Is it a bad idea to do a weigh in while on your period?

Kittieshocinski
Kittieshocinski Posts: 11 Member
edited September 28 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi guys! I don't know about everyone else, but I get so bloated when I am on my period!!!! It looks like I have gained 10 lbs! And sometimes, I do! It does go away after my period, but it is really discouraging when I weigh in that week. Any suggestions on beating the bloat or when I should weigh? Thanks GUYS!!!!

Replies

  • amerr
    amerr Posts: 190
    I weigh myself during my period, but just kind of ignore it knowing that I'll "lose weight" when it's over. I just don't record my weight the week I'm on my period.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    I weigh myself, but I never log it. I figure the number isn't accurate if I'm bloated, retaining water and such. I like to know what kind of weight I've gained during my period, but I don't count it against me (since I always lose it without a short time after ward). :)
  • dawnw30
    dawnw30 Posts: 270
    I just go with the flow (bad pun) and drink extra water to try and deal with the bloat. Honestly...it's a real bite in the butt - and I am trying to resign myself to the fact that my body goes through changes every month and there isn't much I can do about it but hang on for the ride. Afterwards any extra "bloat" weight usually goes away plus some so I guess it all works out in the end. And for the record - whatever idiot came up with the Have a Happy Period thing really needs to be shot!!

    Hang in there hon!! :flowerforyou:
  • sarah44254
    sarah44254 Posts: 3,078 Member
    I guess I am lucky because I have not once gained during that time. Though afterwards I lose a larger amount than average, so something is going on for sure.

    Personally I weigh myself every day, and post my weight here every Sunday. Be it a 'special' week or not, I'm putting that number in. Whether the number is bigger or smaller, I put that number in here! I want to look back and see my trends and what I ate during that time that might influence a gain/loss. So I try to stay consistent.

    I will admit, sometimes I put in my weight more than once a week if I see a large drop!! :)
  • PNWriter
    PNWriter Posts: 223 Member
    I weigh myself, too, during my period. I figure that if I stay true to my plan, then the gains are just interesting to keep track of. It amazes me that my body can gain 10 pounds during that week or so and then a couple days later it's gone plus at least another pound. Weird.
  • rfcollins33
    rfcollins33 Posts: 630
    Don't weigh in the week before or week of. I have had as much as 6 lbs extra weight bc of menstruation. And then right after, it and more weight was gone.
  • I weigh during mine and keep track, my weight fluctuates so darn much from week to week I like to have an idea of when and why
  • ehedges31
    ehedges31 Posts: 72
    Drink lemon water. Its a natural cleanser and will help rid the bloating (it helps in getting rid of excess salt/sodium that attributes to bloating).
  • I read a lot about people bloating and gaining lbs during their period, but I find I'm bloated and uncomfortable the week before and I lose it during. I've only experienced this since I turned 30 too, it didn't happen at all before.
  • Angela_MA
    Angela_MA Posts: 260
    I usually cannot weigh in the week before because that is when I will not see a change or an increase of up to 2lbs. After my period am usually down a pound or 2. I think it depends on everyone.
    Also, I think it is really up to you if you want to weighin our not. If the scales number will bother you if it goes up, then wait until after.
  • jennywrens
    jennywrens Posts: 208
    I weigh and log every week without fail .... I think its important to understand how your body works and if you're aware you gain 2lbs / 4lbs / 10lbs during your period then you can just account for it and move on!!
  • woja9640
    woja9640 Posts: 450 Member
    Make sure you take Midol.... it helps from water retention and bloating. I actually lost 2 lbs while on my period and it jump started me out of my plateau.

    Then again due to my obesity I haven't had a period in over a year. But still I have lost 3.5 lbs since my period 2 weeks ago.
  • melibea
    melibea Posts: 228
    I don't do it because I get so discouraged to see the gain (even if I'm 100% that it is water weight). So I just wait until the next week.
  • stephlake
    stephlake Posts: 105 Member
    I logged it this month bc I am in a weigh in challenge and I felt like a cheater when I considered leaving my weight alone. I figure next week I will be super excited because those three lbs will drop off in addition to any other weight I lose.
  • Sarah_uk
    Sarah_uk Posts: 209
    I weigh myself daily. This way I see the monthly gaining and losing it again pattern, up to 10 pounds with me!
  • dumb_blondes_rock
    dumb_blondes_rock Posts: 1,568 Member
    how can you guys retain water during your period???? All mine usually comes out in tears.....jkjk....its your own decision, if you see your number has gone up or has not gone down and it will discourage you, then don't do it.
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member
    I weigh myself every day and enter the figures into a spreadsheet which produces a graph. Because of this, the effects of events such as TOM are really obvious, and it's easy to see past that and get a clear picture of what the overall trend is doing.
  • lolathompson
    lolathompson Posts: 70 Member
    Thanks goodness for this blog. I weighed in today and I was a tiny bit discourage even though I know Ive been doing well. Still going strong. Toodles.
  • justimogen
    justimogen Posts: 76
    I just go with the flow (bad pun)

    Ha! :)

    I weigh myself just to be sure things are relatively "in check" but I expect at least a 3-5 pound gain from water retention and I don't beat myself up or change anything because of the numbers I see during that week.
  • Barneystinson
    Barneystinson Posts: 1,357 Member
    I weighed myself two days ago (off schedule from my normal Monday weigh-in) during TOM and noted a 4 pound gain. I'm not sure if this was just TOM or eating like crap last week while in Europe. Probably both.

