wrist. I sync it a few times a day to let it update my step count.
  • ForecasterJason
    ForecasterJason Posts: 2,577 Member
    I have a Fitbit One. I like it because it's small and I can clip it on my body, or just put it in my pocket. I don't like the ones you have a wear on your wrist all of the time. With the One, I can almost always find a way to wear it and don't have to worry how it looks with clothes. It seems pretty accurate, and is definitely a motivator for me to be more active.
    Same here. I've only had the One and for the most part I've been satisfied with it.

  • 100df
    100df Posts: 668 Member
    I have the Zip which counts steps. I don't think I exercise hard enough for my heart rate to matter. It was fairly cheap. I clip it to my waist band. It syncs nicely with my phone. It runs off a battery. Battery life is about 6 weeks. I have run mine through the laundry twice and it still works even though it isn't supposed to be waterproof. I have tested with a pedometer I have that uses a pebble bounce to count steps. They are always very close with step counts so I trust the accuracy. I trust the exercise calories it gives me or not.
  • biggsterjackster
    biggsterjackster Posts: 419 Member
    I have the Surge, love the extra features like reading my text messages.
  • lizwooshy
    lizwooshy Posts: 110 Member
    If you are going to use it SOLELY as a step counter, I would recommend downloading a free app for your phone (Pacer syncs with MFP) or getting a cheap old fasion waist pedometer. Save yourself a ton of money.

    It just depends on what your purpose is.
  • Tempest07
    Tempest07 Posts: 256 Member
    I just wanted the steps and heart rate so I got the Charge HR and it's great for my needs. I just enjoy looking at all my stats, and seeing where I can improve or go faster/longer during my workout sessions. Everyone here has good advice. Hope you find what works!

    https://www.fitbit.com/user/3HWMYN

    Feel free to add me. :)

    Brian
  • Colorscheme
    Colorscheme Posts: 1,179 Member
    Don't get the Charge, mine fell apart. I got the Alta, it's like the Charge but no stairs [I don't have stairs at my house] and it's thinner, which I like.
  • Colorscheme
    Colorscheme Posts: 1,179 Member
    edited April 2016
    I got the Alta, simply because it's more stylish than the Flex. Have really increased my activity since getting it and love that it calculates my TDEE as the day goes on!

    I keep the Bluetooth off a majority of the time since I have no use for getting text/call notifications on my wrist. I sync it a few times a day to let it update my step count.

    I can't sync on my phone without turning bluetooth on my phone even though I have the text/call notifications turned off.
  • forthemovies
    forthemovies Posts: 14 Member
    I got the Alta, simply because it's more stylish than the Flex. Have really increased my activity since getting it and love that it calculates my TDEE as the day goes on!

    I keep the Bluetooth off a majority of the time since I have no use for getting text/call notifications on my wrist. I sync it a few times a day to let it update my step count.

    I can't sync on my phone without turning bluetooth on my phone even though I have the text/call notifications turned off.

    I turn it on to sync a few times a day only. But I like keeping it off most of the time. It's like a fun surprise when you've added in 5,000 steps and get a jump in your TDEE (it also keeps you from obsessively checking).

    I never bothered setting up the call/text notifications. Bluetooth tends to drain my phone battery though and I almost never take it on walks...so it'd just be searching for a device that isn't near it.
  • DanaDark
    DanaDark Posts: 2,187 Member
    I got the Fitbit Flex.

    Simply having it on reminds me to move more.

    I am also super competitive and compete with my friends often for getting the most steps... I went from normally 2000-4000 steps a day to averaging 15,000 a day and sometimes going as far as 25,000 a day. HUGE difference for me.
  • lauraesh0384
    lauraesh0384 Posts: 463 Member
    edited April 2016
    I just ordered a Zip. I wanted the One, but the Zip is about 30 dollars cheaper. I wanted a Fit Bit to use strictly as a pedometer, so the other styles didn't appeal to me since the steps won't be accurate if you're using your arms and not actually walking. I have a cheap pedometer now and it works great, but I wanted one I could sync with MFP.
  • Linzon
    Linzon Posts: 294 Member
    I have a Flex but I keep it in my pocket because it wasn't tracking well on my wrist. Maybe I move my arms weird but when I was running it would miss half of my steps, and was iffy when pushing the stroller. Had I known that would be the case I would have just gotten the Zip. I've had it for a couple of years now and the calorie burn has proven accurate for me but I don't do a lot of high-impact exercise.
  • ajc1309
    ajc1309 Posts: 255 Member
    Thanks everyone. I want one for a lot of reasons. I need to lose the extra lbs I've put on and I feel like having one will make me want to watch what I'm eating more. Also at work I'm on my feet for about 10 hours, 5-6 days a week so it'll be cool to see how active I really am. Has anyone noticed that it's helped the with losing weight? My problem is I can't really fit exercising into my day anymore as I'm working all the time and am so tired when I get home.
  • Heartlight441
    Heartlight441 Posts: 278 Member
    I've got the charge HR and I LOVE it!!! I did a lot of research for what I wanted and read tons of reviews for them all. I know I wanted one that has a heart rate feature and I love the app I use with it on my phone and that it syncs with MFP. So happy with it! I do have my eye on the Blaze but I love gadgets and have started running, so someday.
  • ncfitbit
    ncfitbit Posts: 1,058 Member
    edited April 2016
    ajc1309 wrote: »
    Thanks everyone. I want one for a lot of reasons. I need to lose the extra lbs I've put on and I feel like having one will make me want to watch what I'm eating more. Also at work I'm on my feet for about 10 hours, 5-6 days a week so it'll be cool to see how active I really am. Has anyone noticed that it's helped the with losing weight? My problem is I can't really fit exercising into my day anymore as I'm working all the time and am so tired when I get home.