    We'll see what happens on my Monday weigh-in after eating at regular calorie levels and working out consistently for 4 days with to TOM present.
  • woja9640
    woja9640 Posts: 450 Member
    I weighed myself two days ago (off schedule from my normal Monday weigh-in) during TOM and noted a 4 pound gain. I'm not sure if this was just TOM or eating like crap last week while in Europe. Probably both.

    We'll see what happens on my Monday weigh-in after eating at regular calorie levels and working out consistently for 4 days with to TOM present.

    I will just tell you ladies, I had a high enough BMI that my period just "stopped". Now being that I have a genetic disorder which causes early menopause if not no actual period due to low presence of estrogen and progestrone. However I was one of the lucky few who was able to go through adolescence without taking hormone replacment therapy. Anyway, I thought my disorder caused my lack of that TOM, however I was happily wrong.

    By losing 20 lbs, and 4 points off my BMI my period returned. Because I knew about water retention I took Midol and drank a cup of coffee a day.... the caffeine in both is a natural diuretc, which helps us get rid of waste, if you get what I mean and helps us get rid of the excess salt in our bodies that help us retain water.

    I actually wound up losing 2 more lbs while on my TOM.

    As for the Europen Food.... if you ate in France, Italy, Spain and England you know they serve rich food. The French and Italians are notorious for using copious amounts of buttered sauces and demiglaces, etc.
  • Barneystinson
    Barneystinson Posts: 1,357 Member
    I weighed myself two days ago (off schedule from my normal Monday weigh-in) during TOM and noted a 4 pound gain. I'm not sure if this was just TOM or eating like crap last week while in Europe. Probably both.

    We'll see what happens on my Monday weigh-in after eating at regular calorie levels and working out consistently for 4 days with to TOM present.

    I will just tell you ladies, I had a high enough BMI that my period just "stopped". Now being that I have a genetic disorder which causes early menopause if not no actual period due to low presence of estrogen and progestrone. However I was one of the lucky few who was able to go through adolescence without taking hormone replacment therapy. Anyway, I thought my disorder caused my lack of that TOM, however I was happily wrong.

    By losing 20 lbs, and 4 points off my BMI my period returned. Because I knew about water retention I took Midol and drank a cup of coffee a day.... the caffeine in both is a natural diuretc, which helps us get rid of waste, if you get what I mean and helps us get rid of the excess salt in our bodies that help us retain water.

    I actually wound up losing 2 more lbs while on my TOM.

    As for the Europen Food.... if you ate in France, Italy, Spain and England you know they serve rich food. The French and Italians are notorious for using copious amounts of buttered sauces and demiglaces, etc.

    Denmark.

    I ate a lot of dessert and Danish chocolate. The meals (minus the dessert) were nicely portioned. They were made with butter and a bit of cream, but that's okay. It wasn't heavy. Ate a lot of smoked herring and salmon salad.

    If I had better willpower and ate only half the dessert I'd probably be in okay shape this week :)
  • woja9640
    woja9640 Posts: 450 Member
    I weighed myself two days ago (off schedule from my normal Monday weigh-in) during TOM and noted a 4 pound gain. I'm not sure if this was just TOM or eating like crap last week while in Europe. Probably both.

    We'll see what happens on my Monday weigh-in after eating at regular calorie levels and working out consistently for 4 days with to TOM present.

    I will just tell you ladies, I had a high enough BMI that my period just "stopped". Now being that I have a genetic disorder which causes early menopause if not no actual period due to low presence of estrogen and progestrone. However I was one of the lucky few who was able to go through adolescence without taking hormone replacment therapy. Anyway, I thought my disorder caused my lack of that TOM, however I was happily wrong.

    By losing 20 lbs, and 4 points off my BMI my period returned. Because I knew about water retention I took Midol and drank a cup of coffee a day.... the caffeine in both is a natural diuretc, which helps us get rid of waste, if you get what I mean and helps us get rid of the excess salt in our bodies that help us retain water.

    I actually wound up losing 2 more lbs while on my TOM.

    As for the Europen Food.... if you ate in France, Italy, Spain and England you know they serve rich food. The French and Italians are notorious for using copious amounts of buttered sauces and demiglaces, etc.

    Denmark.

    I ate a lot of dessert and Danish chocolate. The meals (minus the dessert) were nicely portioned. They were made with butter and a bit of cream, but that's okay. It wasn't heavy. Ate a lot of smoked herring and salmon salad.

    If I had better willpower and ate only half the dessert I'd probably be in okay shape this week :)

    Ahhhh. Desserts like cakes are hardest to portion out. A normal restaurant size piece of cake is actually 2 servings..... it least that's my estimate. Too bad we can't bring a food scale with us to restaurants.... I think the restaurant servers and cooks would feel insulted LOL.
  • jmgj27
    jmgj27 Posts: 531 Member
    I weigh myself every morning but pay no attention to gains during the week before and week of - they're usually pretty fleeting and not more than about 3lbs - 4lbs. It always disappears right after my period goes and often takes an extra couple of lbs with it. I've been doing this for a while now so I've stopped freaking out when I put on a couple of lbs for no reason. As long as I've been behaving I know that it's just water weight/hormones/sodium issues and it'll disappear in a few days!
  • Barneystinson
    Barneystinson Posts: 1,357 Member
    I weighed myself two days ago (off schedule from my normal Monday weigh-in) during TOM and noted a 4 pound gain. I'm not sure if this was just TOM or eating like crap last week while in Europe. Probably both.

    We'll see what happens on my Monday weigh-in after eating at regular calorie levels and working out consistently for 4 days with to TOM present.

    I will just tell you ladies, I had a high enough BMI that my period just "stopped". Now being that I have a genetic disorder which causes early menopause if not no actual period due to low presence of estrogen and progestrone. However I was one of the lucky few who was able to go through adolescence without taking hormone replacment therapy. Anyway, I thought my disorder caused my lack of that TOM, however I was happily wrong.

    By losing 20 lbs, and 4 points off my BMI my period returned. Because I knew about water retention I took Midol and drank a cup of coffee a day.... the caffeine in both is a natural diuretc, which helps us get rid of waste, if you get what I mean and helps us get rid of the excess salt in our bodies that help us retain water.

    I actually wound up losing 2 more lbs while on my TOM.

    As for the Europen Food.... if you ate in France, Italy, Spain and England you know they serve rich food. The French and Italians are notorious for using copious amounts of buttered sauces and demiglaces, etc.

    Denmark.

    I ate a lot of dessert and Danish chocolate. The meals (minus the dessert) were nicely portioned. They were made with butter and a bit of cream, but that's okay. It wasn't heavy. Ate a lot of smoked herring and salmon salad.

    If I had better willpower and ate only half the dessert I'd probably be in okay shape this week :)

    Ahhhh. Desserts like cakes are hardest to portion out. A normal restaurant size piece of cake is actually 2 servings..... it least that's my estimate. Too bad we can't bring a food scale with us to restaurants.... I think the restaurant servers and cooks would feel insulted LOL.

    The desserts that were catered were served in shotglass portions, so that was good. It was about the equivalent of 1.5 ounces. The dinner desserts were served in small bowls with a side garnish of yogurt sorbet (decent). The thing was, two desserts per day is just too much. Just eating a lunch (shotglass) serving would have been fine. Then add in the couple sticks of chocolate I HAD to buy at the store to try because it was new and shiny and I'd never tried the kind before...

    See, it was really challenging because the plates were laid out in front of you, and sometimes I get that "oh crap, I need to finish the plate" urge, and that's not good. It was all served in courses, all provided by the hotel chef. Which meant awesome food, but a LOT of calories. If I was on my own for a few days - either eating buffet style or getting food out at cafes, I would have most likely lost weight.

    If you're out and about on your own in Copenhagen, prepare to lose weight :) The food is insanely expensive there.
  • barbiex3
    barbiex3 Posts: 1,036 Member
    um my period a few days ago I weighed in at 140 sometimes.. I actually weigh 132.5....
  • I had this problem this month. After coming off the Pill I had a proper period for the first time in years and weighed myself as usual on Saturday morning first thing. I had gained 3lbs! It didn't help my mood to put it mildly. However, a week later I weighed and lost those 3lbs plus another 2lbs. Phew! I would suggest that you still weigh yourself but just allow for bloating. If you know you've eaten well there's no reason why you would put on any fat, just water (and maybe all those hormones weigh a few pounds too)
  • meggamix
    meggamix Posts: 496 Member
    The same thing happens to me. I don't know why I get so discouraged when it goes up. I'm the queen of telling my husband "it's just natural fluctuation" every time he gets on the scale and it's gone up slightly from the day before for no good reason. So it's even more discouraging that I get so discouraged! I'm doing a weight loss challenge right now and we have to pay $5 for every pound we GAIN from one weigh in to the next. Yeah, today I was up 2 pounds because of my special week. I knew I wasn't the only one, but I think my husband started to think I was crazy! :)
This discussion has been closed.