    Any fitbit is just a tool like any other that you can either use or not as you try to lose weight. For me, knowing my TDEE from day to day is extremely useful and having the fitbit sometimes makes the difference between keeping a deficit and not keeping one, but it won't keep me from overeating any more than my food scale because you can still ignore this data. I do think it's good for your situation because it's a great motivator for walking because you will see how important all those little steps are for adding to your daily calorie burn and if you've gone to the trouble of walking10,000 or 12,000 or whatever steps, you might be more inclined to log all your food and see exactly why you are or not losing weight. It keeps me from throwing in the towel when I can't get my regular workout in, too, which is running. I used to think oh well if I can't get a run in, how much could a little walk or two help, but it absolutely does add up.

    I have had all the fitbit models except the zip. I just got the Alta and am not quite sure yet about it's overall durability & features. I did like the stair climbing feature of the Charge I had so I've lost that with the Alta, but I really like a new feature on the Alta where it reminds you every hour if you haven't moved 250 steps. I didn't realize I ever went a whole hour without moving at all some days, but it will buzz and remind you to get those in before the end of the hour. I love that.
  • JessUK98
    JessUK98 Posts: 15 Member
    Have you considered getting a Jawbone Up instead? I was looking at getting either a Fitbit or a Jawbone. I narrowed it down to a Charge HR or an UP3 and went for a Jawbone UP3 in the end. I was mainly interested in the sleep function which is apparently better than the Fitbit version.
    A comparison review of the two is here; http://www.wareable.com/jawbone/jawbone-up3-v-fitbit-charge-hr-best-fitness-tracker-2015

    All depends what you want in the end, but I definitely recommend getting a tracker of some sort. Mine has kept me motivated and doing step duels with friends is fun (can you step dual on Fitbit?). The UP3 also just looks like a bracelet and isn't too bulky.
  • ajc1309
    ajc1309 Posts: 255 Member
    JessUK98 wrote: »
    Have you considered getting a Jawbone Up instead? I was looking at getting either a Fitbit or a Jawbone. I narrowed it down to a Charge HR or an UP3 and went for a Jawbone UP3 in the end. I was mainly interested in the sleep function which is apparently better than the Fitbit version.
    A comparison review of the two is here; http://www.wareable.com/jawbone/jawbone-up3-v-fitbit-charge-hr-best-fitness-tracker-2015

    All depends what you want in the end, but I definitely recommend getting a tracker of some sort. Mine has kept me motivated and doing step duels with friends is fun (can you step dual on Fitbit?). The UP3 also just looks like a bracelet and isn't too bulky.

    I have considered the Jawbone but after reading some reviews I'd rather go for the Fitbit, also at my job I deal with a lot of tech and the Jawbone has had a lot of customer complaints (mostly battery issues).
  • forthemovies
    forthemovies Posts: 14 Member
    ajc1309 wrote: »
    Thanks everyone. I want one for a lot of reasons. I need to lose the extra lbs I've put on and I feel like having one will make me want to watch what I'm eating more. Also at work I'm on my feet for about 10 hours, 5-6 days a week so it'll be cool to see how active I really am. Has anyone noticed that it's helped the with losing weight? My problem is I can't really fit exercising into my day anymore as I'm working all the time and am so tired when I get home.

    Mine has definitely kept me more active and motivated. I'll go for longer walks and create ways to have more activity. Parking at the far end of the lot may only be an extra hundred steps...but it adds up over time! The TDEE calculation is great because I know exactly how much I can eat based on my activity.

    Not sure how much I lost before getting it (I purchased a scale at the same time and did my first weigh in after almost a month of using MFP), but today's weigh in tells me I've lost 4.6 lbs since March 15! Right on track with my 1lb/week goal
  • Karihappy
    Karihappy Posts: 116 Member
    Have the Fitbit Charge HR and love it. :)

    5229779.png
  • haviegirl
    haviegirl Posts: 230 Member
    I have the One--it's great, but I've washed and dried it twice. I can't believe it still works, but it does! So overall I prefer my Charge HR and my Alta; since I wear them on my wrist, I'm never going to accidentally wash them. :) The Charge HR is my everyday Fitbit, the Alta is for when I'm dressed up.
  • kgirlhart
    kgirlhart Posts: 5,185 Member
    I have the One and I love it. Like several others I do not want to have to wear it on my wrist. I like being able to clip it on my bra or waist and forget about it. You can use a pedometer on your phone, but I don't always keep my phone on me so it misses a lot of steps for me. I got my One about halfway through my weight loss journey and I am still losing at the same rate. It does help me to stay motivated. I have a very sedentary job so I really have to work to get my steps in.
  • BurnWithBarn2015
    BurnWithBarn2015 Posts: 1,026 Member
    Maybe also consider a Misfit (Flash)
    Same as the Fitbit but water proof and much much cheaper ($29.99)

    Nice app
    steps
    syncs with MFP
    calorie burn
    sleep
    you can choose what kind o exercise you did
    etc etc

    I like mine a lot
This discussion has been closed.